Pizza in Pasadena, CA is not just food; it’s a neighborhood obsession. Each spot on this list has its quirks—thin, chewy crusts, secret sauces, and toppings that make you rethink everything you know about a good slice. After more than a few “research” nights sampling pizza across the city, I can say Pasadena is packed with flavor and character, all baked into its best pies.
Whether you’re after classic margherita, looking for crispy edges, prefer a plant-based twist, or hunting for the city’s cheesiest corner slice, you’ll find something that feels like it was made just for you. Join me for a doughy expedition through Pasadena’s most beloved pizza joints—some legends, some hidden, all expertly chosen—so you never have to waste a meal on the ordinary.
1. Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana
Settebello Pizzeria Napoletana delivers a slice of Naples right in the heart of Pasadena. Walk in and you’re greeted by the soft crackle from the wood-fired oven and the aroma of real Italian dough. It’s a place where pizza is an art, not just a meal.
My first bite of their Margherita DOC won me over—the combination of San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil tastes like summer evenings in Italy. If you’re adventurous, try the Diavola, where spicy salame meets creamy cheese without overpowering each bite.
Settebello stands out for its authenticity, rustic charm, and commitment to old-world methods. It’s vegetarian-friendly, offers vegan and gluten-free options, and makes every meal feel like a celebration of tradition.
2. Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza is where pizza meets your inner control freak, and that’s a good thing. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve built my “ultimate” pie here, and each trip ends with me vowing to try a different combo next time. The line moves fast, but you’ll find yourself lingering over decisions when faced with 30+ fresh toppings.
Their Build Your Own Classic lets you pile on roasted veggies, goat cheese, and fresh basil—no extra cost for extras. If you’re feeling less decisive, try the Veg Out; it’s loaded but balanced, never heavy.
Blaze stands out for its custom approach, fast-fire’d thin crusts, and welcoming vibe for vegetarians and vegans. Whether you grab yours to-go or eat in, you’ll walk away happy and satisfied.
3. Tarantino’s Pizzeria
Tarantino’s Pizzeria is that quiet corner spot where regulars greet each other by name, and the pizza comes out piping hot. My first visit felt like stepping into someone’s kitchen—casual, no fuss, but focused on real flavor.
The Vegetarian Special is stacked with crisp vegetables and a tangy tomato sauce that complements the soft, chewy crust. If you’re in the mood for something rich, the White Pizza with ricotta and fresh garlic is a creamy classic I can never resist.
Tarantino’s stands out for its friendly table service, honest ingredients, and relaxed, neighborhood feel. It’s pizza that tastes like tradition, with enough variety to keep every visit interesting.
4. The Kitchen Italian Cafe & Pizzeria
The Kitchen Italian Cafe & Pizzeria feels like your favorite family gathering, with big flavors and zero pretense. The first time I stepped in, the aroma of fresh-baked dough and bubbling cheese was enough to set my expectations high—thankfully, the pizza delivered.
If you’ve ever argued over New York vs. Sicilian style, this place lets you taste-test both, plus a thick, comforting Chicago deep dish. The New York Veggie Pizza won me over; its thin crust and fresh toppings had a perfect crunch. For those who want something heartier, the Sicilian-style pie brings that golden, pillowy base.
The Kitchen stands out for variety, generous portions, and an inviting, homey vibe. Everything’s cooked in-house, keeping it real and delicious every time.
5. Domenicos
Domenicos has the kind of old-school charm that makes you want to linger over a meal. I ended up chatting with a couple who have been regulars since the ‘80s, which tells you something about the kind of loyalty this place inspires.
The Vegetarian Pizza is a solid choice, loaded with artichoke hearts, olives, and roasted peppers on a chewy, golden crust. If you want something uniquely Domenicos, try the Pesto Pizza; the fresh basil and creamy cheese balance each other in every bite.
Domenicos stands out for its welcoming service, comforting atmosphere, and time-tested recipes. It’s the kind of spot you revisit to relive the flavors you first fell for—and maybe discover a new favorite as well.
6. Pitfire Pizza
Pitfire Pizza turns up the heat on classic pizza night. Every visit feels like a casual celebration, with open seating and that inviting hum of conversation. I remember grabbing a seat by the window and watching the kitchen work its magic—smoke rising from the open oven, crusts crisping just right.
The Blistered Shishito Pizza is pure fun, bringing together charred peppers, lemon zest, and creamy mozzarella for a kick you don’t see coming. Fans of a classic should try the Margherita, fresh and simple but always spot on.
Pitfire stands out for its inventive toppings, lively setting, and dough that strikes the perfect note between chewy and crisp. Swing by for a quick bite or a relaxed dinner with friends.
7. Pietro’s
+1 626-791-1826
Pietro’s is what you hope for in a neighborhood pizza joint—warm staff, plenty of regulars, and pizza that stays on your mind long after the box is empty. My first slice here came at the start of a long study night, and it ended up fueling hours of conversation and laughter with friends.
The Vegetarian Deluxe lives up to its name, piled with fresh mushrooms, peppers, and onions. For a taste of tradition, the Cheese Pizza lets you appreciate their dough and sauce, both classic and well-balanced.
Pietro’s stands out for honest Italian flavor, crowd-pleasing pies, and a friendly feel that makes every visit easygoing. When you want familiar and satisfying, it always delivers.
8. Pasadena Pizza Co
Pasadena Pizza Co is all about that classic, no-nonsense pizza experience. The first time I tried their pie, I was struck by how everything tasted fresh and homemade, from the sauce to the crisp edges on the crust. It felt like finding a hidden treasure among Pasadena’s pizza scene.
The Garden Delight Pizza stands out, packed with colorful veggies and gooey cheese. It’s filling yet light enough so you don’t need a nap after. If you’re a fan of tradition, their Cheese and Tomato Pizza is simple but perfect, letting every ingredient shine.
Pasadena Pizza Co stands out for consistency, old-school flavors, and portions that please a crowd. This place proves you don’t need frills when the basics are just this good.
9. Rocco’s Tavern
Rocco’s Tavern nails that lively, laid-back vibe where a pizza outing can stretch into a whole evening. My last meal here might have started with pizza, but it was the energy and warm service that kept my group lingering over second helpings.
The Veggie Pizza comes loaded with fresh spinach, mushrooms, and sun-dried tomatoes, striking a nice balance between hearty and bright. If you’re sharing, their classic Margherita Pizza is always a crowd-pleaser and highlights a perfectly chewy crust.
Rocco’s stands out for generous toppings, a great spot for groups, and that neighborhood tavern feel. It’s where you go when you want good flavors and even better company.
10. Lucianos Ristorante
Lucianos Ristorante feels like a classic Italian retreat tucked into Pasadena. My first visit came after a long week, and settling into a cozy booth with the aroma of baking pizza was all the reset I needed.
The Mushroom Pizza steals the show, layered with earthy mushrooms and just the right touch of melted cheese. For something lighter, the Margherita Pizza is fresh and balanced, letting simple flavors shine without any fuss.
Lucianos stands out for its intimate setting, attentive table service, and focus on straightforward Italian quality. When you want tradition with a personal touch, this is where to linger over a slice.
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza are most popular in Pasadena?
You’ll find a mix of styles in Pasadena, from authentic Neapolitan at Settebello to thin, New York-style slices and deep-dish Chicago options. There’s something for every pizza preference.
Are there good vegetarian and vegan pizza options in Pasadena?
Most pizza spots in Pasadena offer vegetarian pizzas, and many—like Blaze Pizza and Settebello—feature vegan cheese and toppings. Just ask, and you’ll likely find a pizza that fits your diet.
Which Pasadena pizzerias are best for families or large groups?
Pasadena Pizza Co, Rocco’s Tavern, and Pitfire Pizza are known for their roomy seating and family-friendly atmosphere. Perfect for sharing big pies with a crowd.
Can I get gluten-free pizza in Pasadena?
Yes, several places, including Blaze Pizza and The Kitchen Italian Cafe & Pizzeria, offer gluten-free crust options so you can still enjoy a great slice.
Do any Pasadena pizza places offer delivery or takeout?
Nearly all the top spots provide takeout, and many, like Domino’s and Papa John’s, have delivery. Smaller local favorites often work with delivery services, so you’re never far from a fresh pizza.