When you mention pizza in Port Washington, the locals don’t hesitate—they start sharing stories, not just restaurant names. This charming Long Island spot is a quiet battleground where crispy crusts, bubbling cheese, and secret sauces fuel friendly debates. Finding the best pizza here isn’t about picking the flashiest storefront, but seeking out dough with personality and toppings that hit that sweet spot between classic and inventive.
Having spent weekends wandering Main Street with the singular goal of tracking down the perfect slice, I’ve landed in tiny pizzerias that deserve world stages and dipped into neighborhood favorites with decades of loyal fans. This list isn’t just about who gets the cheese-to-crust ratio right—it’s about places where one bite makes you pause and reassess your pizza expectations. If you’re ready for a slice of Port Washington that goes beyond the obvious, let’s dig in.
Where to find the best pizza in Port Washington, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Port Washington, NY:
- Salvatore’s Coal Oven Pizzeria
- Carlos Pizza
- Gino’s Pizzeria
- Bellisimo Pizzeria
- Pepe Rosso
- Amalfi Ristorante and Pizzeria
- Bellissimo Pizzeria & Restaurant
- La Piccola Liguria
- Gino’s Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
1. Salvatore’s Coal Oven Pizzeria
You know Salvatore’s Coal Oven Pizzeria is different the moment you walk in and catch that scent rising from the coal-fired oven. Classic, thin crust with a slight smokiness—it’s the kind of pizza that could turn anyone into a regular. Their dough gets just the right amount of char, and the cheese has a rich, almost buttery flavor.
Try the Margherita. The fresh basil and San Marzano tomato sauce taste—well, real, not just toppings but a statement. I once ordered the white pizza on a whim, and the ricotta-to-mozzarella balance left an impression. The veggie options also stack up, so everyone at the table gets a bite that feels thoughtfully made.
For a quick lunch, grab a slice. For dinner, settle in and watch pizza become the main event.
2. Carlos Pizza
Carlos Pizza is the mainstay you’ll hear about from anyone who’s lived in Port Washington for more than a week. Their New York-style slices have a near-legendary crunch—thin, foldable, and satisfyingly crisp at the tip. The atmosphere knows how to keep things simple, with friendly staff who remember your order if you stick around.
Order the classic cheese slice first. You’ll taste that balance of tangy sauce and gooey cheese that brings you back for more. I once tried their veggie slice on a whim and ended up recommending it to almost everyone I know. Their crust has that perfect, just-chewy-enough quality.
Delivery, takeout, or a sit-down—Carlos keeps it consistent. Sometimes, that’s exactly what you need.
3. Gino’s Pizzeria
Gino’s Pizzeria is easy to spot—a steady stream of regulars and newcomers means they’re always tossing dough. This is a place where every slice shows off that balanced, golden crust and tangy sauce that’s just sweet enough to keep things interesting. The aroma coming from their oven is hard to walk past on Main Street.
I still remember my first Grandma slice here. It’s a standout: thin, square, covered in a vibrant layer of tomato and fresh basil ribbons. Perfect for those who love a clean, simple, satisfying bite. Their veggie pie is always piled high and never stingy with toppings.
Gino’s works for a quick slice or a relaxed meal—just grab what calls to you and see what local pride tastes like.
4. Bellisimo Pizzeria
Bellisimo Pizzeria is tucked into Soundview Market Place, but word travels fast about their bold pies. Each pizza here arrives with a crust that’s just the right mix of chewy and crisp, and their cheese coverage borders on luxurious. The staff are laid-back and quick with a recommendation if you need one.
If you want a real treat, order their spinach and mushroom pizza. The toppings are always fresh, and the flavors blend with their sauce in a way that feels thoughtful. I remember stopping in for a late lunch and leaving pleasantly surprised by the slices—hot, hearty, and flavorful.
Dine-in and enjoy the warm, unfussy setting. Bellisimo delivers comfort that doesn’t try too hard.
5. Pepe Rosso
Pepe Rosso blends pizzeria charm with a sit-down feel. Step past the pizza counter and find a cozy dining area dressed in bold murals—it gives you room to settle in and enjoy your meal. There’s nothing flashy here, just quick service and a genuine neighborhood mood.
The pizza shines brightest. Try their veggie or margherita pies for a snapshot of their approach: crisp, bubbly crust and sauce with real depth. I once split a pie with friends and it disappeared before I finished my second slice.
Pepe Rosso is where you wander in hungry, and leave both full and comforted. If you crave a low-key night and honest flavors, this spot delivers exactly that.
6. Amalfi Ristorante and Pizzeria
Amalfi Ristorante and Pizzeria feels like a step into a family home with its inviting, bustling energy. The pizza crusts here are crafted with care—thin, slightly crisp, and sturdy enough for generous toppings. There’s always a hum of regulars chatting, hinting you’ve found a trusted spot.
The white pizza is the move. Garlicky, creamy ricotta with a scattering of spinach makes for a slice that’s both rich and fresh. On cold days, I gravitate toward their veggie pie, which always arrives piping hot and piled high with fresh toppings.
Dine in or take out, you’ll leave thinking about what you’ll order next time. Amalfi’s does classic Italian flavors without ever feeling routine.
7. Bellissimo Pizzeria & Restaurant
Bellissimo Pizzeria & Restaurant nails the balance between casual hangout and real Italian comfort. The crust is their calling card—thin enough for a snap, thick enough for real satisfaction. A friend convinced me to drop by on a gray afternoon, and I’ve been thinking about their pizza ever since.
Go for the vegetable pie. Fresh, well-seasoned, and generously adorned, it gives you everything you could want in a Port Washington pizza. If you have time to linger, grab a seat and watch as the pies leave the oven—each one comes out bubbling and golden.
Here, it’s never just about filling up. Bellissimo offers food that keeps conversations going and brings you back for “just one more” slice.
8. La Piccola Liguria
La Piccola Liguria brings a dose of Italian charm to Shore Road. More than a simple pizzeria, this spot treats pizza like an art form, with classic Italian flavors at the center of every pie and plenty of vegetarian and gluten-free options. Soft lighting and bustling tables make it perfect for both families and date nights.
Try the Ligurian-inspired pizza. It’s just what you want if you crave something a little different—think thin crust, fresh herbs, and a drizzle of olive oil that lifts the whole dish. I once shared a pizza and a salad here for brunch; each bite felt both elevated and comforting.
La Piccola Liguria keeps tradition alive, but never lets the menu feel predictable.
9. Gino’s Pizza
Gino’s Pizza on Main Street is a slice of old-school Port Washington—warm, friendly, and always buzzing. Here, you get pizza with the perfect fold: chewy up top, crisp at the bottom, and layered with just enough sauce to keep you coming back. Walking in always brings a wave of nostalgia, no matter which name locals call it by.
The Sicilian pie is a go-to. Thick crust, airy in the middle, and covered with a blanket of cheese, it’s best shared with friends who know how to appreciate a real corner slice. On the thinner side, their classic cheese pizza is simple and honest, just as it should be.
Gino’s feels like a part of the town’s history—stop by and you’ll understand why the regulars never stray far.
10. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Main Street knows how to make a craving easy to satisfy. This spot is about consistency and speed, which sometimes is all you really want on a busy night. Whether you dine in or order delivery, the process is streamlined and their deals make a group order painless.
The classic thin-crust is my standard pick. Foldable, crisp, and topped with bubbling cheese, it’s proof that chain pizza can still hit the right notes. The veggie option is reliable, generous on toppings, and never soggy. On days when you want comfort food fast, Domino’s keeps things simple—and there’s reassurance in that.
It won’t overshadow your neighborhood pizzeria, but Domino’s promises familiar flavors and delivers, every single time.
More Things to Try in Port Washington, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated pizza places in Port Washington, NY?
Some local favorites include Salvatore’s Coal Oven Pizzeria, Carlos Pizza, Gino’s Pizzeria, Bellisimo Pizzeria, and Amalfi Ristorante and Pizzeria. Each spot brings its own unique style to the table.
Are there any vegetarian pizza options in Port Washington?
Yes, most pizzerias offer vegetarian-friendly pizzas, with fresh veggie toppings and classic Margherita pies that never disappoint.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Port Washington?
Several places, like La Piccola Liguria and larger chains, provide gluten-free crust options for those avoiding wheat.
Which pizza spot is best for takeout or delivery?
Carlos Pizza, Domino’s, and Amalfi Ristorante and Pizzeria are known for quick takeout and reliable delivery services throughout Port Washington.
Is there authentic Italian-style pizza in Port Washington?
Absolutely. Many local spots, like Salvatore’s and La Piccola Liguria, offer pizzas inspired by traditional Italian recipes and use classic ingredients.