Best Pizza in Rehoboth Beach, DE

I first discovered the pizza gems of Rehoboth Beach during a quiet stroll along the boardwalk. The aroma of fresh dough and melting cheese lured me into cozy pizzerias where every bite told a story. I have sampled many slices, and each one highlights a unique twist on this classic dish.

This guide reveals the finest pizza spots in Rehoboth Beach, DE. I share what made these locales memorable and reliable. Clear descriptions and honest opinions help you choose your next perfect slice.

1. Crust & Craft

Crust & Craft is a charming pizzeria on Coastal Hwy known for its warm ambience and culinary flair. Their menu brings classic Italian tastes together with subtle American twists. I was impressed by the inviting décor and attentive service.

The pizza here stands out because each slice is carefully prepared using fresh, high-quality ingredients. The perfectly baked crust and balanced toppings capture the essence of pizza in Rehoboth Beach, DE.

On my visit, I sampled their signature round pizza, which presented a delightful harmony of flavors. The restaurant also offers vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options, reflecting a thoughtful approach to diverse tastes.

2. Louie’s Pizza

Louie’s Pizza has been a staple in Rehoboth Beach since 1974, offering a slice of local tradition with every dish. The restaurant’s enduring charm shines through its timeless menu of pizza, subs, and grinders.

I recall enjoying their classic pizza on a cool evening. The perfectly baked crust, tangy sauce, and fresh toppings created an authentic taste of pizza in Rehoboth Beach, DE. Each bite reflects a blend of tradition and creative flair that distinguishes Louie’s.

With its casual vibe and friendly service, Louie’s Pizza brings a comforting sense of connection to the community. It’s a place where every dish tells a story.

3. Touch of Italy

Touch of Italy brings a slice of New York tradition to Delaware. Rooted in the flavors of Arthur Avenue, this eatery offers an authentic Italian experience. I enjoyed a quiet lunch here, marveling at the well-crafted dishes and inviting ambiance.

Their internationally recognized brick oven pizza is a standout. The crisp crust, fresh toppings, and perfect balance of flavors reflect their dedication to quality and heritage in every mouthful.

The restaurant also offers classic delights like chicken parm and homemade eclairs. Every dish celebrates traditional recipes while accommodating diverse dietary preferences. Touch of Italy is an ideal spot to savor pizza in Rehoboth Beach, DE.

4. Grotto Pizza

Grotto Pizza offers a lively setting along Rehoboth Ave, drawing guests in with its modern yet relaxed style. I remember enjoying a casual dinner here, where the ambiance perfectly complemented their delicious fare.

Their pizza is a must-try, combining a tender, crispy crust with fresh, savory toppings. This combination embodies the best of pizza in Rehoboth Beach, DE, providing a satisfying taste that stands out among local options.

With a variety of dishes and options for vegetarians, vegans, and gluten-free guests, Grotto Pizza caters to diverse tastes. Their commitment to quality and versatility makes it a clear favorite for a late-night bite or a relaxing meal.

5. Grotto Pizza

Grotto Pizza on the Boardwalk at Baltimore Ave. offers a delightful mix of awesome pizza and a cozy ambience. I enjoyed the relaxed vibe here during a lively lunch outing.

Their signature pizza shines with its crispy crust and fresh toppings, making it one of the top choices for pizza in Rehoboth Beach, DE. Every slice delivers a perfect balance of flavors that reflects their commitment to quality.

With a menu that suits vegetarians and those seeking classic Italian fare, Grotto Pizza is an ideal spot for a satisfying meal. A must-try is their classic pie, a dish that perfectly combines tradition and taste.

6. Grotto Pizza

Grotto Pizza at 17 Surf Ave South Boardwalk offers an inviting vibe that instantly makes you feel at home. On a recent visit, I was impressed by their friendly service and modern setting.

Their handcrafted pizza stands out with a perfectly crisp crust and fresh toppings that capture the true essence of quality pizza in Rehoboth Beach, DE. I highly recommend the classic Margherita pizza; its balanced flavors and simplicity wow every time.

Ideal for lunch, dinner, or a late-night bite, Grotto Pizza consistently delivers a satisfying experience you won’t forget.

7. Pete’s Steak Shop

Pete’s Steak Shop in Rehoboth Beach offers a unique fusion of American classics and memorable pizza creations. I was impressed by the welcoming atmosphere and attentive service during my recent visit.

The steak shop stands out with its diverse menu that caters even to pizza lovers. Their handcrafted pizza features a crispy crust and fresh toppings, capturing the essence of quality pizza in Rehoboth Beach, DE.

I highly recommend trying their signature pizza—a delightful blend of flavors that mirrors the shop’s commitment to excellence and versatility. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty meal or a satisfying slice, Pete’s offers a distinctive dining experience.

8. Ava’s Pizzeria & Wine Bar – Rehoboth Beach

Ava’s Pizzeria & Wine Bar – Rehoboth Beach is the newest gem on Baltimore Ave, just a block from the ocean. I visited on a sunny day and was captivated by the open garage doors that let in the refreshing sea breeze.

The inviting, fun atmosphere makes it easy to relax and enjoy your meal. Their signature brick oven pizza, with its crispy crust and fresh toppings, stands out as one of the best pizza offerings in Rehoboth Beach, DE.

Pair your pizza with a glass of wine for a perfect dining experience. The blend of quality ingredients and coastal charm truly sets Ava’s apart.

9. Dalmata Italiano

Dalmata Italiano, located at 28 Wilmington Ave Unit E, offers an authentic Italian dining experience in Rehoboth Beach, DE. I was impressed by the warm ambiance and inviting décor during my recent dinner visit.

Their handcrafted pizza truly stands out. With a perfectly baked crust and fresh, high-quality toppings, every bite reflects tradition and excellence while strictly adhering to halal guidelines.

I highly recommend ordering the classic Margherita pizza. Its balanced flavors and commitment to quality make it a standout dish, showcasing Dalmata Italiano’s dedication to genuine Italian flavor.

10. Pizza Villa

Pizza Villa offers a cozy, budget-friendly spot in the Midway Shopping Center, perfect for a quick and satisfying meal. I recently grabbed a slice while on a casual outing, and the friendly service made the experience even better.

Their pizza stands out with a crispy crust and fresh, flavorful toppings, making it a top choice for pizza in Rehoboth Beach, DE. Every bite reflects quality and commitment to traditional recipes while adhering to halal guidelines.

I highly recommend their signature pizza, which perfectly blends taste and value. It’s an ideal pick for both dine-in and takeout.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Q: What are some popular pizza places in Rehoboth Beach, DE?
A: You can find a range of options from classic pizzerias to modern Italian eateries. Restaurants like Ava’s Pizzeria & Wine Bar, Pizza Villa, and Grotto Pizza are favorites for their unique styles and quality ingredients.

• Q: Are there vegetarian-friendly pizza options available?
A: Yes, many local spots offer delicious vegetarian pizzas loaded with fresh veggies and herbs, ensuring you enjoy a flavorful meal that complies with halal guidelines.

• Q: Can I order pizza for delivery or takeout in Rehoboth Beach, DE?
A: Absolutely! Most pizza restaurants in the area provide both delivery and takeout options, making it convenient to enjoy a meal at home or on the go.

• Q: What is the typical price range for pizza in Rehoboth Beach, DE?
A: Prices vary widely—from budget-friendly slices at casual spots to more gourmet options at upscale pizzerias—ensuring there’s something for every taste and budget.