There’s something incredibly special about finding the perfect slice of pizza – the kind that tantalizes your taste buds from the first bite and leaves you craving more. In York, PA, the quest for this perfect pizza is an adventure that takes you through a culinary landscape rich with tradition, innovation, and a deep love for this universally adored dish. From the thin, crispy crusts of classic Neapolitan pies to the hearty, cheese-laden varieties that make your mouth water just thinking about them, York offers a delightful array of pizzerias that cater to every pizza aficionado’s dream.
Having spent countless evenings exploring the vibrant streets of York, I’ve had the pleasure of indulging in some of the most exceptional pizzas this charming city has to offer. Each pizzeria has its own unique flair, whether it’s a secret family recipe passed down through generations or a modern twist that redefines what pizza can be. In this guide, I’ll take you on a journey to discover York’s best pizza spots, sharing insider tips and personal favorites that promise to make your pizza experience truly unforgettable.
Where to find the best pizza in York, PA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in York, PA:
- Mexitaly Brick Oven Brewhouse
- Marino’s Pizza & Pasta House
- MOD Pizza
- Pizza al Bacio
- Infinito’s Buffet
- Pizza By Alberto
- John’s Pizza Shop
- Primo Pizza Express
- Memory Lane Pizza LLC
- Marcello’s Pizza
1. Mexitaly Brick Oven Brewhouse
Nestled in the Outback Steak Center, Mexitaly Brick Oven Brewhouse combines the best of Italian and Mexican cuisines in a unique setting. With a focus on quality ingredients and generous portions, this pizzeria truly delivers. The vibrant atmosphere invites you to enjoy a pint of fresh craft beer alongside a delicious pizza.
What sets Mexitaly apart is their commitment to a scratch kitchen, ensuring each dish is made from the ground up. Their signature Mexitaly Pizza is a must-try, boasting a perfect balance of flavors with spicy chorizo and fresh peppers on a crispy crust. Pair it with their house salad for a delightful meal that’s both hearty and satisfying.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch or winding down for dinner, Mexitaly offers something special for everyone.
2. Marino’s Pizza & Pasta House
Located on E Market St, Marino’s Pizza & Pasta House is a local favorite renowned for its inviting atmosphere and delicious offerings. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Marino’s serves up classic dishes with a homemade touch that keeps guests coming back for more. The friendly service enhances the experience, making it feel like a true family affair.
What truly makes Marino’s stand out is their extensive menu that goes beyond just pizza. Their Margherita pizza is a standout—made with fresh basil, mozzarella, and a tangy tomato sauce, it captures the essence of Italian pizza perfection. Don’t miss their hearty pasta options, which complement the pizza selection beautifully, creating a well-rounded dining experience.
3. MOD Pizza
Located in the bustling West Manchester Mall parking lot, MOD Pizza offers a unique spin on the classic pizza experience. Here, creativity reigns supreme as each guest can build their own pizza or salad with a staggering selection of over 40 toppings. The atmosphere is vibrant and inviting, perfect for a casual meal or a quick bite.
What truly sets MOD apart is its commitment to personalization and quality. I had the pleasure of crafting a custom pizza loaded with fresh spinach, savory sausage, and a drizzle of balsamic glaze, all atop a perfectly crispy crust. The combination of flavors was as satisfying as it was unique.
With gluten-friendly and vegan options available, there’s something for everyone. Grab a slice of creativity with MOD’s limitless toppings and enjoy a pizza tailor-made just for you.
4. Pizza al Bacio
Situated on Ryan Run Rd, Pizza al Bacio is a cherished spot for pizza lovers in York. With a warm, welcoming vibe, it’s a great place to enjoy a hearty meal with family or friends. The menu is loaded with delicious options, making it a point to cater to various dietary preferences, including vegetarian and vegan choices.
What stands out at Pizza al Bacio is their dedication to fresh ingredients and authentic flavors. My experience there was delightful, especially when I tried their white pizza, topped with creamy ricotta and fresh garlic. Each bite was a perfect balance of richness and comfort.
For a satisfying meal, pair it with their garden salad for a refreshing crunch, making Pizza al Bacio a go-to for quality pizza in York.
5. Infinito’s Buffet
Located on S Queen St, Infinito’s Buffet offers an all-you-can-eat experience that’s a paradise for pizza enthusiasts. The casual, family-friendly atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a relaxed lunch or dinner with friends and family. The variety of food available ensures there’s something for everyone, from pizza to pasta and fresh salads.
Infinito’s stands out for its incredible selection of pizzas, all made fresh and constantly replenished. I enjoyed their Buffalo chicken pizza, which provided a spicy kick balanced by rich cheese. It was delectable and had me going back for second—and third—helpings.
With options to suit all tastes, including vegetarian choices, Infinito’s Buffet is a solid pick for those craving a hearty meal that’s both fun and filling.
6. Pizza By Alberto
Pizza By Alberto, located at 2736 S Queen St, York, PA, has been a culinary landmark since 1959. Known for its cozy, family-friendly atmosphere, it invites both locals and visitors to enjoy an authentic dining experience.
During my visit, the warmth of the staff and the authentic Italian aroma instantly made me feel at home. The menu is vegetarian-friendly and caters to both lunch and dinner, offering a range of options for everyone.
For a true taste of York, I recommend trying the classic Margherita pizza, which showcases their dedication to quality ingredients and traditional recipes. Each bite is a testament to their craft, making Pizza By Alberto a must-visit for pizza lovers.
7. John’s Pizza Shop
Located in the South York Plaza, John’s Pizza Shop is renowned for its friendly service and cozy environment. This inviting spot offers a reliable menu filled with delicious options for lunch or dinner, making it a go-to for families and friends alike.
What sets John’s apart is their commitment to quality and consistency. On my last visit, I savored their delectable pepperoni pizza, which featured generous slices of spicy pepperoni and a perfectly baked crust. Every bite was a satisfying mix of flavors and textures.
For a complete meal, consider pairing it with one of their hearty salads. John’s Pizza Shop excels in delivering comfort food that keeps diners coming back for more.
8. Primo Pizza Express
Located on N Sherman St, Primo Pizza Express is a quick-service gem known for its awesome pizza and friendly vibe. Perfect for a lunch break or a casual dinner, this spot combines speed with quality, ensuring you get exactly what you’re craving without the wait.
What makes Primo stand out is their dedication to fresh ingredients and classic recipes. On my recent visit, I tried their cheesesteak pizza, which impressed me with its rich flavor and generous toppings. Each slice was a delightful combination of savory steak, gooey cheese, and a well-balanced sauce.
Pair it with one of their delicious garlic knots for the perfect meal. Primo Pizza Express truly delivers on flavor and convenience.
9. Memory Lane Pizza LLC
At Memory Lane Pizza LLC, located at 162 Memory Lane, York, PA, nostalgia meets deliciousness in every bite. This charming pizzeria offers a cozy environment, perfect for enjoying a casual meal with family or friends. Whether you’re visiting for lunch or dinner, the welcoming atmosphere sets the stage for a delightful dining experience.
What really stands out at Memory Lane is the rich menu that showcases both Italian classics and creative pizza options. I was particularly impressed by their BBQ chicken pizza, featuring tender chicken, smoky sauce, and a blend of cheeses that created a perfect harmony of flavors.
With their commitment to quality ingredients and friendly service, Memory Lane Pizza is a spot you won’t want to miss when in York.
10. Marcello’s Pizza
Situated on Cinema Drive, Marcello’s Pizza is a beloved destination for pizza enthusiasts in York. With its inviting atmosphere, it’s an ideal spot for both lunch and dinner. Whether you’re dining in or opting for delivery, the service is prompt and friendly, making each visit enjoyable.
What makes Marcello’s stand out is their extensive menu featuring both classic and innovative pizza selections. During my last visit, I tried the meat lover’s pizza, piled high with toppings and boasting an unbeatable flavor combination. The crust was perfectly baked, providing the ideal base for the hearty toppings.
For a complete meal, consider pairing your pizza with their fresh garden salad. Marcello’s Pizza truly embodies the essence of great pizza in York.
More Things to Try in York, PA
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best pizza places in York, PA?
Some top contenders include Mexitaly Brick Oven Brewhouse, Marino’s Pizza & Pasta House, and Marcello’s Pizza. Each offers unique flavors and dining experiences, making them favorites among locals.
2. Can I find vegan pizza options in York, PA?
Yes, many pizzerias in York cater to vegan diets. Check out MOD Pizza or Infinito’s Buffet, both of which offer delicious vegan pizzas made with plant-based toppings.
3. What are common types of pizza styles available in York, PA?
In York, you’ll find a variety of styles, including classic New York-style, Neapolitan, and even creative fusion pizzas that blend different cuisines.
4. Do any pizza places offer gluten-free crusts in York, PA?
Yes, establishments like MOD Pizza and Pizza al Bacio offer gluten-friendly crust options, making it easier for those with dietary restrictions to enjoy pizza.
5. Where can I order pizza for delivery in York, PA?
Many local pizzerias, including John’s Pizza Shop and Primo Pizza Express, offer delivery services. Check their websites or call for delivery options and hours.
6. Are there any pizza places in York, PA, that offer buffet style?
Yes, Infinito’s Buffet provides an all-you-can-eat pizza and pasta experience, ideal for those who want to try multiple flavors in one visit.
7. What is the average price of pizza in York, PA?
Pricing varies, but most pizzerias offer pizzas ranging from $10 to $20, depending on size and toppings. Specialty and gourmet pizzas may be priced higher.
8. Can I find restaurants with outdoor seating for pizza in York, PA?
Some places, like Marcello’s Pizza, may offer outdoor seating during warmer months. It’s best to check with the restaurant directly about available options.