Finding the best pizza in Geneva, NY is like taking a delicious tour through this lakeside town’s culinary heart. I’ve bitten into crispy, caramelized crusts in old-school booths, argued over chunky sauce versus ultra-thin cheese, and lost count of the times a local slice solved my late-night cravings. This isn’t just about mozzarella and pepperoni. Every pizzeria here, from corner mainstays to hidden gems, has a story baked right in.
Whether you crave chewy New York style, classic Italian, or something boldly inventive, Geneva delivers more than a one-topping answer. After countless pizza runs, I’ve sorted the timeless spots from the one-hit wonders. If you’re after that perfect pie—savory, satisfying, and most importantly, trusted by those who actually have sauce on their sleeve—read on. Your next favorite slice is probably closer than you think.
Where to find the best pizza in Geneva, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Geneva, NY:
- Uncle Joe’s
- Cams New York Pizzeria
- Ciccino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Mark’s Pizzeria
- Domino’s Pizza
- Twisted Calzones
- Momberger’s Deli
- Ciccinos Pizza Geneva
- Saverio’s Pizzeria
- Uncle Joe’s Pizzeria
1. Uncle Joe’s
Uncle Joe’s has the cozy familiarity of an old friend and the kind of pizza that makes you plan your next visit before you’ve even left the table. The crust is satisfyingly chewy with a light crisp at the edge—exactly what you want after a walk along the lake.
This spot stands out for its dedication to variety. Their menu features vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free pizza options, so nobody has to miss out. On my last trip, the classic Margherita was a highlight—fresh basil, gooey cheese, and a well-seasoned sauce set a high bar.
If you’re hungry for something signature, their Veggie Supreme brings together vibrant toppings without letting the crust drown under cheese. It’s the sort of pie that sums up Uncle Joe’s welcoming, made-for-everyone spirit.
2. Cams New York Pizzeria
Walking into Cams New York Pizzeria feels like stepping into a lively, no-frills hometown favorite—everyone seems to have a go-to slice here. The staff works with practiced speed, tossing dough and ladling sauce, so your hunger doesn’t stand a chance for long.
Cams shines for its authentic New York-style pizza: crisp, foldable slices with the unmistakable smoky aroma of a hot oven. I find their cheese pizza simple yet perfect—stretchy mozzarella and balanced sauce, all on an impossibly thin base.
If you want more than the basics, try the Veggie or White Pizza. Each showcases fresh ingredients and that signature crackle on the crust. It’s straight-up, classic pizza done flawlessly—no pretension, just honest flavor.
3. Ciccino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Ciccino’s Pizzeria & Restaurant offers more than just pizza—it’s a slice of Italy in the heart of Geneva. The dining room feels welcoming, no matter if you’re in for a quick lunch or a drawn-out family dinner. The service? Always thoughtful without being fussy.
What makes Ciccino’s a standout is the care they put into both ingredients and atmosphere. Their crust has that perfect blend of crunch and chew, while their sauce sings with real tomato flavor. I remember my first bite of their Margherita; bright basil, fresh mozzarella, and a drizzle of olive oil.
If you want something heartier, the Veggie Pizza piles on roasted peppers and mushrooms without skimping on quality. It’s comfort food with an unmistakable Italian touch.
4. Mark’s Pizzeria
Mark’s Pizzeria is all about classic flavor and hometown reliability. It’s the place you end up after a busy day, knowing your pie will turn out just how you want—never overdone, always hot.
This spot stands out for its generous portions and soft, chewy crust that carries fresh toppings every time. I like to order their Veggie Pizza when I’m sharing with friends; the medley of peppers, onions, and mushrooms never disappoints.
The cheese pizza here is also surprisingly memorable. Rich, melty, and never greasy, it’s the answer when you crave something straightforward and satisfying. Mark’s proves that sticking to the basics, when done right, can be exactly what keeps you coming back.
5. Domino’s Pizza
+1 315-789-3090
Domino’s Pizza in Geneva keeps things predictable, which is sometimes exactly what you want. Whether it’s a late night or you’re feeding a crowd, your pizza lands hot and on time, just as promised.
Consistency is Domino’s biggest asset—every pie features that familiar cheesy pull and a crust with just enough crunch. I’ve found their Handmade Pan Pizza perfectly balances a hearty base with savory toppings, making it an easy crowd-pleaser.
The Parmesan Stuffed Crust is worth a try if you crave something richer. It adds extra flavor without overpowering the main event. For those who stick to the classics, the Veggie Pizza is always a safe (and tasty) bet. Domino’s delivers exactly what it promises: satisfying, straightforward pizza every time.
6. Twisted Calzones
+1 315-325-4145
Twisted Calzones brings a playful take on pizza to Geneva, rolling everything you love about a great slice into one piping-hot fold. It’s not your standard pizzeria, and that’s exactly the charm. Each calzone here is crafted to order—bubbling, golden, and satisfyingly stuffed.
The menu highlights classic veggie combinations, but they don’t shy away from bold flavor twists. My top pick is the Veggie Calzone, loaded with roasted peppers, mushrooms, and gooey cheese, all wrapped in a perfectly baked shell.
For those who crave variety, you can build your own creation and truly make it your own. Twisted Calzones turns pizza night into something a little different, with flavors that always hit the spot.
7. Momberger’s Deli
Momberger’s Deli has all the hallmarks of an old-school local legend—steady hands in the kitchen, family history, and an unpretentious vibe that keeps regulars coming back. You feel that “everyone’s welcome” warmth as soon as you step inside, no matter what you’re ordering.
While they’re prized for their subs, Momberger’s pizza deserves a place on your pizza night roster. Their crust is tender with a bit of chew, and the sauce strikes just the right note—tangy, balanced, and never too much. I’ve shared more than one pie here with friends during lunch breaks, and the conversation always pauses for that first bite.
If you appreciate a classic approach, try their Veggie Pizza or basic Cheese Pizza. Simple, fresh, and filling, it’s proof that some family recipes never need changing.
8. Ciccinos Pizza Geneva
Ciccinos Pizza Geneva captures the essence of a true Italian eatery in the heart of town. The welcoming staff and inviting space make each visit feel like a relaxed meal at a friend’s house.
The pizza here stands out for its classic flavor and high-quality ingredients. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or settling in for dinner, there’s care in every detail, from the balanced sauce to the perfect cheese melt. I still think about my first Margherita pizza at Ciccinos—each ingredient tasted fresh and thoughtfully chosen.
Their Veggie Pizza is a favorite for its roasted toppings and crisp, golden crust. If you’re after comfort paired with character, this is a spot that rises above the usual.
9. Saverio’s Pizzeria
(315) 789-6297Call
Saverio’s Pizzeria holds its place as a laid-back local favorite where you’ll find hearty, straightforward pies with plenty of character. There’s a steady stream of regulars—a good sign that the kitchen does the classics right.
The pizzas here come out with just the right blend of crisp and chew in the crust, while their sauce stands out for its bright, zesty flavor. Whenever I stop by, the Veggie Pizza is always on my list; it’s topped with fresh vegetables and never feels overloaded, letting each flavor stand out.
If you’re seeking the comfort of classic pizza prepared with care, Saverio’s is a dependable choice. Their focus on fresh toppings and balanced pies proves that tradition is still alive and well in Geneva.
10. Uncle Joe’s Pizzeria
Uncle Joe’s Pizzeria feels like that neighborhood spot everyone trusts for a quality slice and a friendly chat. There’s an ease to the place—whether you order by phone or drop in, the staff make you feel like a regular.
The pizza here stands out for its handmade touch—the crust is always sturdy yet soft, making it ideal for both classic and specialty pies. Their blend of cheeses and flavorful sauce creates a rich base that never disappoints. I still remember the first time I went for their Veggie Pizza: loaded, colorful, and every topping tasted fresh.
If you want a classic, their Cheese Pizza is a local favorite for a reason. At Uncle Joe’s, you’ll find honest pizza with genuine attention to detail in every bite.
More Things to Try in Geneva, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Geneva, NY?
You’ll find everything from classic New York-style thin crust to thicker, chewy pies. Many places offer both traditional Italian and creative specialty pizzas, so you’ll have options whether you want a foldable slice or something piled high with toppings.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Geneva?
Yes. Several pizzerias, like Uncle Joe’s and Ciccino’s, provide vegetarian and even vegan choices. These spots highlight fresh vegetables and non-dairy cheese options.
Which pizzerias in Geneva offer gluten-free pizza?
Uncle Joe’s and Ciccino’s both feature gluten-free crusts. It’s always a good idea to call ahead and ensure availability or ask about dedicated prep areas if you have allergies.
Can I get pizza delivered in Geneva, NY?
Most major and local pizzerias offer delivery, including Domino’s, Mark’s, and Cam’s New York Pizzeria. Smaller shops may have delivery at certain times, so check their hours.
What are the best pizzerias for a quick slice in Geneva?
For a fast, tasty slice, places like Cam’s New York Pizzeria and Domino’s do the job. If you prefer something with a bit more atmosphere, Saverio’s or Uncle Joe’s are good picks for a quick order and go.