Finding good pizza in a small town always feels like a personal quest. I once drove through Tylertown on a humid summer afternoon, tired and hungry, skeptical that I could find a pie worth bragging about. I was proven wrong—Tylertown delivers where it counts, with local spots that treat pizza more like a craft than a commodity.
If you’ve ever wondered whether Tylertown, MS hides excellent pizza, you’re not alone. Here you’ll discover a range of flavors and crusts that could put city pizzerias to shame. From gooey cheese to hand-tossed perfection, these local favorites know how to satisfy a craving. Whether you want a place to gather with friends or a slice to-go, this guide cuts through the noise, giving you the real story on the best pizza in Tylertown.
1. Pizza Inn
Pizza Inn sits at the heart of Tylertown’s pizza experience. I remember my first visit—the aroma of fresh dough hit the moment I walked through the door. What sets Pizza Inn apart is its commitment to hand-made pizza, baked daily and topped generously. There’s nothing cookie-cutter here.
Grab a seat for the Original Pizza Buffet. It’s the talk of the town, offering classic and specialty pies, each slice with its own personality. The thin crust is their signature, crisp yet chewy, carrying plenty of flavor.
If you’re unsure where to start, go for the classic pepperoni or the veggie supreme. The salad bar is always fresh, and the desserts round things out—proof that Pizza Inn keeps things simple and satisfying.
2. Hunt Brothers Pizza
Hunt Brothers Pizza offers a quick fix for anyone craving a satisfying slice in Tylertown. Stopping by after a late drive, I discovered it’s the place for hot, made-to-order pizza without the fuss. Their fast service and consistent quality make them a go-to for locals on the move.
The menu keeps things direct and simple. Build your own pizza with plenty of classic toppings or pick one of their tried-and-true combinations. The crust comes out golden and crunchy, with cheese melted just right.
Order the classic cheese or try a loaded veggie pie for a fresh, no-nonsense take. Hunt Brothers keeps things honest and straightforward—exactly what you need when hunger strikes.
3. Knight Grocery
(985) 848-5988Call
Knight Grocery is the kind of spot you stumble on and end up telling your friends about for weeks. On my last visit, a quick stop for snacks turned into an impromptu pizza break—and I wasn’t disappointed. Here, the pizza surprises you with its homestyle flavor and attention to detail.
This place stands out for its unfussy, generous toppings and a crust with just the right bite. Every pie feels personal and made with a touch of small-town pride. You’ll often see locals grabbing a box after work, proof that it’s become a community staple.
The classic cheese or vegetable pizza both hit the spot. Knight Grocery’s approach is simple—fresh, straight-from-the-oven, and made to make you feel at home.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Tylertown, MS?
Pizza Inn and Hunt Brothers Pizza stand out locally for their fresh, flavorful pizzas. Knight Grocery, just outside town, is also a popular choice for locals.
Does Tylertown have any pizza buffets?
Yes, Pizza Inn offers a popular pizza buffet with a variety of pies and other options. It’s an easy way to sample several styles in one visit.
Can I order pizza for takeout in Tylertown?
Absolutely. Both Pizza Inn and Hunt Brothers Pizza offer takeout. Knight Grocery is also friendly for call-ahead orders if you prefer to grab and go.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Tylertown?
Yes. All three spots can make a solid veggie pizza. Pizza Inn’s vegetarian selections are especially well-regarded for their freshness and flavor.