Pizza cravings don’t always wait for the weekend or a special occasion. Some days, Elmira’s cold air or a late-night hunger pang signals it’s time to hunt for a great slice. I’ve wandered the city with a fork in one hand, curiosity in the other, tasting everything from bubbling brick-oven pies to reliable takeout classics. Elmira, as it turns out, takes its pizza seriously. Each spot here has a following and a story, and the locals aren’t shy about sharing where to find the best crust.
You’re about to unlock the lowdown on the most notable pizza places in Elmira, NY. Whether you favor a chewy New York slice, a thick Sicilian square, or just need quick comfort in a cardboard box, this guide dives into texture, sauce, cheese—and what really sets each spot apart. It isn’t always about being fancy; sometimes, it’s about a dough recipe that’s stood the test of time or a family secret nestled in the sauce. By the last line, you’ll know exactly where you want your next slice.
Where to find the best pizza in Elmira, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Elmira, NY:
- Vincenzo’s Pizzeria
- Pietro & Son
- Pudgie’s Pizza & Sub Shops
- Original Italian Pizza
- Paesano’s Pizza and Subs
- Pudgies
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Domino’s Pizza
- Wegmans Market Cafe
- Pizza Hut
1. Vincenzo’s Pizzeria
Tucked into North Main Street, Vincenzo’s Pizzeria feels like Elmira’s answer to the classic neighborhood slice joint. You open the door and you’re greeted by the scent of bubbling cheese and the hustle of a kitchen that clearly knows its craft. The locals fill tables here—not because of habit, but because the pizza doesn’t miss.
What impresses most is the dough: soft on the inside, just enough crunch on the edge, and made daily. Try the Margherita or Veggie Special for a taste that’s balanced and bright, with a sauce that could stand on its own. The menu reads like a pizza lover’s greatest hits. For office lunches or family dinners, Vincenzo’s is the spot where friendly service meets serious pizza.
2. Pietro & Son
Pietro & Son, nestled on West Washington Ave, gives old-school Italian energy from the moment you walk in. The unmistakable aroma of baking pies spills right onto the sidewalk, luring me in on more than one rainy afternoon. There’s a warmth here, with families catching up over slices and longtime regulars sharing stories as they wait for takeout.
The star at Pietro & Son is the White Garlic Pizza. It’s crave-worthy—chewy, thin crust topped with a smooth blend of ricotta and mozzarella, finished with a sprinkle of fresh herbs. If you’re in the mood for something classic, their cheese pizza has a tangy, house-made sauce that stands out in Elmira’s pizza scene.
Friendly table service means you never feel rushed. Each visit feels like a mini celebration of Elmira’s local flavor and tradition.
3. Pudgie’s Pizza & Sub Shops
Pudgie’s Pizza & Sub Shops is an Elmira institution for anyone craving casual comfort food after a long day. The vibe feels straight from your childhood—bright lights, booth seating, and the hum of dough being prepped in the background. On evenings when everything else feels closed, Pudgie’s doors are still open, serving up slices that keep regulars coming back.
The real winner here is their thick Sicilian-style pizza. The airy crust holds up under a generous layer of cheese, with sauce that’s balanced and just tangy enough. Pudgie’s takes pride in consistency, whether you’re grabbing a quick dinner or stopping by late for a craving fix.
If you want a little variety, go for the Veggie Supreme—every bite brings something fresh and satisfying. Expect quick service, comfort, and a slice that always hits the spot.
4. Original Italian Pizza
Original Italian Pizza has its own following on South Main Street, and for good reason. The place feels family-run in the best sense—there’s always someone working the oven with care, and service is both fast and friendly. I first stopped here on a winter afternoon, hungry for something real and hearty; their pizza checked all the boxes.
The crust is what sets them apart: thin, crisp, yet still foldable. The Classic Cheese Pizza is where to start, with a sauce that packs a little sweetness and just the right amount of stretch in the cheese. The menu is straightforward, focusing on flavor more than frills.
If you’re looking for old-school comfort, OIP delivers. It’s the kind of pizza that tastes like tradition in every bite.
5. Paesano’s Pizza and Subs
Paesano’s Pizza and Subs is the kind of neighborhood spot where the staff remembers your order by the third visit. There’s a relaxed, welcoming energy here that makes it easy to linger over a hot slice. My first time, I found myself marveling at the scent of fresh dough and bubbling cheese even before my order hit the table.
Paesano’s crust is crisp yet pillowy, the kind that holds toppings without getting soggy. Go for their White Broccoli Pizza if you want something out of the ordinary. The garlic, ricotta, and fresh broccoli blend into a flavor you won’t find everywhere in Elmira.
The place keeps things simple, but what they do, they do well—quality ingredients and perfect bake, slice after slice.
6. Pudgies
+1 607-734-3366
Pudgies on College Ave feels like the pizza spot that’s always been there—a go-to for locals at every hour. There’s a laid-back charm, with quick counter service and plenty of regulars popping in for a slice or two. The atmosphere is casual and the smell of baking dough is hard to resist.
Their signature Thick Crust Cheese Pizza is a standout. It’s loaded with gooey cheese, perfect for those who love a hearty, satisfying bite. I remember grabbing a pie here after a long day, and it came out hot, with a crisp bottom and pillowy center.
This spot is also reliable for breakfast hours, which isn’t something you see every day in the pizza world. Consistency and comfort make Pudgies a staple in Elmira’s pizza scene.
7. Papa Johns Pizza
If you’re craving something familiar and consistent, Papa Johns Pizza on County Road 64 is a dependable stop in Elmira. The vibe here is all about quick service and fresh pies, perfect if you’re on the go. I’ve picked up carryout here after work, and every order was ready on the dot, piping hot and smelling like comfort food should.
Their Garden Fresh Pizza hits a sweet spot—plenty of veggies, a light, slightly sweet tomato sauce, and the signature dough that stays soft yet sturdy. Papa Johns is also a solid pick for family meals or game nights, since the menu goes beyond pizza into breadsticks and other crowd-pleasers.
It’s the place where you get what you expect: fresh ingredients, satisfying slices, and an easy meal solved any day of the week.
8. Domino’s Pizza
If you want pizza exactly how you remember it from late-night study sessions or post-game hangouts, Domino’s Pizza on Maple Ave fits the bill. Speedy delivery is the rule here; I’ve ordered on busy weekends and the box arrives warm and ready, flavors still intact.
Domino’s variety is a major draw. The Handmade Pan Pizza, with its pillowy yet crispy crust, always feels like the right move when you’re after something extra hearty. The Pacific Veggie Pizza keeps things colorful and fresh, with plenty of toppings layered edge to edge.
It’s the reliable pick for busy nights or gatherings where everyone wants something just a little different. Value deals make it easy to try a mix of pies with friends or family.
9. Wegmans Market Cafe
Inside Wegmans on Clemens Center Parkway, the Market Cafe provides a fresh, casual spot for pizza that’s surprisingly satisfying. The space is always bustling, and I’ve found it’s the go-to for a quick lunch or relaxed dinner when you don’t want the usual sit-down scene. Even amid a swirl of grocery shoppers, the pizza counter manages to keep things upbeat and welcoming.
Wegmans’ Stone-Fired Vegetable Pizza is a standout: thin, chewy crust, a medley of roasted vegetables, and a bright sauce that keeps each bite interesting. Slices are generous, and you can watch your pie come together right behind the glass counter.
Here, you get quality, convenience, and variety—plus the ease of picking up a fresh salad or soup to round out your meal. The freshness and gentle char on the crust reliably draw me back.
10. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on South Main Street is one of those places where the sign alone stirs up childhood pizza party memories. What you get is undeniably consistent, whether you go for carryout or settle in a booth. I’ve dropped in here on lazy weekends and found the staff friendly, the orders quick, and the smell of that classic sauce hits you right at the door.
The Original Stuffed Crust Pizza deserves its following—the crust is gooey with cheese, with every pull a stretch. For something different, the Veggie Lover’s Pizza packs on the fresh toppings and tastes just as good reheated the next day.
Everything here focuses on comfort and familiarity. If you want zero surprises and the classics done right, Pizza Hut always delivers.
More Things to Try in Elmira, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Elmira, NY?
Some local favorites include Vincenzo’s Pizzeria, Pietro & Son, Pudgie’s Pizza & Sub Shops, Original Italian Pizza, and Paesano’s Pizza and Subs. Larger chains like Domino’s, Papa Johns, and Pizza Hut are also popular for quick, consistent options.
Which pizza places in Elmira offer vegetarian options?
Almost every pizzeria in Elmira offers solid vegetarian pizzas. Try the Veggie Supreme at Pudgie’s Pizza & Sub Shops, Margherita at Vincenzo’s, or the Stone-Fired Vegetable Pizza at Wegmans Market Cafe for standout choices.
Are there any local pizza spots with delivery in Elmira?
Yes, most local and chain pizzerias, including Pietro & Son, Original Italian Pizza, Domino’s, and Papa Johns, offer delivery. Many also have online ordering for extra convenience.
What type of pizza is popular in Elmira?
You’ll find a mix of styles—thin New York slices, thick Sicilian crusts, and everything in between. Whether you like pan pizza, stuffed crust, or thin and crispy, there’s something for everyone.
Where can I find pizza late at night in Elmira, NY?
Domino’s and Pudgie’s Pizza & Sub Shops typically keep their ovens hot later than most. Chains like Papa Johns and Pizza Hut are good bets, too. Check hours before heading out—they can vary by season and day.