Best Pizza in Columbia, MO

Columbia, MO, is a pizza lover’s dream. I’ve tasted lots of slices here. Trust me, this city has some amazing pizza spots. Whether you crave classic flavors or new twists, you’ll find something great.

When I think of the best pizza in Columbia, MO, I picture gooey cheese and fresh toppings. You’ll want to try the top pizzerias here. Each one has its own unique vibe and delicious pies. I’ll share my favorites and what makes them special for you.

I’m excited to take you on this tasty journey. Let’s explore some local gems together. You’ll learn where to get the best pizza and why these places stand out. Get ready for a delicious adventure!

Top 10 Pizza in Columbia, MO

1. Shakespeare’s Pizza – Downtown
2. Pizza Tree
3. PaPPo’s Pizzeria & Pub W Nifong Columbia, Mo
4. G & D Pizzaria
5. Southside Pizza & Pub
6. Gumby’s Pizza
7. Wise Guys Pizza
8. Shakespeare’s Pizza – South
9. Tony’s Pizza Palace
10. Shakespeare’s Pizza – West

1. Shakespeare’s Pizza – Downtown

Shakespeare’s Pizza – Downtown is pure joy. The moment you step inside, it’s alive with chatter and laughter. Friends and families share stories over pizza, while the smell of fresh dough fills the air. The vibe? It’s warm, friendly, and totally inviting.

Their pizza is magic. The crust is crispy on the outside but soft inside. Every slice is topped with fresh, flavorful ingredients. It’s the kind of pizza that keeps you coming back. Their unique touch adds something special to every bite.

My top pick? The “Masterpiece” pizza. It’s loaded with everything—meats, veggies, and melting cheese. It’s a perfect balance of flavors. For me, it shows why Shakespeare’s is the best spot in Columbia. You have to try it!

2. Pizza Tree

Pizza Tree is such a fun spot! You walk in and feel the chill vibe. The place is colorful, quirky, and just full of life. It’s the kind of place where time slows down, and you just relax.

Now, about the pizza—wow. They do things differently here. Every slice is fresh, bold, and packed with flavor. The crust? Perfectly chewy with just the right snap. The toppings are creative, playful, and oh-so-delicious.

I still can’t get over the “Magic Carpet Ride” pizza. It’s got mushrooms, pesto, and goat cheese. Each bite feels like a flavor explosion. It’s different in the best way. That pie really shows why Pizza Tree is so special. You’ll love it!

3. PaPPo’s Pizzeria & Pub W Nifong Columbia, Mo

PaPPo’s Pizzeria & Pub on Nifong is such a cozy spot. The atmosphere is relaxed and perfect for hanging out. They have both indoor and outdoor seating, so it’s great for any weather. Plus, it’s wheelchair-accessible, which is a huge plus.

The pizza is incredible. The crust is just right—not too thick, not too thin. Every bite is delicious. And the toppings are super fresh. They also do delivery and takeout, which is awesome for lazy nights.

I love the “Craft Your Own Pizza” option. It’s so much fun to create your own masterpiece. The ingredients are top-notch, and you can taste the quality in every bite. Definitely a must-try!

4. G & D Pizzaria

G & D Pizzaria is a fun little spot! It’s tucked away in a strip mall on W Broadway. The vibe is super casual, which I love. You can sit inside or outside, whatever feels right. Plus, it’s wheelchair-accessible, which is great for everyone.

I remember my first visit really well. The staff was friendly, and the place felt welcoming. I enjoyed sitting back and checking out the menu.

What makes G & D stand out is its variety. They have awesome pizzas, but also gyros and steak! It’s not just pizza; it’s a full experience.

If you go, you’ve got to try the gyros. They’re so juicy and flavorful, especially with the creamy tzatziki sauce. And the pizza? Perfectly crispy with all the toppings. You really can’t go wrong!

5. Southside Pizza & Pub

Southside Pizza & Pub is such a fun place! It’s on Peachtree Drive and has a great vibe. The sports bar atmosphere is lively, with pool tables and plenty of TVs. You can really feel the energy. And guess what? It’s wheelchair-accessible too!

I remember my visit clearly. I walked in, and the buzz of excitement hit me. Everyone was cheering for the game. The staff was super friendly and made me feel welcome right away.

What I love about Southside is the variety. They have cheesy pizzas and tasty sandwiches, plus fun shot options. It’s a great spot for a night out with friends.

Make sure to try the “Southside Special” pizza when you go. It’s loaded with fresh toppings and bursting with flavor. You won’t be disappointed!

6. Gumby’s Pizza

Oh, Gumby’s Pizza is awesome! Located on E Broadway, it’s super cozy. You can eat inside or chill outside. The best part? It’s wheelchair-accessible. So, everyone can enjoy it!

I remember my first visit. Walked in and the smell of pizza hit me. Instant hunger! The atmosphere is super relaxed. Great spot for a quick bite or hanging out with friends.

Why is Gumby’s special? Well, the variety! Tons of pizza options, wings, and Italian comfort food. Something for everyone. And the prices? Really affordable.

If you go, try the “Pokey Stix.” They’re cheesy and amazing. Pair them with a classic pizza. It’s a combo that never disappoints!

7. Wise Guys Pizza

Wise Guys Pizza is such a fun spot! It’s located on N 6th Street, right in the heart of things. This laid-back place is popular with college students, especially late at night. You can sit indoors or enjoy some fresh air outside. Plus, it’s wheelchair-accessible, which is great!

I remember my first late-night visit. I was craving pizza after studying all day. The smell hit me as soon as I walked in. It felt like the perfect place to relax and grab a bite.

What really stands out at Wise Guys is their Chicago-style pizza. It’s thick, cheesy, and so good. You don’t find that everywhere!

Definitely try the “Chicago Deep Dish” when you visit. It’s loaded with toppings and super satisfying. You’ll love it!

8. Shakespeare’s Pizza – South

Shakespeare’s Pizza – South is such a fantastic place! Located on Peachtree Drive, it has a really relaxed vibe. You can choose to sit inside or outside, and both options are great. They offer yummy pizza, fresh salads, and a nice selection of drinks like craft beer and cocktails. Plus, you can easily get takeout or delivery!

I remember my visit there after a busy day. I walked in, and the friendly atmosphere made me smile. The smell of pizza was mouthwatering, and I knew I was in for a treat!

One thing I absolutely loved was the “Masterpiece” pizza. It’s stacked with all kinds of meats and fresh veggies. Each bite is just amazing. You’ve got to give it a try!

9. Tony’s Pizza Palace

Tony’s Pizza Palace is one of my favorite spots! It’s right on N 5th Street and has such a cozy vibe. I love how laid-back it feels. They serve everything from pizza to subs and even some yummy Greek dishes. You can sit inside or outside, and it’s wheelchair-accessible, which is great!

I remember going there with my friends one night. The moment we walked in, the smell of fresh pizza made my mouth water. The staff was super friendly and made us feel welcome.

What I really love about Tony’s is the variety. There’s something for everyone on the menu.

You have to try the “Mediterranean Pizza.” It’s loaded with fresh veggies and feta cheese. It’s so flavorful and delicious! You won’t regret it!

10. Shakespeare’s Pizza – West

I’m really excited to share about Shakespeare’s Pizza – West! It’s located on W Broadway, and it has such a cozy atmosphere. You can choose to sit inside or outside, and both are great. Plus, it’s wheelchair-accessible!

I remember the first time I went there. The smell of fresh pizza was just amazing. The staff was super friendly, and I felt at home right away.

What really stands out is their menu. They have delicious pizza and fresh salads. Everything tastes so good.

When you visit, you have to try the “Pesto Chicken Pizza.” It’s loaded with flavor. The pesto pairs perfectly with the chicken. Trust me, you won’t regret it!

Map of Pizza in Columbia, MO

Choosing the Right Restaurant for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

• What are the best pizza places in Columbia, MO?
  Oh, there are so many good ones. Shakespeare’s Pizza, Pizza Tree, and Gumby’s Pizza top my list. You just can’t go wrong with any of them.

• Where can I find vegan pizza in Columbia, MO?
  Vegan pizza is easier to find now. Shakespeare’s Pizza has options, and Pizza Tree does too. They’ve got fresh toppings that’ll make you forget it’s vegan!

• Which pizza place is best for families?
  Hands down, Shakespeare’s Pizza is perfect for families. Big tables, fun vibes, and friendly service—it’s a win.

• Are there late-night pizza spots in Columbia, MO?
  Gumby’s Pizza saves the night every time. Open late, tasty slices, and great prices. It’s a favorite after dark.

• Do any pizza places in Columbia, MO deliver?
  Yes, lots of them deliver. Gumby’s and Papa John’s are popular choices. So convenient when you’re chilling at home.

• What are some unique pizza toppings available in Columbia, MO?
  Oh, Pizza Tree goes wild with toppings! Ever tried kimchi on pizza? Shakespeare’s also gets creative with flavors.

• Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Columbia, MO?
  Gluten-free options are everywhere now. Shakespeare’s has a gluten-free crust. Just call ahead to make sure they have it.

• What’s the most popular pizza spot in Columbia, MO?
  It’s gotta be Shakespeare’s Pizza. Locals love it. Visitors always rave about it. It’s just iconic.