Best Pizza in Cicero, IN

Finding the best pizza in Cicero, IN, is like a fun treasure hunt. Trust me, I’ve tasted so many slices. Each pizzeria offers something special. I’m excited to share my favorites with you.

So, what are the best pizzerias in Cicero, IN? The best spots include Bronko’s of Cicero, Pizza House, DeLullo’s Trattoria, Pizza King, Paladino’s Cicero Pizza, Cicero Country Pizza, Sapori By Antonio Restaurant & Pizzeria, Twin Trees Cicero, Freddy’s Pizza, and Scatchell’s Beef & Pizza. Each place has amazing pizza and a delightful vibe.

Stick around! I’ll take you through each one. You’ll learn what makes them unique. Plus, I’ll share my top picks and must-try dishes. Let’s dive into Cicero’s pizza scene together!

Top 10 Pizza in Cicero, IN

1. Bronko’s of Cicero
2. Pizza House
3. DeLullo’s Trattoria
4. Pizza King
5. Paladino’s Cicero Pizza
6. Cicero Country Pizza
7. Sapori By Antonio Restaurant & Pizzeria
8. Twin Trees Cicero
9. Freddy’s Pizza
10. Scatchell’s Beef & Pizza

1. Bronko’s of Cicero

Bronko’s of Cicero is such a cool spot. It’s at 90 W Jackson St. They have indoor and outdoor seating. So, you can chill inside or enjoy the fresh air. Plus, they offer curbside pickup and takeout.

I loved my visit to Bronko’s. The vibe was super friendly. The staff was really nice. And the pizza? Wow! I tried Bronko’s Special. It was loaded with fresh toppings and melty cheese. The crust was crispy but fluffy.

If you go, try the cheesy garlic bread. It’s so tasty! Bronko’s really knows how to make great pizza. You’ll love it!

2. Pizza House

Pizza House is a great spot at 11 N Main St. It has both indoor and outdoor seating. I love that it’s wheelchair-accessible too. You can grab delivery or takeout, which is super handy. Plus, prices are pretty reasonable.

When I visited Pizza House, I felt right at home. The vibe was relaxed and inviting. The staff was really nice and helpful. And the pizza? Oh my goodness! I had the loaded deluxe pizza. It was amazing! The toppings were fresh, and the crust was perfectly crispy.

You have to try their pepperoni rolls, too. They are so cheesy and packed with flavor. Pizza House is a must-visit for pizza lovers like me!

3. DeLullo’s Trattoria

DeLullo’s Trattoria is my favorite spot in Cicero. It’s at 230 W Jackson St, right in the heart of town. The place is super cozy with both indoor and outdoor seating. It’s perfect for any weather. They also do curbside pickup and takeout. Plus, it’s wheelchair-accessible. They really think of everything.

I loved my visit to DeLullo’s. It felt so warm and welcoming. The staff was friendly and made me feel at home. And the pizza! Oh, the pizza was incredible. The Margherita pizza, with its fresh basil, mozzarella, and tomato sauce, was a game-changer for me.

You have to try the bruschetta. It’s full of flavor and feels so authentic. DeLullo’s brings a piece of Italy to Cicero. Every bite is a delight.

4. Pizza King

Pizza King on West Jackson Street is great. It’s a cozy spot that’s perfect for everyone. They have delivery and both indoor and outdoor seating. Their pizzas are delicious and they also serve tasty sandwiches, salads, and desserts.

I remember the first time I went there. The staff was super friendly. It felt like visiting family. The atmosphere was warm and inviting. Everyone seemed happy and relaxed.

You must try their Royal Feast pizza. It’s full of fresh toppings and has a crispy crust. Also, their cheesy breadsticks are to die for. These dishes show their commitment to great taste and quality.

5. Paladino’s Cicero Pizza

Paladino’s Cicero Pizza is such a cozy spot! It’s right on Brewerton Rd, and they have this amazing vibe. You can grab your food to go, or have it delivered. Or, if you feel like sitting down, they have both indoor and outdoor seating. And trust me, it’s super affordable.

So, the first time I went there, I was welcomed with big smiles. The place smelled incredible, like fresh pizza dough baking. The seats were comfy, and I felt so relaxed. Plus, the staff was super quick and friendly.

What really sets Paladino’s apart is the quality. Every pizza is made with fresh ingredients. The crust is thin and crispy, and the toppings are always generous.

If you go, definitely try their Margherita Pizza. It’s simple but so good. Fresh tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil – perfect! And don’t miss out on their garlic knots. They’re a great sidekick to any pizza. Paladino’s is just the best place to enjoy a meal with loved ones.

6. Cicero Country Pizza

Cicero Country Pizza is at 8292 Brewerton Rd. It feels so cozy. You can sit inside or outside. They also deliver. The place is budget-friendly. There’s a ramp for wheelchairs. You can even book a table.

I remember walking in. The warm smell of fresh pizza hit me. Everyone smiled. The crust is so crispy. And the cheese, oh, it’s perfect.

Try the Supreme Pizza. It has lots of toppings. Every bite is amazing. Get the garlic bread too. It makes the meal complete.

7. Sapori By Antonio Restaurant & Pizzeria

Sapori By Antonio is at 5962 NY-31, Unit 12. This restaurant has such a welcoming vibe. You can sit inside or enjoy the outdoors. They also offer curbside pickup and delivery, which is super handy. Plus, it’s wheelchair-accessible!

When I walked in, I felt right at home. The smell of fresh pizza was amazing. The staff greeted me with big smiles, making me feel special.

What really stands out is the flavor. I tried their Margherita Pizza, and wow, it was fantastic! The fresh basil and mozzarella were just perfect. And don’t skip dessert! Their cannoli is so creamy and sweet. It’s the best way to end a meal there!

8. Twin Trees Cicero

Twin Trees Cicero is at 6259 NY-31. I love this place! It has a fun and friendly vibe. You can sit inside or outside. They also have curbside pickup and delivery, which is super nice. Plus, it’s wheelchair-accessible.

On my first visit, I felt welcome right away. The staff greeted me with big smiles. The delicious smell of pizza filled the air, and I couldn’t wait to try some!

What makes Twin Trees stand out is their menu variety. I really enjoyed their classic cheese pizza. The crust was crispy and the cheese was super gooey. And their buffalo wings? So flavorful and spicy! They make a perfect combo. You have to check it out!

9. Freddy’s Pizza

So let me tell you about Freddy’s Pizza. It’s a cozy spot at 1600 S 61st Ave. They’ve been around since 1968. You can sit inside or outside, which is super nice. If you prefer to eat at home, they have takeout too.

When I first walked in, the smell was amazing. It was like being wrapped in a warm, cheesy hug. The staff greeted me with big smiles. It felt really homey and friendly.

Freddy’s is known for its thick-crust pizza. You have to try the classic pepperoni. The crust is crispy outside and soft inside. Also, the stuffed shells are a must. They’re so cheesy and delicious!

Freddy’s is definitely a place you need to check out if you love pizza.

10. Scatchell’s Beef & Pizza

Scatchell’s Beef & Pizza is at 4700 W Cermak Rd. This place is simple but full of charm. They serve hot dogs, Italian beef sandwiches, and lots of pizza. You can eat inside or outside, which is nice. They also have delivery and takeout if you want to eat at home.

When I walked in for the first time, I felt right at home. The atmosphere was lively and fun. The staff was super friendly, and the food came out fast.

What really stands out here is the Italian beef. It’s so juicy and packed with flavor! You have to try their pizza, too. The crust is soft, and they pile on the toppings. Scatchell’s is perfect for a quick and tasty meal!

Map of Pizza in Cicero, IN

Choosing the Right Restaurant for You

With 10 excellent places, here’s a quick comparison to help you decide:

Frequently Asked Questions

• What are the best pizza places in Cicero, IN?

• My favorites are Bronko’s of Cicero, Pizza House, and DeLullo’s Trattoria. Each has its own special charm and yummy pizza!

• Do any pizza places in Cicero offer delivery?

• Yes, lots of places deliver! Places like Domino’s and Pizza House bring the pizza right to your door.

• Are there gluten-free pizza options in Cicero?

• For sure! Many places offer gluten-free pizza. Just check their menu or ask when you order.

• What are the hours for pizza places in Cicero?

• Hours can vary by restaurant. It’s always a good idea to call ahead or check their website for exact times.

• Can I order pizza online in Cicero?

• Yes, definitely! Many pizza places let you order online. You can easily do it from their websites or apps.

• Are there pizza places in Cicero with outdoor seating?

• Yes, you’ll find some with outdoor seating! It’s nice to enjoy pizza outside when the weather is good.

• What are the most popular pizza toppings in Cicero?

• People love pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms. Those are definitely crowd favorites around here!

• Do any pizza places offer vegan options?

• Yes, a few places offer vegan pizza. It’s worth checking their menu for those options.

• Are there pizza places in Cicero that do catering?

• Yes! Some pizza places cater for events. Just get in touch with them for details.

• What are the prices like for pizza in Cicero?

• Prices are pretty reasonable. You can find pizza for all budgets. Just check the menu for specifics.