Wilmington, DE hides a surprising pizza scene. It’s the sort of place where you can taste tradition at a family-run shop or something different at a creative new spot. I still remember ducking out of a rainstorm and finding a piping-hot slice that instantly made the whole soggy day worthwhile. Every pizza lover I know has a Wilmington story, whether they swear by crispy thin crust or a bubbling cheese pull.
The search for the best slice in town isn’t simple, but it’s never dull. Some places win you over with decades-old sauce recipes, others keep luring you back with fresh spins on old classics. If you want a cozy booth or just a quick counter stop, you’ll find something to love here. This guide narrows down the maze to only the top spots, leaving you hungry for a taste—and ready to trust your next pizza night to the right oven.
1. Gino’s Pizza
Gino’s Pizza on Lancaster Ave feels like a time-tested slice of Wilmington tradition. It’s the sort of place where walking in smells like pizza should—crust, cheese, and a hint of garlic. I still remember my first bite here; the dough had that perfect, chewy foundation, and the sauce offered a kick just right for comfort food.
What sets Gino’s apart is its dependable quality and friendly staff who somehow always get your order just right. Locals talk about the balance in every pie, never too greasy or heavy, and always cooked through just so.
For first-timers, the classic Cheese or Margherita Pizza is where to start. Each slice shows off that signature, slightly crispy base and fresh toppings. Their Veggie Pizza is a close contender, loaded with colorful ingredients that don’t overwhelm the crust.
2. Grotto Pizza
Grotto Pizza is almost a rite of passage for Wilmington locals. Founded back in 1960, this spot blends nostalgia with fresh flavors. I remember my first slice at the Pennsylvania Ave location—there’s a tangy swirl of sauce on top that makes every bite distinctive and memorable. The crust manages to be crispy yet has a light, airy center that never disappoints.
What makes Grotto stand out is its devotion to tradition, from the red-and-yellow branding down to the consistent, crowd-pleasing pies. There’s an easygoing, family-friendly vibe that makes it just as good for Friday nights as for casual lunches, and the staff are always welcoming.
If you’re unsure where to begin, start with the Baker’s Choice Pizza. Loaded with fresh vegetables, it’s balanced and satisfying, showing off Grotto’s reliable touch. The classic Cheese never lets you down and gives you the full taste of their signature sauce swirl.
3. 3 Stars Pizza
3 Stars Pizza might look unassuming from the outside, but it’s a neighborhood favorite for good reason. This Union Street spot greets you with the scent of toasty dough and a staff who recognize their regular customers. My first slice here was a surprise—thin crust with just enough bite, plenty of melted cheese, and a satisfying, homemade sauce.
The charm of 3 Stars is in its consistent quality and no-fuss approach. You won’t find over-the-top toppings, just straight-up good pizza, quick service, and generous portions for the price.
Order the plain Cheese or a veggie-loaded pie for your first visit. The cheese blend and tangy sauce hit the mark, making each slice feel like a proper Wilmington classic.
4. Pizza Pro!
Pizza Pro! on Greenbank Rd makes pizza night refreshingly simple. You don’t need frills here—just a hot, reassuringly cheesy pizza that’s made right and served fast. The first time I stopped in, I was in a rush, but the crew still managed to hand over a bubbling, golden pie with minimal wait.
This spot stands out for speedy service and pies that hold up well, even after a drive home. Each pizza shows real care in its preparation, with a crust that’s crisp but not dry, and plenty of melty cheese topping every slice.
For a true taste of the menu, go for their classic Cheese or Veggie Pizza. The balance of flavors does the basics justice, making this the place to count on when you just want good, honest pizza in Wilmington.
5. Ciao’s Trolley Pizza & Grill
Ciao’s Trolley Pizza & Grill brings a lively, neighborhood vibe to Delaware Ave in Wilmington. Duck in, and you’re greeted by the bustle of regulars who know this is a solid spot for a satisfying slice. My first visit was at lunch on a busy weekday, and the pizza came out fast but packed with flavor.
The pies here stand out for their soft, chewy crust and fresh toppings. Each pizza is baked just enough to be golden and never oversauced, which lets you appreciate the dough and cheese combination at its best.
Order a classic Margherita or go for their Veggie Pizza. Both showcase a careful hand with toppings and a balance that keeps locals coming back for more.
6. Dom’s NY Style Pizzeria
Dom’s NY Style Pizzeria transports you straight to New York with its classic, foldable slices. Dom himself hails from NY, and you can taste that heritage in every pie. My first time here, I went for a plain slice and was impressed by the chewy crust, melty cheese, and just the right splash of sauce—simple, but spot-on.
The strength of Dom’s lies in its commitment to fresh ingredients and made-to-order pies. The atmosphere is laid-back, and the staff always seem genuinely happy to walk you through their menu.
Try the classic NY Cheese Pizza for your first visit. It’s as close to the city as you’ll get in Wilmington, and the balance in every bite shows why this place draws regulars all week long.
7. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza on Marsh Rd delivers exactly what you expect—a reliable, crowd-pleasing pie every time. That familiar aroma hits as soon as you walk in, and there’s something oddly comforting about opening their signature green box. My first order here arrived piping hot, with fresh, chewy crust and plenty of zesty sauce.
This spot is a go-to for delivery or carryout, with impressively consistent quality and speedy service. Whether you’re feeding friends or need a solo dinner on the run, their pizzas always match the same standard.
Classic choices like the Cheese or Garden Fresh Pizza are solid bets for first-timers. If you want a little more kick, the Spicy Italian has a rich, bold flavor without overpowering the balanced crust and sauce.
8. Five Star Pizza
(302) 892-2222Call
Five Star Pizza on Gilpin Dr stays true to its bold name, serving up pizzas that keep locals coming back. I wandered in on a whim and left with slices that were perfectly balanced—thin, crisp crust, a generous but not overwhelming layer of cheese, and sauce with a pleasant little tang.
This place stands out for its reliable flavor and wallet-friendly prices. The staff is fast and friendly, and the atmosphere is fuss-free, which makes it easy to choose for quick meals or larger gatherings.
The classic Cheese Pizza is a crowd pleaser, but their Vegetable Pizza deserves a special nod. It’s loaded with fresh toppings that let you taste each ingredient without sacrificing the pie’s crisp, satisfying base.
9. Omega Pizza
(302) 656-9200Call
Omega Pizza on 4th St has a devoted following in Downtown Wilmington, built on generous portions and serious flavor. My first visit surprised me with substantial slices—just the kind you want after a long day. The crust is sturdy but not dense, making it ideal for folding and holding, NY-style.
What really stands out here is their toppings-to-cheese ratio. Each pie comes loaded with enough freshness to please any pizza purist, but never gets soggy or overloaded. The staff move quickly, so even a lunch rush feels relaxed.
Order the Veggie Pizza for a colorful sampling of everything fresh from their kitchen. Or, if you’re a classic fan, the Cheese Pizza shows off how well they balance dough, sauce, and cheese in every bite.
10. Seasons Pizza
Seasons Pizza on Philadelphia Pike is a staple for anyone who wants options and consistency in Wilmington. Every visit reminds me of friendly staff and a menu that caters to every kind of pizza craving. My first taste here was the kind of experience that lands a place in your regular dinner rotation—plenty of cheese, a sauce with some zing, and a crust that’s neither too thick nor too thin.
The real standout of Seasons is the customization. You can tailor your pizza with a wide range of toppings, and everything holds up well from first slice to last.
If you’re stuck on what to try, their White Pizza or a classic Veggie always hits the spot. Both highlight fresh ingredients and Seasons’ approach to satisfying, crowd-pleasing pies.
Frequently Asked Questions
What kinds of pizza are most popular in Wilmington, DE?
Thin crust, New York-style, and classic cheese pizzas tend to be local favorites. Many spots also offer loaded veggie and white pizzas, which have a loyal following.
Are vegan or vegetarian pizza options easy to find in Wilmington?
Yes, several pizzerias offer vegetarian options, and many will customize toppings to make a pizza vegan. Always check with the restaurant about cheese and sauce recipes if you have dietary needs.
Which Wilmington pizzerias offer delivery?
Most major pizza spots, including Domino’s, Papa Johns, and many local joints, offer reliable delivery. Check their websites for delivery zones and online ordering.
Are there gluten-free pizza choices in Wilmington?
Many larger and family-run pizzerias provide gluten-free crusts. It’s best to call ahead or view menus online for details and cross-contamination info.
Is it easy to find late-night pizza in Wilmington?
Several pizzerias, especially national chains and a few local favorites, stay open late. Always check current hours before heading out for a late-night slice.