Looking for the best pizza in Sykesville, MD isn’t just about finding a meal; it’s about tracking down where the locals gather and flavors come alive. I’ve spent more than enough evenings in Sykesville with a hot box in my lap, comparing the delicate crackle of the crust, the zip of tomato sauce, and which pizzerias actually hit that golden cheese-to-topping ratio. It’s one thing to grab a quick slice—quite another to know where that slice is worth your time.
Each spot on this list has something that stands out. Maybe you crave that soft New York fold, a creative, artisan twist, or the nostalgic taste of classic pepperoni. You’ll find honest insights here—not just names but what makes a pizza joint worth a visit. Whether you’re a deep-dish enthusiast or living for thin and crispy, let me show you where Sykesville’s pizza scene really delivers.
1. Franks Pizza
Frank’s Pizza sits quietly off Liberty Road, but its reputation hums through Sykesville. The crust here has a satisfying chew—not too thick or thin—which makes every bite memorable. On a rainy day, I ducked inside for a quick lunch and ended up losing track of time over a hot, bubbling Margherita pizza. The basil tasted fresh, the sauce leaned just right on tang, and the cheese covered every inch.
If you’re stuck on what to order, the classic New York-style cheese pizza rarely disappoints. Looking for something bolder? Their Veggie Special is generous and layered, perfect for sharing. Frank’s adapts to any appetite, with vegan and gluten-free options always ready. For those who know pizza, this spot does the basics brilliantly.
2. New York J and P Pizza
New York J and P Pizza brings that classic slice experience to Sykesville. The first time I visited, I noticed the thin, foldable slices rolling out fast from the oven, just the way they should. There’s a lively, unpretentious feel inside, and the staff moves with a purpose that says they know what they’re doing.
What makes this spot stand out is their attention to balance. The sauce isn’t overbearing, the cheese is satisfyingly gooey, and the edges have a pleasant crisp. Their classic cheese pizza or the White Pizza are both local favorites for a reason. If you’re fan of veggie toppings, they don’t skimp—they pile them high on the Vegetarian Pizza for a meal that’s both colorful and filling.
3. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza on Liberty Road is where consistency meets convenience. On those busy evenings when I needed an easy dinner fix, their app made the whole process nearly effortless. The pizza always arrived warm, the crust pillowy with a slight crisp on the edge. There’s a comfort in knowing exactly what you’re going to get every single time.
The magic is in the details: their fresh, original dough and signature sauce create a base that can handle almost any topping. I’m partial to their Garden Fresh Pizza—the blend of veggies and tangy sauce just works. The cheese pizza also captures that classic Papa Johns flavor profile. If you like to dip, that signature garlic sauce turns every bite into something extra.
4. Amante Pizza & Pasta
Amante Pizza & Pasta feels like the kind of place locals want to keep secret. The moment you walk in, there’s a comforting aroma that hints you’re in for something good. My first encounter here was a detour from my usual routine—their classic cheese pie grabbed my attention with its golden edge and soft, savory chew.
What makes Amante stand out is their ability to deliver a crust that holds up, but lets the flavors shine. Their Margherita Pizza is a highlight, with bright tomato and fresh basil coming through on every slice. If you’re eager to explore other options, try their Veggie Pizza. Simple, well-executed, and a testament to what great ingredients can do.
5. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s on Liberty Road in Sykesville has mastered the art of fast, familiar pizza. On nights when schedules get chaotic and cravings hit, I know a call to Domino’s means a reliable dinner. The ordering process is simple and the delivery always on time, with pizza that arrives piping hot and ready to eat.
Their Handmade Pan pizza is a winner—thick, buttery, and cheesy in every slice. If you want something classic, the Thin Crust Veggie Pizza packs flavor without feeling heavy. Domino’s stands out for its ability to customize anything, making it easy to satisfy everyone at the table. When value and speed matter, this spot delivers on both every time.
6. Serra Brothers Sports Pub
Serra Brothers Sports Pub takes pizza night and gives it a lively twist. I once stopped in during a game and quickly realized the pizza here isn’t just a side note to the atmosphere—it’s a highlight. The crust is crisp, the sauce is bright, and the cheese melts in all the right ways.
What sets Serra Brothers apart is that every pie comes out of the oven with a personality. Their classic Cheese or Veggie Pizza is a safe bet, but the real move is to customize your own. Sykesville locals rave about the fresh toppings that add a distinct crunch and flavor. It’s a great spot if you want good food with a side of energy and sports.
7. MOD Pizza
MOD Pizza puts you in control of your pizza destiny. Every visit, I find myself experimenting with new topping combos, knowing the price stays the same no matter how creative I get. The staff at the Sykesville location bring good energy, greeting you with patience and almost daring you to try something unexpected.
What’s unique here is customization—over 40 toppings and endless mix-and-match possibilities. I recommend trying the classic MOD Veggie or building your own with a gluten-friendly crust for something lighter. The pizzas come out fast and always have that just-right balance of crisp base and bubbling cheese. If you like variety and creativity served hot, MOD Pizza keeps things fresh every time.
8. Ledo Pizza
Ledo Pizza in Sykesville is a nod to tradition, making square pies that break away from the ordinary. The first time I tasted Ledo’s, that unmistakable flaky crust and sweet sauce combo instantly set it apart. It’s a style that almost begs to be shared and is easy to split among friends or family.
The real standout is their Original Square Cheese Pizza, where every square packs a bit of the tiled, crispy edge and soft center. If you’re in the mood for more, their Veggie Pizza layers on just the right amount of fresh toppings without overwhelming the base. Perfect for a casual lunch or big gathering, Ledo Pizza manages to be both unique and reliably good.
9. Frank’s Pizza
(410) 795-9507Call
Frank’s Pizza on Liberty Road is what many locals consider their go-to for classic pies done right. My recent visit left a mark—the pie had a golden crust, just chewy enough, with gooey cheese layered over a sauce that had a noticeable, fresh zip. The staff were quick, and the atmosphere relaxed, so it’s the kind of spot where you can unwind and enjoy your slice.
Frank’s stands out because of their attention to the basics—each pizza is consistent, flavorful, and never skimps on toppings. Their Cheese Pizza is an excellent starting point, but the Veggie Special is a must if you want something hearty but still light. When you want solid, satisfying pizza in Sykesville, Frank’s delivers every time.
10. Belissimo’s
Belissimo’s is a neighborhood staple for anyone craving straightforward, delicious pizza at a price that isn’t intimidating. My first slice came on a weeknight, and it turned a forgettable day into a comfort food win. Their crust strikes a balance—not too doughy, not too crisp—making it easy to enjoy more than you planned.
What sets Belissimo’s apart is their ability to deliver solid flavor without unnecessary frills. Their Plain Cheese Pizza serves as a reminder that simple, quality ingredients do most of the talking. If you like a little variety, the Veggie Pizza layers generous toppings over their tangy tomato base. Friendly service completes the picture, so this spot is easy to turn into a habit.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places for dine-in or takeout in Sykesville, MD?
Sykesville has several standout spots for both dine-in and takeout, including Frank’s Pizza, Ledo Pizza, MOD Pizza, and Belissimo’s. Each offers unique flavors and a range of menu options to suit every preference.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Sykesville?
Yes, many pizzerias in Sykesville offer vegetarian pizzas, and several—like Frank’s Pizza, MOD Pizza, and Amante Pizza & Pasta—also have vegan and gluten-friendly choices on the menu.
Which pizza spot in Sykesville is best for families?
Ledo Pizza and Belissimo’s are both family-friendly with ample seating, classic menu options, and a welcoming atmosphere that keeps everyone happy.
Where can I order gluten-free pizza in Sykesville?
MOD Pizza and Frank’s Pizza both serve gluten-free crusts, making them a top pick for anyone looking for gluten-free slices.
Is there delivery available from Sykesville pizza places?
Most local pizza spots, including Domino’s, Papa John’s, and New York J and P Pizza, offer delivery for maximum convenience.