Everyone has a pizza story. Mine starts on a foggy evening in Mahopac, searching for a slice that could outdo the countless New York pizzas I’d tried before. Mahopac is not your typical pizza battleground—here, tucked next to lakes and old-time storefronts, pizzerias treat every pie like a proud family secret. You’ll catch the scent of fresh dough as you stroll Main Street, and you might stop just because someone at the next table bit into a slice and went silent for a moment.
If you’re looking for the best pizza in Mahopac, you’re not alone. Consider this your personal tasting guide, built from firsthand bites and countless friendly debates with Mahopac locals. Each spot on this list offers something different—classic pies, wood-fired innovation, bold sauce, or that addictive crispy crust. Whether you’re a thin-crust loyalist or a devotee of rich tomato sauce, you’ll find a reason to keep reading. The search is half the fun, but finding that pizza? That’s where the story gets good.
Where to find the best pizza in Mahopac, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Mahopac, NY:
- Benvenuto Pizza Restaurant
- Mike & Joe’s Pizza & Pasta
- Mario’s Wood Fired Neapolitan Pizza & Pasta
- Four Brothers Pizza
- Dante’s Trattoria
- Zach’s Pizzeria Restaurant
- Cacciatori Pizzeria
- D’Berto Pizzeria
- Trattoria Sei
- Eduardo’s Trattoria
1. Benvenuto Pizza Restaurant
Benvenuto Pizza Restaurant at 35 Secor Rd is a cozy neighborhood spot where regulars and first-timers both feel like insiders. The warm welcome is matched by dough that’s crisp, chewy, and always made fresh. One Friday night, I found myself reaching for a second slice of their classic Margherita, charred just right and layered with just-picked basil.
Benvenuto stands out for its thin-crust pies and rich tomato sauce that tastes like summer in every bite. The kitchen turns out pizza after pizza, but never cuts corners. If you can’t decide, order the White Pizza; it’s pillowy, garlicky, and the ricotta is cloud-like.
Vegetarian-friendly and offering delivery, takeout, and table service, Benvenuto is perfect for a casual lunch or an easy dinner.
2. Mike & Joe’s Pizza & Pasta
Mike & Joe’s Pizza & Pasta, found at 961 Route 6, is the kind of place locals talk about with a slight smile—like they’re revealing a small-town secret. The scent of smoky crust hits you before you even step inside. Once, after a long week, I picked up a piping hot veggie pie from here and found the fresh vegetables and just-melted cheese completely revived my mood.
Their wood-fired pies come out thin, crisp, and lightly blistered in all the right places. If you’re choosing, try the Eggplant Pizza for its earthy flavor, or the classic plain cheese for a lesson in how fresh mozzarella can elevate the basics.
Offering online ordering, pickup, and delivery, Mike & Joe’s has made it easy to get great pizza at home or on the go.
3. Mario’s Wood Fired Neapolitan Pizza & Pasta
Mario’s Wood Fired Neapolitan Pizza & Pasta, at 225 Route 6, is a slice of Naples tucked right into Mahopac. The wood fire is more than a gimmick here; it gives each pie a chewy bite and the signature char that’s impossible to fake. I once lingered at a corner table, watching bubbles rise in the dough while flames licked around the crust—each pizza is a show in itself.
Mario’s stands out for its authentic Neapolitan style and the bittersweet tang of its tomato sauce. For purists, the Margherita Pizza is a must, with its balanced simplicity and fragrant basil. If you want something a bit heartier, their Vegetarian Pizza is a winner for fresh, crisp toppings.
Easy seating, delivery, and takeaway make Mario’s a reliable choice for both a casual lunch or a dinner out.
4. Four Brothers Pizza
Four Brothers Pizza, at 654 US-6 Ste 2, brings a family-friendly energy to Mahopac’s pizza scene. The dining room has a relaxed, come-as-you-are vibe, and the menu leans into comforting, crowd-pleasing classics. I remember a weeknight meal with friends where the table fell silent—the Grandma Pie had just arrived, airy and rich, each bite a moment of quiet satisfaction.
Four Brothers excels at rustic pies with a home-cooked feel, crisp edges, and toppings you can taste in every mouthful. The Spinach White Pizza deserves special mention; it’s layered with creamy ricotta and sautéed spinach, balanced and satisfying.
Vegetarian options, table service, and easy takeout keep things uncomplicated and inviting at Four Brothers Pizza.
5. Dante’s Trattoria
Dante’s Trattoria, at 167 Route 6, balances old-world charm with a bustling local energy. Walking in, the aroma of fresh herbs and sizzling dough always sets the mood. My last visit started with a simple request for a vegetarian pizza and ended with me scraping every last crumb off my plate, totally impressed by their crisp crust and bold tomato sauce.
Dante’s stands out for its classic Italian atmosphere and commitment to quality ingredients. The Margherita Pizza is an easy recommendation—bubbly cheese, flavorful olive oil, and that unmistakable wood-fired finish.
Vegetarian options and gluten-free crusts make this spot flexible, whether you’re stopping in for a quick lunch or a drawn-out dinner with friends.
6. Zach’s Pizzeria Restaurant
Zach’s Pizzeria Restaurant, found at 559 NY-6N, is where you spot locals grabbing a quick slice or staying for a leisurely pie. The seating is unfussy, which only puts more focus on what’s coming out of the oven. On my last trip, the aroma of bubbling cheese and toasted crust pulled me in for a classic Sicilian slice—thick, golden-edged, and reliable as ever.
Zach’s stands out for its no-nonsense attitude and consistently good pizza that doesn’t try too hard to impress. The Sicilian Pizza remains a top pick, while the Vegetable Pie is loaded with fresh toppings for those who want something a bit lighter.
Whether you need a quick dinner or want to savor a slow lunch, Zach’s delivers that old-school, dependable pizzeria comfort.
7. Cacciatori Pizzeria
Cacciatori Pizzeria, at 941 S Lake Blvd, is a local staple that balances tradition and comfort. The first time I stopped in, the staff offered a warm hello, and soon after, a hot, freshly baked pie landed on my table. Their pizzas have that golden, slightly crisped crust that makes every first bite memorable.
Cacciatori stands out with its generous portions and a sauce that’s both tangy and a touch sweet. Be sure to try the Vegetarian Pizza; it comes loaded with colorful veggies and a perfect cheese-to-crust ratio, showing off their care for fresh ingredients.
This spot’s laid-back vibe pairs well with easy lunches or casual dinners, and their classic Italian pizza brings regulars back again and again.
8. D’Berto Pizzeria
D’Berto Pizzeria, located at 995 Route 6, is a no-fuss spot where pizza is the main event. You’ll feel at home from the moment you sit down; I once dropped in for a solo lunch and left feeling like a regular. Each pie is crafted with attention, and you can tell from the crisp, thin crust and the balanced amount of cheese—no slice ever disappoints.
D’Berto’s stands out for its classic New York-style pizza and reliable flavors that never try to overshadow the basics. Their Veggie Pizza is a personal favorite, loaded with fresh vegetables that don’t overwhelm the light, flavorful crust.
This is a place where table service and a relaxed setting make a simple meal feel like a treat.
9. Trattoria Sei
Trattoria Sei, at 597 U.S. 6, brings a bit of modern Italy right into Mahopac. I once enjoyed a summer evening on their patio, where laughter, the aroma of baking crust, and friendly service made the experience stick with me. Every dish here aims for freshness, but you’ll notice it most in the pizza—the crust tastes homemade and the ingredients shine.
Trattoria Sei stands out for its blend of classic and creative pies, all with the attention you’d expect from a chef-owned kitchen. Their Vegetariana Pizza is a vibrant, garden-fresh favorite, or try the Margherita for something clean and simple yet full of flavor.
Dine in, take out, or even host a party—Sei is versatile, thoughtful, and consistently memorable.
10. Eduardo’s Trattoria
Eduardo’s Trattoria, at 115 Secor Rd, welcomes you like an old friend returning home. My first visit was spontaneous—a rainy afternoon call for good pizza and warm company. I settled in and soon had a hot pie with a golden, chewy crust and a layered, robust sauce in front of me. Right away, I understood why so many locals call this a go-to spot.
Eduardo’s stands out with its focus on traditional technique and careful seasoning. Their Classic Margherita Pizza reflects this, blending creamy mozzarella and fresh basil without overwhelming the dough’s natural flavor.
The comforting setting, friendly table service, and consistent quality make Eduardo’s Trattoria an easy favorite for lunch or dinner.
More Things to Try in Mahopac, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated pizza places in Mahopac, NY?
Some favorites include Benvenuto Pizza Restaurant, Mike & Joe’s Pizza & Pasta, Mario’s Wood Fired Neapolitan Pizza & Pasta, and Four Brothers Pizza. Locals also rave about Trattoria Sei and Eduardo’s Trattoria for their creative pies and consistent quality.
Can I find vegetarian pizza options in Mahopac?
Absolutely. Many Mahopac pizzerias offer a variety of vegetarian pies loaded with fresh vegetables, like the White Pizza at Benvenuto or the Vegetariana at Trattoria Sei.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Mahopac?
Yes, several places like Dante’s Trattoria provide gluten-free crusts, so you can enjoy pizza without worry.
Which Mahopac pizzerias offer delivery or takeout?
Most local pizza spots provide delivery and takeout options, including Mike & Joe’s Pizza & Pasta, Benvenuto, and Mario’s Wood Fired Neapolitan Pizza & Pasta. This makes it easy to enjoy a quality pie at home.
What’s the most popular style of pizza in Mahopac?
Classic New York-style thin crust and Neapolitan wood-fired pies dominate the scene. You’ll also find excellent Sicilian pizza at places like Zach’s Pizzeria Restaurant.