Finding a good pizza in Zionsville is a lot like hunting for treasure. You don’t need a map, but a little insider guidance helps. Each spot in this list brings something unique—some offer perfectly crisp crusts, others tempt you with bubbling cheese and secret sauce recipes. I’ve tasted my way through the town; sometimes chasing that elusive spicy kick, sometimes in search of a classic, chewy bite. Each place left a different impression, and every visit turned into a story worth sharing.
For anyone seeking the best pizza in Zionsville, IN, a quick online search doesn’t do justice to the local gems tucked between familiar names. There’s character in these kitchens. Some people talk about pizza like it’s simple. But pizza here is never just cheese and dough—it’s a whole experience. If you’re ready for more than a forgettable slice, you’re in the right place. Let’s see what makes each spot stand out, and which one might become your new go-to.
1. Amore Pizzeria & Ristorante
Amore Pizzeria & Ristorante feels like stepping into a slice of New York, but with the warmth you only find in Zionsville. Family-owned and run by the Simone brothers, the place blends classic East Coast flair with generous local spirit. The dough is tossed daily, and you can taste the care in every bite.
On my last visit, I went for the Margherita pizza. The perfectly thin, crispy crust held up under bright tomato sauce and gooey mozzarella, with fresh basil adding a kick. The Sicilian style is another standout if you crave a thicker, pillowy texture.
Order the New York-style cheese and their veggie-loaded specialty. You’ll leave craving more and maybe plotting your next visit before you’ve even left your seat.
2. Greek’s Pizzeria
If you like pizza that dares to layer on flavor, Greek’s Pizzeria is impossible to skip. This spot holds down Main Street with a menu that goes past the usual and takes its sauces and toppings seriously. The space manages to feel both lively and easygoing—kind of place you’re just as comfortable dining in as grabbing takeout.
They handle the crust with finesse: crisp on the bottom, airy in the middle. Their vegetarian and vegan-friendly options stand out in a town sometimes dominated by cheese. Last time, I couldn’t resist the Greek’s Special—a medley of veggies and cheese over a sauce that hinted at sweetness and spice in one bite.
Order the Greek’s Special, or build your own if you want to play flavor architect. Either way, you get a memorable slice that reflects their inventive spirit.
3. Zionsville Pizzeria
Zionsville Pizzeria has that small-town vibe you want when grabbing a pizza in the heart of Main Street. It’s low-key, laid back, and everyone seems to have a favorite pie. I stopped in for lunch and was greeted with a casual atmosphere and the kind of friendly service you only get at a real neighborhood spot.
Ingredient quality is where they raise the bar. You taste it in every sauce-soaked bite and in their signature hand-tossed crust. The pepper and mushroom combo is great if you like that classic pizzeria feel, and their vegetarian pie comes loaded with fresh toppings.
Order the Deluxe or Veggie pizza to see what the fuss is about. Both showcase the attention and care this team brings to the table.
4. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza on Oak Street delivers exactly what you expect: consistent quality and fast service. When you crave something reliable for a family dinner or game night, this spot rarely lets you down. The open kitchen feel and cheery staff make pickup a bit more enjoyable, too.
The appeal here is in their signature dough and tangy sauce. I’ve had my share of quick dinners from Papa Johns, and their crust always comes out hot, soft, and just chewy enough. The cheese blend melts evenly, making each slice as satisfying as the last.
Try the classic Garden Fresh pizza or the Spinach Alfredo for a twist. Both keep things simple, relying on freshness and flavor—no gimmicks needed.
5. Hot Box Pizza
Hot Box Pizza owns the vibe of a late-night craving spot, but you’ll catch fans showing up at lunchtime too. Their approach is all about customization—bold toppings and build-your-own options that don’t play it safe. There’s a fun energy both in-store and in the flavors that stack onto their classic crust.
I’ve swung by after work with friends just for a casual slice, and found the experience upbeat. The staff makes you feel at home, whether you want a veggie-heavy pie or something unapologetically cheesy and rich.
Go for the Veggie pizza or make your own combination. The balance of crispy crust and generous toppings delivers every time, and you’ll never leave hungry.
6. Fox’s Pizza Den
Fox’s Pizza Den brings a mix of nostalgia and neighborhood comfort. The dining room has that easy, no-frills air—everyone seems to know someone, or at least recognizes a face. During my last visit, the staff had that rare mix of speed and genuine friendliness.
The star here is the hand-tossed crust; it’s got enough chew to make every bite satisfying, but never turns soggy under piles of toppings. Fox’s doesn’t skimp—pizzas come out layered and hearty. This is the place to gather for a laidback group dinner or quick takeout.
Try the Veggie or the Fox’s Special. Both showcase the kitchen’s knack for balancing rich sauces and crisp veggies, turning familiar flavors into something memorable.
7. Hot Box Pizza
This Hot Box Pizza location on Whitestown Parkway has a casual, lively setup that feels perfect for grabbing a quick slice or settling in with friends. Their recipe is all about flavor that pops, endless customizable toppings, and a crust with attitude. There’s a relaxed buzz inside, but the service is as quick as you’d hope.
The beauty of Hot Box is its willingness to bend the rules—wild ingredient combinations and plenty of veggie choices for the adventurous. I met up with friends for dinner and we left with a half-and-half pie, arguing over which half was better. Spoiler: both vanished rapidly.
Try their classic Veggie pizza or invent your own. No matter your pick, expect a lively crunch, plenty of personality, and a pizza that never feels predictable.
8. Sbarro
Sbarro sits tucked off Michigan Road and has carved out a spot for those craving classic, no-nonsense pizza by the slice. This spot is easy to walk into when you’re in the mood for something fast, familiar, and filling. The aroma of fresh dough and melting cheese hits before you’ve even made it to the counter.
What stands out for me is the New York-style pies—wide, foldable, and perfect for a grab-and-go lunch. Every bite delivers a balance of gooey cheese, robust tomato sauce, and a crust that refuses to wilt.
Order the cheese or the veggie slice to capture Sbarro’s straightforward style. They nail the basics, proving sometimes all you want is the comfort of a well-made, classic pizza.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Oak Street is the go-to for a no-fuss, quick fix when pizza cravings strike. Delivery is fast, and the tracking system means you always know when your next cheesy bite is arriving. This place has nailed convenience with a reliable lineup of crusts and toppings.
What’s set Domino’s apart for me is the consistency of their handmade pan crust. It’s thick, buttery, and comes out golden every time. Their vegetable pizzas are deceptively good—a crisp mix of peppers, onions, and mushrooms layered on a zesty sauce. They’re not shy about flavor or cheese either.
Order the veggie pan pizza or classic hand-tossed cheese. Expect steady value, generous toppings, and pizza that hits the right note for easy nights in.
10. Hotbox Pizza
Hotbox Pizza in Townes at Weston Pointe grabs your attention with its easy atmosphere and playful menu. This isn’t the type of place that takes itself too seriously, and the results are pizzas that pack plenty of punch. On a recent visit, the energy was as upbeat as the flavors coming out of the oven.
Customization is Hotbox’s calling card: build your pie from a huge list of ingredients or trust their staff picks. The crust is crunchy at the edge and tender underneath, happy to carry as many toppings as you throw on.
Go for a veggie-loaded specialty or create your own. Each bite delivers strong flavors and a texture that makes it hard not to finish the box on your own.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Zionsville, IN?
Zionsville has a mix of local favorites and trusted chains. Amore Pizzeria & Ristorante is top for New York-style slices, while Hotbox Pizza shines for customization and fun flavors. Fox’s Pizza Den and Greek’s Pizzeria also stand out for quality and variety.
Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Zionsville?
Yes. Spots like Greek’s Pizzeria and Hotbox Pizza offer vegetarian and vegan-friendly pies. You’ll find veggie-loaded specialties and build-your-own menus at most local joints.
Where can I find gluten-free pizza in Zionsville?
Several places, including Domino’s and Hotbox Pizza, offer gluten-free crusts. Double-check with each restaurant for preparation details if you have strong dietary needs.
Which pizza spot is best for families?
Amore Pizzeria & Ristorante and Fox’s Pizza Den are both family-friendly with relaxed settings and plenty of seating.
Do any pizza places in Zionsville offer delivery?
Most do. Chains like Domino’s, Papa John’s, and local favorites such as Hotbox Pizza and Zionsville Pizzeria offer delivery options.