When it comes to pizza, Wheeling, West Virginia offers a surprisingly diverse array of options. Having explored many local favorites over the years, I can confidently say that the city’s pizza scene is both vibrant and satisfying. From traditional toppings to creative twists, every pizzeria brings its own unique flavor to the table. Whether you’re craving a classic slice or something more inventive, Wheeling has something to satisfy every pizza enthusiast.
What sets the best spots apart is not just their toppings, but the quality of ingredients, the passion behind the craft, and the welcoming atmosphere. This guide aims to uncover not only the most popular picks but also some hidden gems that deserve your attention. Prepare to discover Wheeling’s top pizza destinations, each promising a slice worth savoring.
Where to find the best pizza in Wheeling, WV
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Wheeling, WV:
- DiCarlos Pizza
- Dicarlos Pizza Shop
- Domino’s Pizza
- Defelice Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Momma Rsas Fabulous Pizza Ribs
- Original Dicarlo’s Pizza-WHLNG
- Di Carlo Pizza
- Hunt Brothers Pizza
1. DiCarlos Pizza
(304) 233-0730Call
Nestled at 1311 Main Street in Wheeling, DiCarlos Pizza is a local favorite known for its authentic Italian flavors. Having visited several times, I’ve always appreciated their consistent quality and warm atmosphere. Their menu showcases a blend of Italian, European, and Continental cuisines, but their pizza remains the star.
What makes DiCarlos stand out is their commitment to fresh ingredients and traditional recipes. The classic Margherita pizza offers a perfect balance of crispy crust, rich tomato sauce, and fresh basil—reflecting their Italian roots. For a hearty option, the Meat Lover’s pizza is a satisfying choice. Each slice exemplifies the restaurant’s dedication to flavor and craftsmanship.
2. Dicarlos Pizza Shop
Located at 2099 National Road, Dicarlos Pizza Shop is a beloved spot for traditional pizza lovers in Wheeling. During my visits, I’ve appreciated their straightforward approach—cash only, but rich in flavor. The cozy, accessible setting makes it a perfect stop for a quick, satisfying meal.
Dicarlos stands out with its focus on classic, no-frills quality. Their cheese pizza is reliably delicious, with a crispy crust and gooey cheese. For something more hearty, try the pepperoni pizza; it’s baked to perfection with plenty of toppings and bold flavor. This simple yet flavorful style keeps customers coming back.
3. Domino’s Pizza
Located at 77 Bridge Street Plaza, Domino’s Pizza in Wheeling offers a reliable experience for pizza enthusiasts. From my visits, I’ve always appreciated their quick service and consistent flavor, whether I opt for takeout or delivery. Their wide menu ensures there’s something for everyone, from pizza lovers to those craving a hearty salad or wings.
What sets Domino’s apart is their versatility and quality. The thin New York Style pizza is perfect for a quick bite, while their Handmade Pan pizza offers a thicker, more indulgent option. I recommend trying the Cheesy Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza—it’s a flavorful twist that captures their commitment to satisfying cravings with bold, fresh ingredients.
4. Defelice Pizza
Located at 1000 National Road, Defelice Pizza is a trusted choice for those seeking authentic Italian flavors in Wheeling. From personal visits, I can attest to their friendly service and the inviting aroma that greets you upon arrival. Their menu combines classic Italian dishes with a focus on quality ingredients.
What makes Defelice Pizza stand out is their attention to traditional methods and fresh toppings. The Margherita pizza features a perfectly crispy crust, fresh basil, and a rich tomato sauce—exemplifying their commitment to authenticity. For a more indulgent option, the Meat Lovers pizza packs plenty of toppings on a well-baked crust, demonstrating their dedication to flavor and consistency.
5. Pizza Hut
At 2345 National Road, Pizza Hut continues its tradition of delivering familiar comfort in Wheeling. Having ordered from here multiple times, I appreciate their wide variety of options and the convenience of online ordering for carryout or delivery. Their signature dishes live up to the brand’s reputation for consistency and flavor.
What makes Pizza Hut stand out is their signature Original Stuffed Crust pizza, which offers a cheesy edge that’s hard to beat. For a classic touch, the Meat Lovers pizza is a hearty choice. Pair it with their signature wings for a full, satisfying meal rooted in the brand’s promise of quality and flavor.
6. Papa Johns Pizza
Located at 949 National Road, Papa Johns Pizza in Wheeling emphasizes quality with its motto of “Better Ingredients. Better Pizza.” From my experiences, I appreciate their focus on fresh, high-quality toppings and their signature sauce that enhances every slice. Whether I visit for carryout or delivery, the consistent flavor keeps me coming back.
What makes Papa Johns stand out is their commitment to using fresh dough and ingredients in every pizza. Their Classic Pepperoni pizza is a reliable favorite, showcasing their simple yet flavorful approach. Pair it with their seasoned breadsticks for a complete, satisfying meal rooted in quality and taste.
7. Momma Rsas Fabulous Pizza Ribs
(304) 232-0182Call
Located at 85 33rd Street, Momma Rsas Fabulous Pizza Ribs is a local spot that I’ve enjoyed exploring. Their dedication to quality ingredients and flavorful recipes makes each visit memorable. Although they are known for ribs, their pizza offers a delicious twist on classic flavors.
What makes Momma Rsas stand out is their unique menu that pairs mouthwatering ribs with tasty pizza options. The Cheese Pizza is a simple yet satisfying choice, demonstrating their commitment to fresh, quality ingredients. For a more hearty option, try their Meat Lover’s Pizza, which showcases bold flavors and generous toppings, reflecting their house-made style.
8. Original Dicarlo’s Pizza-WHLNG
Located at 1311 Main Street, Original Dicarlo’s Pizza-WHLNG is a cornerstone of Wheeling’s pizza scene. Having enjoyed a meal there, I can attest to their consistent quality and inviting atmosphere. Their menu blends traditional Italian flavors with a hometown touch, making every bite memorable.
What sets Original Dicarlo’s apart is their commitment to authentic recipes and fresh ingredients. The Classic Cheese Pizza offers a crispy crust, rich sauce, and gooey cheese, embodying their dedication to traditional style. For something more savory, the Veggie Supreme showcases fresh vegetables atop a perfectly baked crust, highlighting their attention to flavor and quality.
9. Di Carlo Pizza
(304) 232-9219Call
Located at 1272 Main Street, Di Carlo Pizza is a staple for pizza lovers in Wheeling. From my visits, I’ve appreciated their quick service and no-nonsense approach to delivering quality food. It’s a perfect place for a satisfying takeout meal when craving authentic pizza.
What makes Di Carlo Pizza stand out is their focus on simple, flavorful ingredients. The Cheese Pizza highlights their fresh dough and rich tomato sauce, providing a classic taste. For a hearty option, the Pepperoni Pizza is always a reliable choice that showcases their commitment to quality and tradition.
10. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Located at 151 16th Street, Hunt Brothers Pizza offers a convenient and flexible pizza experience in Wheeling. Having ordered from them a few times, I’ve found their customizable slices and reliable delivery make them a go-to choice for quick, satisfying meals. Their focus on affordability and variety appeals to many local customers.
What makes Hunt Brothers Pizza stand out is their ability to serve fresh, made-to-order slices that reflect consistency and quality. The Pepperoni and Cheese slices are always dependable and flavorful, displaying their commitment to satisfying simple cravings. For those who want variety, their assortment of toppings ensures everyone finds something they enjoy.
More Things to Try in Wheeling, WV
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Wheeling, WV? Some top options include DiCarlos Pizza, Original Dicarlo’s, Pizza Hut, and Papa Johns. Each offers unique styles, from traditional Italian to classic fast-food pizzas.
Are there any local or family-owned pizza spots in Wheeling? Yes, spots like Momma Rsas Fabulous Pizza Ribs and Defelice Pizza are locally loved for their authentic flavors and friendly service.
Do Wheeling pizzerias offer takeout or delivery? Most places, including Domino’s and Papa Johns, provide convenient carryout and delivery options to suit busy schedules.
Are there gluten-free or vegetarian pizza options available in Wheeling? Many pizzerias, like Vocelli Pizza and Domino’s, offer vegetarian and gluten-free choices for dietary preferences.