Pizza cravings don’t really care about the occasion; they just show up. That’s how I ended up weaving through Niceville, searching for the crust that’s got the right snap, the sauce that doesn’t shy away, and enough cheese to make you pause mid-bite. Finding true pizza bliss in a small Florida town isn’t about luck—it’s about knowing where to look.
Over time, locals pointed me to tucked-away gems and family mainstays, joints with wood-fired ovens and takeout counters buzzing with regulars. If you think great pizza can’t be found outside a big city, Niceville is happy to prove you mistaken. Whether rustic or classic, thin crust or deep dish, Niceville’s pizza spots offer every kind of slice. Let’s get into the best that Niceville has to offer—you’ll want to keep this list handy.
1. Landshark’s Pizza
Landshark’s Pizza feels like the kind of place that remembers your face and your favorite slice. This spot stands out in Niceville for big, generous pizzas baked in a brick oven, giving every crust a golden edge and rich flavor. There’s no confusion over why locals keep recommending it.
On one visit, I tried the Supreme pizza—hearty toppings spread edge-to-edge, and the dough stayed crisp even under the cheese. The flavor balance proved this isn’t your typical chain experience.
Order their brick oven calzones or classic cheese pizza if you want to taste their approach to dough and sauce. The casual energy and friendly staff only make your meal more enjoyable. For groups, the wide booth seating and kid-friendly atmosphere seal the deal.
2. Ciao Bella Pizza
Ciao Bella Pizza is what happens when care and craft meet a neighborhood favorite. The first time I walked in, I could smell the garlic and tomato in the air—always a promising sign. This place wins you over with handmade dough and classic sauce recipes, the kind that instantly feel familiar.
The Margherita is a local legend: crisp crust, a bright splash of sauce, and fresh basil lightly scattered over molten cheese. You get the sense that each pizza is built to be memorable, not just filling.
If you’re after something robust, try their veggie or gluten-free options. Even simple cheese slices arrive thoughtfully prepared, making it the go-to spot for fresh, satisfying pizza in Niceville.
3. Caio Bella
See Menu
Caio Bella is one of those places where the simple things shine. Tucked along Highway 20, it’s easy to pass by—until you catch the scent of baking crust and herbs. The cozy, come-as-you-are setting invites neighbors and newcomers alike, making every meal feel comfortable.
On my visit, I ordered their veggie pizza, and it didn’t disappoint. The crust was crisp but not too thin, and the fresh toppings let each bite stand on its own. They put real care into the dough and are generous with the cheese, which is just what you want in a local pizza haunt.
If you’re looking for a lunch break or dinner out, try their classic cheese or veggie pies. Caio Bella’s style is all about making honest, flavorful pizza that’s just right every time.
4. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza proves that pizza night doesn’t have to mean compromise. During a rainy Niceville evening, I grabbed a classic cheese pizza here and was struck by the bold tomato flavor and the slight dusting of herbs tucked between each slice. Their pizzas are always served hot, with a crust that manages to be both chewy and crisp.
This spot is especially good for quick takeout or cozy dinners at home. Their menu covers all the bases, but the veggie pizza is a solid pick—fresh toppings and just the right ratio of cheese to sauce.
Choose their classic or veggie options to get a sense of Marco’s signature flavor. The consistent quality is what keeps this franchise feeling like a local favorite.
5. Tisanos Garlic Grill
Tisanos Garlic Grill fuses Italian recipes with a relaxed, down-home vibe. Walking through the doors, you’ll notice the chatter of regulars and the scent of baking pizza that fills the air. This is a spot where family history and good food go hand in hand, thanks to its roots in both Italy and the Niceville community.
I tried their classic Margherita pizza, and the result was fresh and balanced—crispy crust, just enough cheese, and a sauce with real depth. That sauce, in particular, gives Tisanos its signature flavor.
Order their veggie or classic cheese pies to experience the best of their oven. Pair your meal with the easy-going company and you’ll see why Tisanos stands out among Niceville’s pizza options.
6. Hungry Howies Pizza & Subs
Hungry Howies Pizza & Subs is the answer for anyone who likes variety as much as value. I found my way in on a Saturday lunch run and saw a crowd of regulars lining up for carryout. Their flavored crusts are what make this spot different, with choices like garlic herb or buttery blends adding something special to every bite.
On my last visit, I went for the classic veggie pizza on a seasoned crust. Each slice was flavorful, with the right mix of toppings and a base that held up, never soggy.
Try the cheese or veggie pies—you’ll taste why locals come back for a quick, satisfying meal. For pizza that’s never boring, Hungry Howies delivers every time.
7. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza in Niceville is all about consistency and familiar flavors. On busy weeknights, I’ve relied on their speedy delivery more than once—hot pizza at the door, every time. What sets Papa Johns apart is the signature dough, made fresh daily, and a tangy tomato sauce that’s full of zing.
Their cheese pizza sets the pace for the rest of the menu, layered generously with cheese and baked to a golden finish. The veggie pizza is another solid choice, especially when you want something lighter but still filling.
Order the classic cheese or veggie pie to get the best experience. You always know what to expect, and that’s exactly why Papa Johns is so reliable for pizza in Niceville.
8. Brozinni’s Pizzeria Niceville
Brozinni’s Pizzeria Niceville delivers that classic pizzeria experience with a local twist. I stopped in for lunch and was greeted by the warm, yeasty scent that only comes from fresh dough. Their New York-style crust is thin, foldable, and just chewy enough, making every bite satisfying.
The cheese pizza here is always a standout: wide slices, a perfect cheese-to-sauce ratio, and an airy yet crisp base. Their veggie pies don’t skimp, either; each topping tastes fresh and held its own.
Try a classic cheese or specialty veggie slice for the true Brozinni’s treatment. Whether for a laid-back brunch or a late-night craving, this friendly spot always hits the spot for pizza in Niceville.
9. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Niceville brings back memories of after-school slices and family pizza nights. The first thing you notice is the signature aroma—yeasty dough and rich, tomato sauce drifting from the ovens. The Original Stuffed Crust® is a must if you’re looking for pure cheese satisfaction, with gooey cheese tucked right into the edges.
I usually go for the classic cheese or the Veggie Lovers®, both layered with toppings and always arriving hot. Every slice is familiar and comforting, which is why crowds keep coming back.
Order their cheese or veggie pizzas to get the full Pizza Hut experience. It’s casual, it’s fast, and there’s a certain nostalgic comfort in every crispy-edged bite.
10. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza in Niceville is the undeniable choice for those afternoons when you need a pizza—and you need it fast. I’ve dropped by for their Hot-N-Ready cheese pizza, and it was ready to go with no wait, still piping hot and easy on the wallet. The appeal here is speed and simplicity; get in, get your pizza, and get on with your day.
Their classic cheese pizza delivers a chewy, fresh crust every time. For more flavor and crunch, the veggie pizza is another wallet-friendly option packed with goodness.
Order the Hot-N-Ready cheese or veggie pies to keep things easy. Little Caesars keeps it uncomplicated and reliable—sometimes, that’s the best pizza move you can make in Niceville.
Frequently Asked Questions
What pizza restaurants in Niceville offer vegetarian or gluten-free options?
Most top spots, including Landshark’s Pizza, Ciao Bella Pizza, Tisanos Garlic Grill, Marco’s Pizza, and Papa Johns, offer vegetarian options and some provide gluten-free crusts as well.
Where can I find pizza delivery in Niceville?
All the popular chains such as Marco’s Pizza, Papa Johns, Domino’s, Pizza Hut, Hungry Howies, and Little Caesars offer delivery services. Local places like Brozinni’s Pizzeria and Landshark’s Pizza also often deliver or offer easy pickup.
Which pizza spot in Niceville is best for families?
Landshark’s Pizza is known for its family-friendly vibe, with an arcade and dog-friendly patio. Brozinni’s and Pizza Hut are also great for groups thanks to spacious seating and a casual environment.
Can I find good pizza for a quick lunch in Niceville?
Absolutely. Try Little Caesars for fast grab-and-go pies, or Pizza Hut and Hungry Howies for speedy lunch specials.
Are there local pizza restaurants in Niceville, or just big chains?
Niceville features a mix of both. For local flavor, try Tisanos Garlic Grill, Ciao Bella Pizza, Landshark’s Pizza, and Brozinni’s.