Finding the best pizza in Peoria, IL can feel like hunting for hidden treasure. With a rich tapestry of options, from classic pies to innovative toppings, the city caters to every palate. Whether you’re a traditionalist who appreciates the simplicity of a Margherita or an adventurous eater who loves unusual ingredients, Peoria boasts a pizzeria for you. I remember the first time I indulged in a slice at a local spot, the warm, cheesy goodness enveloping my senses. It’s moments like those that inspire you to explore the culinary landscape of this vibrant town.
As you delve into this guide, expect to uncover a mix of beloved local favorites and hidden gems. Each entry reflects a unique slice of Peoria’s culinary scene, offering delightful dining experiences. You’ll find tried-and-true establishments alongside newer spots that challenge the pizza norms. So, grab a seat, prepare your taste buds, and let’s embark on this delicious journey to discover the top pizza places in Peoria. You never know; you might just find your new go-to spot.
Where to find the best pizza in Peoria, IL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Peoria, IL:
- Sugar
- Agatucci’s Restaurant
- Brienzo’s Wood Fired Pizza
- Hoops Pub & Pizza
- Double A’s
- Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza
- Monical’s Pizza
- Chicago Grill
- Veterans Pub and Pizza
- Oliver’s Pizza & Pub North
1. Sugar
Sugar is a delightful spot at 826 SW Adams St that redefines pizza with a creative twist. Known for its welcoming atmosphere, this restaurant offers a range of options catering to various dietary preferences, including vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free choices. My visit here transformed my perception of pizza; the fresh ingredients and thoughtful preparation left a lasting impression.
What sets Sugar apart is its commitment to quality and innovation. The signature pizzas, like the Fig and Prosciutto, showcase the perfect blend of sweet and savory flavors, making it a must-try. Pair it with a side of their house-made garlic knots—they’re simply irresistible. Sugar isn’t just a pizzeria; it’s an experience that celebrates great food and community.
2. Agatucci’s Restaurant
Agatucci’s Restaurant, located at 2607 N University St, has been a Peoria staple since 1926, firmly establishing itself as the go-to place for phenomenal thin crust pizza. The nostalgic atmosphere invites you to savor each bite while appreciating its rich history. My first experience here was unforgettable; the delightful crunch of the crust paired with the perfect blend of toppings was a revelation.
What makes Agatucci’s stand out is not just its pizza but the range of delicious Italian fare. I highly recommend trying the pepperoni pizza, where the crispy crust beautifully complements the zesty sauce and gooey cheese. Pair it with their house salad for a refreshing bite. Agatucci’s is more than just pizza—it’s an enduring culinary experience.
3. Brienzo’s Wood Fired Pizza
+1 309-966-4185
See Menu
Located at 4450 N Prospect Rd Ste C-12, Brienzo’s Wood Fired Pizza is the premier destination in Central IL for gourmet wood-fired pizzas. The restaurant boasts a cozy atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating options, making it perfect for any occasion. My visit was highlighted by the heavenly aroma of freshly baked pizzas, which set my taste buds tingling in anticipation.
What really makes Brienzo’s stand out is its emphasis on customization. You can create your own individual pizza masterpiece, allowing for unique flavor combinations. Don’t miss their famous beer cheese breadsticks, which make for a perfect appetizer. Pair your pizza with one of their craft beers for an extraordinary culinary experience.
4. Hoops Pub & Pizza
Hoops Pub & Pizza, situated at 516 Main St, is a vibrant spot that blends the fun of a pub with delicious pizza roots. The welcoming vibe and friendly service immediately made me feel at home during my visit. It’s a great place to unwind after a long day, with a menu that caters to both sports fans and food enthusiasts.
This establishment stands out for its diverse offerings and lively atmosphere, particularly during game nights. The Hoops Supreme Pizza, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, and fresh vegetables, is a crowd favorite. Pair it with their chicken wings for a classic pub experience. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Hoops combines excellent service with tantalizing tastes.
5. Double A’s
Located at 7716 Illinois 91, Double A’s Pizza Sports Bar and Grill is a local favorite blending delicious food with the excitement of sports entertainment. Upon entering, I was struck by the lively atmosphere, bolstered by numerous big-screen TVs showcasing games. It’s an excellent spot to enjoy a pizza while cheering for your team.
What makes Double A’s a standout destination is its extensive menu, featuring a variety of mouthwatering pizzas and appetizers. One dish you shouldn’t miss is the Double A’s Special Pizza, loaded with pepperoni, green peppers, and olives for a burst of flavor. Pair it with a cold beer from their selection to enhance your dining experience. Whether you’re in for a lunch break or a late-night snack, Double A’s guarantees a fun time.
6. Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza
Located at 4700 N University St, Nick-N-Willy’s Pizza offers a delightful mix of convenience and quality that makes it a go-to for pizza lovers in Peoria. My first bite of their fresh, flavorful pizza left a lasting impression on me. The cozy atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a casual meal or a quick order to go.
What sets Nick-N-Willy’s apart is their commitment to catering to various dietary needs, offering both vegetarian and vegan options. Their custom pizza allows you to choose your own toppings, making each order a unique experience. I recommend trying the Mediterranean Veggie Pizza, topped with fresh vegetables and tangy feta, which perfectly showcases their dedication to quality and flavor. It’ll definitely elevate your pizza game.
7. Monical’s Pizza
Located at 4408 N Knoxville Ave, Monical’s Pizza has been a cherished name in Peoria for years. Walking into the restaurant, you’re greeted by a warm, family-friendly atmosphere that invites you to relax and enjoy your meal. During my visit, I was impressed by the welcoming service and the unmistakable aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air.
What truly makes Monical’s stand out is its signature thin crust pizza, which is perfectly crispy and loaded with flavor. I highly recommend the Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza, topped with robust spices that give it an extra kick. Their house salad pairs wonderfully with any pizza, making for a well-rounded meal. Monical’s is your perfect destination for a delightful pizza night.
8. Chicago Grill
Nestled at 814 W Pioneer Pkwy, Chicago Grill is a bustling eatery that brings a taste of the Windy City to Peoria. The inviting atmosphere struck me immediately, and I felt a sense of excitement as I scanned the menu filled with classic comfort food options. My visit was enhanced by the friendly staff, setting the tone for a great dining experience.
Chicago Grill stands out with its dedication to fresh ingredients and a diverse menu. Their Chicago-style deep dish pizza is a must-try; it’s rich, hearty, and undeniably satisfying. Pair it with their giant breadsticks for a delightful side. Whether you dine in or opt for takeout, Chicago Grill guarantees a memorable meal that will keep you coming back.
9. Veterans Pub and Pizza
Nestled in Peoria, IL, Veterans Pub and Pizza is a hidden gem that brings together a warm, welcoming atmosphere with seriously good pizza. Located at 2525 NE Adams St, this local spot is perfect for a laid-back lunch or casual dinner with friends and family.
What sets Veterans Pub and Pizza apart is its commitment to quality and community. The staff treats you like family, and the vibe feels like a hometown hangout. During my visit, the energy was vibrant, and the smell of fresh-baked pizza filled the air—it instantly felt like the kind of place you’d want to return to.
You can’t visit without trying their classic cheese or veggie pizza, loaded with fresh toppings and a perfectly crisp crust. Their signature dough and flavorful sauce make every slice memorable, reflecting their passion for pizza done right.
If you’re in Peoria and craving quality pizza in a friendly pub setting, Veterans Pub and Pizza is a must-visit.
10. Oliver’s Pizza & Pub North
Located at 3300 W Willow Knolls Dr, Oliver’s Pizza & Pub North offers a fantastic blend of great food and a welcoming atmosphere. My visit was highlighted by the friendly service and the lively ambiance, making it an ideal spot for casual dining with friends or family.
What truly makes Oliver’s stand out is its dedication to variety and quality. The menu caters to all tastes, featuring delicious vegetarian-friendly options. I highly recommend their Buffalo Chicken Pizza, which strikes a perfect balance between spicy and savory, topped with fresh ingredients. Don’t forget to try their crispy garlic knots as a side—they’re addictively good. Oliver’s is a hidden treasure in Peoria that delivers satisfying dishes in a cozy pub setting.
More Things to Try in Peoria, IL
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza styles available in Peoria, IL?
Peoria offers a variety of pizza styles, including the popular thin crust, classic deep dish, and even wood-fired options. Each pizzeria has its unique take, ensuring there’s a pizza style for every preference.
2. Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Peoria?
Absolutely! Many pizzerias in Peoria cater to dietary preferences with vegetarian and vegan options. Be sure to check the menu for these choices, as they often have specialty pizzas loaded with fresh veggies and plant-based ingredients.
3. Can I order pizza for delivery in Peoria?
Yes, most pizza places in Peoria offer delivery services. Many also partner with apps like DoorDash or Grubhub for added convenience, so you’re just a few clicks away from enjoying your favorite pizza at home.
4. Where can I find pizza deals or specials?
Keep an eye on local pizzerias’ websites or their social media pages for weekly specials and discounts. Many places offer deals on certain days of the week, making it a perfect time to satisfy your pizza craving.
5. What’s a recommended pizza place for a family-friendly atmosphere?
Many pizza spots in Peoria, like Monical’s Pizza and Chicago Grill, provide a welcoming environment that’s great for families. These places often have kid-friendly menus and comfortable seating.