Pizza cravings don’t sit patiently. When you want a great slice, only the real deal will do. Franklin Square delivers this in spades, with pizzerias popping up on almost every corner. I still remember my first hunt for pizza here on a rainy Saturday—hood pulled up, streetlights glowing, the choice was almost overwhelming. From that night, I started keeping a mental list, comparing crusts, sauces, and the general vibe, determined to find the best pizzas in town.
After far too many napkin stacks and taste-tests, I’ve put together a guide that gets straight to the point. Whether you like classic slices, inventive toppings that never push boundaries too far, or a hidden family recipe in a cozy spot, you’ll find your next favorite here. Expect accurate details, zero fluff, and slices as good as your last bite. Dive in and let’s uncover the top spots for pizza perfection in Franklin Square.
Where to find the best pizza in Franklin Square, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Franklin Square, NY:
- Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc
- Prince Umberto
- Laterazza Pizza
- Caprio Brick Oven Pizzaria
- Nonno Toto
- Fire Stone Grill & Pizza
- Lazzarano Pizza
- Carmela’s Pizzeria
- Lia’s Pizzeria
- Romeo’s Pizza
1. Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc
Genovese Pizzeria & Restaurant Inc draws you in with its inviting atmosphere and the scent of fresh-baked dough wafting out the door. My first slice here—plain cheese, straight from the oven—had a crisp bottom and just enough char on the crust to keep things interesting.
What sets Genovese apart is their ability to balance classic Italian flavors with a homey, family-style vibe. The Margherita pizza stands out, thanks to its bright tomato sauce and creamy mozzarella warmed into a gentle melt. If you like trying new takes, the Genovese Special is packed with flavor and never too heavy.
The quality is consistent, whether eating in with friends or grabbing a pie to go. For anyone in Franklin Square chasing authenticity, Genovese won’t disappoint.
2. Prince Umberto
Prince Umberto has the feel of a neighborhood staple, with a hum of activity that tells you locals love it. Every time I walk in, I spot someone picking up a familiar order, and you get the sense this place has regulars for a reason.
What really stands out? Their Sicilian slice. It comes out golden and thick, airy inside but never soggy underneath, with a tangy sauce layered generously. The Grandma pizza is another favorite—thin, crisp, and loaded with fresh basil and a bold sauce that lingers nicely.
Service is quick, making this the perfect stop when you want quality without the wait. You’ll leave with that just-right, satisfied pizza glow.
3. Laterazza Pizza
Laterazza Pizza sits right on Hempstead Turnpike, always smelling like fresh dough and oregano. My visits here usually end up with a box of leftovers—it’s impossible not to overorder. The energy is casual, and you’ll notice a stream of hungry regulars on most nights.
This spot shines with its classic cheese slice: thin, sturdy crust, never floppy, with sauce that strikes the right tangy note. For something a little different, try the white pie; garlicky, creamy, and perfect for anyone who wants a break from red sauce.
Laterazza’s pizzas never feel greasy or heavy. Each slice tastes fresh, and the ingredients speak for themselves. Perfect for a quick solo lunch or a relaxed dinner out.
4. Caprio Brick Oven Pizzaria
(516) 303-9360Call
Caprio Brick Oven Pizzaria rewards you from the moment you step in—the aroma from the brick oven is impossible to ignore. I first wandered in on a quiet afternoon and ended up staying for an extra slice. The pizza has a distinct toasted edge, all thanks to that real brick oven in the back.
The Margherita pizza is the star. It’s got a bubbly crust, bright sauce, and melty cheese that stays light. If you’re into bolder flavors, the veggie-loaded pie always hits the spot, each topping fresh and thoughtfully layered.
The value here is real, too. Caprio keeps prices in check while delivering quality that’s anything but ordinary. It’s a solid bet for great pizza in Franklin Square.
5. Nonno Toto
(516) 326-2310Call
Nonno Toto delivers that comforting nostalgia of a true neighborhood pizza spot. My first visit was after a long day, and the warm welcome set the tone for the meal ahead. There’s a homestyle vibe, and you notice right away this isn’t just another casual pizzeria.
Their Sicilian pizza deserves special mention—thick, pillowy, crisp on the base, and the tomato sauce is bright but not overly sweet. If you’re feeling adventurous, try their signature Nonno Toto slice. The blend of cheeses and herbs gives it a memorable twist you won’t find elsewhere.
Quality runs deep here. Each pie feels crafted, not rushed. Nonno Toto is a reliable pick for comfort food done just right in Franklin Square.
6. Fire Stone Grill & Pizza
Fire Stone Grill & Pizza captures attention with its modern look and the subtle scent of wood-fired crust as soon as you walk in. I wandered in after a busy afternoon and left impressed with both the speed and the bold flavors on my plate. There’s a bit of flair here you don’t always find in neighborhood pizza joints.
The Stone Oven pizza is the must-try—every bite boasts a crispy yet chewy base, with toppings arranged just right for maximum flavor. Their veggie pizza is another solid bet, featuring fresh vegetables that still have a pleasant bite.
It’s a great spot when you want a change from the ordinary, but still want comfort food with no shortcuts taken on quality or freshness.
7. Lazzarano Pizza
(516) 216-1831Call
Lazzarano Pizza is one of those no-frills spots that gets straight to what matters: good pizza, fast. I’ve dropped by more times than I can count, usually when the craving for a classic slice hits out of nowhere. Each time, the service is brisk and the food hot from the oven.
The cheese slice here is always on point, with a golden pull on each bite and just the right ratio of sauce to cheese. If you’re more adventurous, the vegetable slice is loaded but somehow never gets soggy or heavy.
This is the kind of place that turns a quick lunch into a small pleasure—nothing fancy, just straightforward pizza done right every time.
8. Carmela’s Pizzeria
Carmela’s Pizzeria brings the charm of old-school Italian comfort straight to Hempstead Turnpike. The first time I stopped in, it was the promise of imported ingredients and a dash of history that drew me. Sitting at a table with an award on the wall, the sense of tradition here is unmistakable.
The Margherita slice is a must—fresh basil, creamy mozzarella, and sauce that tastes like it took its time. For a twist, try one of their weekday specials, like a complimentary topping, which always makes the experience feel a bit more personal.
It’s a friendly spot with a loyal following, and every slice reflects real attention to detail. Carmela’s is perfect for anyone who values both story and substance in their pizza.
9. Lia’s Pizzeria
Lia’s Pizzeria feels like a neighborhood tradition that everyone knows about, even if you just moved to Franklin Square. My first visit was on a busy weekend night, yet the staff made the experience effortless—from seating to the first piping-hot slice landing on the table.
The Grandma slice is where Lia’s really shines. It arrives with a crisp, thin base topped with a balanced layer of fresh tomato and basil—a great example of how simple ingredients work wonders when treated right. For something with a little more bite, the Sicilian slice never disappoints either.
Consistently good pies and a warm, welcoming vibe make this spot worth coming back to, whether you’re solo or with a crowd.
10. Romeo’s Pizza
Romeo’s Pizza is tucked into Dogwood Ave, and there’s something comforting about its old-school sign and steady stream of pickups. I wandered in one weekday afternoon, and the no-nonsense approach—order, eat, enjoy—was refreshing. No bells, no whistles, just good pizza that speaks for itself.
The plain slice is always a winner here. Crispy underneath, soft up top, and the cheese has that signature stretch everyone loves. Their veggie slice is also a staple, with fresh toppings layered on a sturdy crust that never buckles.
The service is efficient, and the prices are friendly. Romeo’s doesn’t complicate things, focusing on reliable classics that hit the spot every single time.
More Things to Try in Franklin Square, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of pizza are popular in Franklin Square, NY?
You’ll find a range of pizzas here, including classic cheese, Sicilian, Grandma, Margherita, and plenty of veggie options. Many pizzerias serve both traditional thin crust and thicker, pan-baked slices.
Do Franklin Square pizzerias offer gluten-free options?
Several spots do offer gluten-free crusts, but availability varies. It’s best to call ahead, especially if you have specific dietary needs.
Can I get pizza delivered in Franklin Square?
Yes, most pizzerias offer delivery, with some also available on popular apps for extra convenience.
Are there any late-night pizza places in Franklin Square?
A few pizzerias stay open late—usually until 10 or 11 p.m. Checking a restaurant’s website or calling is a quick way to confirm current hours.
What makes pizza in Franklin Square stand out?
Pizzerias here often combine local loyalty with classic Italian family recipes. The result is pizza that’s both fresh and comforting, with unique touches at each spot.