Finding good pizza isn’t just about melted cheese and golden crust. In Yorktown, NY, each pizzeria seems to have its own philosophy—one place swears by a decades-old family sauce recipe, another is all about that impossibly crisp, chewy base. The town might not have the crowds of the city, but it has a way of turning pizza night into a memorable ritual. I remember the first slice I tried here: fresh basil, not too much oil, a bite that made comparison almost unfair. Since then, sussing out the next “best pizza” has felt like a kind of local treasure hunt.
Yorktown’s pizza scene is lively and competitive, and the choices can be dizzying if you don’t know where to start. Some places lean classic, some go bold, but all try to earn a spot as your new go-to. This guide doesn’t hype the flashiest toppings or the most secret menu hacks—it’s about clarity, flavor, and honest satisfaction. Whether you favor thin, pillowy, plain, or loaded, read on. Your next favorite slice might be waiting at the next corner.
Where to find the best pizza in Yorktown, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Yorktown, NY:
- Nonna’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Three Boys Pizzeria
- Sophia’s Pizza
- Maria’s Pizza
- Yorktown Pizza & Pasta
- Domino’s Pizza
- Cfa Pizza Corp
- New York Pizza Company
- Calabria Pizza & Pasta
- Don Tonnaso’s Beastro
1. Nonna’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
(914) 962-0300Call
Step into Nonna’s Pizzeria & Restaurant at Yorktown Green Shopping Center and you’ll find a place where tradition gets the spotlight. My last visit there, I couldn’t help but notice how the brick oven works its magic—each pizza emerges with just the right char and chew. The Margherita is a safe bet, but the real charm is in their classic cheese; it’s a lesson in balance: crisp yet tender dough, homemade sauce, and a layer of cheese that stretches just right.
Nonna’s stands out for its warmth both in the food and in the way staff remember your order after a visit or two. If you’re torn, go for the white pizza with garlic. It’s one of those local secrets that regulars crave. Parking is easy, the prices don’t pinch, and if you stay for a slice, expect to want another.
2. Three Boys Pizzeria
(914) 245-4811Call
There’s something about the cozy, unpretentious feel of Three Boys Pizzeria that keeps people coming back. On my first stop here, the aroma alone set the bar high, and the first bite delivered exactly what the scent promised: a classic New York-style slice, big on flavor and light on pretense.
This spot thrives on consistency and friendliness. If you’re new, you can’t go wrong with their pepperoni pizza. The slices are wide, the cheese melts just right, and the pepperoni gets those perfect crispy edges. The crust holds it all together—never too flimsy, always chewable.
Not feeling pepperoni? The veggie pie offers a bright, fresh take with just the right amount of char. Either way, Three Boys knows how to keep pizza lovers happy with simple, honest flavors.
3. Sophia’s Pizza
(914) 302-6201Call
Sophia’s Pizza sits across from the bustle of the Yorktown Green Shopping Center, yet inside feels calm and inviting. Stopping here one rainy afternoon, I was immediately drawn in by the sight of bubbling pies behind the counter. The first bite of their Sicilian slice—airy, crisp on the bottom, slightly sweet sauce—made it clear this place knows its dough.
What sets Sophia’s apart is the care put into each pie. The mozzarella is always fresh, and the veggies on the primavera pie tasted like someone had just picked them. If you’re unsure what to try, start with the grandma slice. Its rustic edges and balanced flavors show off Sophia’s knack for simple, honest pizza done right.
4. Maria’s Pizza
(914) 962-3583Call
At Maria’s Pizza, classic Italian comfort is the rule. Stepping in, it’s hard not to notice the aroma of slow-simmered sauce and dough fresh from the oven. The family-run feel is genuine—staff chat with regulars, and the space feels like an extension of someone’s kitchen.
Maria’s stands out with its balance of flavors and tradition. Their thin-crust pizza is a go-to: the dough is crisp without being brittle, and the sauce hints at fresh basil. The mozzarella is rich, never rubbery or bland. Margherita puts the quality front and center, but the quattro formaggi is a quiet star for cheese lovers.
If you’re after pizza that tastes like it’s made by hand, Maria’s delivers exactly that.
5. Yorktown Pizza & Pasta
Yorktown Pizza & Pasta manages to blend cozy vibes with a sprawling menu, perfect for both pizza traditionalists and the adventurous. Dropping by for a late lunch, I tried a slice of their “Grandma Pie” and immediately appreciated the homemade touch—crisp edges, tangy sauce, and stretchy, mild cheese.
The menu goes beyond the basics, offering everything from classic cheese to specialty pies, but it’s their fresh basil and perfectly seasoned tomato sauce that make each bite memorable. The Sicilian pizza, in particular, boasts a golden, thick base and straightforward flavors that don’t need any extras.
If you want something more than pizza, their garlic knots and penne alla vodka turn a quick meal into a proper Italian feast. It’s a spot that promises satisfaction, especially when you’re craving comfort in a slice.
6. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza at Underhill Plaza has built its reputation on speed and reliability. There’s something reassuring about knowing your go-to order will hit the spot every time. For those nights when I need comfort food fast, their thin crust pepperoni (no haram toppings, of course) arrives piping hot and ready to fold.
What makes Domino’s stand out is its variety and customizability. You can fine-tune your pizza down to the slightest detail—extra cheese, light sauce, or a crispy pan base. If you’re not in the mood for a traditional pie, give the “Handmade Pan” a try. The texture sits perfectly between crisp and fluffy.
Domino’s fits any schedule, whether it’s late, last minute, or just a cozy night in. It’s dependable pizza, dialed in for cravings of every kind.
7. Cfa Pizza Corp
(914) 214-8432Call
Cfa Pizza Corp might fly under the radar in Yorktown, but its approach is all about straightforward goodness. I stopped in after hearing about their generous slices and found a spot that doesn’t try to do too much—just pizza, done right. The menu is refreshingly simple, letting you focus on what matters: the crust and the cheese.
The freshness here really makes a difference. Their plain cheese slice is golden, cheesy, and has a slightly tangy sauce that’s easy to enjoy. For something a bit different, the veggie pie packs crisp peppers and onions, lending bright flavors with every bite.
If you’re the sort who enjoys an unfussy, classic pizza experience, Cfa Pizza Corp has the essentials covered, one slice at a time.
8. New York Pizza Company
New York Pizza Company, also known as Slice Pizzeria, feels like one of those neighborhood gems everyone claims as their own. On my last visit, a plain cheese slice hit every note—light, crisp base, not too thick, not too thin, with a sauce that tastes like it spent some serious time simmering.
The real charm is in their no-frills, wallet-friendly approach. With prices on the lower side, you never have to think twice about grabbing an extra slice. Try their veggie or mushroom pies if you want something a little brighter—their vegetables are always fresh and well-seasoned.
Whether you’re in for a quick lunch or late-night bite, New York Pizza Company delivers comfort by the slice, keeping things simple and satisfying in every order.
9. Calabria Pizza & Pasta
Calabria Pizza & Pasta in Shrub Oak knows how to create a pizza worth coming back for. Each visit has confirmed their reputation—whether you dine in or grab takeout, the slices never skimp on freshness. Their kitchen works with quality ingredients, and you can taste it in every bite.
Generous daily specials and friendly service add to the appeal. The plain cheese pie is a reliable standard, but the margherita pizza puts their skill front and center: fresh basil, rich tomato sauce, and a crisp, tender crust that stands out. Even better, the portions are hearty without feeling overwhelming.
If you’re planning to share, their grandma pizza and garlic knots make the meal feel festive. Calabria combines that classic neighborhood pizzeria spirit with a commitment to true flavor.
10. Don Tonnaso’s Beastro
Don Tonnaso’s Beastro lives up to its reputation as a spot where Italian classics meet a bit of flair. The atmosphere is just the right mix of casual and inviting, ideal for an unhurried meal. My visit started with a warm welcome and the suggestion to try their signature margherita—it was a wise choice.
Their pizzas excel because of the balanced flavors. Expect a crackly crust, a touch of char from the oven, and a sauce with genuine depth. The white pizza, topped with fresh mozzarella and garlic, is another standout—creamy, fragrant, and light all at once.
Don Tonnaso’s doesn’t overwhelm with choices, but focuses on doing a few things incredibly well. It’s pizza that lingers in your memory, slice after slice.
More Things to Try in Yorktown, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Yorktown, NY?
You’ll find classic New York-style thin crust, as well as Sicilian and grandma pies. Some spots even serve specialty and gluten-free options.
Are there good places for a sit-down pizza meal in Yorktown?
Absolutely. Many pizzerias like Nonna’s and Don Tonnaso’s Beastro offer welcoming dine-in spaces along with their takeout menus.
Which pizza place delivers in Yorktown?
Most local spots, including Domino’s, Calabria Pizza & Pasta, and Yorktown Pizza & Pasta, offer delivery. Check individual sites for their delivery zones and minimum orders.
Where can I find vegetarian pizza options?
Just about every pizzeria on the list serves vegetarian pies. Try the margherita, veggie, or white pizza at most places for a meat-free treat.
Is there anywhere to get pizza late at night in Yorktown?
Domino’s typically stays open later than the smaller, local pizzerias, making it a go-to if you find yourself hungry after hours.