Nothing tests a town’s character quite like its pizza. In Hershey, the charm of chocolate isn’t the only thing pulling people in. The diversity and quality of pizza joints sprinkled across this sweet spot could turn even the most devoted dessert lover into a sauce-and-cheese enthusiast. I remember my first slice in Hershey, sitting in a no-frills booth, surprised at how a small local shop could serve up a crust with just the right chew. It made me realize there’s more to this area than roller coasters and candy bars.
Whether you love classic pies or have a nose for creative toppings, Hershey serves up styles that suit every taste and every crowd. The local spots carry the town’s friendliness, and even the big chains seem to compete harder for your attention. So, if you’re on the hunt for the next pie worth bragging about, stick around. Your next slice might just become your new favorite memory.
1. Jo-Jo’s Pizza
Jo-Jo’s Pizza isn’t just about grabbing a quick slice; it’s a local institution with a steady following. Step inside and you’ll notice the calm confidence of a place that’s been getting it right for years. There’s a warmth here that isn’t rushed—staff greet regulars by name and never fumble an order.
The magic is in their traditional-style pies, baked with crisp edges and tangy sauce that tastes like someone in the back just crushed the tomatoes. The crust walks the perfect line between chew and crunch—a rare feat. My usual order is a plain cheese or the veggie, both reliable ways to test the chef’s touch.
If you’re hungry for classic, unpretentious pizza that never feels phoned in, Jo-Jo’s should top your list.
2. PALERMOS Pizza II
If you think every pizza place feels the same, PALERMOS Pizza II will surprise you. It’s tucked easily along East Chocolate Avenue, but it never fades into the background. There’s a buzz of regular traffic, and something inviting about the fresh dough scent that escapes whenever the door swings open.
PALERMOS stands out for its balance of generous portions and budget-friendly prices, especially their Large Cheese Pizza for $10.99. It doesn’t hurt that the pies come out crisp and loaded with tangy sauce under a sturdy blanket of Grande cheese.
Their stromboli is worth a detour, but for that first visit, get a classic cheese or add on veggies for an extra punch of flavor. The menu is broad, so even non-pizza lovers have good options to keep everyone happy.
3. A & M Pizza Restaurant
At A & M Pizza Restaurant, the friendly, family-run atmosphere greets you as soon as you open the door. This place feels like an old friend once you’ve been in even once, thanks to its welcoming staff and laid-back vibe. I first stopped by on a rainy afternoon, hoping for a quick lunch, and ended up lingering far longer than planned, chatting and savoring each bite.
Their traditional dough and zesty, house-made sauce give every slice a backbone of real flavor. Cheese lovers are in for a treat, but if you want to branch out, the veggie pizza stands out with its fresh toppings and golden crust. Everything here feels thoughtfully prepared and never rushed.
If you want classic, heartfelt pizza done right, this is your spot.
4. Mr Sorrento’s Pizza
(717) 534-1660Call
Mr Sorrento’s Pizza captures the feel of a neighborhood pizzeria—familiar, friendly, and always humming with the comfort of regulars. Walking in, I noticed families sharing large pies and friends swapping stories over slices. This is the kind of spot where they remember your order if you come back twice.
The appeal lies in their classic approach: a sturdy, golden crust, a bright tomato sauce, and cheese that stretches just the right way. The crust always hits that elusive line between crispy and chewy. The veggie pizza is loaded with fresh ingredients, and the plain cheese is a test any pizza fan should try first.
If you’re after honest, fuss-free pizza with a local soul, Mr Sorrento’s keeps things simple and exactly right.
5. J & S Pizza
(717) 867-5508Call
J & S Pizza draws you in with the sort of unassuming, small-town vibe that never feels forced. It’s the spot where you’ll hear local chatter and see regulars picking up their usual. I stopped in once after a long day, and a single slice was enough to turn my whole evening around.
The dough is hearty and handmade, with a perfect balance between crispy and soft. The sauce has a gentle tang that never overpowers. If you’re someone who thinks the simple pies reveal the real deal, try their cheese or plain veggie. Every pizza arrives steaming, fresh, and crowd-pleasing.
For a reliable and satisfying pizza experience, J & S gets the formula just right.
6. Bear’s Den at the Hershey GRLL
Bear’s Den at the Hershey GRLL is more than a pizza stop—it’s an experience built for families and true sports fans. Picture a hockey-rink theme, big screens on every wall, and friendly staff who keep things lively. When I wandered in on a game night, the energy was infectious and the pizzas came out piping hot every time.
Their pizza stands out for its fluffy, hand-tossed crust and generous cheese coverage. The veggie pizza is always a hit at my table, thanks to crisp toppings and a sauce that balances sweet with savory. For group outings, sharing a pizza here feels especially festive.
If you’re after good pizza and a lively, welcoming spot to catch the big game, Bear’s Den delivers both in spades.
7. Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar
Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar is a legend with roots in Pittsburgh, but its Hershey spot feels like it belongs to the locals. If you walk in craving great pizza and a lively scene, you’ve landed in the right place. On my last visit, I sat near the window with friends, watching the world go by and sharing slices that disappeared almost too quickly.
Their pizza is about hearty flavors and crowd-pleasing combinations. Crust is crisp, cheese is rich, and toppings don’t skimp on the freshness. A classic cheese or a loaded veggie pizza are both great picks, depending on your mood.
For anyone looking to pair great pies with a buzzing, friendly energy, Primanti Bros. nails it every time.
8. Your Place Restaurant & Sports Pub
Your Place Restaurant & Sports Pub feels like Hershey’s living room—warm, familiar, and buzzing with conversation. It’s family-owned, and you can sense the pride in every detail. This was where I first tried their crisp, golden pizza crust, surrounded by regulars who rave about the stromboli as much as the pies.
The pizza here has a signature style: thick, airy crust and plenty of bubbling cheese. Go classic with a cheese pie or try the veggie if you like fresh toppings and a tangy sauce that lifts every bite. Large screens make it easy to catch a game while you eat.
It’s the place for big flavors, good company, and a slice that always leaves you satisfied.
9. Mangia Mangia
Mangia Mangia is the place you visit when you want your pizza to feel like an Italian holiday—without ever leaving Hershey. The dining room fills with the aroma of fresh dough, and there’s always a cheerful hum from tables sharing stories over hot pies. I remember my first visit: the staff treated me like family, guiding me through their favorite menu picks.
The pizzas here bring real rustic flair—thin, crisp crust topped with simple, high-quality ingredients. The Margherita stands out, with bright tomato, creamy mozzarella, and a fresh basil finish. Or try a veggie pizza for a generous serving of garden-fresh toppings.
Everything at Mangia Mangia feels thoughtfully made, perfect for when you want pizza that feels special and truly authentic.
10. Fenicci’s of Hershey
Fenicci’s of Hershey is more than Hershey’s oldest restaurant—it’s where tradition meets a crowd that appreciates the classics. The warm buzz of conversation never seems to fade, and there’s a sense you’re part of local history with every bite. I found myself instantly charmed by the vintage flair and the parade of regulars who remember every staff member’s name.
Their famous Upside Down Pizza is the star here—a unique spin that puts the cheese beneath the sauce, creating a hearty, perfectly layered slice every time. The flavor is bold and anchored by their homemade sauce recipe that’s stuck around for generations.
If you want to try a Hershey original, this is the spot where pizza gets a memorable twist.
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of pizza can I find in Hershey, PA?
You’ll find a wide range from classic thin crust and thick Sicilian styles to specialty pies topped with everything from fresh veggies to inventive cheese blends. There are also spots putting their own twist on old favorites, so there’s plenty to explore beyond the basics.
Are there any local pizza places open late in Hershey?
Yes, a handful of local pizzerias and chains in Hershey serve late into the evening, especially on weekends. Always check each restaurant’s hours before heading out, as they can shift with the season or event calendar.
Is there good pizza for vegetarians in Hershey?
Most of Hershey’s pizzerias offer strong veggie options, with fresh toppings like mushrooms, peppers, onions, tomato, and olives. Some even have signature vegetable pies with their own unique spin.
Which Hershey pizza spots are good for families?
Family-friendly picks include Jo-Jo’s Pizza, Bear’s Den at the Hershey GRLL, and Fenicci’s of Hershey. These spots combine a relaxed setting with plenty of choices for kids and adults alike.
Can I order pizza delivery in Hershey?
Absolutely. Delivery is available from both national chains and many local favorites. Most places offer phone and online ordering, making it easy to enjoy your pie at home or in your hotel room.
Are there gluten-free pizza options available?
A growing number of Hershey pizza shops offer gluten-free crusts. Always check with the restaurant about preparation if you have specific allergy concerns.