Finding the best pizza in Umatilla, FL is a lot like stumbling across a hidden gem on a familiar road—you never forget the first bite that makes you rethink all your previous pizza standards. My search for the perfect slice took me from crowded plazas to quiet storefronts, where bubbling cheese and golden crust were sometimes outdone by a single bite of well-seasoned sauce. Each spot has its own story woven into the dough, and I’ve sampled enough slices to separate the average from the unforgettable.
Whether your cravings lean toward classic pepperoni or something with a little more flair, you’ll find honest reviews here to steer your next pizza night. This isn’t just a list—it’s a map for your taste buds, with options for dine-in, carryout, or simply grabbing a quick bite after a long day. Keep your appetite ready. The best pies in Umatilla are coming up, and you just might find your new favorite spot.
1. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on N Central Ave stands as a familiar favorite in Umatilla. Walk inside and you’re met with the comforting aroma of fresh dough and bubbling cheese. I’ve found their original stuffed crust transforms a standard pizza night into something memorable. When I’m in the mood for something hearty, their Meat Lovers® pizza hits all the right notes—generous toppings, a soft, yet crisp crust, and a rich tomato sauce that keeps you reaching for another slice.
For an easy meal, their classic pepperoni is always reliable, delivering that signature Pizza Hut flavor you crave after a long day. OutPizza the Hut? Not likely. Here, time-tested favorites mean you always know what to expect—pizza done right, every single time.
2. Nicky D’s Pizza
Nicky D’s Pizza feels like the neighborhood’s best-kept secret tucked beside Island Lake Lane. On my first visit, the unmistakable scent of hand-tossed dough and melting cheese set the tone before I’d even placed my order. What truly makes Nicky D’s stand out is the care that goes into every pie—which shows up in the thin, crispy crust and balance of fresh toppings.
When I’m there, I never skip their Supreme pizza. Each bite layers smoky vegetables with quality cheese and a classic sauce that brings everything together. For a twist, the Veggie Delight offers a bright, fresh profile perfect for lighter cravings. If you’re searching for a spot where pizza still feels personal, Nicky D’s does it with heart.
3. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Hunt Brothers Pizza sits just off Highway 42, tucked inside a convenience stop that surprises you with the quality of a local pie shop. What sets Hunt Brothers apart isn’t just the quick service—it’s the customizable pizzas, made fast and hot. My first slice here felt like finding pizza gold where you least expect it.
The standout is their “All Toppings No Extra Charge” promise, making it easy to load up on favorites like mushrooms, onions, or jalapeños. Their Classic Crust hits a sweet spot between crispy and chewy, while the Cheese Pizza offers golden, gooey comfort. If you need fast, flavorful pizza with real options, Hunt Brothers delivers every time.
4. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Eustis is the go-to answer when pizza cravings hit late or you need dinner in a hurry. My first delivery arrived faster than expected, piping hot and just as good as dining in. Domino’s has carved out a niche for speed, consistency, and that signature chewy crust that keeps regulars coming back.
If you’re in Umatilla, try their Handmade Pan Pizza for a thick, buttery crunch. The Parmesan Stuffed Crust is another crowd-pleaser, layering extra flavor into every bite. Classicists swear by the thin New York Style for its perfectly foldable slices. With so many options, Domino’s makes it simple to find your own favorite style, without the wait.
5. Tony’s Pizza & Subs
Tony’s Pizza & Subs on E Orange Ave brings a neighborhood feel to every meal, serving up Italian comfort food that never disappoints. My first taste here was a slice of classic cheese pizza with a thin, crackly crust and just the right amount of gooey cheese. The vibe is casual, with big portions and friendly faces behind the counter.
Their veggie pizza packs crisp peppers and mushrooms, proving Tony’s isn’t afraid to load up on fresh toppings. If you’re really hungry, order their calzones—a local favorite that showcases their dough at its best. When you want familiar flavors with a touch of local flair, Tony’s comes through.
6. Anthony’s Pizza
Anthony’s Pizza in Mount Dora sits just off Highway 441, perfect for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner. My visit felt like stepping into a cozy, no-frills spot where the pizza does all the talking. Anthony’s prides itself on simple, hearty pies made to satisfy without breaking the bank.
Try the cheese pizza for a true taste of their crust—pillowy, tender, and topped with a balance of sauce and mozzarella. For heartier appetites, the veggie pizza stands out with fresh toppings and bold flavors. If you’re looking for a place where quality and value meet, Anthony’s delivers in every way that matters.
7. Takis Pizza House
(352) 357-0022Call
Takis Pizza House on S Bay St gives you that classic pizzeria vibe, where the aroma of freshly baked dough draws you right in. My first slice here was a simple cheese pizza, and the crust had that perfect golden snap followed by a soft, chewy bite—exactly what you want from a local pizza house.
Takis stands out for its generous portions and consistent quality. Their margherita pizza is one to try, with fresh basil and tomatoes adding brightness to each slice. For fans of traditional flavor, the veggie supreme is loaded with peppers, onions, and black olives, a showcase of Takis’s dedication to freshness. Whether you dine in or carry out, you’ll taste genuine care in every pizza.
8. Takis Restaurant & Pizza
Takis Restaurant & Pizza on S Bay St feels like a local institution. Every visit brings the comfort of familiar faces and that unmistakable scent of baked dough and herbs. My first meal here started with a warm, cheesy slice straight from the oven, and it’s easy to see why Takis draws devoted regulars.
What distinguishes Takis is their blend of Mediterranean and Italian flavors. The Greek pizza is a must-try, topped with fresh tomatoes, spinach, and feta that deliver a bold, tangy bite. If you’re after something classic, their veggie pizza is loaded with crisp, colorful veggies that highlight the kitchen’s focus on freshness. For anyone looking for authentic flavor, Takis is a sure bet.
9. Mellow Mushroom Mount Dora
Mellow Mushroom Mount Dora is more than a pizza spot—it’s a quirky experience you don’t forget. From colorful murals to retro lamps, the setting is almost as inviting as the menu. The fresh, stone-baked pies feel thoughtfully made, and the spring water crust gives their pizza a lightness that keeps you coming back.
My go-to order is the Veg Out pizza, piled high with mushrooms, spinach, and peppers on that signature crispy-yet-chewy base. If you’re adventurous, try the Holy Shiitake Pie for a rich, earthy twist that’s all about the mushrooms and creamy sauce. For those seeking something different from the usual chains, Mellow Mushroom delivers bold flavors and serious variety in every slice.
10. Papa Murphy’s Take N Bake Pizza
Papa Murphy’s Take N Bake Pizza in Mount Dora puts a clever spin on pizza night. The first time I carried home one of their unbaked pies, it felt oddly satisfying to finish baking it in my own oven. The result? A piping hot pizza with a crust fresh out of the oven—just the way you like it.
What truly sets Papa Murphy’s apart is the customization. You choose your crust, your toppings, and bake it when you’re ready. Their Herb Chicken Mediterranean pizza is a standout, loaded with fresh veggies and a burst of herbs. For purists, their Classic Cheese is deliciously simple. When you want fresh and hot pizza on your schedule, Papa Murphy’s delivers.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Umatilla, FL?
Umatilla has a mix of national chains and local spots. Some favorites include Nicky D’s Pizza for its homemade crust, Pizza Hut for its stuffed crust, and Hunt Brothers Pizza for fast, customizable slices.
Do pizza places in Umatilla offer vegetarian options?
Yes, most offer vegetarian pizzas. Look for favorites like veggie lovers, margherita, or build-your-own from places such as Nicky D’s, Mellow Mushroom, and Domino’s.
Is delivery available for pizza in Umatilla?
Absolutely. National chains like Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Papa Johns deliver, and some local spots may partner with delivery services. Always check with the restaurant for the latest delivery details.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Umatilla?
Some chains, including Domino’s and Papa Murphy’s, provide gluten-free crusts. It’s wise to call ahead or check online menus for choices at specific locations.
Where can I find take-and-bake pizza in Umatilla?
Papa Murphy’s Take N Bake Pizza in nearby Mount Dora is the top spot. They prepare your pie fresh and you finish baking it at home.
Which pizza spot is best for large groups or parties?
Pizza Hut and Tony’s Pizza & Subs are reliable for big orders, with ample seating and customizable menus for gatherings.