Nestled along the scenic shores of Fernandina Beach, FL, the pizza scene here is as inviting as it is diverse. Each pizzeria offers its own charm and variety. I have explored these spots personally, and I can attest to the quality and creativity found in every slice. The local establishments provide a mix of traditional and inventive styles that cater to many tastes.
During my visits, I found that the care put into both the dough and the toppings consistently stands out. The flavors are fresh and well-balanced, demonstrating a true passion for the craft. In the following sections, you will discover detailed insights into each pizza haven, ensuring you make the best choice for your next meal. Every spot has its unique appeal, so there is something special waiting for every pizza lover.
1. Arte Pizza
+1 904-277-1515
Arte Pizza has been at the heart of Fernandina Beach’s pizza scene since 2006. Their Napoli style pizzas are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients that stand out in every bite. I was particularly impressed with their wood-fired Margherita, which offered a crisp, smoky crust.
The dough is crafted daily with special high-gluten flour, while Wisconsin cheeses add an exceptional touch. The use of wild caught shrimp in select dishes reinforces their commitment to quality.
For a unique twist, try the seafood pizza. Arte’s signature style and attention to detail shine through in every slice.
2. Moon River Pizza
+1 904-321-3400
Moon River Pizza offers a relaxed setting in Fernandina Beach that makes every pizza night memorable. I enjoyed the friendly service and clean, inviting interior that reflects the charm of the area.
The wood-fired pizzas stand out, featuring a perfectly crisp crust and fresh toppings. I recommend trying their classic Margherita; its simplicity and taste capture the essence of quality pizza in Fernandina Beach.
Their menu accommodates various preferences including vegetarian and gluten-free options. Moon River Pizza’s commitment to flavor and style makes it a go-to spot for a satisfying meal.
3. Townies Pizzeria
+1 904-277-4755
Townies Pizzeria is a local favorite in Fernandina Beach, known for its warm, homegrown ambiance. I experienced genuine hospitality that made me feel like part of the family.
The menu bursts with fresh garden ingredients, elevating traditional recipes. Their classic Margherita pizza, with fresh basil and vibrant tomatoes, perfectly embodies their commitment to quality.
A welcoming atmosphere and consistent excellence position Townies as a standout choice for pizza in Fernandina Beach.
4. First Love Brewing
First Love Brewing offers a unique blend of community spirit and culinary creativity in Fernandina Beach. During a recent visit, I savored the intimate atmosphere and felt the genuine passion for quality firsthand.
Their artisan pizza, baked in a Cuppone Oven, features a beautifully crisp base and fresh toppings that complement their rotating taps. I recommend pairing a slice with one of the thoughtfully curated brews.
This microbrewery combines a commitment to excellence with a casual dining experience that feels both innovative and true to its roots.
5. Natural Slice Pizza
+1 904-491-4115
Natural Slice Pizza offers a vibrant, family-friendly ambiance at the Omni Amelia Island Resort. Its surf-inspired decor sets a relaxed tone perfect for enjoying flavorful pizzas in Fernandina Beach.
On my visit, I was impressed by their hand-tossed dough and the freshness of every ingredient. The create-your-own option makes each meal uniquely satisfying, allowing you to craft your ideal pizza.
I recommend trying a specialty pizza to fully savor their commitment to quality and creativity. Every bite reflects the diverse, fresh tastes that make Natural Slice Pizza stand out in town.
6. The Loop Restaurant
+1 904-321-0093
The Loop Restaurant has been a cherished spot in Fernandina Beach since 1981. I recently dined there and enjoyed the warm, community vibe that makes it feel like a second home.
Their menu offers fresh ground burgers, open-fire grilled dishes, and notably, cheesy pizzas that capture a perfect balance of flavor and tradition. The pizzas, with their crisp crust and savory toppings, truly reflect the restaurant’s commitment to quality.
If you’re in the mood for a hearty, satisfying meal, try one of their specialty pizzas. The Loop’s unique blend of classic and contemporary dishes is sure to leave you wanting more.
7. Ops Pizza Kitchen
+1 904-277-8665
Ops Pizza Kitchen in Fernandina Beach offers a welcoming ambiance that immediately draws you in. I had a delightful lunch here, enjoying the friendly service and vibrant setting that truly stands out.
Their menu features an array of artisan pizzas crafted with fresh ingredients and innovative flair, ensuring each slice is both flavorful and memorable. Their commitment to quality is evident with every bite.
If you visit, don’t miss their signature pizza, which perfectly marries traditional flavors with creative toppings. This dish encapsulates Ops Pizza Kitchen’s excellence, making it a top pick for any pizza lover in Fernandina Beach.
8. V Pizza – Fernandina Beach
+1 904-659-0026
I recently visited V Pizza – Fernandina Beach and was immediately charmed by its lively yet laid-back atmosphere.
The restaurant seamlessly blends Italian and American influences, creating a unique pizza experience that truly stands out in Fernandina Beach. The care in preparing each pizza, from the hand-tossed dough to the fresh toppings, is evident with every bite.
During my visit, I enjoyed their signature specialty pizza, which offered a delightful mix of flavors that resonated with both traditional and modern tastes. This dish perfectly captures the quality and creativity V Pizza is known for.
9. Coastal Pizza
+1 904-491-9998
See Menu
I recently stopped by Coastal Pizza at the Island Walk Shopping Center, and its relaxed, friendly vibe immediately won me over.
The restaurant impressively blends fresh, hand-crafted flavors with a laid-back coastal twist, making it a standout in Fernandina Beach. I was particularly pleased with the vegetarian-friendly pizza options and the crispy, delicious crust they serve.
If you’re looking for a pizza that mirrors both tradition and coastal innovation, I recommend trying one of their specialty pies. Each slice highlights their commitment to quality and the coastal spirit, making it a must-try in Fernandina Beach.
10. Ciao Italian Eatery
+1 904-206-4311
Ciao Italian Eatery, located at 614 Centre St, offers a modern yet casual setting that highlights fine ingredients and gracious service. I was impressed by the welcoming ambiance and the restaurant’s commitment to quality.
During my visit, I enjoyed a beautifully crafted pizza that balanced classic Italian flavors with fresh, halal-friendly ingredients. The blend of traditional and signature dishes truly showcases their culinary expertise.
If you’re in Fernandina Beach, I recommend ordering their signature pizza. It reflects the eatery’s stylish approach and dedication to quality, making it a standout dish in this charming Italian eatery.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are some popular pizza spots in Fernandina Beach, FL?
A: Popular choices include Natural Slice Pizza, The Loop Restaurant, Ops Pizza Kitchen, V Pizza, Coastal Pizza, and Ciao Italian Eatery. Each offers a unique twist on classic and gourmet pizzas.
Q: Can I find halal-friendly pizza options?
A: Yes, many restaurants offer vegetarian options or use fresh ingredients that can align with halal standards. It’s best to ask the staff about their ingredients to ensure they meet your halal requirements.
Q: Do these places offer both dine-in and takeout options?
A: Absolutely. Most establishments provide dine-in experiences along with takeout and delivery, making it easy to enjoy pizza wherever you are.
Q: What type of pizza variety can I expect?
A: From traditional Italian and gourmet to creative specialty pizzas with diverse toppings, there’s something for every palate in Fernandina Beach.
