Looking for the best pizza in West Islip, NY is a little like searching for treasure that’s always close at hand. The town offers a medley of flavors for every type of pizza lover—whether you crave classic New York slices, airy brick-oven crusts, or that irresistible blend of crisp edges and gooey cheese. Having spent more than my fair share of time debating with friends over the perfect pie, I’ve come to realize that West Islip’s pizza scene has more depth than you might expect. Each stop on this list has surprised me: a tangy sauce here, a whisper-thin crust there, and on occasion, the kind of bite that makes you savor it a little slower.
Finding your go-to pizza in West Islip isn’t just about toppings or crust thickness. It’s about the mood, the people you share it with, and the small discoveries along the way. Whether you’re a seasoned local or just visiting for a taste of something better than your average chain, you’ll find something that lingers in your memory—and on your taste buds—for days. Ready to find out which pizzerias rise above the rest? The hunt is half the fun, and your new favorite slice may be just around the corner.
Where to find the best pizza in West Islip, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in West Islip, NY:
- Americano Pie Bar Restaurant
- Angela’s Pizzeria
- The Pizzeria of Islip
- 7-Eleven
- Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta
- Crispino
- Italiano’s
- Jason Freda
- Chuck E. Cheese’s
- Slices & Ices Pizzeria
1. Americano Pie Bar Restaurant
Americano Pie Bar Restaurant, just a quick drive from West Islip, feels both familiar and fresh. The menu is a mix of modern comfort and classic pizza, pulling off that balance with style. I remember my first bite of their Margherita pizza—the sauce tasted bright, and the crust had just the right char. It’s the kind of place where every table seems to have a different favorite.
The wood-fired pies are real standouts. The Bianca, with its blend of ricotta and mozzarella, is rich without being heavy. If you like something a little more classic, order their Pepperoni Pie. The meat is flavorful and the cheese melts into every bite.
Americano Pie Bar is also vegetarian and vegan friendly. Try their Veggie Supreme, which always feels fresh and generous. For a sit-down meal or takeout, this spot makes pizza memorable in West Islip.
2. Angela’s Pizzeria
Angela’s Pizzeria is where locals in West Islip head when they want that reliable, no-nonsense slice. It’s the kind of place where the scent of baking dough hits you before the door even closes behind you. On more than one occasion, I’ve found myself weighing my options at the counter, only to let the staff suggest their favorite of the day—which never disappoints.
The classic cheese pizza is what makes Angela’s stand out. The balance between sauce and cheese is spot on, and the crust is crisp without being tough. If you’re after something with a little personality, the Vegetable Pie comes loaded with fresh toppings.
Angela’s does takeout and delivery well, making it a solid pick when you’re craving comfort food at home. Simple, consistent, and always satisfying.
3. The Pizzeria of Islip
The Pizzeria of Islip is the kind of neighborhood eatery that quickly becomes a habit. Each visit, I’ve noticed families and regulars chatting comfortably, which speaks volumes about its local following. The place keeps things straightforward—good pizza, friendly service, and no over-complication.
Their Sicilian slice stands out for its pillowy crust and subtle, savory sauce. If you prefer something with a little more bite, the White Pizza, topped with creamy ricotta and spinach, offers a lighter but flavorful option.
Online ordering is a breeze, so a craving never has to wait. The Pizzeria of Islip caters to every kind of pizza enthusiasm, promising both convenience and quality with each order.
4. 7-Eleven
7-Eleven on Sunrise Hwy isn’t what most think of for pizza, but it has its own charm, especially when you need a quick bite day or night. On one late study session, the convenience was unbeatable—a hot slice, ready in minutes, and surprisingly satisfying for a grab-and-go meal.
The cheese pizza is the go-to here, fresh out of the warmer and with an even layer of melted cheese. It’s simple, affordable, and fills that craving for a fast lunch or late snack.
No tablecloths or artisanal flour here—just straight-up, honest convenience. When time’s short and pizza can’t wait, 7-Eleven delivers the basics just right.
5. Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta
(631) 321-4100Call
Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta brings a cozy, neighborhood feel to West Islip’s pizza selection. It’s one of those places where the owner greets you like a regular—even on your first visit. My most memorable lunch here was a slice of their thin-crust cheese pizza, which set the bar for simplicity done right.
Their thin-crust pies are crisp and flavorful, holding up well under the generous cheese and sauce. For something a bit more filling, try the Veggie Pizza. The vegetables are always fresh, and the balance of flavors is spot on.
Affordable prices and friendly staff make Anthony’s a local staple. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or catering an event, the pizza speaks for itself—classic, tasty, and unfussy.
6. Crispino
Crispino is that slightly under-the-radar spot on Higbie Ln that locals talk about when asked where to get genuinely good pizza. My first time there, a friend insisted I try their Grandma Pie. One bite and it was clear—this place doesn’t mess around with flavor or freshness.
The Grandma Pie is a highlight here—thin, square, and bursting with garlicky tomato sauce and just the right amount of cheese. The crust manages to be both crisp and tender, which is a rare feat.
If you’re feeling adventurous, order the Margherita. The basil packs a punch and the mozzarella is as creamy as it gets. Crispino offers a pizza experience that balances tradition and creativity, making it a regular favorite for many West Islip residents.
7. Italiano’s
(631) 587-1172Call
Italiano’s sits on Udall Rd and feels like the kind of old-school spot you wish you’d discovered sooner. I remember ducking in during a rainstorm and being greeted by that comforting mix of pizza aromas and laughter from the kitchen. It’s a place where regulars linger and new visitors quickly feel at home.
Their classic Neapolitan pie sets the standard. Expect a thin, foldable crust with a slightly smoky edge, layered with tangy sauce and perfectly stretchy cheese. Each bite brings nostalgia and comfort.
If you want something heartier, try their Veggie Pizza. The toppings are always fresh, never an afterthought, and the slice never droops. Italiano’s balances tradition, quality, and a welcoming neighborhood vibe—making it a dependable choice for pizza in West Islip.
8. Jason Freda
(631) 661-6246Call
Jason Freda is one of those pizzerias you might pass by if you’re not paying attention—but you’d be missing something special. One afternoon, I stopped in on a whim and ended up with a slice so satisfying it made me wonder why I hadn’t discovered the place sooner.
Their specialty pies are what set them apart. The White Pizza with fresh ricotta is a standout—creamy, garlicky, and beautifully baked. For something classic, the plain cheese slice is sturdy and flavorful, never greasy.
Jason Freda is a quietly reliable stop in West Islip, with friendly service and consistently good quality. If you like your pizza with a personal touch, you’ll find yourself coming back for more.
9. Chuck E. Cheese’s
Chuck E. Cheese’s on Sunrise Hwy is less about artisanal crust and more about fun, family, and memories in the making. I once tagged along to a birthday party and realized that, for kids, this is pizza bliss wrapped in arcade lights and laughter. The staff keeps things cheerful, making it an easy pick for groups with little ones.
The classic cheese and veggie pizzas are kid-friendly and crowd-pleasing. The crust is soft and mild, built for easy munching between games. Pies come out hot and keep everyone fueled for another round at the arcade.
If you’re planning a celebration or just need a family-friendly spot, Chuck E. Cheese’s delivers on both pizza and play. It’s cheerful, lively, and always reliable for a group meal.
10. Slices & Ices Pizzeria
(631) 893-8000Call
Slices & Ices Pizzeria is a West Islip staple for anyone craving no-frills, straight-from-the-oven pizza. My go-to stop after a day out, this spot always hits the mark for classic slices without the wait. Stepping inside feels like a throwback, with regulars laughing and the kitchen working at a lively pace.
The cheese slice is the star here, with just the right ratio of sauce to cheese and a crust that’s both crispy and soft. If you’re up for sharing, try a whole veggie pie—generously topped and never soggy.
Slices & Ices keeps things simple and wallet-friendly, so you can fill up and still have change for a cold drink or one of their classic Italian ices on the side.
More Things to Try in West Islip, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are some popular pizza places in West Islip, NY?
West Islip has a great lineup including Crispino, Italiano’s, Slices & Ices Pizzeria, and Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta. Each spot has its own style, so you’ll find everything from classic New York slices to modern pies.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in West Islip?
Yes, many local pizzerias such as Americano Pie Bar Restaurant, Angela’s Pizzeria, and Crispino offer vegetarian pizzas and often have vegan-friendly options. Just ask when you order and the staff is usually happy to help.
Where can I get pizza late at night in West Islip?
7-Eleven is your best bet for late-night pizza cravings. Some traditional pizzerias may have extended hours, but 7-Eleven is reliable for a hot slice when most options have closed.
Can I order pizza online from West Islip pizzerias?
Absolutely. Places like The Pizzeria of Islip and several others offer online ordering and delivery. This is perfect for staying in and enjoying great pizza without leaving your couch.
Do any pizzerias in West Islip offer gluten-free pizza?
Many local pizzerias recognize the need for gluten-free options. Check with Americano Pie Bar or inquire directly at your favorite spot—most are happy to accommodate.