Finding the best pizza in Winston-Salem, NC, is an adventure worth taking. Over the years, I’ve explored numerous local spots, discovering that each offers a unique twist on a beloved classic. From crispy wood-fired pies to traditional Italian-style slices, the city’s pizza scene is as diverse as its neighborhoods. My personal favorites have consistently combined quality ingredients with authentic flavors, making each bite memorable.
This guide aims to steer pizza lovers toward those places that truly stand out. Whether you’re craving a quick slice or a sit-down meal with family, Winston-Salem’s pizza joints have something for everyone. Rest assured, the spots on this list are carefully selected based on quality, atmosphere, and genuine local acclaim. Prepare to indulge in some of the finest pizzas you’ll find in North Carolina.
Where to find the best pizza in Winston Salem, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Winston Salem, NC:
- Mellow Mushroom Winston-Salem
- Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar
- Mario’s Pizza
- Vinnie’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
- Cugino Forno Pizzeria Winston Salem
- Mission Pizza Napoletana
- Zito Pizzeria and Grill
- Elizabeth’s Pizza Italian Restaurant
- Elizabeth’s Italian Restaurant
- Mama MIA Italian Pizzaria
1. Mellow Mushroom Winston-Salem
Mellow Mushroom Winston-Salem offers a pizza experience that blends creativity with quality. Their stone-baked, hand-tossed pizzas have a signature spring water crust, providing a distinct flavor and crisp texture that sets them apart. Walking in, you’ll immediately notice the eclectic, art-filled atmosphere that adds a relaxed yet vibrant energy to every visit.
Personally, I appreciate how Mellow Mushroom balances fun with serious dedication to ingredients. Their commitment to fresh, high-quality toppings shines through in every slice. The Kosmic Karma pizza is a standout, featuring a flavorful sauce mix, mushroom medley, and fresh herbs that exemplify the restaurant’s unique Southern-style twist.
Vegetarian and vegan options add to the appeal, making it easy for everyone to find something delicious. If you want a reliable spot that offers more than just pizza, Mellow Mushroom’s creative menu and inviting space make it a must-visit in Winston-Salem.
2. Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar
+1 336-837-0664
Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar in Winston-Salem creates the perfect setting to gather over expertly made pizza. Their pizzas come straight out of a wood-fired oven, delivering a smoky flavor and crisp crust that immediately catches your attention. The atmosphere strikes a welcoming balance between casual and stylish, making it ideal for everything from family dinners to relaxed nights out.
What sets Brixx apart is their commitment to scratch-made ingredients and genuine hospitality. I recommend trying the Margherita pizza — its fresh basil, creamy mozzarella, and vibrant tomato sauce showcase the quality and simplicity baked into every pie. Vegan and gluten-free options ensure everyone can enjoy their meal without compromise.
Brixx also shines with its craft bar offerings and friendly service. It’s a spot where you don’t just eat pizza; you connect over a thoughtfully prepared meal that honors both tradition and innovation in Winston-Salem’s pizza scene.
3. Mario’s Pizza
Mario’s Pizza brings a taste of authentic New York-style pizza to Winston-Salem, crafted by brothers who grew up in Brooklyn. Their deep roots in Italian tradition shine through in every bite, making it easy to see why locals keep coming back. The thin, foldable crust with just the right amount of chew is a highlight that truly defines their style.
During my visits, I found the classic cheese slice hard to resist—it’s simple yet packed with fresh mozzarella and a rich tomato sauce that feels homemade. Beyond pizza, their Stromboli and calzones offer a savory twist, perfect for sharing or grabbing on the go.
Mario’s stands out with its family-owned charm and consistent quality. This spot is a solid choice when craving genuine New York flavors right in Winston-Salem.
4. Vinnie’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant
Vinnie’s Pizzeria & Italian Restaurant offers a warm, family-friendly atmosphere with a rich selection of classic Italian dishes. Located on Peters Creek Parkway, it’s a go-to spot for those seeking authentic pizza made with fresh ingredients. The restaurant’s consistent quality and attentive service make every visit enjoyable.
From my experience, the margherita pizza stands out for its perfectly crispy crust and vibrant tomato sauce, topped with fresh basil and mozzarella. Their Italian entrees and appetizers complement the pizza perfectly, creating a well-rounded dining experience.
Vinnie’s dedication to quality and classic flavors makes it a reliable choice for pizza lovers. Whether for lunch or dinner, it’s a place where tradition meets comfort in Winston-Salem.
5. Cugino Forno Pizzeria Winston Salem
Cugino Forno Pizzeria in Winston-Salem offers an authentic taste of Italy right in the heart of the city. Their signature style comes from using imported ingredients and cooking pizzas in a wood-burning oven with volcanic rock from Mount Vesuvius. The result is a perfectly blistered crust that cooks in just 90 seconds, delivering a fresh, flavorful experience every time.
During my visit, the Margherita pizza stood out for its delicate balance of fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and basil, a true testament to their commitment to traditional Italian techniques. The fast cooking time doesn’t compromise quality; each bite is crisp, light, and bursting with genuine flavor.
Cugino Forno is ideal for pizza lovers who value authenticity and speed without sacrificing taste. If you’re searching for the best pizza in Winston-Salem, this pizzeria’s dedication to Italian roots makes it a must-try.
6. Mission Pizza Napoletana
Mission Pizza Napoletana holds the distinction of being North Carolina’s first pizzeria dedicated to true Neapolitan-style pizza. Their focus on traditional wood-fired ovens delivers vibrant, airy crusts with slightly charred bubbles that speak to authentic technique. It’s no surprise they have earned a spot among America’s 101 Best Pizzas.
On my visit, the Margherita classica immediately caught my attention. Each ingredient—from the San Marzano tomato sauce to the fresh mozzarella di bufala—works in harmony, showcasing the care and precision behind every pie. The subtle smoky flavor from the wood fire adds depth without overpowering.
Mission Pizza Napoletana offers pizza in its purest form, honoring tradition and quality. For those craving genuine Neapolitan pizza in Winston-Salem, this spot is a destination worth visiting.
7. Zito Pizzeria and Grill
Zito Pizzeria and Grill in Winston-Salem welcomes guests with a menu full of classic and creative options. Their commitment to fresh ingredients and customizable pizzas makes every meal feel personal and satisfying. The casual yet inviting space is ideal for lunch or dinner with friends and family.
What impressed me most was their build-your-own pizza option, allowing you to craft a pie tailored to your taste, from the crust to a variety of fresh toppings. The crust strikes a fine balance between thin and chewy, perfectly supporting the rich sauces and cheeses.
With vegetarian and vegan selections, Zito ensures that all diners have plenty of choices. Their friendly service and consistent quality make it a reliable pick for those seeking great pizza in Winston-Salem.
8. Elizabeth’s Pizza Italian Restaurant
Elizabeth’s Pizza Italian Restaurant is a staple in Winston-Salem known for its comforting, classic Italian flavors. The warm, inviting atmosphere makes it a great spot for lunch or dinner, whether you’re in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely meal with family.
During my visit, the standout was their supreme pizza, loaded with fresh toppings and perfectly melted cheese atop a crispy, well-balanced crust. The sauce offers a delightful tang, which complements the rich toppings without overwhelming them.
Elizabeth’s dedication to quality ingredients and traditional recipes shines through in every dish. Beyond pizza, their menu offers hearty Italian favorites, ensuring a satisfying meal. If you want reliable, flavorful pizza in Winston-Salem, Elizabeth’s is a trusted choice.
9. Elizabeth’s Italian Restaurant
Elizabeth’s Italian Restaurant on University Parkway offers authentic Italian flavors in a cozy, welcoming setting. Their menu features a variety of classic dishes, but the pizza consistently draws enthusiastic reviews for its fresh ingredients and perfectly baked crust.
During my visit, the Four Cheese pizza caught my eye. It balances mozzarella, parmesan, provolone, and ricotta, creating a rich, creamy taste that pairs beautifully with their homemade tomato sauce. The crust is thin yet sturdy, holding the toppings without losing its crispness.
What makes Elizabeth’s stand out is its dedication to traditional recipes and fresh, quality ingredients. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, this restaurant offers a dependable and flavorful pizza experience in Winston-Salem.
10. Mama MIA Italian Pizzaria
Mama MIA Italian Pizzaria offers a charming and authentic Italian pizza experience in Winston-Salem. Known for its friendly service and cozy atmosphere, it’s a favorite among locals looking for traditional flavors made with fresh ingredients. The hand-tossed crust is a highlight, striking the perfect balance between soft and crispy.
During my visit, the Veggie Deluxe pizza impressed me with its vibrant mix of fresh vegetables and gooey cheese, exploding with flavor in every bite. The sauce has a bright, zesty profile that complements the toppings beautifully, making the pizza both satisfying and refreshing.
Mama MIA’s focus on quality ingredients and straightforward Italian recipes makes it a standout choice. Whether for takeout or a relaxed dinner, it delivers a genuine slice of Italy right in Winston-Salem.
More Things to Try in Winston Salem, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I find the best pizza in Winston-Salem, NC?
A: Winston-Salem boasts a variety of pizza spots, but places like Mellow Mushroom, Cugino Forno, and Mission Pizza Napoletana are widely praised for their fresh ingredients and authentic styles.
Q: Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Winston-Salem?
A: Yes, many local pizzerias such as Brixx Wood Fired Pizza and Zito Pizzeria and Grill offer vegetarian and vegan-friendly options, ensuring everyone enjoys a great meal.
Q: Which pizzas are signature dishes in Winston-Salem?
A: Classic pies like the Margherita at Mission Pizza Napoletana and the Kosmic Karma at Mellow Mushroom highlight unique local takes on traditional recipes.
Q: Do any Winston-Salem pizzerias offer gluten-free pizza?
A: Yes, several places including Mellow Mushroom and Brixx Wood Fired Pizza provide gluten-free crusts to accommodate dietary requirements.
Q: Can I order pizza for takeout or delivery in Winston-Salem?
A: Absolutely. Restaurants such as Mario’s Pizza and Elizabeth’s Italian Restaurant offer convenient takeout and delivery services for quick and easy meals.
Q: What makes Winston-Salem pizza unique compared to other cities?
A: The city’s pizza scene combines authentic Italian techniques with Southern influences, offering a diverse range of flavors and styles using quality local and imported ingredients.