Searching for the best pizza in Point Pleasant, NJ feels a bit like searching for hidden treasure—you know the prize is there, but the real fun is in the journey. Point Pleasant may seem like another classic Jersey Shore town, yet its pizza offerings are anything but ordinary. The scent of fresh dough wafts down the avenues, and it’s not uncommon to hear locals debating thin versus thick crust or reminiscing about a favorite slice after a long day at the beach.
A few years ago, I found myself strolling these very streets, letting curiosity lead my taste buds on a tour. From casual counters to well-loved family spots, each pizzeria offered up something special. This guide draws on that hands-on (and taste-driven) experience to save you from mediocre slices and point you toward the pies locals swear by. Whether you crave classic cheese or inventive toppings, keep reading. The real question isn’t if you’ll find great pizza here—it’s which spot you’ll try first.
1. Pats Pizza
Pats Pizza is the spot locals mention first when the craving hits. The atmosphere is warm, easy-going, and instantly familiar—think friendly faces behind the counter, and the subtle sound of dough hitting the oven. I remember my first visit clearly: the slice arrived piping hot, the crust crisp with just that slight, chewy pull that makes you want another bite.
What makes Pats stand out? Their consistency. The cheese is always golden and melty, the tomato sauce tangy without stealing the show. You taste quality in every slice.
If it’s your first trip, try the classic cheese or the margherita. The crust-to-sauce ratio is spot on and really reflects their attention to detail. Pats proves that in Point Pleasant, simple done right is still unbeatable.
2. Pizza Express
Pizza Express is where versatility and flavor meet. This place has a laid-back vibe that’s always buzzing with locals. During one rainy afternoon, I found myself ducking in for a quick bite. The staff were chatty, the service quick, and the aroma of freshly baked pizza lingered in the air.
The menu covers a lot, but it’s their pizza that keeps people coming back. Every pie comes out with a golden, crisp base and toppings that taste fresh. There’s a sense of pride in every slice.
The veggie pizza is a standout—packed with peppers, olives, and mushrooms, yet never soggy. If you want to branch out, the white pizza offers a garlicky richness that’s hard to ignore. At Pizza Express, you can taste the love in every layer.
3. MonAlyssa Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
MonAlyssa Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria brings a taste of Italy to Point Pleasant. This spot is a favorite for both family gatherings and relaxed date nights. On my visit, the staff treated us like old friends, and the kitchen sent out pizza that looked as good as it tasted.
What makes MonAlyssa stand out? Attention to detail. The crust is thin, slightly charred, and holds up beautifully under a generous layer of sauce and cheese. Fresh basil on top seals the deal.
The margherita pizza is a must—simple, balanced, and bursting with flavor. If you need something gluten free, they’ve got you covered without skimping on taste. MonAlyssa captures the heart of Italian pizza with every bite.
4. Little Caesars
See Menu
Little Caesars on Bridge Ave is where convenience meets comfort food. This chain might be known nationwide, but the Point Pleasant location has its own loyal following. I stopped in one afternoon for a quick bite and found the staff moving like a well-oiled machine, keeping everyone’s pizzas piping hot and fresh.
Speed is the main attraction. The Hot-N-Ready pizzas are truly that—ready to grab and go, perfect for a busy beach day or late-night munchies. Every slice delivers the classic Little Caesars flavor: a soft, chewy crust topped with a layer of bold tomato sauce and a generous blanket of cheese.
The classic cheese or veggie pizza are solid choices here. If you like your pizza fast and filling, Little Caesars always hits the spot.
5. Joe Spano’s Tomato Pies
Joe Spano’s Tomato Pies is a slice of old-world charm right in Point Pleasant. Stepping inside feels like joining a family tradition that’s been running for generations. My first tomato pie here was a revelation—thin, crisp, and kissed with just enough sauce to let the fresh ingredients shine.
What sets Joe Spano’s apart is their dedication to the art of the tomato pie. The crust is light yet sturdy, with a delicate char that hints at time spent in a well-seasoned oven. Flavors are balanced and unpretentious.
The signature tomato pie is the main attraction and lives up to its reputation—simple, fresh, and expertly crafted. For anyone serious about pizza, this place sets a high standard in town.
6. Point Pizza by Pudgy
Point Pizza by Pudgy is something of a legend with locals. Walking in, you’ll find a classic vibe that’s comfortably unpretentious. One evening after an exhausting beach day, I grabbed a slice here and instantly understood the buzz—crunchy crust, zesty sauce, gooey cheese, all coming together in perfect balance.
The focus here is freshness. Each pizza is made to order, ensuring your slice is as good as it gets. There’s a sense that nothing leaves the kitchen unless it meets Pudgy’s high standards.
The Sicilian pie is a highlight, with its thick, airy crust and a layer of sauce that actually tastes like sun-ripened tomatoes. For straightforward, no-frills pizza pleasure in Point Pleasant, this is a can’t-miss stop.
7. Little Mia’s II
Little Mia’s II feels like a secret spot that regulars try to keep quiet but can’t help talking about. I ducked in for a post-sunset bite one summer and got hooked on the classic, neighborhood charm—and the unmistakable scent of fresh-baked dough.
This isn’t your average pizza joint. The pies are handcrafted, with crust that’s both pillowy and crisp, and toppings that go right to the edge. Every bite feels indulgent but never heavy.
The white pizza here deserves special mention—creamy, garlicky, and beautifully balanced with melty cheese. For anyone looking for pizza that tastes homemade and full of personality, Little Mia’s II stands out among Point Pleasant’s favorites.
8. Maria’s Pizza
(732) 701-3246Call
Maria’s Pizza sits quietly on Route 88, but there’s nothing shy about the flavors inside. I wandered in one crazy-busy Saturday and was shocked by how efficient and personable the staff were, even as the phone rang nonstop and takeout bags disappeared out the door.
Here, you’ll find pizza rooted in tradition, with a focus on full flavors and honest ingredients. Their pies come out hot and perfectly textured—no biting into lifeless crusts here.
The veggie pizza especially hits the mark, loaded with fresh vegetables but still light enough to eat slice after slice. For a taste of what loyal locals keep coming back for, try Maria’s when you want pizza with both heart and soul.
9. Vesuvio Pizza
Vesuvio Pizza is a spot that feels like a neighborhood landmark, even if you’ve just discovered it. Walking in, you’ll notice the easy flow of regulars grabbing their favorites, evidence that this place has built real trust in the community. My first bite here—a straight cheese slice—set a standard I keep coming back to.
The crust offers that classic New Jersey snap, and there’s obvious care in every sprinkle of cheese and brush of sauce. They use fresh ingredients, and you can really taste the difference.
The margherita pizza is where Vesuvio’s shines, riding that line between simplicity and serious flavor. When you want local pizza that delivers every time, Vesuvio is a sure thing in Point Pleasant.
10. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza at Bridge Ave brings familiarity and flexibility to your pizza cravings. One late night after a busy week, I relied on their speedy delivery and was surprised at just how consistent they are, no matter how many pies are ordered.
This chain stands out by offering options for every taste—from classic thin crusts to their pillowy, handmade pan. The staff keeps things prompt and friendly, and the menu makes it easy to customize your order.
The thin crust veggie pizza packs crunch and flavor in every slice. If you’re feeling adventurous, go for the Parmesan stuffed crust for extra cheesy satisfaction. Domino’s proves that, even in a town packed with options, sometimes convenience paired with flavor is exactly what you need.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Point Pleasant, NJ?
You’ll find several standouts, including Pats Pizza, MonAlyssa Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria, Joe Spano’s Tomato Pies, and Point Pizza by Pudgy. Each has its own style, from classic thin crust to Sicilian-style pies.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Point Pleasant?
Yes, many local spots offer vegetarian pizzas, and some like Pizza Express even have vegan choices. Always check the menu or call ahead for options.
Do any Point Pleasant pizzerias offer gluten-free pizza?
Absolutely—MonAlyssa Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria and a few others provide gluten-free crusts, so you can enjoy great pizza no matter your dietary needs.
Can I get pizza delivered in Point Pleasant?
Most places, including Domino’s, Pizza Express, and many local pizzerias, offer delivery and takeout for extra convenience.
Who has the best classic cheese pizza in town?
For a tried-and-true cheese slice, try Pats Pizza, Vesuvio Pizza, or Maria’s Pizza. Each has a loyal following for a reason.