St. Augustine has a small-town charm that hides a vibrant pizza scene. I have explored many local spots and found that each pizzeria has its own twist. The city offers a mix of classic recipes and modern spins that suit every taste. This guide will help you find the best pizza in town.
I spent a sunny afternoon sampling slices, and each bite told its own story. The simplicity of thin crusts and the burst of fresh toppings impressed me. Trusting my palate, I gathered the top spots that show care in every slice served. Read on to discover a slice of the local flavor.
1. Carmelo’s Marketplace
+1 904-829-2337
See Menu
Carmelo’s Marketplace offers a unique blend of convenience and local charm at 146 King St in St. Augustine. I found its cozy feel and welcoming service refreshing.
During my visit, I enjoyed a slice of pizza that perfectly balanced fresh toppings with a crispy base. The taste was a clear nod to quality ingredients and care.
I recommend trying their vegetarian pizza, ideal for a light lunch or a relaxed dinner. Each bite reflects a commitment to flavor and community.
With options for delivery, table service, or takeout, Carmelo’s Marketplace stands out as a versatile hotspot for pizza lovers.
2. Pizzalley Chianti Room
Pizzalley Chianti Room sits at 60 Charlotte St, offering a warm and inviting ambiance. I enjoyed an evening there, relishing the balance of flavors and friendly service.
Their menu impresses with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. The quality and care in every dish reflect a commitment to healthy tastes.
I recommend trying their signature vegetarian pizza. It beautifully blends fresh ingredients with a perfectly crisp crust that captures the essence of St. Augustine’s pizza scene.
Flexible and accessible, Pizzalley Chianti Room welcomes diverse dining preferences, making it a standout destination for anyone seeking quality pizza.
3. 180 Vilano Grill & Pizza
180 Vilano Grill & Pizza is a family-owned gem on Vilano Road. I experienced their warm service and genuine hospitality during a relaxed dinner.
Their pizza stands out with a no-frills approach, showcasing fresh ingredients and a perfectly crisp crust. Every slice reflects care and quality.
I suggest trying their signature pizza, which pairs well with a glass of local wine or refreshing homemade Sangria. The inviting atmosphere and thoughtful service make this spot a must-visit for pizza lovers.
4. Violas
Violas, located on A1A in Saint Augustine Beach, impresses with its vibrant atmosphere and loyal local clientele. I discovered the spot during a leisurely afternoon and was immediately drawn in by its warm service.
Their pizza, crafted with fresh, high-quality ingredients, stands out in St. Augustine’s competitive scene. I recommend their signature pie for its balanced flavor and perfectly crisp crust.
With options catering to vegetarians, vegans, and gluten-free diets, Violas excels in meeting diverse tastes. Reserving a table after 4pm enhances the cozy dining experience.
5. Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine
+1 904-826-4040
Mellow Mushroom St. Augustine creates a vibrant dining experience with its art-filled, family-friendly setting. I enjoyed the relaxed atmosphere and creative energy during my recent visit.
Their hand-tossed, stone-baked pizza is a standout delight. I suggest trying the classic southern pizza with a unique spring water crust; it perfectly blends fresh, quality ingredients.
Offering vegetarian and vegan options along with friendly service, Mellow Mushroom elevates every meal. The lively ambiance and innovative menu make it a must-visit for pizza lovers in St. Augustine.
6. Romano’s On The Beach
+1 904-461-1111
Romano’s On The Beach in St. Augustine is celebrated for its diverse menu and inviting charm. I had the pleasure of tasting their renowned pizza during a relaxing afternoon, and every bite was unforgettable.
The signature pizza impressed me with its rich Italian flavor and crisp, fresh crust made from scratch. The blend of quality ingredients perfectly reflects Romano’s commitment to tradition and excellence.
Offering vegetarian and gluten-free options adds to its broad appeal. I recommend ordering the signature pizza to experience an extraordinary fusion of authentic Italian expertise with a touch of modern American flair.
7. Pizza Time of St Augustine
+1 904-819-0133
Pizza Time of St Augustine, located at 124 Saint George Street, offers a vibrant mix of Italian flavors with a fast-food twist. I recently stopped by and was impressed by their friendly service and efficient delivery of quality food.
What makes this place stand out is its dedication to using fresh, halal-friendly ingredients in every dish, with a wide selection of vegetarian and vegan options.
I highly recommend trying their signature pizza, which masterfully blends traditional Italian taste with modern quick-service convenience. It’s an ideal choice for those seeking a halal twist on classic pizza in St. Augustine.
8. Borrillo’s Pizzeria and Beer & Wine Garden
+1 904-829-1133
Borrillo’s Pizzeria and Beer & Wine Garden on San Marco Avenue offers an inviting blend of Italian flair and a relaxed, lively atmosphere. I recently enjoyed a visit where the warm service and vibrant ambiance truly stood out.
During my visit, I savored their signature pizza, made using fresh, halal-friendly ingredients. The crispy crust and inventive toppings perfectly capture the essence of quality pizza in St. Augustine.
Paired with a selection of fine wines and craft beers, your meal at Borrillo’s becomes a memorable dining experience. It’s a top spot for those looking for authentic Italian flavors in a community-oriented setting.
9. Five Star Pizza
Five Star Pizza, located on S Ponce de Leon Blvd, delivers flavorful pizza, wings, and more with an impressive fast delivery service until 3:00 a.m. daily. I recently ordered their signature halal-friendly pizza, and the convenience paired with delicious taste made my night.
Their dedication to quality and speedy service truly sets them apart. Every bite of pizza is a testament to fresh ingredients and excellent preparation.
I highly recommend trying their classic pizza, enjoyed in a halal-friendly way to maintain quality and authenticity – a perfect choice for a late-night meal in St. Augustine.
10. Tony’s Pizza – New York Style
+1 904-471-8660
Tony’s Pizza – New York Style, located in Saint Augustine Beach, offers a vibrant atmosphere with speedy service. I recently stopped by and was impressed by their warm welcome and efficient delivery.
They stand out by using fresh, halal-approved ingredients to craft a distinctive New York-style pizza. The thin, crispy crust and balanced flavors showcase their commitment to quality.
I highly recommend ordering the classic New York style pizza. Its authentic taste and halal-friendly preparation make it a standout choice for any pizza lover in St. Augustine.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are some popular pizza spots in St. Augustine, FL?
A: Popular spots include Romano’s On The Beach, Tony’s Pizza – New York Style, and Borrillo’s Pizzeria, among others. Each offers a unique twist on classic pizza.
Q: Are there halal-friendly pizza options available?
A: Yes, many pizzerias in St. Augustine prioritize fresh, halal-approved ingredients, ensuring a safe dining choice for those following halal guidelines.
Q: Do these restaurants cater to vegetarians or vegans?
A: Absolutely! Most pizza places offer vegetarian-friendly options and some even feature dedicated vegan choices.
Q: What styles of pizza can I expect in St. Augustine?
A: You can find a range from traditional Italian styles to New York thin crust and even unique local twists that capture the city’s vibrant culinary scene.
Q: Is delivery or takeout available?
A: Certainly! Many pizzerias offer both delivery and takeout services, making it convenient to enjoy pizza anywhere in St. Augustine.
