It only took one bite to convince me that Omaha has pizza worth traveling for. I’ve tasted brick-oven slices in Brooklyn, folded cheesy layers in Chicago, and sampled thin-crust classics in San Francisco—but Omaha surprised me. The variety here isn’t just a list of local spots; it’s a reflection of the city’s comfort-loving, flavor-forward spirit. Whether you’re craving hand-tossed perfection, artisan toppings, or a classic pepperoni slice done right, Omaha delivers without the fanfare—just good food made by people who care.
This guide breaks down the most crave-worthy pizzerias across Omaha, NE—from hidden gems tucked inside neighborhood bakeries to sleek downtown kitchens firing up dough with style. Each pick has earned its spot not by flashy slogans or gimmicks, but by consistently offering high-quality, flavorful pizza that respects tradition while embracing local taste. Ready to find your next go-to pie? Let’s start slicing through Omaha’s best.
Where to find the best pizza in Omaha, NE
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Omaha, NE:
- Orsi’s Italian Bakery & Pizzeria
- Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria
- Mangia Italiana Pizza & Pasta
- Zio’s Pizzeria
- Tasty Pizza
- Oscar’s Pizza and Sports Grille
- Piezon’s Pizzeria
- Via Farina
- Mama’s Pizza
- Pitch Pizzeria -West Omaha
1. Orsi’s Italian Bakery & Pizzeria
Nestled at 621 Pacific Street, Orsi’s Italian Bakery & Pizzeria has been a cornerstone of Omaha’s culinary scene since 1919. My first visit was like stepping into a slice of Italy, where the aroma of freshly baked bread and rich cheeses greeted me warmly. Over generations, they’ve perfected the art of authentic Italian baking and pizza making, offering a taste that’s both timeless and unique.
What sets Orsi’s apart is their commitment to quality and tradition. I highly recommend trying their classic Margherita pizza, topped with fresh basil and rich mozzarella, reflecting authentic Italian flavors. For those seeking something different, the Vegetarian Pizza showcases fresh, colorful ingredients on a flaky crust. Every bite demonstrates their skill in balancing tradition with local taste, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in Omaha.
2. Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria
At Pitch Coal-Fire Pizzeria, located at 5021 Underwood Ave, every visit feels like a special occasion. I was captivated by the inviting, rustic atmosphere and the irresistible aroma of coal-fired pizza. Their oven, fired with natural coal, imparts a smoky depth that elevates each pie into something memorable. It’s clear that quality ingredients and a passion for flavor are at the heart of every dish.
For a must-try experience, order the Margherita pizza—simple yet sublime, with fresh basil and mozzarella. The Mia pizza, topped with a fried egg and fennel sausage, offers an adventurous twist. With over 20 toppings available, customizing your perfect pizza here is part of the fun. Pitch’s dedication to craftsmanship makes it a standout spot for pizza in Omaha.
3. Mangia Italiana Pizza & Pasta
Tucked away at 6516 Irvington Rd, Mangia Italiana Pizza & Pasta blends tradition with heart. My first visit felt like a homecoming—warm staff, cozy setting, and the smell of garlic and tomato simmering in the air. Having earned the People’s Choice title several years in a row, it’s not hard to see why locals trust Mangia for a consistent, authentic Italian experience.
Pizza-wise, the Deluxe Pizza stands out, layered with savory vegetables, melted cheese, and a well-balanced sauce. I also enjoyed the Vegetarian option, where freshness and crunch met on a perfectly baked crust. Mangia’s reputation is built on simplicity done right, and the flavors carry that legacy forward. For those seeking real comfort in every slice, this spot is worth savoring.
4. Zio’s Pizzeria
Since opening in 1985 at 1109 Howard St, Zio’s Pizzeria has been a cornerstone for authentic New York-style pizza in Omaha. My first visit felt like a quick trip to the city—crusts that were perfectly thin and crisp, topped generously with fresh ingredients. Their long-standing reputation is evident in every bite, backed by over 35 awards for the best pizza in town.
For a true taste of New York, the Zio’s Margherita Pizza offers a beautifully balanced combination of rich sauce, fresh basil, and gooey cheese. If you’re in the mood for variety, their Calzone and pasta dishes are equally satisfying. Zio’s commitment to quality and tradition makes it a top choice for pizza lovers seeking an authentic experience in Omaha.
5. Tasty Pizza
Located at 1418 S. 60th St., Tasty Pizza embodies the heart of Midtown Omaha. During my visit, I was struck by the warm, cozy atmosphere and the inviting aroma of freshly made pizza. As a locally owned spot, Tasty Pizza takes pride in crafting each pie from scratch with fresh ingredients, making every bite feel personalized and genuine.
The Bacon Gouda Pizza is a standout—rich, smoky, and beautifully balanced with a creamy cheese layer. Their menu also offers a variety of vegetarian and vegan options, reflecting their commitment to inclusivity and quality. For those seeking a pizza that’s both traditional and inventive, Tasty Pizza delivers from the first slice to the last.
6. Oscar’s Pizza and Sports Grille
Located at 17330 Lakeside Hills Plaza, Oscar’s Pizza and Sports Grille offers a lively dining experience perfect for sports fans and families alike. My visit was marked by a vibrant atmosphere filled with the sounds of game day and the aroma of freshly baked pizza. The restaurant’s emphasis on quality and a relaxed vibe makes it stand out in Omaha’s busy dining scene.
The highlight is their classic Oscar’s Special Pizza, loaded with savory meats, vegetables, and just the right amount of cheese. Their menu also includes a variety of hearty salads and wings, making it ideal for sharing. Whether for a late-night snack or a family dinner, Oscar’s delivers on flavor and atmosphere, keeping sports fans coming back.
7. Piezon’s Pizzeria
Tucked into West Center Road, Piezon’s Pizzeria blends East Coast tradition with Midwestern charm. The space is cozy but modern, with a neighborhood feel that makes you want to linger. It’s the kind of place where the staff remembers your name and your usual order.
What sets Piezon’s apart is its commitment to scratch-made dough and house-blended cheese. The crust is thin, crisp, and just chewy enough to hold up under generous toppings. Their Margherita Pizza is a standout—simple, fresh, and balanced. For something heartier, the Piezon’s Combo delivers a satisfying mix of vegetables and beef pepperoni.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or settling in for dinner, Piezon’s offers a pizza experience that feels both familiar and elevated.
8. Via Farina
Situated at 1108 South 10th Street, Via Farina shines as a bastion of inclusive, clean-eating options in Omaha. From my first visit, I was impressed by their vibrant atmosphere and the thoughtful menu that caters to vegetarians, vegans, and gluten-sensitive diners alike. The focus on quality and variety makes every meal feel special.
For a memorable pizza, try the Vegan Margherita, topped with fresh herbs and a rich tomato sauce on a crispy, gluten-free crust. Their Classic Cheese Pizza also highlights their dedication to simple, flavorful ingredients. Each dish reflects Via Farina’s commitment to health-conscious, artfully crafted food that doesn’t compromise on taste.
9. Mama’s Pizza
Mama’s Pizza on Saddle Creek has been a local favorite since 1975, and it’s easy to see why. The casual vibe, generous portions, and nostalgic charm make it a go-to for families and longtime Omaha residents. I remember walking in and being greeted by the aroma of fresh dough and melted cheese—it felt like home.
What sets Mama’s apart is their commitment to quality. Their pizzas are made fresh daily, with a crust that’s crisp on the outside and soft inside. The Vegetarian Pizza is a standout—loaded with mushrooms, onions, black olives, green peppers, and tomatoes, it’s hearty without being heavy.
If you’re craving something bold, try the Garlic Chicken Alfredo Pizza. It’s rich, flavorful, and showcases Mama’s knack for blending comfort with creativity. Whether dining in or grabbing takeout, Mama’s delivers consistency and warmth in every bite.
10. Pitch Pizzeria -West Omaha
Located at 17808 Burke Street, Pitch Pizzeria – West Omaha offers a modern, inviting space with an industrial-chic vibe. My visit was memorable thanks to the warm lighting and exposed brick, creating the perfect backdrop for a flavorful experience. The standout is their coal-fired pizza, which delivers a smoky richness on every slice.
For a classic taste, try the Margherita pizza, featuring fresh basil, mozzarella, and a crisp crust. For something bold, the Peppadew Pizza is a delightful mix of spice and sweetness. Their menu’s diverse selection and quality ingredients make Pitch a true gem for pizza lovers seeking flavor and sophistication.
More Things to Try in Omaha, NE
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in Omaha for authentic Italian-style pizza?
If you’re after authentic Italian-style pizza, head to Orsi’s Italian Bakery & Pizzeria. They’ve been serving Omaha since 1919 and are known for their double-crusted Goudarooni and fresh Italian bread. Mangia Italiana is another solid pick, offering hearty slices and traditional red sauce dishes.
2. Where can I find coal-fired pizza in Omaha?
Pitch Coal-fire Pizzeria is your go-to. Their coal-fired ovens give the crust a distinct char and flavor. Try their Peppadew Pizza for something with a little kick.
3. Are there any good pizza spots for a casual family night out?
Yes. Mama’s Pizza and Pizza Ranch are both family-friendly with spacious seating and a relaxed vibe. Varsity Sports Cafe also offers a casual setting with TVs for game nights.
4. What’s the best place for New York-style pizza in Omaha?
Zio’s Pizzeria is a local favorite for thin, foldable slices that channel that classic New York feel. They have multiple locations, so it’s easy to find one nearby.
5. Which pizzerias offer vegetarian options?
Most of the top spots do. Tasty Pizza has a standout veggie pizza with spinach, mushrooms, and black olives. Noli’s Pizzeria also offers creative vegetarian pies with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
6. Where can I get pizza by the slice in Omaha?
Lighthouse Pizza is known for giant slices and late-night hours. It’s a popular stop for a quick bite or post-event snack.
7. Are there any halal or haram-free pizza options in Omaha?
While not all pizzerias label their offerings as halal, many places like Via Farina and Piezon’s Pizzeria focus on vegetarian options and simple ingredient lists, which can be suitable for those avoiding haram items. Always check with the restaurant directly to confirm.
8. What’s the most unique pizza in Omaha?
La Casa Pizzeria serves a rectangular, Romano-style pizza with a cracker-thin crust and tangy sauce. It’s a local classic with a flavor profile that stands out.
9. Which pizza places are best for takeout or delivery?
Marco’s Pizza, Godfather’s Pizza, and Sam & Louie’s are reliable for quick delivery and easy online ordering. They offer a wide range of toppings and crust styles.
10. Is there a place in Omaha that serves Neapolitan-style pizza?
Yes, SPIN! Neapolitan Pizza specializes in wood-fired, Neapolitan-style pies with a soft, chewy crust and fresh toppings.