If you’ve ever found yourself wandering Main Street, stomach rumbling, eyes darting for that perfect slice, you know there’s no shortage of choices in Holbrook. Each spot seems to promise “the best pizza in town,” but the phrase loses meaning when you’re holding a floppy, tasteless piece of cardboard. So what makes the real winners here stand out? I’ve spent nights arguing with friends over crust textures, sampled cheese from bubbling pies, and risked a burnt mouth just to get that first, hot bite.
Holbrook’s pizza scene is more than a string of take-out joints—it’s a fusion of local family recipes, classic New York style, and a few unexpected surprises. Whether you crave a thin, crispy base or a slice loaded with toppings, you’ll find your match here. The spots on this list aren’t random; they’re handpicked from experience, heated debates, and a fair amount of pizza-induced joy. Settle in while I guide you through the picks that have earned their place on Holbrook’s pizza radar.
Where to find the best pizza in Holbrook, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Holbrook, NY:
- Joe’s Pizza & Pasta
- Aegean Pizza & Italian Restaurant
- Costco
- Mamma Lombardi’s Restaurant
- Domino’s Pizza
- Oven Lovin Heros & Pizza
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Lombardi’s Market
- Angelina’s Pizza
- Villa Lombardi’s
1. Joe’s Pizza & Pasta
Joe’s Pizza & Pasta brings a classic New York pizzeria vibe—unpretentious, cozy, and always busy. When I last stopped by, a thin, piping hot Margherita was the first thing I ordered. The crust balanced the right amount of chew with a subtle crackle, and the sauce tasted like it simmered all day.
The menu is straightforward, but the flavors aren’t. Their Sicilian slice is a local favorite: thick, airy dough with just enough cheese and a tangy, robust sauce. If you like your pizza simple but expertly done, start here.
Joe’s doesn’t just serve food; they serve comfort. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a pie to go, each bite feels like home. Ask for the classic cheese—sometimes less really is more.
2. Aegean Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Aegean Pizza & Italian Restaurant blends warmth and tradition in a way that always feels inviting. On my last visit, I lingered over a big slice of their signature White Pizza, which stands out for its creamy ricotta and perfectly browned mozzarella. The staff seem to know the regulars by name, which says plenty about their loyal following.
The crust has that sweet spot between crisp and tender, making each bite memorable. Aegean doesn’t shy away from bold flavors, and their veggie slice is piled high yet manages not to overwhelm the dough beneath.
If you want a cozy spot for lunch or a quick takeout dinner, this is your place. Start with a classic cheese or try the Sicilian for a thicker, heartier base—the perfect representation of their casual Italian style.
3. Costco
Costco in Holbrook may not look like your typical pizzeria, but it attracts pizza fans for reasons that go beyond price. I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve grabbed a slice while running errands and ended up surprised by the generous size and sturdy, chewy crust. It’s the definition of straightforward comfort food.
What sets Costco pizza apart is that it’s always hot, fresh, and made for sharing. The cheese and sauce ratio feels just right, each bite rewarding in its familiarity.
Order their cheese or veggie pizza by the slice or as a whole pie when you have a crowd to feed. It’s simple, satisfying, and never fussy—a true Holbrook staple for families on the go or anyone craving a no-nonsense slice.
4. Mamma Lombardi’s Restaurant
Mamma Lombardi’s feels like walking into a friend’s home for dinner, with walls echoing generations of family stories. I remember my first bite of their Margherita pizza—thin, oven-blistered crust and a balance of fresh mozzarella and basil that called for slow, appreciative eating.
The scratch kitchen makes all the difference here. Sauces are bright, crusts are crisp, and you can taste real care in every slice. Even the pizza menu impresses, with dozens of classic and creative choices available.
If you want variety, consider the Quattro Stagioni or go for a classic Cheese if you prefer simple pleasures. This spot captures the essence of traditional Italian pizza with each dish, making it a must for anyone craving the real thing in Holbrook.
5. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Holbrook nails consistency and convenience every time. I’ve grabbed a late-night Thin Crust Veggie and been surprised by the loaded toppings and the way the cheese stretches with each pull. For those nights when kitchen ambition runs low, Domino’s steps up.
The menu covers classic and inventive bases, from the Handmade Pan to the crisp New York Style crust. If you want something filling, their cheese pizza is gooey and hits the spot, while the Veggie is loaded without weighing you down.
Domino’s is the king of fast, hot delivery and those tempting deals. Grab a classic slice for quick comfort or experiment with the Parmesan Crust for a little extra flavor. It’s pizza that comes to you, exactly the way you want it.
6. Oven Lovin Heros & Pizza
Oven Lovin Heros & Pizza brings an old-school pizza shop charm to Holbrook. I first wandered in after a busy afternoon, drawn by the aroma drifting out onto Main Street. Their pizza combines a hearty, chewy crust with generous sauce, each slice feeling like a reward for your patience.
What separates Oven Lovin is their consistency and the sheer comfort packed into every bite. The classic cheese slice is timeless, but if you’re feeling adventurous, try the veggie option. Each topping is fresh, never skimped, and the pizza never arrives greasy.
This is the neighborhood spot that keeps customers returning for decades. Pair a slice with one of their famous heros for a true taste of local tradition in Holbrook.
7. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza in Holbrook always delivers exactly what it promises: a fresh, hot pie with dough that feels pillowy and flavors that never taste artificial. My own go-to is their classic cheese pizza, which arrives with a crisp edge and a satisfying stretch of mozzarella.
Their commitment to “Better Ingredients” is more than a catchy phrase. You’ll notice the tangy signature sauce and the way each topping feels thoughtfully chosen. The veggie pizza is another highlight, with colorful peppers and just the right sprinkle of seasoning.
If you’re looking for takeout that hits the spot, start here. The pizzas are always cut clean, and the crust will stay soft even after the drive home. For a simple pleasure, stick to the basics and enjoy how Papa Johns does classic pizza right.
8. Lombardi’s Market
Lombardi’s Market brings a touch of Italy to Holbrook in the most genuine way. My first time there, I was lured in by trays of fresh-baked pizza cooling behind the counter, each one looking like a meal meant for a celebration. You can tell these pies are crafted by people who care about tradition.
The dough comes out light but sturdy, just the way a good slice should be. The Margherita is a must—bursting with fresh basil, crisp edges, and that classic, bright tomato sauce.
Stop by for a quick bite or pick up a whole pie for the family. Lombardi’s Market sets itself apart by taking everyday pizza and turning it into something that feels a little more special, every single time.
9. Angelina’s Pizza
Angelina’s Pizza has that friendly, no-frills energy you want in a neighborhood pizzeria. I dropped by on a rainy afternoon, craving something comforting, and their classic cheese slice delivered simple satisfaction. The crust is sturdy but never heavy, and the sauce leans just a bit sweet—enough to keep you reaching for another bite.
What makes Angelina’s shine is their dedication to quality with every fresh pie. The veggie pizza stands out for its bright, crisp toppings and just the right ratio of cheese to sauce.
If you love a pizza that tastes like it was made especially for you, this is your spot. Grab a slice of their Margherita for a taste of something both familiar and a little bit special, right in the heart of Holbrook.
10. Villa Lombardi’s
Villa Lombardi’s wraps you in a warm, elegant atmosphere from the moment you step inside. My first meal here felt special before the food even arrived, and their pizzas easily matched the mood—think thin, C risp crusts and velvety cheese baked to perfection.
Pizzas here reflect a genuine Northern Italian spirit, balancing tradition and bold flavors. The Margherita is delicate and fresh, while their veggie pie delivers vivid flavors and a medley of textures in each slice.
This is the kind of place to enjoy pizza as a main event, not just a quick bite. Whether it’s a quiet dinner or a longer celebration, Villa Lombardi’s elevates every slice in a way that makes you want to linger a bit longer.
More Things to Try in Holbrook, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Holbrook, NY?
Some of the top options include Joe’s Pizza & Pasta, Aegean Pizza & Italian Restaurant, Mamma Lombardi’s, Angelina’s Pizza, and Lombardi’s Market. Each spot offers its own style and loyal following.
Where can I find vegetarian pizza in Holbrook?
Nearly every pizzeria in Holbrook offers vegetarian-friendly options. Joe’s, Mamma Lombardi’s, and Papa Johns have standout veggie pies with generous toppings and flavorful sauces.
Does Holbrook have gluten-free pizza?
Yes, places like Mamma Lombardi’s offer gluten-free options. Always check with the restaurant to confirm availability and preparation details.
Which pizza places are good for families?
Mamma Lombardi’s, Oven Lovin Heros & Pizza, and Lombardi’s Market are relaxed spots ideal for families. They offer plenty of seating, takeout, and a friendly atmosphere.
Are there late-night pizza options in Holbrook?
Domino’s and Papa Johns are reliable for late-night delivery or carryout, making them convenient for last-minute cravings.
Can I get pizza delivered in Holbrook?
Yes, most places including Domino’s, Papa Johns, and Lombardi’s Market offer delivery services. Some also partner with delivery apps for extra convenience.