Finding truly great pizza in Taunton, MA isn’t just about mozzarella or the perfect crust snap; it’s about chasing those small, stand-out moments. Picture late nights when that last slice is suddenly the best thing on Earth, or the satisfaction that comes from discovering a neighborhood spot that out-bakes the bigger chains. I still remember a spontaneous stop years back—a nondescript spot, one slice, way too much cheese, and the feeling I’d stumbled onto something locals keep secret. Taunton rewards the curious.
If you’ve ever wondered where to find the best pizza in Taunton, you’re not alone. Good pizza sparks debates, loyalty, maybe even a few family arguments. Over the years, I’ve mapped out the slices, bickered about toppings, and taste-tested my share of dough—from classic spots to new surprises. This guide ranks the top pizzerias in town, favoring honest flavors and local favorites, and skips anything that doesn’t match Taunton’s style. Hungry? Let’s get started.
1. HomePlate
HomePlate lands high on anyone’s Taunton pizza list for a reason. It’s more than just a sports bar; it feels like that easygoing spot where you could eat in sweats or dress up a bit—either way, you’re in good company. I first tried their pizza after a game-day crowd and quickly realized why locals give knowing nods when you mention the name.
Their pizzas are built around a chewy, golden crust with just enough crunch. Don’t skip their Supreme Pie, which layers fresh vegetables and savory meats in ideal balance. If you want a twist, their white pizza options offer a garlicky foundation topped with generous cheese.
Vegetarian and gluten-free pizza fans are also at home here, so there’s something for all palates. Hearty portions and bold flavors set HomePlate apart on Taunton’s crowded pizza map.
2. Devito’s Pizzeria
+1 508-977-0444
Devito’s Pizzeria is the kind of place where the pizza feels handcrafted rather than hurried. It sits right on Taunton Green, and the scent of baking dough and melting cheese always seems to draw you in. My first slice from Devito’s—gooey cheese, balanced sauce, crisp-edged crust—felt both classic and unexpectedly good.
Devito’s pies are generous, with fresh toppings and just the right cheese-to-crust ratio. Their Margherita pizza is a solid choice, bringing together bright tomato and fresh basil in a way that highlights their signature dough. If you’re having a tough day, the Veggie pizza is comfort in a box—colorful, flavorful, filling.
The menu stretches beyond pizza, but the commitment to quality shows in every slice. If you care about flavor over flash, Devito’s is your spot for a genuine Taunton pizza experience.
3. Berkley Beer Company
Berkley Beer Company is the wildcard in Taunton’s pizza scene. This isn’t your standard pizzeria; it’s where house-brewed drinks and creative pies share a table, and the vibe is always lively. My first time here, I settled onto the roomy patio, pizza in hand, sun setting, and it felt like a mini escape from routine.
Their pizza menu is playful, leaning into fresh herbs and inventive toppings that keep things interesting. The Margherita pizza is a favorite—simple, fragrant, with a dough that strikes a perfect balance between soft and crisp. If you want variety, the specialty white pizzas are worth a shot.
Service is friendly and never rushed, and there’s a low-key energy that’s rare. For a laid-back pizza night with room to settle in, Berkley Beer Company delivers something refreshing in every sense.
4. Whittenton House of Pizza
Whittenton House of Pizza has a loyal following for good reason. This classic neighborhood pizzeria has a cozy, familiar feel—a place that’s all about reliable slices and regular faces behind the counter. My first visit was on a chilly afternoon; one hot, cheesy slice later, I understood the local devotion.
They keep the crust golden and just the right thickness, making each pie both sturdy and soft. The House Special Pizza is a standout, loaded with fresh vegetables and flavorful cheese, and every bite feels carefully put together. For those who prefer basics, their cheese or veggie options showcase a well-balanced flavor without too much fuss.
Portions are generous, prices are fair, and the pizza doesn’t try too hard—it just delivers. Whittenton House of Pizza is proof that sometimes tradition tastes best.
5. G & S Pizzeria and Seafood
G & S Pizzeria and Seafood proves you don’t need to pick between pizza or seafood—they do both with easy skill. Stopping in for a slice, I was surprised by how swiftly their pizza hit the table, and even more by the balanced flavor of each bite. There’s a comfort in knowing your go-to slice and a crispy side can all come from the same kitchen.
Their signature pizza dough is soft inside, lightly crisp outside, making every pie consistent and satisfying. The Mediterranean Pizza deserves special mention, with colorful toppings and a punch of flavor that marks G & S as a place for more than just the basics.
Ordering is smooth, staff are patient, and portions always impress. If you’re after a spot that’s got a little of everything yet never skimps on quality, this is your stop.
6. Papa Gino’s
Papa Gino’s is woven into the pizza story of New England, and its Taunton location feels instantly familiar. There’s something about the scent of their thin-crust pies baking that always brings back memories of post-game celebrations and quick family dinners. The dough is made fresh daily, and you can taste the difference—simple, honest, and light.
The traditional cheese pizza here is as classic as it gets, layered with their signature sauce and a blend of three cheeses for full flavor. For those wanting extra, the Veggie Delight carries crisp, fresh toppings that keep every slice interesting without weighing it down.
Quality and consistency define Papa Gino’s. If you crave an uncomplicated pizza night or want a quick lunch that never disappoints, this spot delivers every time.
7. Papa Gino’s
This Papa Gino’s location keeps Taunton pizza tradition alive with thin, memorable pies and quick, friendly service. Each visit brings the familiar crunch of their crust and that unmistakable aroma—honest, unfussy, and downright comforting. My last takeout order was still warm by the time I got home, with the cheese perfectly melted.
Their Pepperoni pizza stands out, thanks to real, zesty pepperoni and gooey cheese that won’t slide off the slice. For something simple, a cheese and tomato pie lets their house-made sauce shine with just the right tang and richness.
Clean, reliable, and well-loved, this Papa Gino’s is about sticking to what works. Whether you’re a traditionalist or just want a speedy dinner, it’s a steady choice in Taunton.
8. Kyrdino’s Pizza
Kyrdino’s Pizza brings a touch of local personality to every pie. Their menu is full of options, whether you’re craving classic comfort or feeling adventurous. I dropped in on a busy weekend, watched the kitchen crew work with practiced speed, and could tell right away this was a place that takes real pride in their food.
The Greek Pizza at Kyrdino’s is a standout, with briny olives, fresh veggies, and a sprinkle of feta that turns a simple slice into something memorable. Their Veggie pies offer bright, garden-fresh flavors on a chewy crust that never disappoints.
Service is quick whether you’re staying in or taking out, and portions keep you satisfied. Kyrdino’s is ideal if you want true variety with every visit.
9. New Weir Pizza & Restaurant
New Weir Pizza & Restaurant has that neighborhood-spot charm, where regulars greet the staff by name and newcomers are soon in on the secret. My first order came on a cold night—one bite of their hot, cheesy slice brought instant comfort and made the place an instant favorite.
Their House Special Pizza has a little bit of everything, loaded with a colorful mix of fresh veggies and plenty of cheese, all riding on a golden, puffy crust. If you like a classic approach, their Cheese or Mushroom pies highlight the texture of their dough and their balanced tomato sauce.
Service is quick, portions are hearty, and the menu keeps the quality steady. New Weir Pizza & Restaurant is perfect for those who appreciate consistency and genuine flavor in every slice.
10. Taunton House of Pizza
Taunton House of Pizza delivers steady, satisfying slices every time. It’s a simple, unpretentious spot with a focus on what matters most: the food. I stopped in on a busy Friday and saw a mix of families, friends, and solo diners all tucking into fresh, piping-hot pizzas—a sign a place is doing it right.
Their Meatless Special is a favorite, full of crisp vegetables and a light, flavorful sauce over a well-crafted crust. If you like a heartier option, the Cheese Lovers pizza layers enough cheese to satisfy without overwhelming the balance or texture.
Portions are generous and service feels genuine. For a dependable Taunton pizza night that skips the fuss, this spot gets my vote.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Taunton, MA?
You’ll find strong contenders like HomePlate, Devito’s Pizzeria, Whittenton House of Pizza, and New Weir Pizza & Restaurant. Each spot offers its own take on familiar pies, so there’s something for every preference.
Do any Taunton pizza restaurants offer gluten-free options?
Yes, several places such as HomePlate and Devito’s Pizzeria offer gluten-free crusts so everyone can enjoy a great slice, regardless of dietary needs.
Can I get vegetarian pizza options in Taunton?
Absolutely. Most pizzerias in Taunton, including Whittenton House of Pizza and Papa Gino’s, feature hearty vegetarian pies loaded with fresh veggies and cheese.
Is delivery available for pizza in Taunton, MA?
Most local pizzerias, including G & S Pizzeria and Kyrdino’s Pizza, offer delivery. Some even have easy online ordering for extra convenience.
Which pizza place is best for large groups or families?
HomePlate provides a family-friendly atmosphere with hearty portions, making it ideal for group gatherings. Many other spots are just as welcoming, so a little planning ahead can help you choose your favorite.