Nothing sharpens the appetite quite like the search for great pizza. Scarborough, ME, has a way of surprising even the most seasoned food lovers. I remember my first visit: the sound of the ocean in my ears, a blanket of evening fog rolling in, and the scent of baking dough trailing through the air. The town isn’t loud about its secrets, but dig a little deeper, and the local pizzerias reveal themselves.
Finding the best pizza in Scarborough might sound simple, but each spot has its own tale, flavors, and loyal following. Whether you prefer a classic slice, bubbling cheese, or thin crust kissed by wood-fire, you’ll find it here. I’ve tasted my way through every oven in town, and this guide hands you the highlights—no guesswork required. Stay a while and your next pizza favorite might be hiding a short drive from the beach.
1. Portland Pie Company
A visit to Portland Pie Company feels like sharing a meal with friends, even if you walk in solo. Tucked near the heart of Scarborough, this spot nails both atmosphere and flavor. Each pie starts with crusts inspired by Maine classics, from basil to beer-infused dough. The staff is always quick with pizza wisdom, and regulars swear by the hands-on hospitality.
The Buffalo Chicken pizza hits all the right notes—zesty, smoky, and generous with toppings. Looking for something lighter? The veggie lovers’ Melrose is a feast of roasted vegetables on a crisp, chewy base. Gluten-free and vegan travelers will also find satisfying options.
Portland Pie Company is proof that craft and comfort can go hand in hand, slice after slice.
2. Romeo’s Pizza
At Romeo’s Pizza, you’re not just a guest—you’re part of an ongoing pizza tale that stretches back years. I stopped by after hearing a local couple debate their favorite toppings in line. Inside, I found a dining room filled with laughter, quick service, and the promise that you’ll leave happy or it’s on the house.
Romeo’s stands out for its crust: perfectly crispy on the edge, tender in the middle, and able to handle any topping. The menu celebrates variety, but the Greek Pizza is a standout, layered with feta, spinach, and tomato. It’s the kind of pie you return for, week after week.
If you’re craving a new take, try the veggie-packed House Special or order a classic cheese to taste the dough at its best.
3. Burano’s Wood-fired Pizzeria
Stepping into Burano’s Wood-fired Pizzeria feels like an invitation to slow down. The scent of crackling wood sets the scene long before your pie hits the table. I once waited by the oven, mesmerized as a fresh pizza blistered and bubbled right before my eyes.
What sets Burano’s apart is the crust—lightly charred, chewy, and perfectly balanced. Their wood-fired Margherita is a must: simple, yet brimming with flavor from fresh basil and melted mozzarella. You can taste the care in every bite.
Adventurous eaters should try their White Pie, a creamy swirl of ricotta and garlic laid over that signature crust. Burano’s makes it easy to believe pizza can be both rustic and refined.
4. Pat’s Pizza of Scarborough
Pat’s Pizza of Scarborough feels like a hometown gathering spot, whether you’re catching a game or treating the family. My first slice here was in the Oak Hill Dining Room during a Red Sox game. Between cheers and good-natured debates, it became clear—Pat’s isn’t just a place to eat, but a place to connect.
What makes Pat’s stand out is the sense of tradition. The dough is always fresh, the sauce has just enough tang, and the cheese blend stretches just right. Try the classic Pat’s Special, loaded with plenty of veggies and pepper; or if you want something simple, the cheese and tomato pie hits all the notes of old-school comfort.
It’s the perfect spot to grab a quick takeout or linger with friends over a pitcher, making each visit memorable.
5. Cargo Pizza Company
Catching up with Cargo Pizza Company is a small adventure. The sight of their sleek food truck near the coast promises something different from the usual pizza stand. Meeting friends there for lunch, with the ocean breeze and the buzz of anticipation, made grabbing a slice feel like the main event of the day.
Cargo stands out for its balance—a rustic, slightly chewy crust meets bold toppings. Their Breakfast Pizza is a must if you’re an early riser; otherwise, the Supreme blends garden veggies and bubbling cheese with satisfying results.
There’s something about hot, fresh pizza from the side of a truck that turns a quick meal into a small memory worth repeating.
6. Little Caesars
Sometimes you need a pizza fix—fast and fuss-free. That’s where Little Caesars fits the bill in Scarborough. I’ve dashed in more than once, hungry after work, and walked out within minutes with a piping hot pie. For anyone who values convenience, the efficiency here is hard to beat.
What makes Little Caesars stand out is their consistency. The Hot-N-Ready Classic Cheese Pizza is always reliable: golden crust, tangy sauce, and a generous layer of cheese. If you want to mix it up, the Veggie pizza gives a fresh twist without waiting long.
It’s an affordable option that doesn’t skimp on flavor when time is tight, making it an easy favorite for busy days or low-key nights.
7. Amato’s Sandwich Shops
Amato’s Sandwich Shops might be known for its Italian sandwiches, but their pizza has a style all its own. Popping in for lunch, I’ve found that even in a rush, their service keeps things friendly and quick, with locals chatting as they wait for their favorite orders.
Their pizzas set themselves apart with a hearty, slightly sweet sauce and a dough that’s satisfyingly soft yet crisp at the edges. The Veggie Pizza is a standout, loaded with mushrooms, peppers, and onions—a garden on dough. If you like classics, their Cheese Pizza brings all the nostalgia in every bite.
Amato’s makes it easy to grab a slice for takeout or linger at a booth and savor the flavors of Scarborough with friends.
8. Little Caesars
+1 207-283-0021
The Little Caesars on Stone Brooke Rd might look unassuming from the outside, but it’s a hidden hero for quick, satisfying pizza. I’ve ducked in between errands, and there’s comfort in knowing a fresh, hot pie is never more than a few minutes away. The service moves at the speed of hungry families, making this a top pick for spur-of-the-moment cravings.
What sets this spot apart is the value—good pizza without the wait or the dent in your wallet. Their classic Hot-N-Ready Pepperoni Pizza always delivers that familar, savory bite and a satisfying crust every time.
If you prefer something lighter, their veggie option is a solid choice, loaded with plenty of crunch and flavor.
9. Dunstan Tap & Table
Dunstan Tap & Table delivers more than classic pub fare—it’s the place where summer and local flavor meet. My last visit was during a mellow afternoon, where the scent of dough mingled with the hum of conversation. The open, airy space manages to feel lively yet laid-back, making it easy to settle in for a long meal.
The menu puts its own spin on pizza, elevating each pie with fresh toppings. The Roasted Vegetable Pizza pops with color and flavor, served on a just-chewy crust. Here, even a classic cheese slice feels upgraded thanks to top-quality ingredients and a bit of creative flair from the kitchen.
Dunstan Tap & Table is a strong pick if you want to linger over good food in genuinely good company.
10. It’ll Be Pizza
It’s easy to be curious about It’ll Be Pizza—the name alone sets the stage for a no-nonsense pie. On my visit, the kitchen’s energy made the place feel genuine, like you’d stumbled across a local secret. There’s a certain charm to seeing stacks of dough being hand-pressed, promising each order is made with intention.
This pizzeria stands out with its made-to-order approach and creative flair. Their Classic Cheese Pizza highlights a tangy, balanced sauce and a pillowy crust just crisped at the edge. If you want a taste of Scarborough with a twist, the Mediterranean-inspired pie adds roasted vegetables and a sprinkle of herbs for brightness.
It’ll Be Pizza is all about simple, fresh, and flavorful slices served with a side of neighborhood pride.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated pizza places in Scarborough, ME?
Local favorites include Portland Pie Company, Romeo’s Pizza, and Burano’s Wood-fired Pizzeria, each known for their quality ingredients and welcoming vibe.
Are there any gluten-free or vegan pizza options in Scarborough?
Yes, spots like Portland Pie Company and Romeo’s Pizza offer gluten-free and vegan-friendly pizzas, so everyone can enjoy a slice.
Which Scarborough pizzerias offer delivery or takeout?
Nearly all the main contenders—such as Amato’s Sandwich Shops, Pat’s Pizza, and Little Caesars—offer takeout. Many, including Romeo’s Pizza, provide delivery too.
Is there wood-fired pizza available in Scarborough?
Absolutely. Burano’s Wood-fired Pizzeria specializes in wood-fired pies with that rustic, lightly-charred crust pizza fans love.
Where can I find late-night pizza in Scarborough?
Little Caesars and some pizza chains stay open later and are reliable for a quick, satisfying slice at the end of the day.
Do any pizza spots in Scarborough have vegetarian options?
Most local pizzerias, including Pat’s Pizza of Scarborough and Dunstan Tap & Table, feature tasty vegetarian pizzas loaded with seasonal veggies.