In Sellersburg, pizza isn’t just a meal—it’s a way for locals to unwind after a long week, enjoy a football night, or settle a family debate over “who picks dinner.” Having sampled slices across the area, I can tell you that the town’s pizzerias surprise you at every turn. From late-night cravings to a neighbor’s laid-back gathering, one thing is clear: Sellersburg takes its pizza seriously.
Whether you’re on the hunt for crust that crackles under your bite, unique house sauces, or the pure comfort of nostalgic flavors, this small town serves up pizza experiences worth remembering. I’ve tracked down the best places based on dough quality, sauce flavor, and the feel of a truly satisfying slice. If you’re after perfect pizza in Sellersburg, your solution might just be waiting a block or two away—let’s find it together.
1. Mazerella’s Upper Crust Pizza
Tucked along Indiana Avenue, Mazerella’s Upper Crust Pizza feels like the gold standard for pizza in Sellersburg. Step inside and the aroma alone draws you in, promising a meal that goes beyond basic take-out.
What sets Mazerella’s apart is the crust—crispy at the edge yet full and chewy beneath the toppings. Their signature Upper Crust Deluxe, loaded with fresh veggies and savory meats, deserves attention. Try their white garlic pizza if you crave a richer, creamier flavor profile.
The vibe is both relaxed and family-friendly, which makes it easy to linger longer than planned. If you’re seeking a memorable, local favorite, Mazerella’s is always a reliable bet.
2. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza at Heritage Square isn’t just about speed. Sure, their delivery is quick, but what keeps me coming back is their sheer consistency. Every slice is piping hot and carries that classic Domino’s flavor—tangy sauce, stretchy cheese, and a dough that holds up under pressure.
The menu has something for everyone. If you’ve never tried their Handmade Pan Pizza, start there. It packs a perfect crunch and a soft bite. For flavor seekers, the Parmesan Stuffed Crust is a must, rich and indulgent after a long day.
Cheesy bread is a must for sharing, and their range of vegetarian options makes it easy to include everyone. This spot’s all about delivering familiar comfort, whether you’re picking up or settling in for delivery night.
3. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Hunt Brothers Pizza is a true hidden gem tucked along Apple Leaf Lane. My first visit felt like I’d stumbled upon a well-kept community secret—friendly faces, a quick turnaround, and pizza that rivals the big chains in taste.
They offer a rare bonus: every topping is included at no extra charge. It’s fun to tailor your pie exactly the way you want. Craving something classic? Their cheese pizza offers a blissfully gooey bite and crisped edges.
If you like choices, opt for the original crust, which soaks up sauce, or go thin for that extra crunch. Hunt Brothers has a knack for keeping things simple while delivering quality and value in every slice.
4. Sir Dano’s Pizza Parlor
(812) 246-3346Call
Sir Dano’s Pizza Parlor is the kind of place you find once and then keep going back to. It’s been a local staple for years, promising genuine comfort and laid-back charm. Walking in, you’ll notice an old-school vibe—and the aroma of pizzas baking doesn’t hurt either.
This spot stands out for its almost legendary crust, golden and crisp but never tough. Their veggie pizza surprised me with its freshness and perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio, making each bite sing.
If you like a hearty pie, order the deluxe loaded with freshly cut toppings. It’s the sort of pizza that makes you slow down and savor the moment, whether dining in or carrying out for the family.
5. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza in Sellersburg delivers on its promise of “Better Ingredients. Better Pizza.” My experiences here have always been marked by the unmistakable scent of fresh dough and generous toppings, a combination that’s tough to ignore. The staff is quick to make you feel welcome, whether you’re grabbing takeout or waiting for delivery.
Their original crust remains a favorite of mine—fluffy yet crisp, built to handle plenty of toppings. If you enjoy bold flavors, try their Spicy Italian or fresh garden veggie pizzas. Both are loaded yet balanced, and every slice offers the taste of carefully chosen ingredients.
Order the garlic sauce on the side. It’s one of those small touches that somehow makes the entire meal linger in your memory long after the last bite.
6. Pizza King
Pizza King has earned its loyal following since 1956, and with just one slice, I understood why. There’s a retro charm here, a throwback to the days when pizza was simple but far from ordinary. Each visit feels like a nostalgic journey, with staff who seem to know your favorite order before you say it.
What makes Pizza King memorable is their crumbled sausage and signature red sauce, sweet and savory in all the right ways. Their pizza is cut into those little rectangles—somehow, it’s perfect for sharing. If you want something even heartier, their Stromboli Wrap Up has a reputation for good reason.
Craving a true local classic? A Pizza King pie is the move. It sets the bar for comfort food in the Sellersburg area.
7. Sherrilli’s Pizzeria
Sherrilli’s Pizzeria is more than a pizza stop—it’s a Sellersburg tradition where every bite feels crafted with care. My last visit, I noticed the genuine pride the team takes in prepping each pie, chatting up regulars as the oven works its magic.
Their square-cut pizzas are Sherrilli’s hallmark, and the sauce here is what pulls you in—bright, tangy, and never overpowering. Grab the classic cheese or load yours with fresh mushrooms and green peppers for extra kick.
If you want dependable, consistent pizza, Sherrilli’s is hard to top. The flavors reflect both their heritage and the town’s loyal community, creating a sense of home with every slice.
8. Bearno’s Pizza
Bearno’s Pizza brings a slice of classic Italian spirit just a short drive from Sellersburg. The dining room always buzzes, locals swapping stories while the thin-crust pies crisp up in the oven. I’ve found this is the kind of spot where even a plain cheese tastes like a celebration.
Their signature Bearno’s Special comes loaded with vibrant veggies and hearty, seasoned toppings. Each bite gives off a balanced mix of flavors, the cheese melting perfectly into the lively sauce. The crust, always golden, has the kind of crunch you end up chasing from slice to slice.
For a traditional experience, order the vegetable pizza or the famous Sicilian-style pie. Bearno’s makes sure every visit feels like a welcome home.
9. Toppt
Toppt delivers a refreshing spin on the pizza scene near Sellersburg. My first time here, the staff patiently walked me through the build-your-own options, letting creativity (and appetite) take the lead. Think craft pizza with an inviting, modern edge.
What sets Toppt apart is their bold approach—choose a crust, select a sauce, and stack on as many toppings as you want. The ingredients are fresh, and the toppings range from classic to clever, which makes every visit unique. Their thin-and-crispy base gets high marks for holding up under every layered bite.
The veggie-packed “Garden” pizza is a standout, but you can’t go wrong building your own masterpiece. Toppt captures the spirit of pizza as a personal adventure.
10. Godfather’s Pizza
Godfather’s Pizza at Jeffersonville, housed inside Huck’s, delivers hearty, crowd-pleasing pies just a short drive from Sellersburg. Each visit feels friendly and efficient, ideal if you want quality without a long wait. I always notice how their pizzas arrive steaming hot and generously topped—the kitchen doesn’t cut corners.
Their thick, chewy crust is a calling card. Try their all-meat or veggie pizza for a flavor-packed combo that truly fills you up. The sauce has a bold edge, and every bite delivers a proper balance of chew and crunch.
If you’re after classic comfort and great value, Godfather’s is a go-to. It’s perfect for feeding a group or picking up a satisfying weeknight meal.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated pizza places in Sellersburg, IN?
Some local favorites include Mazerella’s Upper Crust Pizza, Sir Dano’s Pizza Parlor, and Sherrilli’s Pizzeria. Chains like Domino’s and Papa Johns are also popular for convenience and consistency.
Are there any spots for gluten-free pizza in Sellersburg?
A few chain locations such as Domino’s and Papa Johns offer gluten-free options. Always check with the restaurant for details on crust types and kitchen practices.
Which pizza restaurants offer delivery in Sellersburg?
Most national chains—including Domino’s, Papa Johns, Pizza Hut, and Little Caesars—provide delivery. Some local shops may offer it as well, depending on the day and time.
Where can I get a classic thin-crust pizza?
Mazerella’s Upper Crust and Toppt are known for their well-crafted thin crust. Both let you load on your favorite toppings without sacrificing crispness.
Do Sellersburg pizza places have vegetarian choices?
Yes, nearly every shop has vegetarian pizzas available, often featuring a mix of fresh vegetables, classic cheeses, and signature sauces.
What are some must-try specialty pizzas in Sellersburg?
Signature choices like the Upper Crust Deluxe at Mazerella’s, the Garden pizza at Toppt, and Bearno’s Special offer bold combinations unique to each restaurant’s style.