Imagine a place where the aroma of freshly baked pizza crust mingles with the salty sea breeze of the Atlantic. Wilmington, NC, with its vibrant coastal charm, is home to some of the most mouthwatering pizza joints you’ll ever come across. Whether you’re a local or a visitor, the quest for the perfect slice in this city is a journey worth embarking on. From traditional Margherita to inventive gourmet creations, Wilmington’s pizza scene offers something to tantalize every palate.
My own adventure began on a balmy summer evening. Strolling through the historic downtown, I stumbled upon a cozy pizzeria that promised an authentic experience. The first bite of their wood-fired pizza, with its crispy crust, gooey cheese, and fresh, flavorful toppings, was a revelation. It was then I knew I had to explore more. Join me as I guide you through the best spots in Wilmington, where culinary craftsmanship and local flair converge to create unforgettable pizza experiences.
Where to find the best pizza in Wilmington, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Wilmington, NC:
- Italian Bistro
- Benny’s Big Time Pizzeria
- Fat Tony’s Italian Pub
- Slice of Life
- I Love NY Pizza
- Osteria Cicchetti
- Jax 5th Ave Deli & Ale House
- Mellow Mushroom Wilmington
- Agostino’s Pizza & Pasta, Inc.
- Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar
1. Italian Bistro
Tucked away on Market Street, Italian Bistro delivers a slice of Italy with a Wilmington twist. The moment you step inside, the warm lighting and rustic décor set the tone for a relaxed, satisfying meal. It’s the kind of place where locals linger over dinner and newcomers quickly feel at home.
What sets Italian Bistro apart is its commitment to fresh, locally sourced ingredients and a menu that balances comfort with craft. Their pizza crust is thin, crisp, and just chewy enough to hold up under generous toppings. I tried the Margherita on a whim—simple, but executed with precision. The basil was bright, the mozzarella creamy, and the sauce had that slow-simmered depth you can’t fake.
If you’re unsure what to order, go for the House Special Pizza. It’s a well-balanced mix of vegetables and cheese that showcases their attention to flavor without overwhelming the palate. Pair it with a side of their garlic knots and you’ve got a meal that’s both indulgent and grounded in quality.
Whether it’s a casual lunch or a quiet dinner, Italian Bistro proves that great pizza doesn’t need to shout—it just needs to be made right.
2. Benny’s Big Time Pizzeria
Benny’s Big Time Pizzeria in Wilmington, NC, is a vibrant spot that brings the joy of Italian cuisine to the Southern coast. Located at 206 Greenfield St, this pizzeria offers a lively atmosphere perfect for family gatherings or a night out with friends. Their wood-fired pizzas, ravioli, and bucatini are crafted to perfection, making it a must-visit for Italian food lovers.
During my visit, the Margherita Pizza stood out with its fresh basil, rich tomato sauce, and creamy mozzarella, all baked to a crisp in their wood-fired oven. The Vegetarian Pizza was another highlight, offering a delightful mix of seasonal vegetables that showcased their commitment to vegetarian-friendly options.
What sets Benny’s Big Time Pizzeria apart is their dedication to happiness through food. The gluten-free options and vegan-friendly dishes ensure that everyone can enjoy a meal here. For an authentic taste of their style, I highly recommend trying the Spiedini, a unique Italian skewer that’s both flavorful and fun to eat.
Whether you’re a local or a traveler, Benny’s Big Time Pizzeria is a fantastic spot to indulge in Italian cuisine with a Southern twist. Visit their website at www.vivianhoward.com/bennysbigtime/ or call +1 910-550-2525 for more information.
3. Fat Tony’s Italian Pub
Fat Tony’s Italian Pub delivers casual dining with an edge, nestled right in downtown Wilmington. Its blend of comfort food, lively ambiance, and two patios—one with a view of the Cape Fear River—makes it hard to beat for lunch, dinner, or late-night cravings. The vibe is relaxed, but the food is serious business.
What drew me in was their vegetarian-friendly pizza menu, which doesn’t cut corners. The crust is hand-tossed, baked crisp, and carries just the right chew. I went for their Garden Veggie Pizza, piled high with fresh produce and balanced with melted mozzarella. It was light, satisfying, and full of flavor.
They also offer gluten-free and vegan options, making Fat Tony’s a go-to for varied dietary preferences. If you want to mix it up, pair a slice with a side of seasoned fries or a fresh salad—they nail the details without overcomplicating things.
Whether you’re catching the sunset from the patio or grabbing a bite after a show, Fat Tony’s Italian Pub delivers hearty Italian-inspired fare that’s built for repeat visits.
4. Slice of Life
Tucked into downtown Wilmington, Slice of Life offers more than just late-night curb appeal. It’s where locals and night owls converge over slices that manage to be both unfussy and unexpectedly bold. The wood-paneled booths and quick-moving staff keep things casual, but the pies are anything but forgettable.
What sets it apart? Consistency and character. The crust walks the fine line between chewy and crisp, and the toppings never feel skimpy. It’s the kind of place where your first visit turns into a tradition.
Order the White Pizza for something rich but balanced. The Veggie Supreme hits every texture, while the gluten-free option isn’t just an afterthought—it’s thoughtfully crafted. Slice of Life doesn’t try too hard. It simply delivers.
5. I Love NY Pizza
Nestled on North Front Street, I Love NY Pizza brings a slice of New York’s classic style to Wilmington. Its compact, no-frills setting is perfect for a quick, satisfying meal. The focus here is on delivering authentic New York-style pizza with a crispy crust and generous toppings.
During a late-night visit, I ordered their Cheese Slice—it was everything a New Yorker would love: crispy edges, gooey cheese, and a well-balanced sauce. The pizza’s quality and flavor instantly transported me to the city that never sleeps.
If you’re craving a familiar, comforting bite, go for the Meat Lovers’ Pizza. It’s loaded with toppings, flavorful, and crafted for those who want a hearty, satisfying meal. I Love NY Pizza captures the essence of New York’s pizza scene with every slice.
6. Osteria Cicchetti
Located on Military Cutoff Road, Osteria Cicchetti offers a sophisticated take on Italian cuisine in Wilmington. Its inviting atmosphere and attentive service create a perfect setting for both lunch and dinner. The restaurant’s focus on fresh, high-quality ingredients shines through in every dish.
During my visit, I was captivated by their Neapolitan-style Margherita Pizza. The thin, slightly charred crust paired with fresh basil and mozzarella epitomized authentic Italian craftsmanship. It’s clear they prioritize tradition and flavor.
They also excel in accommodating dietary preferences like vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. For a true taste of their style, try the prosciutto Piccolo pizza—layered with cured meats and a perfectly crisp base that highlights their culinary authenticity and attention to detail.
7. Jax 5th Ave Deli & Ale House
Jax 5th Ave Deli & Ale House is a vibrant spot in Wilmington, NC, combining the charm of a local deli with the energy of a craft beer pub. Known for its Boar’s Head meats and cheeses, the menu offers fresh, high-quality ingredients that elevate every dish. With 24 beers on tap and 22 TVs, it’s an ideal destination for food lovers and sports enthusiasts alike. The outdoor seating provides a cozy atmosphere, perfect for enjoying Wilmington’s mild evenings.
What truly sets Jax apart is their unique pita bread pizzas, crafted using handmade pita shipped exclusively to the deli. These pizzas are a must-try! The crust is light, crispy, and perfectly complements the flavorful toppings. The Mediterranean Pizza is a standout, loaded with fresh veggies, feta cheese, and a zesty sauce. Pair it with a local craft beer for the ultimate experience.
This deli also caters to diverse preferences with its vegetarian-friendly options and warm, welcoming vibe. Whether you’re stopping in for a casual lunch, a late-night bite, or a weekend brunch, Jax delivers with quality and consistency. You’ll leave satisfied, already planning your next visit.
For a taste of Wilmington’s finest, Jax 5th Ave Deli & Ale House is the place to be. Don’t miss their pita pizzas—they’re truly one of a kind!
8. Mellow Mushroom Wilmington
Mellow Mushroom Wilmington offers a vibrant, art-filled atmosphere that makes every meal memorable. Located on Oleander Drive, this locally owned pizzeria combines creative décor with a menu that emphasizes quality ingredients and unique flavors. Its family-friendly environment makes it perfect for casual outings or relaxed dinners.
My visit was enhanced by their stone-baked, hand-tossed pizzas. The Spring Water Crust provides a distinctive, flavorful base that elevates every bite. I recommend the Mellow Pepperoni, topped with fresh ingredients and perfectly crispy edges.
They also cater to dietary preferences with vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options. Each pizza reflects their commitment to high-quality, locally sourced ingredients. Mellow Mushroom is more than just pizza—it’s a creative culinary experience in Wilmington.
9. Agostino’s Pizza & Pasta, Inc.
Agostino’s Pizza & Pasta, Inc. on New Centre Drive offers a warm, welcoming atmosphere perfect for family dinners or quick bites. Their menu focuses on classic Italian dishes made with fresh ingredients, ensuring every dish is flavorful and satisfying.
During my visit, I tried their Margherita Pizza. The crust was perfectly baked, with a light, crispy finish, topped with fresh basil, mozzarella, and rich tomato sauce. It truly reflected their commitment to quality and authentic Italian flavors.
They also provide vegan and vegetarian options, along with reliable delivery and takeout services. For an authentic taste and a memorable meal, Agostino’s delivers quality and tradition in every bite.
10. Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar
+1 910-256-9677
Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar on Main Street blends casual charm with careful craftsmanship. The scent of smoky crust hits you the moment you walk in, and their open kitchen lets you watch the pizzas crisp up in the wood-fired oven—comforting and precise in equal measure.
What sets Brixx apart is its focus on scratch-made dough and thoughtfully sourced ingredients. The space invites gatherings, but the food holds your attention. During my visit, I went for the Wild Mushroom pizza. The earthy flavor of roasted mushrooms paired with creamy mozzarella and a drizzle of arugula pesto offered the right balance of richness and freshness.
With vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free options woven seamlessly into the menu, Brixx is inclusive without being overdone. It’s the kind of place where wood-fired simplicity meets flavor-forward thoughtfulness.
More Things to Try in Wilmington, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the best pizza place in Wilmington, NC?
That depends on your taste. For wood-fired flavor, try Brixx Wood Fired Pizza + Craft Bar. If you’re after classic New York-style slices, I Love NY Pizza and Brooklyn Pizza Co. are local favorites. For something more upscale, Benny’s Big Time Pizzeria offers chef-driven pies with seasonal ingredients.
2. Are there any halal or pork-free pizza options in Wilmington?
While most pizzerias offer vegetarian options, halal-specific menus are limited. Your best bet is to call ahead and ask about customizable pizzas with no pork or alcohol-based ingredients. Many places like Your Pie and Brixx allow you to build your own pizza from scratch.
3. Where can I find gluten-free or vegan pizza in Wilmington?
Brixx, Mellow Mushroom, and Your Pie all offer gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese. These spots are known for accommodating dietary needs without compromising flavor.
4. What’s the best pizza for late-night cravings?
Slice of Life is a go-to for night owls. With multiple locations and a menu that includes pizza, wings, and more, it’s a reliable stop after hours.
5. Are there any local pizza spots with outdoor seating?
Yes. Fat Tony’s Italian Pub has a patio with river views, and Mellow Mushroom offers a laid-back outdoor dining area. Both are great for casual meals with a breeze.
6. Can I get pizza delivered in Wilmington?
Absolutely. Most places, including Michaelangelo’s, Papa Murphy’s, and Agostino’s, offer delivery through apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats. Some even have their own delivery services.
7. What’s a good pizza place for families?
Italian Bistro and Stella’s Pizza & Grille are both family-friendly with spacious seating and kid-approved menus. They’re relaxed, welcoming, and consistent.
8. Are there any pizza buffets in Wilmington?
Yes, Cicis Pizza offers a budget-friendly buffet with a rotating selection of pizzas, pasta, and salad. It’s casual and ideal for groups.
9. Where can I find authentic Italian-style pizza?
Osteria Cicchetti and Pizzeria Don Luca lean into traditional Italian flavors, with thin crusts, fresh herbs, and simple toppings that let the ingredients shine.
10. What’s the most unique pizza spot in Wilmington?
Girls With Dough stands out for its creative toppings and rotating seasonal specials. It’s a smaller operation, but the attention to detail is big.