Best Pizza in Lafayette, LA

In the heart of Lafayette, LA, the quest for the best pizza is a delicious adventure. With a melting pot of flavors and styles, pizza lovers can find everything from classic thin crust to creative gourmet options. Whether you’re a cheese aficionado, a meat lover, or a veggie enthusiast, Lafayette’s pizzerias are ready to cater to your cravings. This city has earned a reputation for its remarkable pie options, making it essential for anyone to discover what the local pizza scene has to offer.

Having explored the many pizzerias in Lafayette, I have come across some real gems that cater to different tastes and preferences. Each place has its own special twist, creating a tapestry of flavors that go beyond just pepperoni and cheese. Join me as we dive deeper into the top spots for pizza, and prepare to find your new favorite slice in this vibrant culinary landscape. You might just find a place that turns your pizza night into an unforgettable evening.

Where to find the best pizza in Lafayette, LA

Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Lafayette, LA:

  1. Dean-O’s Pizza
  2. Antoni’s Italian Cafe
  3. Pizza Village
  4. Central Pizza & Bar
  5. Deano’s South
  6. Pizza Artista
  7. Pizza Village
  8. Alesi’s Italian Restaurant
  9. Blaze Pizza
  10. BJs Pizza

1. Dean-O’s Pizza

Dean-O's Pizza
Image by: TripAdvisor
305 Bertrand Dr, Lafayette, LA 70506-5635
+1 337-233-5446
See Menu

Dean-O’s Pizza offers a wonderful mix of flavors in a family-friendly atmosphere. Nestled on Bertrand Drive, this spot makes choosing dinner easy with its extensive menu tailored for all tastes. From build-your-own pizzas to delightful pasta dishes, you’ll find something for everyone.

What makes Dean-O’s truly special is the commitment to quality; every bite reflects a passion for Italian cuisine. A personal favorite is the chicken parmesan pasta, which perfectly balances rich flavors and freshness. Of course, their specialty pizzas are a must-try, showcasing creativity and quality ingredients that will leave you craving more.

Overall, Dean-O’s Pizza stands out as a staple in Lafayette, ensuring that each meal is an enjoyable experience for the whole family.

2. Antoni’s Italian Cafe

Antoni's Italian Cafe
Image by: TripAdvisor
1118 Coolidge Blvd Ste A, Lafayette, LA 70503-2629
+1 337-232-8384
See Menu

Antoni’s Italian Cafe, nestled under a stunning Crepe Myrtle, offers a charming escape in Lafayette. Established in 1996, this locally owned gem captures the essence of authentic Italian cuisine in a warm and inviting setting. The ambiance, paired with excellent service, makes it a favorite spot for those looking to unwind with a glass of wine while enjoying her homemade dishes.

What sets Antoni’s apart is its commitment to fresh, handmade offerings. Their homemade pizza dough is a highlight, creating a perfect base for their flavorful pizzas. I highly recommend trying the loaded vegetarian pizza, crafted with fresh ingredients that showcase the true essence of their culinary philosophy.

Whether you’re in the mood for pizza or another Italian classic, Antoni’s guarantees a memorable dining experience.

3. Pizza Village

Pizza Village
Image by: TripAdvisor
1935 Moss St, Lafayette, LA 70501-2117
+1 337-232-1418
See Menu

Pizza Village, a Lafayette staple for over 50 years, embodies the Cajun tradition in its pizza-making. Located on Moss Street, this full-service, family-style restaurant creates a welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. With options for dine-in, carryout, and even drive-thru, it’s a convenient choice for any pizza lover.

What makes Pizza Village stand out is its rich history and commitment to flavor. The Cajun twist on classic pizzas sets them apart from the rest. I personally enjoy their spicy Cajun sausage pizza, which perfectly balances the zestiness of Cajun spices with the comforting cheese and sauce.

For a family-friendly dining experience with a touch of local flair, Pizza Village delivers both in atmosphere and taste.

4. Central Pizza & Bar

Central Pizza & Bar
Image by: TripAdvisor
423 Jefferson St, Lafayette, LA 70501-7013
+1 337-534-0887
See Menu

Central Pizza & Bar, located on Jefferson Street, is a lively spot that perfectly combines a vibrant atmosphere with deliciously crafted pizzas. The inviting decor makes it an ideal place to gather with friends or family, making every meal feel special. The restaurant offers a variety of options for dine-in or takeout, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a slice of happiness.

What really sets Central Pizza & Bar apart is their focus on quality ingredients and innovative recipes. I particularly enjoy their BBQ chicken pizza, which features a delightful blend of tangy sauce and fresh toppings that create a symphony of flavors. It’s a perfect example of how they elevate traditional pizza to a new level.

If you’re looking for a fun dining experience in Lafayette, Central Pizza & Bar should definitely be on your list.

5. Deano’s South

Deano's South
Image by: TripAdvisor
2312 Kaliste Saloom Rd, Lafayette, LA 70508-6808
+1 337-534-8092
See Menu

Deano’s South, located on Kaliste Saloom Road, is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Lafayette. This cozy spot combines a warm ambiance with a menu that celebrates Italian traditions while offering something unique. The inviting space is perfect for family gatherings or casual dinners with friends, ensuring a delightful dining experience.

What makes Deano’s South stand out is its commitment to diverse options, including vegan choices alongside classic favorites. I often gravitate towards their mushroom and spinach pizza, which is crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients. The earthy flavors and delicious crust come together in a way that leaves a lasting impression.

For a satisfying meal that celebrates flavor and creativity, Deano’s South is definitely worth exploring.

6. Pizza Artista

Pizza Artista
Image by: TripAdvisor
5409 Johnston St, Lafayette, LA 70503-5135
+1 337-706-7631
See Menu

Pizza Artista in Lafayette, LA, is a haven for pizza lovers. Located at 5409 Johnston St, this pizzeria offers a unique experience with its customizable 10.5-inch pizzas, all starting at under $8.00. The vast array of fresh ingredients and gluten-free options ensures there’s something for everyone, whether you prefer traditional, deluxe, or specialty toppings.

What sets Pizza Artista apart is the incredible variety and quality of its toppings, including local favorites like andouille, cajun sausage, shrimp, crawfish, and crab. The pizzas are fast fired over an open flame, achieving a crispy perfection in just three minutes. This speedy service, combined with the affordability, makes it a top choice for both lunch and dinner.

During my visit, I created a pizza with cajun sausage, shrimp, and a mix of fresh vegetables. The flavors were bold and authentic, truly capturing the essence of Lafayette’s culinary scene. For a delightful taste of Louisiana on a pizza, I highly recommend trying these toppings.

Pizza Artista is vegetarian and vegan-friendly, accepting all major credit cards including American Express, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa. For a quick, delicious, and customizable meal, Pizza Artista is the place to be.

7. Pizza Village

Pizza Village
Image by: TripAdvisor
2340 Kaliste Saloom Rd, Lafayette, LA 70508-6808
+1 337-706-8644
See Menu

Located on Kaliste Saloom Road, Pizza Village has been a Lafayette favorite for over 40 years, specializing in Cajun-style pizza. This full-service, family-friendly restaurant features an inviting atmosphere, complete with outdoor seating and a bar area. Whether you’re catching up with friends or enjoying a meal with family, the environment perfectly complements the experience.

The standout here is undoubtedly their unique take on pizza, which embraces local flavors. I highly recommend the cajun shrimp pizza. The generous toppings and vibrant spices showcase the rich culinary heritage of the area, making it a must-try for any visitor.

With a commitment to quality and a fun atmosphere, Pizza Village ensures a satisfying dining experience for all.

8. Alesi’s Italian Restaurant

Alesi's Italian Restaurant
Image by: TripAdvisor
4110 Johnston St, Lafayette, LA 70503-3814
+1 337-984-1823
See Menu

Alesi’s Italian Restaurant, located on Johnston Street, is a cherished spot for authentic Italian cuisine in Lafayette. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, it’s perfect for both a casual lunch and a more intimate dinner. The restaurant prides itself on its quality offerings and exceptional service, making every guest feel at home.

What sets Alesi’s apart is their deep commitment to traditional flavors and fresh ingredients. I highly recommend their margherita pizza, which highlights the classic combination of fresh basil, tomatoes, and mozzarella. The crust is thin and perfectly crispy, embodying the essence of Italian pizza.

With options for vegetarians and a focus on quality, Alesi’s is a spot not to be missed when exploring pizza in Lafayette.

9. Blaze Pizza

Blaze Pizza
Image by: TripAdvisor
111 Meadow Farm Rd. Suite 100, Lafayette, LA 70508
+1 337-205-0402
See Menu

Blaze Pizza at 111 Meadow Farm Rd. Suite 100, Lafayette, LA 70508 is where quality meets speed. With artisanal ingredients and over 30+ toppings, you craft your perfect pizza. Their fast-fire’d oven cooks your creation to crisp perfection in just 180 seconds.

One visit and I was hooked. The bustling assembly line, the aroma of fresh toppings, and the sight of pizzas blazing in the oven—it’s an experience. The pizzasmiths are dedicated, ensuring each pizza is a masterpiece.

What sets Blaze Pizza apart is their commitment to quality and customization. For a true taste of Blaze, try the Veg Out pizza. Loaded with fresh veggies and gooey cheese, it’s a vegetarian delight reflecting their inventive approach.

10. BJs Pizza

BJs Pizza
Image by: TripAdvisor
2484 W Congress St, Lafayette, LA 70506-5549
+1 337-534-4234
See Menu

Nestled in Lafayette, Louisiana, BJs Pizza is a local gem offering a delightful blend of comfort and flavor. Located at 2484 W Congress St, this eatery is a staple for both lunch and dinner, celebrated for its cozy dining experience and delectable menu.

One visit to BJs Pizza, and you’ll understand why the locals rave. The atmosphere is warm, and the staff treats you like family. Their signature pizzas are a must-try, reflecting the rich culinary traditions of Lafayette. The crust is perfectly crisp, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful.

When you’re there, don’t miss out on their specialty pizzas, which showcase unique combinations and bold flavors. Each slice is a testament to their dedication to quality and taste.

More Things to Try in Lafayette, LA

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What are the best pizza places in Lafayette, LA?
Some top contenders include Dean-O’s Pizza, Antoni’s Italian Cafe, and Pizza Village. Each offers unique styles, toppings, and dining experiences to cater to every pizza lover’s taste.

2. Do any pizza spots offer gluten-free options?
Yes, many pizzerias in Lafayette, like Blaze Pizza and Pizza Artista, provide gluten-free crust options for those with dietary restrictions.

3. Can I customize my pizza?
Absolutely! Many local pizza restaurants, such as Blaze Pizza and Pizza Artista, allow you to personalize your pizza with a variety of toppings and sauces.

4. Is delivery available for pizza in Lafayette?
Yes, several pizza establishments offer delivery through apps like Waitr and ASAP, making it easy to enjoy your favorite pie at home.

5. Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options?
Yes, places like Central Pizza & Bar and Alesi’s Italian Restaurant provide vegetarian and vegan options, ensuring everyone can find a tasty meal.

6. What type of pizza is Lafayette known for?
Lafayette is known for its Cajun-inspired pizzas, featuring unique toppings like shrimp, andouille sausage, and other local favorites that showcase the region’s flavors.