Finding great pizza is one of life’s quiet triumphs. Norman might be known as a college town, but its pizza scene stretches far beyond campus cravings or last-minute study fuel. The range is remarkable: whether you fancy a local pie with a cult following or a national name that gets your order just right every time, Norman isn’t short on choices.
My own search for the best slice in Norman has been, let’s say, thorough. I’ve been that person weighing thin or thick crust, admiring inventive toppings, or puzzling over which place nails that perfect golden edge. Along the way, I’ve uncovered pizzerias that suit every mood—a quick lunch, a family night, or the sort of dinner that makes weeknights feel special. If you’re ready to explore slices both classic and creative, this guide will point you straight to Norman’s top ovens.
1. Hideaway Pizza
Hideaway Pizza has a knack for keeping both newcomers and regulars coming back. Tucked near OU’s campus, this spot feels like a slice of Norman’s history.
The menu shines with 26 specialty pizzas and a build-your-own option if you’re feeling creative. Try the “Big Country”—it’s hearty, loaded with veggies and cheese, and shows Hideaway’s focus on bold layers. The “Sicilian” is another favorite for its crave-worthy crust.
Vegetarian and vegan options don’t feel like an afterthought here, making group outings a breeze. Table service is friendly, the energy is always lively, and you won’t leave hungry.
To me, Hideaway is best for long lunches and laughter-filled dinners, especially if you end with their cinnamon sticks. They’ve mastered the art of comfort food with style.
2. Volare
Volare feels like a little piece of Italy tucked into Norman. The aroma of fresh dough and bright basil greets you as soon as you walk in, and the staff knows their menu inside and out.
The pizzas here are thin crust masterpieces. I keep coming back for the Margherita—simple but packed with flavor from their house-made sauce and gooey mozzarella. If you want something a bit more adventurous, try the Bianca. It’s a white pizza elevated by a drizzle of olive oil and loads of ricotta.
Volare’s vegetarian-friendly approach and cozy dining vibe make it a perfect spot for gatherings or a casual date night. The attention to detail is clear, right down to the last crisp bite.
This is where I go when I want pizza that’s truly handcrafted, with every bite offering a taste of tradition.
3. New York Pizza & Pasta
New York Pizza & Pasta takes its pizza game seriously. You’ll notice the difference in the first bite—crisp crust, gooey cheese, and just the right amount of sauce layered on every pie. The vibe is unfussy, perfect for a quick lunch or relaxed dinner.
I gravitate toward their classic Cheese or Veggie slices, which always hit that perfect point between chewy and crunchy. Everything is fresh, and the slices are big enough to fold, New York style. Their pasta dishes are generous, but pizza is definitely the main event.
Delivery is fast, and takeout is spot-on if you want to enjoy a real slice of New York without leaving Norman. Whether you’re grabbing a whole pie or a single slice, you get quality every time.
4. Pizza Shuttle
Pizza Shuttle is Norman’s answer to late-night cravings and spontaneous pizza parties. This is the spot where speedy delivery meets craveable flavor, and there’s always a deal worth grabbing.
Their classic Cheese and Veggie pizzas are reliable favorites, but Pizza Shuttle also nails it with unique creations. I always find myself returning for their specialty pies—loaded with fresh toppings and a crust that’s somehow both soft and crispy.
There’s no fussiness here, just straightforward, feel-good pizza that arrives hot and ready when you need it. It’s the place you call when you’ve got a house full of friends or a long study session ahead.
For a true taste of Pizza Shuttle’s style, try building your own pie. The process is simple, the prices are kind to your wallet, and the result always satisfies.
5. Cicis Pizza
Cicis Pizza is where you go in Norman when “just one slice” won’t cut it. The buffet is the big draw, letting you sample everything in one visit, from the classic cheese pizza to veggie creations and even dessert pies.
I’ve had more than a few gatherings here with friends, stacking up plates and debating which pizza deserves a second round. The crust is always light and crispy, and the constant rotation keeps things fresh and hot.
Don’t overlook their salad bar as a fresh way to break up all the pizza. The cinnamon rolls are the not-so-secret highlight for anyone with a sweet tooth.
Cicis shines for its value, variety, and casual, all-ages energy. It’s perfect for families, groups, or anyone who hates settling for just one flavor.
6. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza in Norman is my go-to for those nights when only classic pizza will do. The difference is in the dough—soft, fresh, always with that bit of pull that makes you want one more slice. The signature sauce has a tang that keeps the flavors lively, not heavy.
Ordering is simple, whether you want delivery or a quick carryout. I usually opt for their Garden Fresh or the cheese pizza, which lets the quality of the ingredients shine. The garlic dipping sauce has become an essential side for me—it makes every bite a little more indulgent.
Papa Johns stands out for reliability and always-honest flavors. If you’re feeding a group, their large pies keep everyone happy and, in my experience, leftovers are rare.
For fresh-ingredient pizza with a familiar comfort factor, this spot never lets me down.
7. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Norman keeps things efficient and unfussy, which is why it’s a go-to for busy nights or group hangouts. Their delivery really is as fast as everyone claims—my pizza always arrives hot and never short on cheese.
I gravitate toward the Handmade Pan pizza for its golden, thick crust and edge-to-edge toppings. If you’re after something lighter, the Thin Crust is consistently crisp and flavorful, perfect for piling on veggies.
What sets Domino’s apart for me is the variety. From the Parmesan Stuffed Crust to vegetarian-friendly choices, there’s a pie for every craving. The online ordering system is so smooth, you’ll have your meal planned out before your hunger even peaks.
If you want reliability and crave-worthy flavor with plenty of options, Domino’s has you covered every time.
8. DoubleDave’s Pizzaworks
DoubleDave’s Pizzaworks inside HeyDay Entertainment is where fun and food overlap in Norman. It’s always buzzing, full of families making the most of arcade games and hot, fresh pizza all in one place.
The standout here is the Peproni Rolls: soft, doughy bites filled with cheese and pepperoni, a cult classic for a reason. For pizza, build your own or go with their hand-tossed works—the Veggie pizza is my personal must-try, loaded and never skimpy on toppings.
DoubleDave’s feels laid-back and friendly, whether you’re there for a casual slice or to fuel up between games. Service is quick, and big groups fit right in.
When you want pizza with a side of good times, DoubleDave’s never disappoints.
9. Domino’s Pizza
This Domino’s Pizza on N Interstate Dr has all the consistency you expect but with a personal touch that stands out. It’s my top pick when I want my meal fast and made to order. Staff here have never missed a beat—my orders are accurate and the pizza always hits hot, with bubbling cheese right out of the oven.
The Handmade Pan pizza is king for its pillowy crust and the way it holds generous toppings. Their Veggie pizza is stacked with crisp, colorful vegetables—never wilted or bland. If you’re up for an extra treat, the Parmesan Stuffed Crust is a flavor bomb that nobody at my table can resist.
Ordering online or picking up in person, you’ll find this Domino’s reliable, quick, and always ready with a good deal.
For anyone searching for no-nonsense, craveable pizza in Norman, this Domino’s nails it every time.
10. Chuck E. Cheese
Chuck E. Cheese is where pizza meets pure fun, especially for kids. The energy is high, thanks to arcade games, prizes, and nonstop entertainment. For family celebrations, this spot is a fixture in Norman—I’ve seen parties here turn into cherished memories over a few slices and game tokens.
The pizza is classic and made to please—soft crust, gooey cheese, and enough flavor to keep grownups reaching for another slice. My go-to is their Veggie pizza, which stands out with its fresh toppings and crowd-friendly style.
Chuck E. Cheese makes group outings and birthdays stress-free, with seating for large parties and lots of smiles all around. Their salad bar is a nice fresh option when you’re ready to balance the pizza fun.
If you need a place in Norman where food and fun share the stage, Chuck E. Cheese fits the bill.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pizza place in Norman for families?
Many families love Hideaway Pizza and Chuck E. Cheese for their lively atmosphere and spacious seating. Both offer ample menu options for kids and groups.
Where can I find late-night pizza in Norman?
Pizza Shuttle and both Domino’s Pizza locations are known for late hours and fast delivery, making them a go-to after a long evening.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Norman?
Yes. Hideaway Pizza, Volare, and Cicis Pizza all offer creative vegetarian pizzas. Hideaway and Volare also cater to vegan diners, so everyone can find a slice they like.
Which Norman pizzerias offer delivery?
Most big names like Domino’s, Papa Johns, Pizza Shuttle, and New York Pizza & Pasta provide reliable delivery all over town.
Is there a spot for all-you-can-eat pizza in Norman?
Cicis Pizza has a well-known buffet, featuring classic and specialty pizzas, pasta, and dessert at one affordable price.