When you find yourself in White Oak, PA, one thing is clear: pizza rules the dining scene. Some hunt down gooey cheese, others look for that perfumed edge of char on a stone-baked crust. Curious stomachs and loyal locals bounce from neon-lit storefronts to cozy family kitchens, hoping to find a new favorite. Each place has its own take—some stretching mozzarella to gravity-defying lengths, some hand-tossing dough with a showman’s flair.
After tasting my way through the area, I discovered this: White Oak’s pizza isn’t just satisfying—it’s personal. A regular’s favorite pie might be a newcomer’s bold experiment. One rainy evening, lost in a booth, I watched a parade of platters bearing everything from classic cheese to inventive veggie combos. That’s when it hit me: hunting for the best pizza isn’t about the fanciest sauce or the biggest slice. It’s about how each spot brings a little something extra to the table. If you want to know where to dig in, I’ve got you covered—with stories and slices to spare.
1. Pizza Bianca
(412) 673-1856Call
If there’s a spot locals whisper about, it’s Pizza Bianca on Lincoln Way. The first time I walked in, the aroma turned me from “just browsing” into a regular. This is a place where pizza gets treated with a craftsman’s touch.
Pizza Bianca’s secret sits in the dough—light, airy in the middle, and crisp on the edges. Toppings always taste fresh, never too heavy. Their classic cheese pizza wins hearts for its balance, but I can’t resist a slice of their white pizza, garlicky and never oily.
Go with their Bianca Special. It’s loaded, but somehow never overwhelming, letting each ingredient shine. You’ll get why so many chase this slice in White Oak.
2. Fox’s Pizza Den
(412) 678-1445Call
Fox’s Pizza Den sits right on Lincoln Way, and you’ll know you’re close when that homestyle scent hits you from the parking lot. This isn’t some run-of-the-mill chain spot. There’s a local warmth that stretches from the counter to the last bite of your slice.
What makes Fox’s stand out is its generous toppings and old-school dough. Everything here feels like it’s built for sharing—think loaded pies with golden crusts. I’ve stopped in with friends after a game and the place is always buzzing but never too crowded.
Their Big Daddy pizza is a legend: enormous, always fresh, and meant for groups. Try the Veggie pizza if you want to appreciate their produce game. For classic pizza night, Fox’s covers every base.
3. Lucianos Restaurant
Lucianos Restaurant sits right on Long Run Road, giving off that old-school Italian kitchen feel the second you walk in. It’s the kind of place where the staff remembers your name and regulars talk about the crust with pride. With a generous parking lot and easy wheelchair access, comfort and good food come together here.
The pizza at Lucianos has a distinct touch—thin, crackly crusts topped with stretchy cheese and just enough sauce. On my last visit, the Margherita pizza stole the show. Fresh basil and ripe tomatoes added a pop of color and flavor you don’t always find elsewhere.
If you’re hungry, try their Sicilian pizza. It’s square, airy, and feeds a crowd without ever getting soggy. Ask for the white pizza if you want something a little different but just as crave-worthy.
4. City Pizza & Pasta
(412) 672-2489Call
Right along Lincoln Way, City Pizza & Pasta keeps things straightforward. It’s not fancy, but the menu hits exactly where cravings strike. The first thing I noticed was how fast the service is, without ever feeling rushed. This is a favorite for grabbing pizza on those busy, no-fuss nights.
Their style sets them apart—classic, round pies with chewy crusts and rich tomato sauce that hits the tangy-sweet spot. I’ve often stopped in after work, and the pepperoni pizza always gets my order. Every slice is loaded and never stingy on cheese.
If you’re in the mood for variety, go for their veggie pizza. The fresh-cut toppings are stacked high, making it one of the best value pies in White Oak. City Pizza & Pasta turns a simple dinner into reliable comfort every time.
5. Palmer’s Pizza
Palmer’s Pizza anchors the Oak Park Mall, and its laid-back vibe makes it the kind of spot where you linger over a second slice. The staff here greet you with real enthusiasm, and I’ve even seen them remember the favorite orders of regulars.
What grabs you first is Palmer’s crust—light but sturdy enough to stand up to a hearty helping of cheese and sauce. This place does classics right, but it also has a few tricks up its sleeve. The Palmer’s Deluxe pizza is my go-to. Every topping stays fresh and balanced, nothing feels lost in the shuffle.
If you want something unique, check out their spinach and ricotta pizza. It’s rich, savory, and always manages to win over even die-hard pepperoni fans.
6. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Long Run Road is the spot for anyone wanting that familiar crunch and stretch you can only get from a pan pizza. Walking through the door always triggers a little nostalgia—those red cups, cozy booths, and the buzz of families digging in. Even during busy hours, carryout and delivery are reliable and quick.
This is where classic American-style pizza takes center stage. The Original Stuffed Crust is a winner for cheese lovers. Every slice gives you that gooey pull that somehow never gets old. The Veggie Lover’s pizza, loaded with bell peppers and mushrooms, is a dependable favorite for something lighter but still hearty.
For a real crowd-pleaser, the Meat Lovers (minus any haram toppings, of course) always draws a tableful of smiles. Pizza Hut’s style is comfort food at its easiest, and sometimes, that’s exactly what you want.
7. Little Caesars Pizza
Little Caesars Pizza on Lincoln Way is all about speed, value, and consistency. If you’ve ever run in for a Hot-N-Ready after a late day, you know the drill: fresh pizza, no wait, and a price that barely dents your wallet. You’ll spot families and college students alike snatching up boxes for game night or a quick dinner fix.
This spot delivers with a crust that’s always tender in the middle and crisp along the edges. Their classic cheese pizza is dependable, but the real secret is the Detroit-style deep dish. Each corner gets that caramelized cheese finish everyone craves.
For the best value, try their ExtraMostBestest pizza. It’s a mouthful of melty cheese and savory sauce—perfect for when you want that satisfying pizza experience without spending big.
8. Fellini’s Pizzeria
Fellini’s Pizzeria on Lincoln Way is the kind of neighborhood spot you stumble into once and remember for years. The vibe is relaxed, but the pizza means business—thin, bubbly crusts and sauce with a subtle herbal kick. Service is friendly and laid-back, making every meal feel unrushed.
I grabbed a table on a rainy night, and the aroma alone made the decision easy. Their Spinach Pizza stands out with just the right blend of greens and cheese—nothing soggy, every bite fresh. The place gets bonus points for their generous topping options and consistent quality.
The White Pizza is a local favorite, brushed with garlic and topped with ricotta. It captures what Fellini’s does best: simple, memorable pizza done right every time.
9. Veltre’s Pizza & Sandwiches
Veltre’s Pizza & Sandwiches on State Street brings a satisfying mix of nostalgia and steady quality. I dropped by with friends one Friday, and what hit me was how the place never skimps on ingredients. You get that unmistakable aroma of baking dough the moment you walk in.
Veltre’s is all about generous cheese, well-cooked toppings, and a crust with just the right chew. Their signature pizza is loaded with flavor and can easily serve a crowd. It’s the sort of pie you look forward to after a long week.
The Deluxe pizza comes heavily recommended. Loaded with fresh veggies and savory bits, it brings out everything Veltre’s does best—hearty, balanced, and never greasy.
10. Mama Pepino’s Pizza
Mama Pepino’s Pizza on Oneil Blvd gives you that hometown feel the moment you walk through the door. The setting is unpretentious, focusing all the attention on their pizza—always made with quality cheese and a chewy, airy crust. Locals swear it’s the place for a low-key, satisfying dinner.
On my last visit, I couldn’t resist snagging a slice of their Traditional pizza. The sauce here has that perfect hint of herbs, not too sweet, not too tangy. The cheese is always bubbling and never skimpy.
Be sure to try their Sicilian pizza. Square, thick, and served piping hot, it’s the dish that keeps regulars coming back. Mama Pepino’s has built a loyal following, and it’s easy to see why after one bite.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in White Oak, PA?
Some top picks include Pizza Bianca, Lucianos Restaurant, Veltre’s Pizza & Sandwiches, and Fellini’s Pizzeria. Each spot offers its own take—from classic pies to unique specialties.
Are there any locally owned pizza shops in White Oak?
Yes. Places like Pizza Bianca, Palmer’s Pizza, and City Pizza & Pasta are locally run and have built reputations with their original recipes and community spirit.
Who has the best Sicilian pizza in White Oak, PA?
Mama Pepino’s and Lucianos Restaurant are often recommended for their thick, square Sicilian pies. Both manage to keep the crust light and the toppings generous.
Which pizza spots offer fast delivery or takeout?
Pizza Hut, Domino’s, and Little Caesars are known for quick turnaround and online ordering, while many local favorites like Fox’s Pizza Den also offer speedy takeout.
Are there pizza places with vegetarian options?
Definitely. Most pizzerias, including Fellini’s and City Pizza & Pasta, serve a variety of veggie pizzas loaded with fresh, flavorful toppings.
Can I find halal or vegetarian-friendly pizza in White Oak?
While explicitly halal pizza is rare, many places offer vegetarian pies and will make pizzas without any haram items if you ask when ordering.
Where can I get a slice late at night?
Chain spots like Domino’s and Pizza Hut usually offer the latest hours, especially for delivery. Double-check online or call ahead for current hours at each location.
Which White Oak pizza shop is the most affordable?
Little Caesars is tough to beat for value, with their Hot-N-Ready deals. City Pizza & Pasta is also known for wallet-friendly pricing without skimping on quality.