Hunting for great pizza in Manorville, NY can feel like chasing a moving target. This small corner of Long Island balances between local legends and new names that dare to stand out—all claiming a slice of the spotlight. Sifting through glossy menus and glowing reviews rarely tells you the whole story. I’ve spent more hours than I’d admit, driving from one steamy pizza box to the next, brushing flour from my jeans, and learning which crusts crackle just right.
Every pizzeria in Manorville has its quirks and secret strengths. Some are neighborhood treasures that have quietly mastered the art of the classic slice. Others get bold with toppings or surprise you with perfectly charred dough. Trying each one isn’t just about eating pizza—it’s about joining local debates, uncovering sauces that wake up your tastebuds, and finding where tradition meets creativity. If you’re hungry for answers (and maybe a slice), you’re in the right spot.
Where to find the best pizza in Manorville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Manorville, NY:
- Pennachio’s
- Carlo’s Pizza Manorville
- jaymie’s Pizza
- Carlo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante
- PizzAmore
- John Vito’s Pizza Corp
- The Slice
- Savarona Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Mastic Pizza & Cafe
- Alitalia Pizza & Restaurant of Center Moriches
1. Pennachio’s
Pennachio’s sits quietly off County Road 111 but rarely stays a secret for long. The minute you walk in, you’re greeted by the comforting aroma of their signature pies and a staff that treats every guest like a regular. My first visit ended with a perfect margherita slice—crisp crust, just the right char, and bright, fresh basil.
What sets Pennachio’s apart is attention to detail. The dough is always light but sturdy, never soggy in the middle, which means each slice holds its own from first bite to last. The sauce tastes like summer tomatoes, with no shortcuts taken.
If you’re ordering, don’t miss their classic cheese pizza or Sicilian pie. Both showcase Pennachio’s respect for tradition and their dedication to quality. This is where Manorville’s pizza cravings feel truly satisfied.
2. Carlo’s Pizza Manorville
Carlo’s Pizza Manorville is one of those spots where the line out the door makes perfect sense once you taste a slice. My last visit was a classic New York experience—folding a hot, cheesy slice and realizing I’d found my new go-to.
What makes Carlo’s stand out is their balance. The crust hits that sweet spot of crispy and chewy, and the cheese-to-sauce ratio is always on point. It never feels overloaded or skimped.
If you’re new, try their plain cheese or the white pizza. Both highlight their ingredient quality and skill, while the garlic knots are a quiet addiction not to be overlooked. This is the kind of pizza that turns one slice into three before you know it.
3. jaymie’s Pizza
jaymie’s Pizza sits a little off the beaten path, but that just means more pizza for those in the know. I learned about it from a local who swore their slices were worth a detour—and they were right. The first thing you notice is the inviting, unfussy vibe, where the pizza does all the talking.
What sets jaymie’s apart is their handcrafted approach. The crust is always crisp, the sauce has a touch of sweetness, and the cheese melts evenly from edge to edge. It’s a spot where quality isn’t compromised, even during the busy lunch rush.
Try the veggie slice or a classic plain pie. Both showcase jaymie’s Pizza’s dedication to flavor and their knack for keeping things simple and satisfying.
4. Carlo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante
(631) 878-2345Call
Carlo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante carries the heart of an Italian kitchen right onto Wading River Rd. When I stopped in, the scent of baking dough and roasted garlic made the wait feel like part of the experience. The space buzzes with families, sharing laughter and stacks of warm, cheesy slices.
Carlo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante is special because it blends classic pizzeria comfort with a more refined touch. You can tell every pizza is made with pride, from the careful layering of cheese to their perfectly crisped edges.
If you’re looking to try something great, order a Margherita or their veggie-loaded pie. Both highlight their fresh ingredients, bright flavors, and a crust that manages to be both crisp and airy—an unmistakable Manorville classic.
5. PizzAmore
PizzAmore is the type of place where regulars greet each other by name—but new faces always get a warm welcome. My first visit was fueled by curiosity and ended with a box of leftovers I couldn’t bear to leave behind. The staff keeps things friendly, while the pizza is anything but ordinary.
PizzAmore really stands out for their creative approach. They use fresh cheeses and a sauce that packs a gentle zing, finding balance rather than going overboard. Every bite is thoughtfully made, and it shows.
If you want their best, try the thin-crust grandma slice or their veggie pizza. These options are crisp, full of flavor, and let you see exactly why PizzAmore is a favorite in the Manorville area.
6. John Vito’s Pizza Corp
(631) 591-3922Call
John Vito’s Pizza Corp has that classic neighborhood vibe that makes you want to linger a bit longer. I ended up here after a short drive, greeted by the steady hum of the oven and a counter loaded with fresh, bubbling pies. There’s a lived-in comfort to the place that makes it easy to become a regular.
What makes John Vito’s shine is the reliability of their pies. The slices are generous, with crusts that balance chew and crunch, and a sauce that’s tangy without being overpowering. This is a place that nails the fundamentals.
Go for their plain slice to get the full experience, or try the Sicilian if you want a sturdier bite. Both options show off John Vito’s focus on honest, no-nonsense pizza that keeps you coming back.
7. The Slice
The Slice is the spot that brings the local community together with an impressive and lively menu. Walking in, I was struck by the sheer variety on display—specialty pies lined up next to classic slices, sending out a warm, toasty aroma. Every visit feels like food adventure, whether you’re craving a quick bite or looking to try something different.
What makes The Slice unique is their range. You can get everything from a deep dish pizza to inventive specialty pies, always with high-quality ingredients and a crust that lands in that golden zone between thick and crisp. They don’t shy away from bold flavors.
If you want the true experience, sample their signature deep dish pizza or a veggie specialty pie. Both options let you see the kitchen’s creativity and their skill for making each slice truly satisfying.
8. Savarona Pizzeria & Restaurant
Savarona Pizzeria & Restaurant is the kind of welcoming place that quickly earns a spot in your regular rotation. My first time there, late on a rainy afternoon, I ended up sharing laughs with the staff while waiting for a steaming hot pie. The dining room buzzes with happy families and that unmistakable scent of fresh dough in the air.
Savarona excels at consistency. Each pizza comes out with a thin, golden crust, just the right chew, and toppings placed with care. Their sauce is balanced, not too sweet or salty, and the cheese always tastes fresh and plentiful.
Order a classic margherita or any of their specialty veggie pies—they highlight Savarona’s attention to detail and knack for turning simple ingredients into something reliably crave-worthy.
9. Mastic Pizza & Cafe
(631) 395-7400Call
Mastic Pizza & Cafe is a true neighborhood favorite that never lets you down after a long day. My first visit was on their busiest night, but service was quick and the pizza came out piping hot—a small victory in itself. The laid-back atmosphere makes you want to stay for just one more slice.
What separates Mastic Pizza & Cafe from the pack is their generous portions and commitment to classic flavors. The crust is always perfectly golden, and you can taste the freshness in every bite of sauce and cheese.
If you’re picking something to try, go for their cheese pizza or one of their veggie pies. Both show off Mastic Pizza & Cafe’s focus on honest, satisfying slices that hit the spot every time.
10. Alitalia Pizza & Restaurant of Center Moriches
(631) 874-3810Call
Alitalia Pizza & Restaurant of Center Moriches has the charm and warmth of a place that’s been in the neighborhood for decades. The first time I popped in, a steady stream of regulars filtered through, everyone talking about their favorite pies with real affection. That’s how you know you’re in the right place for pizza.
Alitalia stands out for its balance of old-school authenticity and approachable comfort. The sauce is rich but never overpowering, and the crust carries enough chew to stand up to heartier toppings. Each pie is made with a level of care you can taste.
Try the veggie pizza or plain slice if you like things classic. Both highlight Alitalia’s steady hand with flavors and their devotion to honest, satisfying pizza that brings people back week after week.
More Things to Try in Manorville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Manorville, NY?
Some top choices include Pennachio’s, Carlo’s Pizza Manorville, and jaymie’s Pizza. Each spot offers unique takes on classic and specialty pizzas, so you’ll find something for any craving.
Are there any vegetarian pizza options in Manorville?
Absolutely. Most local pizzerias, including Pennachio’s and Savarona Pizzeria & Restaurant, offer a variety of veggie pies made with fresh ingredients.
Which places offer gluten-free pizza in Manorville?
Several local favorites, such as Carlo’s Pizza Manorville and The Slice, have gluten-free crust options available upon request.
Can I order pizza for delivery in Manorville?
Yes, most pizza places offer delivery. It’s a great option for days when you want a fresh pie brought straight to your door.
Where can I get a traditional New York-style slice in Manorville?
Try Pennachio’s or John Vito’s Pizza Corp for that classic New York-style pizza—thin, flexible, and foldable with just the right amount of crunch.