When it comes to pizza in Youngstown, OH, you’re in for a treat. This city boasts a vibrant food scene that shines particularly bright in its love for pizza. Whether you’re a fan of classic toppings or adventurous flavor combinations, Youngstown has something for every palate. I remember the first time I bit into a slice from one of the local pizzerias—crisp crust, melty cheese, and just the right amount of tomato sauce. It was a slice of heaven, and it’s experiences like this that keep pizza lovers coming back for more.
In this guide, you’ll discover the best pizza spots across Youngstown, curated from personal favorites and community recommendations. Each pizzeria has its unique charm, tempting offers, and mouthwatering options. By the end, you’ll have all the insights needed to choose your next pizza destination. Get ready to explore the flavors of Youngstown that make each bite a delightful experience, filled with local flair and undeniable quality.
1. Wedgewood Fernando’s Pizza
Wedgewood Fernando’s Pizza has been a local staple since 1967, founded by Pasquate “Patsy” Acconcia and later joined by Fernando Riccioni. This pizzeria stands out for its commitment to fresh, made-to-order pizzas with unique toppings and a special recipe sauce. The dough is crafted daily, ensuring a quality product that honors tradition while tantalizing taste buds.
During a visit, I was struck by the warmth of the family atmosphere. The passion of Fernando and his daughters shines through in every slice. The homemade sausage is a must-try, adding a robust flavor that complements their classic pepperoni. Pair it with their signature sauce on a perfectly baked crust for a true Youngstown experience.
If you’re looking to dive into local flavors, don’t miss the vegetarian-friendly options that still reflect Wedgewood’s dedication to quality. Grab a slice, sit back, and discover why this pizzeria holds a special place in the hearts of locals.
2. Bella Napoli
Tucked in the heart of Canfield, Youngstown, Bella Napoli is a cozy gem that brings the comforting flavors of Italy to Ohio. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warm hospitality and the irresistible aroma of freshly baked pizza. It felt like stepping into a family kitchen.
What truly sets Bella Napoli apart is their commitment to authentic, high-quality ingredients and vegetarian-friendly options. The staff is attentive and the environment feels like home — perfect for a relaxing lunch or dinner. Their table service adds a personal touch, while takeout is great for pizza nights at home.
You can’t go wrong with their Margherita Pizza — the crust is crisp, the sauce bright, and the cheese melts perfectly. It’s a true taste of Napoli in Youngstown.
3. Avalon Downtown
Avalon Downtown is a vibrant addition to the Youngstown pizza scene, perfectly situated in the heart of the city. The moment I stepped inside, the lively ambiance and friendly staff immediately made me feel at ease. It’s an ideal spot for both casual lunches and dinner outings.
What distinguishes Avalon Downtown is their focus on local ingredients and creative flavor combinations. Each pizza is a work of art, crafted with care and attention to detail. Their vegetarian-friendly options are especially commendable, catering to a variety of preferences.
Don’t miss the Pesto Chicken Pizza; its fresh basil pesto paired with tender chicken offers a unique twist that reflects Avalon’s innovative style. It’s a delicious example of how they elevate classic pizza into something truly special.
4. Inner Circle Pizza
Inner Circle Pizza Boardman-Poland, established in 1972, is a beloved local eatery in Youngstown, OH. Renowned for its homemade pizza, calzones, and Stromboli’s, each dish is crafted from traditional family recipes using only the freshest ingredients.
On my last visit, I was captivated by their No. 1 rated jumbo cut, grade “A” wings with a variety of mouth-watering sauces. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it a perfect spot for both lunch and dinner, whether you choose to dine in or take out.
For a true taste of Youngstown, I highly recommend their signature pepperoni pizza. The perfect balance of crispy crust, tangy sauce, and generous toppings truly showcases Inner Circle Pizza’s dedication to quality and flavor.
Don’t miss out on their hot and cold sandwiches as well, which are perfect complements to their standout pizza offerings. Experience the warm, inviting flavors that have made Inner Circle Pizza a local favorite for decades.
5. Rise Pies
+1 330-965-4261
See Menu
Rise Pies in Boardman, OH, is a standout destination for pizza lovers seeking fresh, fast, and flavorful meals. Located at The Shops at Boardman Park, this casual eatery specializes in artisan pizzas made with high-quality ingredients and baked to perfection in a blazing hot oven. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, their menu is designed to cater to diverse tastes, including vegetarian-friendly and vegan options.
What sets Rise Pies apart is their dedication to customization. Each pizza is crafted with care, from the hand-stretched dough to the selection of premium toppings. Their signature Margherita Pizza, with its perfect balance of fresh mozzarella, basil, and tangy tomato sauce, is a must-try.
For a unique experience, try the Build-Your-Own Pizza, allowing you to tailor every bite to your liking. With its exceptional quality and welcoming atmosphere, Rise Pies is a go-to spot for pizza lovers in Youngstown.
6. Wedgewood Fernando’s Pizza
Wedgewood Fernando’s Pizza at 6200 South Avenue has been serving up high-quality pizza since 1995, following the rich traditions set by its founders in 1967. The establishment prides itself on using only the finest ingredients, preparing everything from scratch to ensure an exceptional dining experience. From the moment you taste their pizza, it’s clear that quality is their top priority.
During a visit, I experienced the distinct flavors that have made this pizzeria a local favorite. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service enhance the overall vibe, making it a great spot for lunch or dinner.
For an authentic taste, try the specialty pizza, such as their famous pepperoni and homemade sausage. Each bite reflects Wedgewood’s dedication to quality and tradition, ensuring that you’ll want to come back for more.
7. Cornersburg Pizza Boardman
Tucked in the heart of Boardman, Cornersburg Pizza Boardman delivers a true taste of Youngstown’s rich pizza tradition. From the first bite, you can tell this isn’t just any pizza spot—it’s a local gem with a legacy of quality and flavor.
What makes Cornersburg Pizza stand out is its perfectly crisp crust, generous toppings, and signature sauce that’s both tangy and savory. The moment I walked in, the warm aroma and friendly staff made me feel right at home.
If it’s your first visit, don’t miss the classic cheese or pepperoni pizza—a true reflection of Youngstown’s old-school pizza style. Each slice is a reminder of why locals keep coming back.
Whether for lunch or dinner, it’s comfort food done right.
8. North Lima Pizza
North Lima Pizza is a hidden treasure just outside Youngstown, known for its great variety and exceptional taste. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted with a friendly atmosphere that felt inviting, much like visiting a neighbor’s home. The staff was eager to help with recommendations, showcasing their commitment to customer satisfaction.
What really sets North Lima Pizza apart is its generous portion sizes and fresh ingredient selection. Each pizza is crafted to order, ensuring quality with every bite. Their signature white pizza, topped with ricotta and mozzarella, has a creamy texture that pairs beautifully with their perfectly baked crust.
For a true experience of their craftsmanship, the meat lover’s pizza is a crowd favorite, packing in flavor that will leave you wanting more. It’s a must-try for anyone visiting.
9. Uptown Pizza
Uptown Pizza is a quintessential stop for pizza lovers in Youngstown, found conveniently on Belmont Avenue. From the moment I walked through the door, I was welcomed by a warm atmosphere and the tempting aroma of freshly baked pizza. This eatery combines quality and friendliness, making it the perfect place for casual lunches or dinners.
What sets Uptown Pizza apart is their commitment to fresh ingredients and a diverse menu that includes vegetarian-friendly options. Their dough is made daily, ensuring each pizza has that perfect, crusty bite. The Uptown Special, loaded with a delightful mix of toppings, is a must-try and reflects their emphasis on quality.
If you’re looking for a satisfying meal, the buffalo chicken pizza is another standout, providing a spicy, tangy twist that captures the essence of local flavors.
10. Belleria Pizza and Italian Restaurant
Tucked away in Youngstown, Belleria Pizza and Italian Restaurant is a local gem known for its classic Italian flavors and warm, family-style atmosphere. From the moment you step in, you’re greeted like family, and the aroma of fresh-baked pizza instantly makes you feel at home.
What truly sets Belleria apart is their consistent quality and hearty portions. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, the service is always friendly and fast. I remember sharing a pie with friends on a cold Ohio evening — the crust was perfectly crisp, and the sauce had the right balance of sweetness and spice.
If it’s your first visit, try the Original Belleria Pizza — a local favorite. The vegetarian version is loaded with fresh toppings and showcases the kitchen’s care for flavor and tradition.
For a true taste of Youngstown’s pizza legacy, Belleria is a must-visit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are the best pizza places in Youngstown, OH?
A: Some of the top spots include Wedgewood Fernando’s Pizza, Bella Napoli, Avalon Downtown, and Inner Circle Pizza. Each of these places offers a unique style and flavor, ensuring you’ll find something to enjoy.
Q: Is pizza in Youngstown vegetarian-friendly?
A: Absolutely! Many pizzerias, such as Uptown Pizza and Belleria Pizza and Italian Restaurant, offer a variety of vegetarian options. You’ll find toppings ranging from fresh vegetables to specialty cheeses.
Q: Can I get pizza delivered in Youngstown?
A: Yes, many pizza places in Youngstown offer delivery services, including Wedgewood Fernando’s Pizza and Belleria Pizza. Check their websites or call ahead to confirm availability.
Q: What is unique about Youngstown-style pizza?
A: Youngstown-style pizza often features a thick crust and a distinctive toppings arrangement—cheese goes on top of the toppings. The sauce is usually tangy, complementing the flavor profile nicely.
Q: Are there vegan pizza options available?
A: Yes, several pizzerias in Youngstown, like Rise Pies, provide vegan options, including cheese alternatives and a variety of fresh toppings. It’s always best to check the menu or ask the staff for vegan-friendly offerings.
Q: Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Youngstown?
A: Many pizzerias, including Bella Napoli and Inner Circle Pizza, offer gluten-free crusts as an option. Be sure to inquire when ordering to ensure you’re getting the best option for your dietary needs.
Q: What are some popular toppings for pizza in Youngstown?
A: Popular toppings include classic pepperoni, sausage, fresh vegetables like bell peppers and onions, as well as unique local specialties like homemade sausage and extra cheese.
Q: What are good side dishes to order with pizza?
A: Consider ordering appetizers like chicken wings, garlic knots, or salads. They pair well with pizza and are popular among locals.