There’s a particular charm to Syracuse pizza. Maybe it’s the snow that sharpens appetites or the way family recipes quietly compete across neighborhoods. Trying pizza in Syracuse isn’t just about cheese and crust—it’s the delicious tension between old favorites and bold newcomers, with each spot staking its claim slice by slice. Whether you crave crispy edges, pillowy dough, or that elusive perfect sauce-cheese balance, Syracuse’s pizza scene is generous with options.
I still remember my first slice at a tiny pizzeria tucked away near the university. People from all walks of life were crowded into booths, leaning over paper plates and arguing about which place truly did it best. That’s the essential Syracuse experience: real debate over really good pizza. So, if you’re on a quest to find the best pizza in Syracuse, NY, you’re in the right place—with more than a few unforgettable pies ahead.
Where to find the best pizza in Syracuse, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Syracuse, NY:
- Just Wing It
- Uncle Chubby’s Pizza
- Apizza Regionale
- Daniella’s Steakhouse
- Strong Hearts Cafe
- The Preserve at 405
- Nick’s Pizza
- Varsity Pizza
- Paladino’s Pizza
- Twin Trees Too
1. Just Wing It
(315) 314-7978Call
Just Wing It sits on Milton Ave, quietly winning over skeptics with pizza that’s anything but ordinary. This spot might seem wing-focused at first, but the pizza is its best-kept secret. The crust comes out perfectly golden, airy, and never too greasy. The Westside crowd knows: you come here for more than just classic pepperoni.
I once stopped in on a whim and ended up hooked on their “Stoned Crust” pizzas. There’s a playful twist to every pie, from a four-cheese blend to a tangy signature red sauce that pushes each bite above the ordinary.
Try the Buffalo Chicken Pizza; it’s a Syracuse favorite and captures everything Just Wing It does well—rich flavor, hearty toppings, and just the right snap of heat. It’s the kind of pizza that makes you plan your next visit before you even leave.
2. Uncle Chubby’s Pizza
Uncle Chubby’s Pizza on Wolf Street is the kind of neighborhood staple where cravings get answered right. It’s casual, lively, and most days you’ll catch regulars ducking in for a hot pie or something from the deep menu of comfort food classics. Even if you arrive for pizza, their legendary wings and calzones often tempt you before you reach the counter.
The dough here is soft inside, with a bit of chew, and the sauce hits that sweet spot between tangy and mild. Once, during a late-night pickup run, I ended up adding a slice of veggie pizza to my usual order—no regrets. That’s the thing about Uncle Chubby’s—every slice feels fresh off the block.
Order the Deluxe Pizza to see their generous approach in full form; each bite brings big toppings, gooey cheese, and pure Northside comfort. Grab some “doogles” for dessert if you need convincing to stick around longer.
3. Apizza Regionale
Apizza Regionale, tucked away in Downtown Syracuse, is where local tradition and wood-fired innovation meet. The space feels sleek yet inviting, with the steady warmth of the oven setting the scene for a memorable meal. Here, “apizza” isn’t just a nod to New Haven style—it’s a craft, evident in every way they treat the dough and toppings.
The crust at Apizza Regionale manages an elusive mix of crispy bottom and delicate char, yet never leaves you reaching for a glass of water. During my last visit, a friend insisted on splitting the Margherita. One bite in, it was clear: this place takes its tomatoes and fresh mozzarella seriously.
The Margherita and Pistachio Pizzas are must-tries. The former showcases the sauce-forward, traditional approach; the latter surprises with crushed pistachio and a hint of lemon zest. Both make a strong case for Apizza Regionale’s reputation—and why you’ll keep coming back.
4. Daniella’s Steakhouse
Daniella’s Steakhouse is the rare spot that pulls off steakhouse polish without feeling stuffy. Nestled near the State Fairgrounds, it’s warm, inviting, and equally known for its pizza as its steaks. There’s a real attention to detail, whether you’re ordering something off the grill or straight from their stone oven.
On my first visit, I was drawn in by the friendly buzz and ended up with a seat near the kitchen. That’s where you can catch pies emerging, golden and bubbling, with the aroma of roasted garlic in the air. The crust here is tender inside and crisp outside, perfect for holding generous toppings.
The classic Cheese Pizza delivers a satisfying blend of creamy mozzarella and tangy sauce, showcasing Daniella’s balance of flavors. For something bolder, try their veggie pizza and see how their steakhouse roots elevate even the simplest ingredients.
5. Strong Hearts Cafe
Strong Hearts Cafe on East Genesee Street is known for pushing boundaries—deliciously and thoughtfully. This spot prides itself on creative, completely plant-based pizza options that even skeptics end up craving. The bright, laid-back space is perfect for catching up with friends or fueling up after a long day.
The menu weaves a range of flavors, combining seasonal veggies, house-made spreads, and inventive dairy-free cheeses. My first time, I went out of curiosity and came away surprised at how satisfying their classic “Cheese” pizza could be without any actual cheese. That’s the Strong Hearts magic—fresh, conscious, and never dull.
Try the Buffalo Cauliflower Pizza to see how they give a Syracuse staple a fresh twist. Whether you’re plant-based or just curious, their pizzas reflect a new kind of comfort food—thoughtful, bold, and very satisfying.
6. The Preserve at 405
The Preserve at 405 brings a laid-back charm to Syracuse’s Inner Harbor, complete with a roomy patio and views worth lingering over. This is the kind of place where friends gather for relaxed evenings, and conversations stretch late into the night. Their stone-fired pizzas come out bubbling and crisp, marrying classic combinations with a few smart surprises.
My first visit was a summer evening with jazz floating from the speakers and the fire pit casting a soft glow. Servers glide around with generous pies and a steady stream of local fans. You can sense the pride in how each pizza hits the table—aromatic, hot, and easy to share.
The Margherita Pizza is especially worth trying, thanks to its bright tomato sauce and fresh basil. For something more adventurous, their specialty veggie pizzas deliver big flavor while staying satisfyingly light. This spot makes everyday gatherings feel like a special occasion.
7. Nick’s Pizza
(315) 463-6425Call
Nick’s Pizza is the kind of local spot you stumble upon and wonder how you never noticed before. Tucked along Thompson Road, it brings in a steady mix of families, students, and people who know great pizza when they taste it. The place is easygoing and reliable, with friendly service that feels genuine every time.
I once popped in during a Syracuse snowstorm and left with a large pie so good it changed my winter mood. Their pizza is always hot, with a classic, chewy crust and plenty of topping choices to suit any craving. Each slice holds its shape and flavor from first bite to last.
The Supreme Pizza is a strategy for indecisive eaters; plenty of veggies and just the right amount of gooey cheese. Nick’s is for those who like their pizza straightforward, fresh, and never fussy.
8. Varsity Pizza
Varsity Pizza is a Syracuse landmark where the energy rarely dips, especially on game days. It’s perched right off S Crouse Ave, making it the unofficial campus kitchen for students, locals, and anyone craving a classic slice. The walls are lined with memorabilia, and there’s a buzz in the air that says you’re part of something bigger than lunch.
My first Varsity slice came during a rain-soaked March, and it nailed every comfort-food note I needed. The sauce is vibrant, the crust is just thick enough, and the cheese lands in that satisfying midpoint between gooey and chewy. You don’t rush a meal here with friends—Varsity invites you to linger.
Go for the traditional Cheese or Veggie Pizza; their straightforward approach is what makes these pies shine. Varsity captures the heart of Syracuse’s pizza tradition—simple, timeless, and reliably delicious.
9. Paladino’s Pizza
Paladino’s Pizza, set in the Northern Lights Plaza, feels like the kind of place where regulars are made after one visit. Stepping in, you’re met with the aroma of cheese bubbling and dough baking—a comfort on busy days. There’s a relaxed, family-friendly energy here that gets you settling in before you know it.
On my last trip, I went for a simple slice and ended up ordering an entire pie to take home. Their crust stands out—soft but with a good chew, just sturdy enough for generous toppings. The tomato sauce is bright and pairs perfectly with their creamy cheese.
The White Pizza is a solid choice here. Its smooth ricotta and melt-in-your-mouth mozzarella highlight Paladino’s careful touch and quality ingredients. You’ll taste why locals keep coming back.
10. Twin Trees Too
Twin Trees Too on Milton Ave is woven into the local pizza lore of Syracuse. It’s known for its friendly, welcoming space and the kind of menu that invites exploration beyond your usual choice. There’s always a lively mix of regulars, families, and newcomers soaking up the relaxed atmosphere.
My first visit, I was tipped off by a local about the “famous cut”—those rectangular slices are a hallmark, and they carry their toppings right to the edge. The crust is pillowy but holds up, and you can taste the care in every bite.
The Sicilian Pizza is an absolute must at Twin Trees Too. Each square is thick, soft, and topped generously. It’s the slice that captures why Syracuse keeps putting this spot near the top of its pizza lists.
More Things to Try in Syracuse, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What pizza style is Syracuse known for?
Syracuse is famous for its classic New York-style pizza—thin, crisp crust, gooey cheese, and a sauce that leans tangy. You’ll also find thicker Sicilian pies and creative specialty pizzas around town.
Are there good places for vegan or vegetarian pizza in Syracuse?
Absolutely. Strong Hearts Cafe is a standout for delicious plant-based pizzas, and many other pizzerias offer inventive veggie pies or can customize to fit dietary needs.
Who delivers pizza late at night in Syracuse?
Many spots—like Uncle Chubby’s Pizza and Varsity Pizza—take orders late into the night, perfect for post-game cravings or a last-minute study snack.
Can I find gluten-free pizza options in Syracuse?
Yes, several pizzerias such as Apizza Regionale and Twin Trees Too offer gluten-free crusts. It’s always best to call ahead to check availability.
What’s the most popular pizza topping in Syracuse?
Pepperoni is tops for traditionalists, but Buffalo chicken pizza has become a local favorite for those looking for a bit of heat and something unique to the area.
Is there a best time to visit pizzerias in Syracuse for a fresh pie?
Early evenings are prime time, but most places keep slices coming hot throughout the day. Fridays and weekends draw larger crowds, so plan accordingly if you’re looking for a quick bite.