Looking for the best pizza in Tyler, TX feels a bit like hunting for treasure. The city’s pizza scene offers everything from classic New York-style slices to crispy brick oven masterpieces—each spot promising something unique. Over the years, I’ve watched local favorites and new ovens alike stuff their menus with distinct recipes, keeping taste buds curious and loyal customers coming back on Friday nights.
Each pizzeria in Tyler brings its own flavor twist. Some crank up the garlic, others believe the secret lies in a pillowy crust or a perfect balance of cheese and sauce. If you’ve ever debated where that next pizza night should happen, you’re in the right place. Below, you’ll find a lineup of standout pizza spots—including a few places you might not expect. Dive in and get ready to meet the pies that make Tyler proud.
Where to find the best pizza in Tyler, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Tyler, TX:
- Bruno’s Pizza
- Rotolo’s Pizzeria
- New York Pizza & Pasta Italian Kitchen
- Rounder’s Pizza
- Sola Bread Co.
- Bruno’s Pizza
- Ken’s Pizza
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Mazzio’s Pizza
- Parry’s Pizzeria & Taphouse
1. Bruno’s Pizza
Bruno’s Pizza is a Tyler favorite with a knack for dependable, mouthwatering pies. Tucked away on South Vine, its inviting, no-frills atmosphere is just the kind of spot where you’ll want to linger over a hot slice. Service is personal and attentive, so you always feel like a regular even on your first visit.
The magic happens in the kitchen: crusts are always crisp and chewy, and sauces have that homemade zip. The cheese blend comes gooey and golden, with generous slices that demand a second helping. I’m partial to their classic pepperoni, but the vegetarian pizza is a real showstopper—vivid with fresh veggies and full of flavor.
If you’re seeking local tradition and stand-out flavor, this is the place. Whether for lunch or dinner, Bruno’s transforms a simple meal into a satisfying ritual.
2. Rotolo’s Pizzeria
Rotolo’s Pizzeria serves up good vibes and even better pizza. The dough is made from scratch every morning, and the kitchen never skimps on fresh, hand-chopped veggies. It’s the kind of place where you can watch a game, catch up with friends, and find a pie that just hits the spot.
What makes Rotolo’s pop is their playful menu—think inventive combinations and a big lineup of Texas craft drafts. I’m a fan of the classic Margherita or their Veggie Supreme, piled high with all the crisp fixings you could want. Gluten-free diners will like having real choices beyond salad.
The kitchen’s commitment to freshness and quality shines in every slice. For those looking for a casual meal that still brings flavor, Rotolo’s is a top contender in Tyler.
3. New York Pizza & Pasta Italian Kitchen
New York Pizza & Pasta Italian Kitchen brings a slice of the Empire State straight to Tyler. The thin, foldable crust is delightfully authentic—chewy at the edge, crisp underneath, just as a New York pie should be. There’s always a lively energy here, and the kitchen turns out pizzas with true character.
This spot takes pride in serving generous portions and dialing in classic flavors. Whether you crave a zesty Veggie pizza or the plain cheese, you’ll find toppings fresh and sauces with just the right tang. Vegan and vegetarian options round out the menu for a satisfying meal no matter your preference.
My go-to is the Margherita: simple, beautifully balanced, and never disappoints. It’s honest New York-style pizza done well, without having to leave Tyler.
4. Rounder’s Pizza
+1 903-509-2100
Rounder’s Pizza keeps things casual but never cuts corners on flavor. It’s the kind of no-fuss joint where the staff remembers your order and the pies always hit the table piping hot. There’s something comforting about their approach—fresh dough rolled daily, toppings added with care, and a crust that lands somewhere between crunchy and soft.
What sets Rounder’s apart is the generous layering. There’s always the perfect balance—ample toppings, just enough sauce, plenty of cheese. Vegetarians are in for a treat, thanks to their loaded veggie pizza, always colorful and satisfying.
If you haven’t tried their classic cheese or a custom combo loaded with your favorites, you’re missing out on a homegrown Tyler staple. Rounder’s makes every pizza feel like a personal recommendation.
5. Sola Bread Co.
Sola Bread Co. is where pizza meets true artisan craft. From the first moment you step in, you sense the warmth of a family-run kitchen. The wood-fired oven anchors their process, turning out blistered, chewy crusts you’ll remember.
What makes Sola shine is its commitment to high-quality ingredients and a balanced palate. The pizzas here are a little different—lighter, beautifully textured, and layered with farmer’s market freshness. Their Margherita is a revelation, but I’m always tempted by their seasonal veggie pies.
The focus remains on simple, honest flavors and bread you can’t stop thinking about. For anyone who values both taste and tradition, a visit to Sola Bread Co. feels less like a meal and more like a gathering.
6. Bruno’s Pizza
This Bruno’s Pizza location brings a familiar sense of comfort, whether you’re dining in or grabbing a box to go. There’s a certain satisfaction in knowing you’ll always get a crispy crust and a pile of toppings every time. The dining room has the easy charm of a neighborhood spot where families share laughs and slices.
What really sets this Bruno’s apart is their steady attention to quality. Each pizza is made to order, with a golden, chewy base and a smoky edge from the oven. The sauce is always bright and the cheese plentiful.
Don’t miss their signature pepperoni or veggie pizza, which always land at that perfect intersection of crispy and gooey. For a classic Tyler pizza night, this Bruno’s is tough to beat.
7. Ken’s Pizza
Ken’s Pizza is a local institution, holding its spot on South Broadway for generations. The no-nonsense approach and classic buffet make it a go-to for those craving familiar flavors in a relaxed atmosphere. It feels like the kind of place your grandparents grew up loving—and nothing about its charm has faded.
Piping-hot pies arrive with a signature thin and crispy crust, where every bite brings a good pull of cheese and a savory layer of sauce. The buffet is generous, always stocked with fresh options and bursting with variety.
For the full experience, start with a simple cheese or supreme pizza. Each slice is direct, satisfying, and captures the essence of Tyler’s pizza tradition. Ken’s is best enjoyed with a group, making every meal feel like a mini celebration.
8. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza is a familiar name in Tyler, and for good reason. The location on South Broadway is always buzzing with folks ready for that trademark pillowy crust and tangy signature sauce. It’s the spot you turn to when you want your pizza hot, fresh, and fast—without sacrificing on taste.
What makes Papa Johns distinct is the focus on consistently fresh ingredients. Each order feels made for you, whether you pick up in person or opt for the speedy delivery. Their pizza always arrives with that satisfying aroma—inviting you to dig in right away.
Try their classic Garden Fresh for a burst of veggies on that signature hand-tossed crust. If you’re in a hurry or hosting friends, Papa Johns makes pizza night effortless and reliable.
9. Mazzio’s Pizza
+1 903-592-0897
Mazzio’s Pizza delivers the kind of comfort that only comes from a neighborhood favorite. Tucked on East 5th, it’s a casual, kid-friendly spot where the booths fill up quickly and everyone’s got a favorite order. The service is quick, making it easy for those on a lunch break or grabbing family dinner on the go.
The crust here is what draws people in—light, airy, and always golden. Mazzio’s doesn’t skimp on toppings either, so every bite feels loaded with flavor. It’s the kind of pizza you crave on busy weeknights or whenever you want straightforward satisfaction.
For a real crowd-pleaser, get their Super Veggie or the create-your-own for something truly yours. Mazzio’s stands out as a no-fuss, flavor-forward stop in Tyler’s pizza landscape.
10. Parry’s Pizzeria & Taphouse
Parry’s Pizzeria & Taphouse brings the big flavors of New York to Tyler in a setting that balances energy and laid-back charm. The menu is massive, but their pizza is genuinely the standout—thin, foldable, and full of that classic NYC chew. It’s a great spot for groups, with long tables and a lively hum from the taphouse on busy nights.
Everything at Parry’s feels crafted with attention to detail, from crisp-edged crusts to the generous scatter of fresh toppings. Their veggie pizza is a strong pick for anyone looking for a colorful, well-balanced pie.
Try the classic cheese or any of their signature New York-style pizzas to see what truly makes Parry’s special. It’s consistently delicious and offers a slice of the city, right in the heart of Tyler.
More Things to Try in Tyler, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Tyler, TX for families?
Bruno’s Pizza, Ken’s Pizza, and Mazzio’s Pizza are local favorites with casual spaces and menus that make them easy picks for family dinners.
Are there any pizza spots in Tyler with vegetarian or vegan options?
Yes, you’ll find strong vegetarian choices at Sola Bread Co., Rotolo’s Pizzeria, New York Pizza & Pasta Italian Kitchen, and more. Some also offer vegan cheese and toppings—just ask when you order.
Where can I find authentic New York-style pizza in Tyler?
Parry’s Pizzeria & Taphouse and New York Pizza & Pasta Italian Kitchen both specialize in that signature thin, foldable crust for anyone craving a true New York bite.
Which pizza places in Tyler deliver?
Most major spots—Papa Johns Pizza, Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and others—offer delivery. Many local favorites, like Bruno’s, also deliver or partner with food delivery apps for easy ordering.
What’s the best pizza for a quick lunch in Tyler?
Papa Murphy’s is a great choice for grab-and-go, while spots like Ken’s Pizza or Mazzio’s Pizza have buffets for a fast, filling option. For classic slices or speedy service, Rounder’s Pizza is reliable too.