Finding the best pizza in Watertown, NY is both a serious mission and a joy. This corner of upstate New York surprises you: hometown pizzerias hold their own beside national chains, each tossing crusts and layering cheese with a hint of local pride. As someone who’s sampled slices in places big and small, I can tell you Watertown pizza is worth the detour. My own first bite here was a creamy, bubbling masterpiece from a family shop near Public Square—I still remember savoring the blend of mozzarella and just-spiced-enough sauce as the world outside faded away.
This guide is your shortcut to the tastiest pies in the area, whether you’re after thin crust or pan-style, a plain cheese classic or a loaded specialty. I’ve combed through the city’s pizza kitchens, each one with its quirks, from old-school favorites to easy grab-and-go slices. If you’re wondering where to find your new pizza spot, dive into these picks—your next craving just found its match.
Where to find the best pizza in Watertown, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Watertown, NY:
- Cam’s Pizzeria
- Art’s Jug Restaurant
- Fairground Inn
- Mr Sub Sandwich Shop
- Original Italian Pizza
- Bernardo’s Pizzeria
- Papa Tino’s Pizzeria
- Domino’s Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Little Caesars
1. Cam’s Pizzeria
Cam’s Pizzeria sits right on Public Square, and it’s the kind of spot that locals mention first when talking about good pizza. Walking in, you’re hit with the aroma of fresh dough and melting cheese—a promising start for any visit.
What sets Cam’s apart is their chewy, hand-tossed crust and generous, golden mozzarella. I found my go-to order fast: their classic cheese pizza, which delivers the perfect sauce-to-cheese ratio with every slice. Cam’s also offers vegetarian options and a menu broad enough for families, but I always come back to that classic pie.
Portion sizes are satisfying and the atmosphere is relaxed, perfect for an easy lunch or casual dinner. If you crave Watertown’s best straightforward pizza experience, this place delivers in more ways than one.
2. Art’s Jug Restaurant
Art’s Jug Restaurant is a slice of Watertown history, family-run since 1933 and proud of it. Stepping inside feels like stepping into tradition. Generations of the Sboro family have perfected their recipes, and regulars will tell you there’s a special comfort in every bite.
What makes Art’s Jug stand out is their commitment to quality. Their pizza arrives with a crisp, golden crust and a sauce that tastes homemade. My visit ended with me reaching for another piece of their classic cheese and veggie pizzas, both sporting generous toppings and ideal cheese melt. Their pizza leans hearty and classic, with a chatty, welcoming staff.
If you appreciate a place where every pizza feels crafted rather than churned out, this spot is a must. Bring a friend or two—these pies are made for sharing and savoring.
3. Fairground Inn
Fairground Inn delivers small-town charm with every meal, making it a favorite for locals seeking comfort food and good company. The first time I walked in, the buzz of laughter and the tempting scent of baked dough let me know I’d picked the right place.
Their pizza menu caters to all tastes. Standouts include the vegetarian pizza, loaded with fresh veggies and a crisp, light crust. For those with dietary needs, the gluten-free and vegan options make Fairground Inn especially welcoming. My own recommendation is to start with their classic cheese or veggie pie—the cheese stretch is top-notch, and the sauce has a bold, tangy flavor.
If you’re after genuine flavors and a friendly vibe, this spot checks every box. Fairground Inn’s dedication to inclusivity and fresh ingredients truly sets it apart in Watertown’s pizza scene.
4. Mr Sub Sandwich Shop
Mr Sub Sandwich Shop may be known for subs, but its pizza has undeniable local fans. Nestled on Public Square, this shop makes a habit of surprising first-timers. I popped in for a sandwich, but the scent of baked dough convinced me to try a slice—and I didn’t regret it.
Mr Sub’s pizza is everything good pizza should be: soft crust with a satisfying edge, bold tomato sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. Try their thick, square-cut pizza, which has a nostalgic, homemade flair you won’t easily find elsewhere in Watertown. It’s the kind of comfort food you grab after work or share over lunch with friends.
If you want a low-key, satisfying pizza experience in the heart of the city, Mr Sub won’t steer you wrong.
5. Original Italian Pizza
Original Italian Pizza on N Massey Street is a neighborhood classic, known for generous portions and old-school charm. The first time I visited, the warm greeting and the smell of baking crust were enough to win me over before I even ordered.
The pizza here leans hearty and classic, with a chewy crust that stands up well to their robust tomato sauce. The pepper and mushroom pizza is a personal favorite—fresh vegetables over thick, bubbling cheese truly bring out that “homemade” feel. Every slice feels crafted with care and tradition in mind.
For an authentic, filling pizza that feels like a taste of Italy right in Watertown, Original Italian Pizza continues to live up to its name.
6. Bernardo’s Pizzeria
Bernardo’s Pizzeria makes a strong impression right from the start—the aroma of fresh dough hits you the moment you walk in, hinting at pizza that’s a step above. Their reputation for daily-made dough isn’t just hype, either. The crisp crust holds up to hearty toppings and stands out for its freshness.
What sets Bernardo’s apart is their attention to detail. Each pie is topped with high-quality cheese and a sauce that’s just tangy enough. Their classic Margherita pizza is a favorite of mine: light, balanced, and bursting with flavor from fresh basil and ripe tomatoes.
Regulars know to check for rotating specials, so there’s always something new to try alongside the traditional offerings. For pizza with heart and a bit of nightly variety, Bernardo’s paves its own path.
7. Papa Tino’s Pizzeria
Papa Tino’s Pizzeria is tucked away on Mill Street, but don’t let the location fool you—this spot’s pizza easily grabs attention. My first slice here was straight out of the oven, with bubbling cheese and a satisfyingly crisp crust. Every pie feels like a special delivery from a real neighborhood kitchen.
Papa Tino’s wins points for its bold, tangy sauce and fresh daily dough. The vegetarian pizza is loaded with fresh veggies and doesn’t skimp on flavor or toppings. I often recommend their cheese pizza for its classic taste and balance—never heavy, never skimpy.
Perfect for families or casual nights, Papa Tino’s keeps it simple and delicious, serving pizza that hits the spot every single time.
8. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Route 11 stays true to its national reputation but adds a touch of local reliability that Watertown diners appreciate. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or planning a group dinner, this spot always seems ready to deliver fast and fresh. I’ve found their pizzas arrive piping hot, with cheese that’s perfectly melted and toppings spread right to the edge.
Variety is Domino’s standout quality. Fan favorites include the Handmade Pan Pizza for thick, fluffy bites, or the thin and crispy New York Style if you prefer to fold your slice. Their vegetarian options are solid, and the cheese pizza brings the familiar, comforting flavors you might crave after a busy day.
If you love customizing your order or want pizza that’s consistent every time, Domino’s is always a safe bet in Watertown.
9. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Bys Route 3 draws in both regulars and travelers craving classic, consistent pizza. There’s something about the signature scent of baking dough and cheese here that always feels nostalgic. My last visit was a reminder of why this chain still matters—every bite tasted just as expected, comfortingly familiar.
The big draw is their Original Stuffed Crust pizza. The rich, gooey cheese-filled edge turns an average pizza night into something special. I also like the Veggie Lover’s for a colorful, satisfying option that doesn’t overpower with toppings.
If you’re in the mood for pizza with a reliable flavor profile, Pizza Hut is the kind of spot where you can always count on that perfect, cheesy pull.
10. Little Caesars
Little Caesars on State Street is where Watertown locals go when they want pizza fast and fresh without overthinking the menu. I walked in on a busy weeknight and watched as piping hot pizzas came out at a rapid pace. There’s a simple joy in grabbing a box and knowing exactly what you’re getting—that consistency is part of their charm.
The star here is the Hot-N-Ready pizza. The classic cheese or veggie pies are always on hand, making walk-in orders easy for anyone on the go. The crust is thick, a little chewy, and has a flavor that stands alone, even without extra toppings.
If your craving hits out of nowhere, or you just want something quick and satisfying, Little Caesars delivers every single time.
More Things to Try in Watertown, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Watertown, NY?
Some of the most popular spots include Cam’s Pizzeria, Art’s Jug Restaurant, Fairground Inn, and Bernardo’s Pizzeria. Each offers its own take on classic and specialty pizzas.
Where can I find vegetarian or vegan pizza in Watertown?
Fairground Inn offers both vegetarian and vegan options. Many pizzerias like Cam’s and Papa Tino’s also serve vegetarian pies—just ask about available toppings and cheese choices.
Which pizza places in Watertown offer delivery?
Most major chains such as Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Little Caesars provide delivery. Local spots like Cam’s Pizzeria and Bernardo’s Pizzeria also offer this service.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Watertown?
Yes, Fairground Inn is known for its gluten-free pizza. Some other restaurants may also have gluten-free crusts, so it’s best to call ahead and check.
What’s Watertown known for when it comes to pizza?
Watertown’s pizza style ranges from chewy hand-tossed crusts to hearty, thick slices—often with local ingredients, generous cheese, and signature tomato sauce. Family-owned shops give the city’s pizza scene a unique, welcoming vibe.