Finding the best pizza in Sherman, TX, is more than just a craving—it’s an adventure waiting to satisfy your taste buds. Having explored the local scene extensively, I can say confidently that Sherman offers a diverse range of pizzerias, each with its own unique twist on this beloved dish. Whether you prefer a classic Italian-style pie or inventive toppings that push the boundaries, there’s something here for everyone. My own experiences trying various spots have consistently highlighted the quality, consistency, and genuine passion behind each oven-baked masterpiece.
What sets Sherman’s pizza scene apart is the variety and character each restaurant brings to the table. From family-friendly chains to cozy local joints, there’s a wealth of options that make choosing one the real challenge. This guide aims to simplify your search and point you toward the establishments that truly stand out. Ready to discover where to get the best slice? Let’s dive into Sherman’s top pizza places.
Where to find the best pizza in Sherman, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Sherman, TX:
- Italian Affair Pizza
- Palio’s Pizza Cafe
- Little Caesars
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Cellarman’s Pub & Brewery
- Cicis Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Chuck E. Cheese’s
- Pizza Hut
- Golden Corral
1. Italian Affair Pizza
Italian Affair Pizza in Sherman, TX, is a local gem known for its authentic and delightful Italian flavors. Nestled at 104 N Woods St, this cozy eatery offers a warm atmosphere perfect for both lunch and dinner. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, the welcoming staff ensures a memorable experience.
Having dined there, I was struck by the rich, savory aromas and the vibrant flavors of their pizza. What truly sets Italian Affair Pizza apart is their dedication to quality ingredients and traditional recipes. Their pies boast a perfectly crisp crust, a testament to their meticulous preparation.
Be sure to try their signature Margherita Pizza, a simple yet elegant dish that highlights the freshness of their basil and mozzarella. This pizza embodies the essence of Italian cuisine, making Italian Affair Pizza a must-visit in Sherman.
2. Palio’s Pizza Cafe
Palio’s Pizza Cafe in Sherman, TX, is renowned for its commitment to quality and fresh ingredients. Located at 865 E North Creek Dr, the restaurant offers a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for family meals or a casual dinner. The aroma of baking pizza immediately signals something special happening in the kitchen.
During my visit, I was impressed by how their dough, made from scratch daily, creates a light yet sturdy crust. Their signature pizzas are loaded with generous toppings and the finest 100% mozzarella cheese, delivering genuine flavor in every bite. I highly recommend the Margherita or their Veggie Lover’s pizza, as they beautifully showcase the restaurant’s dedication to fresh ingredients and classic techniques.
Palio’s truly stands out in Sherman for its balance of quality and quantity, making it a top choice for pizza lovers craving authenticity and flavor.
3. Little Caesars
If you’re craving affordable, fast, and delicious pizza, Little Caesars at 2114 Texoma Pkwy, Sherman, TX, is a must-visit. With quick service and a no-frills setup, it’s perfect for a casual lunch or dinner with friends or family. The atmosphere is simple, but the flavors are bold and satisfying.
I remember grabbing a Hot-N-Ready Classic Cheese Pizza after a long day—fresh, warm, and ready in minutes. It hit the spot without breaking the bank. The staff was friendly and efficient, making the experience even better.
What makes Little Caesars stand out is their consistent quality and unbeatable value. Try the ExtraMostBestest Pizza, featuring more cheese and toppings than the classic—a true flavor upgrade.
Skip the frills and go for flavor. Little Caesars delivers big taste, fast.
4. Papa Johns Pizza
If you’re craving delicious, high-quality pizza in Sherman, TX, look no further than Papa Johns Pizza at 2918 N Sam Rayburn Fwy. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of fresh dough and perfectly seasoned sauce sets the tone for a satisfying meal. The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and the food always hits the spot.
What makes this location stand out is their commitment to “Better Ingredients. Better Pizza.” Every bite of their handcrafted pizza reflects fresh, never-frozen dough, vine-ripened tomato sauce, and premium toppings. It’s easy to taste the difference!
I always go for the Garden Fresh Pizza or the classic Cheese Pizza, both rich in flavor and perfect for a halal-friendly option. Pair it with their garlic knots—you won’t regret it!
Whether you’re grabbing lunch, dinner, or a family meal to-go, Papa Johns in Sherman delivers consistent quality with every order.
5. Cellarman’s Pub & Brewery
Cellarman’s Pub & Brewery in Sherman, TX, has been serving up top-notch craft food and ales since 1998. Located at 2130 Texoma Pkwy, this lively spot combines a welcoming atmosphere with a reputation for quality. The wood-fired pizzas, in particular, stand out as a highlight on their menu.
During my visit, I enjoyed their wood-fired pizza with fresh toppings and a crispy crust. The smoky flavor from the oven added a special touch that’s hard to find elsewhere. Their extensive selection of craft beers complements every bite.
What truly makes Cellarman’s special is their dedication to blending bold flavors and authentic brewing techniques. I recommend the Margherita pizza, which reflects their commitment to quality and classic Italian-inspired ingredients.
6. Cicis Pizza
Cicis Pizza, located on N Grand Ave in Sherman, TX, is a go-to spot for those craving variety without breaking the bank. With an all-you-can-eat setup and a laid-back atmosphere, it’s ideal for both quick lunches and casual dinners.
What sets Cicis apart is its unlimited buffet offering, featuring a wide selection of pizzas crafted with familiar, comforting flavors. I enjoyed the classic Pepperoni, but the Spinach Alfredo was the surprise favorite—creamy, cheesy, and just the right touch of savory.
The staff keeps the buffet fresh and stocked, making the experience smooth. For pizza lovers exploring Sherman, Cicis offers customizable options that reflect their motto: simple ingredients, satisfying flavor.
If you’re going, start with their Buffalo Chicken Pizza—zesty and bold, it’s a local favorite that captures Cicis’ fun, accessible style.
7. Domino’s Pizza
Looking for great pizza in Sherman? Visit Domino’s at 2301 Loy Lake Road. We’re passionate about delivering the best pizza experience, whether you prefer carryout or delivery. Try our thin, foldable New York Style pizza or the thick, Handmade Pan pizza. For something extra cheesy, go for our Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza.
Beyond pizza, we offer fan-favorite dishes like mac and cheese, salads, pasta, and chicken wings, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Our unbeatable deals provide great value, making it easy to enjoy more for less.
I love the Handmade Pan pizza for its rich, buttery crust and generous toppings. It’s a must-try that truly reflects Domino’s commitment to quality and taste. Order today and satisfy your cravings!
8. Chuck E. Cheese’s
Chuck E. Cheese’s at 201 N Walnut St in Sherman isn’t just a pizza spot—it’s a full-on experience. Known for its family-friendly atmosphere, it blends casual dining with arcade fun, making it a go-to for parents looking to entertain kids while grabbing a bite.
The pizza here leans classic: thin, crispy crusts with a generous layer of cheese and a mild, kid-approved sauce. If you’re ordering, go for the Cheese or Veggie Pizza—they’re simple, satisfying, and made to please a crowd. The crust has a light crunch, and the cheese pull is surprisingly solid.
What makes it stand out? It’s the combination of entertainment and consistency. You’re not just eating—you’re making memories, one slice at a time.
Website: chuckecheese.com | Phone: +1 903-892-2007
9. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut at 2020 Texoma Pkwy in Sherman delivers what it promises—familiar comfort with a side of convenience. Whether you’re grabbing a quick dinner or feeding a crowd, it’s a reliable stop for hot, cheesy satisfaction.
What sets it apart is the crust game. The Original Stuffed Crust® is a local favorite, packed with gooey cheese that doesn’t skimp. Pair it with the Veggie Lover’s® Pizza for a hearty, flavorful bite that stays true to Pizza Hut’s signature style.
Ordering is easy, and the service is consistent. I’ve swung by after a long day and left with a piping hot pie that hit the spot—no fuss, just solid pizza.
Website: pizzahut.com | Phone: +1 903-892-0303
10. Golden Corral
Golden Corral at 900 US Highway 82 E in Sherman offers a diverse dining experience with options spanning breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Known for its buffet style, it’s a great spot for families or groups who enjoy variety in one place.
What makes Golden Corral unique is its extensive selection, including Italian, American, steakhouse, and pizza. The pizza station provides fresh slices that are perfect for a quick, satisfying meal. The quality is consistent, with a range of toppings and flavors to choose from.
Personally, I found their pizza and fresh salads to be standout offerings—balancing hearty and healthy options. It’s a reliable destination for those looking for a plentiful, family-friendly meal with plenty of variety.
Website: goldencorral.com | Phone: +1 903-892-3366
More Things to Try in Sherman, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in Sherman, TX?
Sherman, TX, offers a variety of great pizza places. Some popular choices include Napoli’s Italian Restaurant, known for its authentic Italian pizza, and Cellarman’s Pub & Brewery, which offers unique pizza options with craft beer. Luigi’s Italian Cafe is another local favorite for its delicious pizza and cozy atmosphere.
2. Do any pizza places in Sherman, TX, offer delivery?
Yes, several pizza places in Sherman offer delivery services. Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Papa John’s are well-known for their delivery options. Local pizzerias like Napoli’s and Luigi’s often offer delivery through third-party services like DoorDash or Uber Eats.
3. Are there gluten-free pizza options available in Sherman, TX?
Many pizzerias in Sherman cater to gluten-free diets. Chains like Domino’s and Pizza Hut offer gluten-free crust options. For a local touch, Napoli’s Italian Restaurant also provides gluten-free pizzas upon request.
4. What are some unique or specialty pizzas I can try in Sherman, TX?
In Sherman, you can find a variety of specialty pizzas. Cellarman’s Pub & Brewery is known for its creative toppings and craft beer pairings. Napoli’s offers traditional Italian pizzas with unique toppings like prosciutto and arugula. You can also find interesting combinations at Palio’s Pizza Cafe, which offers gourmet pizzas with fresh ingredients.
5. Are there vegan pizza options in Sherman, TX?
Yes, many pizza places in Sherman are accommodating to vegan diets. Domino’s and Pizza Hut offer vegan crusts and toppings. You can also request vegan cheese at places like Luigi’s Italian Cafe and Palio’s Pizza Cafe.
6. Can I find halal pizza options in Sherman, TX?
While specific halal-certified pizza places might be limited, many restaurants are willing to accommodate dietary preferences by omitting non-halal ingredients. It’s best to call ahead and inquire about specific options at places like Napoli’s or Luigi’s.
7. What are the opening hours of pizza places in Sherman, TX?
Most pizza places in Sherman, like Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Papa John’s, open around 10 or 11 AM and close between 10 PM and midnight. Local spots like Napoli’s and Cellarman’s typically have similar hours but may vary, especially on weekends. It’s a good idea to check their websites or call for specific hours.
8. Are there any pizza buffet places in Sherman, TX?
Yes, Cici’s Pizza offers a popular pizza buffet with a variety of pizzas, salads, and desserts. It’s a great option for families and groups looking for an all-you-can-eat experience.