Finding good pizza in Garden City, NY is a rite of passage. Crisp edges, bubbly cheese, and that first bite—there’s a story behind every slice. I’ve wandered the busy main streets and side roads here on many nights, all in pursuit of the most memorable slices. It’s a journey filled with tangy sauces, swoon-worthy crusts, and a few surprises along the way.
If you think you’ve already tasted the best, think again. Garden City’s pizza scene keeps raising the bar, and each stop on this list proves it. Whether you’re a classic cheese loyalist or you lean into inventive toppings, you’re likely to find a new favorite. This guide comes from someone who takes pizza seriously. Let’s navigate the saucy, cheesy landscape together—a delicious adventure is ahead.
Where to find the best pizza in Garden City, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Garden City, NY:
- Grimaldi’s Pizzeria
- Rustica Brick Oven Cafe
- Pizza Supreme
- Garden City Pizza
- Marco’s Pizza
- Sbarro
- Pizzeria G
- Bleecker Street Pizza
- Grimaldi’s Pizza
- Guido’s Pizzaria Inc
1. Grimaldi’s Pizzeria
Grimaldi’s Pizzeria sits at 980 Franklin Ave and draws pizza lovers for good reason. There’s something special about their signature crust—it’s crisp with just the right chew. I once stopped in on a rainy night, craving comfort, and left convinced their pies are reliable mood-lifters.
The wood-fired pizzas are the main event here. The classic Margherita brims with rich sauce and fresh basil, while the White Pizza has a creamy finish perfect for late-night cravings. Gluten free, vegetarian, and vegan options add to the crowd-pleasing menu.
Try a custom pie with roasted vegetables for a taste of Garden City’s best. Grimaldi’s delivers warmth and tradition by the slice, which is exactly why it belongs at the top of any pizza list.
2. Rustica Brick Oven Cafe
Rustica Brick Oven Cafe, found at 1 Nassau Blvd, feels like a neighborhood secret worth sharing. On my last visit, the smell of fresh dough and the open flames behind the counter set the mood for something memorable. There’s a distinct rustic charm; it’s clear the team puts care into every pie.
The brick oven makes all the difference. Each pizza arrives with a blistered, smoky crust, crisp yet light. Their Margherita showcases this best, blending creamy mozzarella with fragrant basil and a tangy tomato base.
The Rustica Veggie—piled high with seasonal vegetables—offers a colorful taste of the cafe’s creativity. The menu is vegetarian friendly, keeping everyone at the table satisfied.
3. Pizza Supreme
Pizza Supreme on Stewart Ave feels like a cornerstone for anyone who loves authentic New York–style pizza. My first bite into their signature slice reminded me why thin crust will always have a loyal following. There’s a satisfying snap, balanced by generous cheese and a sauce that leans just a bit sweet.
Their Supreme Special is a crowd-pleaser, brimming with fresh peppers, mushrooms, and olives. It captures the spirit of the place: classic flavors done right. Each order arrives hot and fresh, whether you pick it up or have it delivered.
The veggie slice is a must for anyone craving greens with their cheese. Pizza Supreme keeps it simple, letting the quality of the ingredients take the lead every single time.
4. Garden City Pizza
Garden City Pizza is more than a staple—it’s woven into the rhythm of Franklin Ave. I’ve popped in at odd hours, and there’s always a sense of welcome, whether the craving hits midday or late at night. The menu runs deep, but pizza is clearly the headliner.
Classic cheese slices here are honest and satisfying, showing off a perfect ratio of crust to topping. If you want to sample something outside the norm, their spinach or eggplant pies are packed with flavor and absolutely worth a try.
Portions are generous, making it an easy stop when you’re hungry or feeding a group. It’s a reliable spot where comfort food always hits the mark.
5. Marco’s Pizza
Marco’s Pizza feels like the go-to place when you want a no-fuss, consistently tasty pie. After a long day, I’ve found comfort in their warm, cheesy slices more than once. The vibe is always casual, and service never feels rushed.
Marco’s original crust sets it apart. It’s golden, just thick enough for each bite to feel hearty, yet never heavy. If you’re indecisive, try the Garden Pizza; crisp veggies and a hint of garlic bring out the best in every topping.
The cheese pizza is a safe bet for purists, while their deluxe pies let you sample the range of fresh produce. Marco’s keeps the menu straightforward, focusing on what it does best—great pizza, time after time.
6. Sbarro
Sbarro at Roosevelt Field Shopping Center brings a bit of classic mall nostalgia with every slice. There’s something reassuring about spotting that familiar counter when hunger strikes during a shopping trip. I’ve ducked in countless times for a quick meal, and Sbarro always delivers with its signature New York–style pies.
Their cheese slice stands tall—gooey, foldable, and easy to eat on the go. If you’re looking for something a little more robust, their veggie slice layers on peppers, spinach, and olives for extra color and flavor.
Portions are generous, making it easy to share or fill up after a long day. Sbarro stays true to its roots by keeping things simple, satisfying, and fast.
7. Pizzeria G
Pizzeria G on 7th Street catches your eye with its cozy storefront and keeps you coming back with top-tier pies. The last time I stopped by, the friendly staff and the smell of fresh dough made waiting feel almost enjoyable. There’s a local energy here that bigger chains can’t replicate.
The Neapolitan-style pizza is the standout. A thin, soft base with blistered edges, layered with bright tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella, speaks to real craftsmanship.
Try the classic Margherita or a veggie-topped pie to taste their quality ingredients at work. Pizzeria G’s menu stays focused—what they do, they do well, and every slice is proof.
8. Bleecker Street Pizza
Bleecker Street Pizza, tucked on Old Country Road, feels like a little slice of the city in Garden City. The first time I dropped in, the staff treated me like a regular, and the kitchen buzzed with energy. It’s the kind of spot where you can grab a slice and watch the world go by.
The crust here is thin and crisp, providing a perfect base for their rich tomato sauce and quality cheese. Bleecker’s Famous Slice is a nod to tradition but feels fresh with each bite.
Go for the white pizza or a veggie slice if you’re in the mood for something different. At Bleecker Street, every pie feels like it’s made with care and a bit of New York attitude.
9. Grimaldi’s Pizza
Grimaldi’s Pizza on Franklin Ave has built a reputation that stretches far beyond Garden City. My last visit turned into an impromptu dinner with friends, and every bite was an event. The interior feels inviting, perfect for anything from a quick lunch to a slow, shared meal.
The standout here is their coal-fired pizza, known for a crisp base and subtle smoky notes. There’s real balance in every slice, from the sweetness of the sauce to the melt of the cheese.
The Margherita and veggie pies are clear favorites, each showcasing fresh, quality ingredients. Grimaldi’s delivers on those small details—classic pizza, done with just the right flourish.
10. Guido’s Pizzaria Inc
(516) 354-2721Call
Guido’s Pizzaria Inc on New Hyde Park Rd is the kind of place that wins fans by doing the essentials well. I remember ducking in for a quick slice one rainy afternoon, only to linger longer than planned. The smell of baking dough and the hum of kitchen chatter set a comforting stage.
Their pizza has a sturdy, golden crust—just thick enough to satisfy, but never heavy. The cheese blend is generous, and the sauce has a hint of sweetness that stands out without overpowering.
The veggie slice is a reliable favorite, stacked with fresh toppings and balanced flavor. Guido’s brings cozy, classic pizza done right, making it a reliable stop for a quality meal any day.
More Things to Try in Garden City, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top places for pizza in Garden City, NY?
Some local favorites include Grimaldi’s Pizzeria, Rustica Brick Oven Cafe, Pizza Supreme, and Garden City Pizza. Each spot offers its own style, so you can find anything from classic New York slices to creative veggie pies.
Do any Garden City pizzerias offer gluten-free or vegan options?
Yes, places like Grimaldi’s Pizzeria offer gluten-free and vegan-friendly choices. Always call ahead or check online menus for the latest selection.
Which pizza place is best for takeout or delivery?
Most pizzerias in Garden City, such as Pizza Supreme, Marco’s Pizza, and Domino’s Pizza, provide reliable takeout and delivery services for a quick and easy meal at home.
Where can I get a classic New York–style slice in Garden City?
Pizza Supreme and Sbarro are known for their classic, foldable New York–style slices that are both convenient and flavorful.
Are there any spots with good vegetarian pizza in Garden City?
You’ll find great vegetarian options at Garden City Pizza, Rustica Brick Oven Cafe, and Bleecker Street Pizza, featuring fresh veggie toppings and cheesy goodness.