There’s a science to tracking down the best pizza in Arlington, TX. This isn’t a job for the indecisive or the easily distracted. Choosing the right place could mean the difference between a crust that makes you question reality and one that leaves you plotting your next slice elsewhere. Fortunately, Arlington is dotted with pizzerias promising just the right mix of chewy dough, perfectly blended sauce, and toppings that actually mean something.
My own quest for great pizza in Arlington started out simple: escape bland chain pies and find something that people talk about—at least among those who know the value of robust flavor and a well-fired oven. The result? A list that’s both broad in choices and razor-sharp in quality, so you’ll always find a spot that suits your mood. If you’ve ever wondered where local pizza obsessives keep returning, you’re about to have your answer.
Where to find the best pizza in Arlington, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Arlington, TX:
- Moni’s
- Nizza Pizza North Arlington
- New Yorker Pizza and Pasta
- Blaze Pizza
- Brooklyn’s Best Pizza & Pasta
- Mellow Mushroom Arlington
- Italy Pizza and Pasta
- Old School Pizza Tavern
- Pie Five Pizza Co.
- Prespa’s
1. Moni’s
Moni’s captures the feel of a warm, neighborhood spot where locals actually linger over slices rather than rush out the door. I’ve found it’s the kind of place where you’re greeted by name if you’ve been in more than once. The staff moves at a friendly pace, and you can tell they care about what comes out of their kitchen.
What makes Moni’s stand out is their dedication to quality—big, foldable New York-style slices, but also a crust that never gets lost under layers of sauce and cheese.
For those searching for the best pizza in Arlington, I’d point straight to the Margherita Pizza. Its fresh basil, silky mozzarella, and balanced sauce really sum up what Moni’s is about: simple, unpretentious quality. Vegetarian and vegan options round out the menu, making it easy for everyone to leave happy.
2. Nizza Pizza North Arlington
Nizza Pizza North Arlington feels like a step into classic East Coast pizza tradition, but with a Texas spin. I stumbled in hungry one afternoon and came out a convert—this place knows how to treat pizza lovers.
The crust is what grabs you first. It’s thin, crisp at the edges, and carries that slow-proofed flavor. Every bite of their pizza shows real attention to detail, with toppings placed just right and cheese that doesn’t drown the pie.
Try the Spinach Pizza or the Vegetarian Combo. Both give you a generous helping of fresh vegetables, bright sauce, and plenty of flavor without being heavy. There’s nothing rushed at Nizza, only slices that get better with each bite.
3. New Yorker Pizza and Pasta
New Yorker Pizza and Pasta is a go-to for anyone craving that true New York slice—think thin, wide, and just the right amount of chew. The space has that timeless, family-owned feel where regulars get the first nod and newcomers never stay strangers for long.
Tables fill up fast, especially on weekends, but there’s rarely a sense of rush. You can unwind, talk, and really enjoy your meal here. It’s BYOB, so those laid-back dinners can get even cozier.
For pizza, the White Pizza stands above the rest. It’s simple, loaded with creamy ricotta, mozzarella, and garlic, showing off how less is more. Don’t miss the classic cheese pizza either; it nails that New York flavor Arlington rarely sees.
4. Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza is the spot for those who want pizza with a twist of speed and creativity. Think fast-fired pies where you call the shots but never sacrifice taste. My first visit was equal parts experiment and adventure, customizing a pizza I could call my own in a place that actually encourages it.
What makes Blaze stand out is its open assembly line. You can pick from over 30 toppings, watch as it all comes together, and then see it vanish into their blazing oven. Just a few minutes later, that custom creation is crisp and ready, exactly how you pictured it.
If you aren’t sure where to start, the Green Stripe Pizza is a safe bet. Pesto, roasted veggies, and cheese meet in a way that makes each bite brighter than the last. There are also plenty of vegetarian and vegan options, so everyone can find a slice to crave.
5. Brooklyn’s Best Pizza & Pasta
Brooklyn’s Best Pizza & Pasta does exactly what the name promises: it channels the spirit of Brooklyn pie into Arlington without missing a beat. Walk in and you’re greeted by the scent of garlic and bubbling cheese that lets you know they don’t cut corners here.
I stopped in on a rainy afternoon and ended up staying longer than planned, drawn in by the friendly buzz and a pizza that arrived piping hot, the crust charred in all the right places. The red-checkered tablecloths and casual chatter make you feel like you’ve stumbled onto a neighborhood favorite.
You can’t go wrong with a slice of their Veggie Pizza. It’s loaded with fresh mushrooms, bell peppers, and black olives, creating a pie that’s colorful, crisp, and full of flavor. This is where you go when you want that unmistakable old-school style done right.
6. Mellow Mushroom Arlington
Mellow Mushroom Arlington feels like stepping into an art project fueled by creativity—and really good pizza. The quirky decor caught my eye the first time I visited, but it was the stone-baked crust and inventive toppings that convinced me to come back.
This is the spot for those who appreciate a crust with some personality. Mellow Mushroom leans into bold flavor combos and a dough that’s both soft and sturdy—perfect for carrying plenty of toppings.
The Holy Shiitake Pie deserves special mention. Roasted mushrooms, creamy cheese, and a drizzling of garlic aioli make this pizza unforgettable. With vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options, there’s something here for everyone, regardless of your preferences.
7. Italy Pizza and Pasta
Italy Pizza and Pasta is one of those hidden gems tucked away from Arlington’s busiest streets. My introduction came from a friend who swore it served the city’s most satisfying classic pies. The low-key atmosphere feels almost nostalgic, with friendly service and a menu packed with Italian comfort.
What sets Italy Pizza and Pasta apart is their dedication to traditional recipes. The dough, cheese, and sauce come together in a balanced, old-world style that always leaves you satisfied but never weighed down.
If you’re looking for the signature experience, order the Vegetarian Pizza. The combination of fresh peppers, mushrooms, and olives over a chewy base showcases both freshness and skill. It’s a no-nonsense place serving pizza that’s all about tradition and quality ingredients.
8. Old School Pizza Tavern
Old School Pizza Tavern is set inside a craftsman-style house, which immediately gives it a different kind of charm. The vibe is laid-back, and there’s a big patio that stays lively on good weather days. My own visit was during a sunset, sipping a soda while waiting for pizza—it felt like finding the best back-porch spot in town.
People love Old School for its no-fuss, perfectly baked pies. You get plenty of topping choices, but the familiarity of the dough and sauce makes it feel comfortingly classic.
The standout here is the Classic Veggie Pizza. Loaded with spinach, tomatoes, mushrooms, and just enough cheese, it’s a pizza that doesn’t hide behind gimmicks. It’s hearty, fresh, and easy to call a favorite.
9. Pie Five Pizza Co.
Pie Five Pizza Co. lands right on the mark for those who want control over every inch of their pizza. My last trip here was a custom-building adventure, and somehow it all worked perfectly without waiting around forever. The process is smooth, and you get a pie tailored to your mood in just minutes.
Pie Five stands out for its focus on fresh dough and house-made sauces. The options are flexible, with gluten-free and cauliflower crusts, plus vegan cheese that actually melts and tastes great. It’s clear they put thought into accommodating different diets without sacrificing taste.
Start with the High Five Pizza if you want something bold and balanced. Hand-cut veggies, melty cheese, and top-notch sauces come together on a crispy crust, showing off everything Pie Five does best.
10. Prespa’s
Prespa’s feels equal parts hometown hangout and hidden Italian kitchen. My first meal here was a quiet night with close friends, where conversation came easy and the pacing of dinner felt unhurried. There’s something genuine about the way the staff checks in and remembers regulars.
Prespa’s sets itself apart with pizzas that focus on fresh ingredients and time-honored recipes. The crust is gold—crisp on the outside and airy inside, carrying a bright, simple tomato sauce that doesn’t overwhelm.
Go for the Veggie Pizza. It arrives loaded with bell peppers, onions, black olives, and tomatoes, each bite distinct and well-balanced. Vegetarian and vegan options mean everyone gets a seat at the table, pizza in hand.
More Things to Try in Arlington, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Arlington, TX?
Some favorites include Moni’s, Nizza Pizza North Arlington, New Yorker Pizza and Pasta, Mellow Mushroom Arlington, and Brooklyn’s Best Pizza & Pasta. Each brings a unique style and atmosphere, from New York classic to local artisan.
Where can I find vegetarian or vegan pizza in Arlington?
You’ll find solid vegetarian and vegan options at places like Blaze Pizza, Mellow Mushroom Arlington, Prespa’s, and Pie Five Pizza Co. Many also offer vegan cheese and gluten-free crusts.
Which pizza spots offer gluten-free crusts in Arlington?
Blaze Pizza and Pie Five Pizza Co. both feature gluten-free or cauliflower crusts. Mellow Mushroom Arlington also offers gluten-free options, so everyone can find something delicious.
Are there any local pizza places with delivery in Arlington?
Yes, most spots such as Nizza Pizza North Arlington, New Yorker Pizza and Pasta, Italy Pizza and Pasta, and Prespa’s offer delivery along with takeout. Many use delivery apps to reach even further.
What is the pizza scene like in Arlington, TX?
Arlington’s pizza game covers classic New York pies, creative modern builds, and comforting local favorites. There’s something for every taste, whether you love thin crust, want vegan toppings, or prefer extra cheese.