Pizza cravings don’t wait for special occasions. In Rhinebeck, NY, ordinary days turn into memorable ones with a single slice. I remember wandering down Market Street, cool air in my face, the aroma of dough wafting from a tiny pizzeria. Each bite was clear proof that Rhinebeck takes its pizza seriously—thin crust, bubbling cheese, the kind of pie that stays in your memory longer than you expect.
Finding the best pizza here isn’t about luck; it’s about knowing where to look. Rhinebeck’s pizza scene surprises you. One spot delivers classic NY-style slices with a perfect fold, another serves pies so loaded with fresh toppings you can taste the garden. Whether you love tradition or prefer modern twists, this guide covers the standouts, the hidden gems, and the reliable favorites. Let’s get straight to the most satisfying part—discovering where your next great pizza is waiting.
Where to find the best pizza in Rhinebeck, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Rhinebeck, NY:
- Pizzeria Posto
- Village Pizza of Rhinebeck
- Four Brothers Pizza Inn & Restaurant
- C J’s
- Captain Pizza
- Francesca’s Restaurant
- Two Brothers Pizza II Inc
- Cj’s Pizza Italian Restaurant
- C J’s Italian Restaurants
- C J’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
1. Pizzeria Posto
Set on East Market Street, Pizzeria Posto draws in both locals and out-of-towners. The space buzzes, especially at dinner, with a wood-fired oven taking center stage. Passing by, I once gave in to curiosity and left with a new standard for pizza.
Their crust sets them apart—thin, chewy, with a distinct smokiness. Every pie glows with a charred edge that’s hard to forget. The Margherita, with its fresh mozzarella and snappy basil, shows off everything Posto does well. Their inventive seasonal toppings are always a conversation starter.
Diners with dietary preferences find plenty of choices, from vegetarian to gluten-free pizzas. For a real taste of Rhinebeck, start with a classic pie and try the rotating specials. It’s pizza, elevated, yet simple enough for any craving.
2. Village Pizza of Rhinebeck
Village Pizza of Rhinebeck feels like Rhinebeck’s living room. The staff greet you with easy conversation, and the aroma of pizza fills every inch of the cozy space. My first visit happened by accident—a hungry afternoon—and it turned out to be the highlight of my trip uptown.
Their specialty slices are the draw here. I always go for the veggie slice, layered with crisp peppers and broccoli, or a classic plain slice that lets the sauce’s tang shine. The pizzas have a soft, airy crust that holds up well, even on a heavy pour of toppings.
If you’re looking for simple comfort, this spot delivers, literally and figuratively. Grab a pie, and you might just linger longer than planned.
3. Four Brothers Pizza Inn & Restaurant
Four Brothers Pizza Inn & Restaurant is a Rhinebeck staple, tucked along Route 9G. I stopped in on a rainy evening, and the warmth inside made it easy to linger. The space is classic—red booths, friendly staff, the hum of families sharing a meal.
What sets Four Brothers apart is the balance in their crust: crisp on the outside, soft within. The Greek-inspired Four Brothers Special, loaded with fresh veggies and a light sprinkle of feta, stays in my mind. Their white pizza, creamy and garlicky, is another standout.
If you want table service with your pizza, this is your spot. Settle in, take your time, and try the house special for true local flavor.
4. C J’s
C J’s is the kind of unpretentious spot that makes you feel like a regular on your first visit. Tucked along Old Post Road, it’s a favorite for both early risers and those craving a laid-back dinner. I walked in during lunch and found the atmosphere buzzing with the rhythm of a well-loved hometown hangout.
Their pizza is straightforward and satisfying, with a sauce that’s bright and not too heavy. The cheese pizza here is a local go-to—the perfect balance between chewy and crisp. Don’t skip their veggie slice, either; the fresh toppings give it a garden-fresh snap.
C J’s casual vibe and reliable menu make it a place where cravings are satisfied, no questions asked. With breakfast, lunch, and dinner covered, you’ll always find a reason to stop in.
5. Captain Pizza
(845) 876-3435Call
Captain Pizza isn’t flashy, but it nails what matters—flavor and value. With a spot on Spring Brook Avenue, it’s the place locals turn to for a quick, budget-friendly meal. I landed here after a long day, hands full of change, and left satisfied, wallet intact.
Their crust leans classic New York: foldable, just a bit chewy, perfect for grabbing on the go. Slices come hot from the oven with a generous layer of cheese that stretches on every bite. The plain cheese or a veggie slice are easy standouts, simple yet done right.
Service is quick and friendly. If you need a no-frills, honest slice, Captain Pizza serves up straight-up comfort every time.
6. Francesca’s Restaurant
(845) 876-2129Call
Francesca’s Restaurant sits right on Route 9, welcoming travelers and locals with a classic red-brick storefront. My stop here after a rambling drive turned out to be more than a refueling—it was a full-on pizza experience. The place buzzes with regulars chatting and sharing stories across tables.
The thin-crust pizza here is crisp and flavorful, holding its own against any craving. Their Margherita pizza is a must: ripe tomato, creamy mozzarella, and fresh basil combine for a balanced bite every time. The crust is that rare mix—light, but strong enough to hold all the goodness together.
With a menu that focuses on quality, Francesca’s delivers comfort food that goes beyond expectations. If you’re after a slice that keeps things simple and honest, start here.
7. Two Brothers Pizza II Inc
Two Brothers Pizza II Inc sits on Spring Brook Avenue, calling out with a classic, welcoming sign. On my last visit, the steady flow of regulars picking up orders said all you need to know about their reputation. There’s no rush here—just that easy, hometown energy and the scent of fresh dough rising in the oven.
What makes Two Brothers memorable is their commitment to generous portions and bold flavors. Their classic cheese pizza is gooey and satisfying, with a sauce that hints at just the right amount of herbs. The veggie-loaded slice stands out for its freshness and crisp edge.
If you want a hearty lunch or a pizza that can hold its own at dinner, Two Brothers delivers consistency that makes repeat visits a given.
8. Cj’s Pizza Italian Restaurant
Cj’s Pizza Italian Restaurant stands as a friendly fixture on Old Post Road, warmly blending the best of American comfort with Italian tradition. I stopped here with friends on a chilly afternoon, and the staff treated us like old neighbors, which set the tone for the whole meal.
The pizza here is classic, with a soft, chewy crust and just the right amount of sauce. The Margherita, topped with fresh basil and creamy mozzarella, hits that perfect spot between rustic and refined. For something different, the veggie pizza shines with plenty of crisp, garden-fresh toppings.
This spot is one of those rare places that keeps both the regulars and newcomers happy. Perfect for an unhurried meal after a long day.
9. C J’s Italian Restaurants
C J’s Italian Restaurants has a long-standing spot in Rhinebeck, with a homey atmosphere that makes it easy to settle in for a meal. I wandered in on a weekend evening when the dining room hummed with laughter and clinking glasses—classic signs it’s a local favorite.
Their pizza truly delivers on the Italian promise: thin, sturdy crust, tangy tomato sauce, and well-melted cheese. For something classic, the plain cheese pizza is always a winner. But you can’t go wrong with their veggie pizza, which features bright, fresh toppings that show off the quality of their ingredients.
Whether you’re after a simple slice or a tableful for a group, C J’s covers all the bases, blending old-school charm with reliable flavor.
10. C J’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
C J’s Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is tucked away on Old Post Road, offering a welcoming place for pizza fans and Italian food lovers alike. The dining room always buzzes with locals catching up over their favorite pies. My own visit was on a chilly evening, and a hot slice made it feel like home right away.
The pizza here packs a punch with a golden, slightly crisp crust and tangy, flavorful sauce. Their Margherita is a top pick—fresh mozzarella and basil balance every bite, while the veggie pie always comes loaded and never soggy.
Good for groups or a quiet slice solo, this spot delivers on both taste and hospitality. Satisfaction here comes with every fresh, mouthwatering slice.
More Things to Try in Rhinebeck, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the best pizza place in Rhinebeck, NY?
That depends on your style. Pizzeria Posto is famous for wood-fired crust and fresh ingredients, while Village Pizza of Rhinebeck is loved for classic comfort slices. Four Brothers Pizza Inn & Restaurant is a go-to if you want table service and a family vibe.
Where can I find vegetarian or vegan pizza in Rhinebeck?
Several spots cater to special diets. Pizzeria Posto offers vegan and vegetarian pizzas, and Village Pizza has plenty of veggie options. Just ask for details—these kitchens are used to customizing orders.
Which pizza place is best for quick takeout?
Captain Pizza and Two Brothers Pizza II Inc are both reliable for fast, tasty takeout. Their pizzas hold up well for a trip home and don’t skimp on size or flavor.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Rhinebeck?
Absolutely. Pizzeria Posto has gluten-free crusts, and other spots can usually accommodate if you call ahead and check.
Is there a late-night pizza spot in Rhinebeck?
While Rhinebeck tends to quiet down early, some pizzerias offer extended evening hours, especially on weekends. Call ahead for hours to be sure you won’t miss out on a late slice.