Craving pizza in Troy, MI sparks a delicious problem—the options are as varied as a perfectly loaded supreme. One cold evening, I ducked into a pizzeria just off Big Beaver Road, expecting little more than the usual slice. What I found was bold sauce, stretchy cheese, and a crust with just the right bite. That moment marked the start of my ongoing quest for Troy’s best pies, and trust me, the journey has been filled with delightful surprises.
Choosing the right pizza spot matters. Whether you want classic, cheese-loaded comfort or crave inventive toppings, Troy’s pizza scene has something to please every palate. This guide pulls from hands-on tasting and local buzz to help you discover your own favorites. Read on for the best places to grab a slice in Troy, each one carefully selected for flavor, consistency, and quality ingredients.
1. Alibi of Troy
Step inside Alibi of Troy and you’ll quickly see it’s more than just a neighborhood staple. The setting works for everything—family gatherings, lunches with friends, or meeting up after work. I remember my first visit, when the server recommended their signature pizza. One bite in, and I understood the loyal following.
Alibi’s pizza is a perfect blend of crispy crust, zesty sauce, and bubbling cheese. The veggie-loaded pizza wins me over every time. Their gluten-free options are solid, making it easy for everyone at the table to dig in.
If you want authentic, try their classic Alibi Special. The loaded pies here—generous, not greasy—set them apart in Troy. This spot delivers true comfort and serious flavor.
2. Renee’s Gourmet Pizzeria
Renee’s Gourmet Pizzeria truly redefines what allergy-friendly pizza can taste like. On my last visit, I watched a family celebrating over pies, amazed at how easily gluten-free and vegan diets blended into the party. Renee’s shines for its commitment: every pizza is crafted to be safe for all, without missing a single beat on flavor or crunch.
The gluten-free Margherita is a must-try, with tangy sauce and fresh basil you can taste in every bite. Their veggie-packed options bring loads of color and flavor to the table. It’s rare to find pizza this inclusive and still indulgent.
If you’re seeking a place where everyone can share a meal—without compromising taste—Renee’s is the rare spot in Troy that delivers exactly that.
3. California Pizza Kitchen
California Pizza Kitchen shakes up the Troy pizza scene with a playful twist on the classics. My first time there, the open kitchen and bright atmosphere set the tone. The flavor profiles are bold, and none of the pizzas shy away from creativity.
The California Veggie pizza is a standout—it’s loaded with fresh vegetables and a herby crust that somehow tastes like summer. The gluten-free options are crisp and don’t compromise on flavor. Even the vegan cheese melts just right, a rare thing to find.
For those who want something different from the usual, CPK’s inventive pies are worth the outing. From shareable slices to solo meals, they deliver vivid flavors every time.
4. Peppy’s Pizza-Subs & Bakery
Peppy’s Pizza-Subs & Bakery gives off that classic, inviting vibe you hope to find in a local pizza joint. Walking in, the aroma of fresh dough and sauces makes a strong first impression. It’s the kind of place where regulars still get greeted by name.
The secret here is in the crust—chewy inside, just the right crunch on the outside. Their Veggie Pizza is a favorite, loaded with peppers and mushrooms that taste freshly chopped. There’s something homey about every bite.
If you’re after a hearty meal, their thick Sicilian pizza squares deserve a spot on your table. Peppy’s keeps things simple, but the quality is anything but ordinary.
5. Tony’s Pizzeria
Tony’s Pizzeria is the kind of spot you stumble into once and make a habit of returning to. My first visit felt like being welcomed into someone’s kitchen. There’s a neighborhood warmth that’s hard to fake, and the pizzas echo that same heartfelt approach.
The cheese pizza steals the show here, with a golden crust and oozy cheese you can’t help but savor. You’ll find simple toppings, applied generously, bringing out real flavor in every slice. The lunch crowd knows what’s up, which tells you something.
Looking for something shareable? Order the veggie pizza for a bit of everything. Tony’s proves that great pizza doesn’t need a long list of tricks—just solid, honest ingredients.
6. Shield’s Restaurant Bar Pizzeria
Shield’s Restaurant Bar Pizzeria has deep Detroit roots and a loyal following in Troy. You’ll notice the friendly buzz from the moment you step inside, especially on game nights. I once tried their deep-dish veggie pizza during a playoff rush—the place was packed, but the service was smooth and the food more than worth the wait.
Shield’s square, deep-dish pizzas are the stars. The crust has a crispy, golden edge and the cheese stretches just right. Their classic veggie pie is both hearty and fresh, with each topping tucked into a rich, zesty sauce. It’s a taste of Detroit tradition in every bite.
Whether you dine in or take out, Shield’s offers consistent quality and a sense of community that’s tough to top in Troy.
7. Crispelli’s Bakery & Pizzeria
Crispelli’s Bakery & Pizzeria delivers that artisan touch without the upscale fuss. My first bite of their thin-crust pizza felt like it came straight from a wood-fired oven in Italy—delicate but bursting with flavor. You can see their passion for old-school baking in every detail.
The Margherita pizza here is pure simplicity at its best, with bright tomato, basil, and generously creamy cheese. Their vegan options hold their own too, tasting fresher than most spots in town. The bakery side tempts you with fresh bread and pastries to take home.
If you like Detroit-style, Crispelli’s doesn’t disappoint with its thick, airy base and caramelized edges. This is where gourmet meets everyday comfort, perfectly suited for any pizza lover in Troy.
8. Buddy’s Pizza
Buddy’s Pizza is pure Detroit tradition plated up in the heart of Troy. The moment I tried their Detroit-style square pizza, I knew why locals swear by it. That high-edged, caramelized crust is more than just crispy—it’s a whole experience in itself.
The Classic Veggie Pizza at Buddy’s never skimps on fresh toppings. Each slice is loaded with brightly flavored veggies, a tangy sauce, and plenty of gooey cheese—all resting on a satisfyingly thick, chewy crust. The blend is simple but memorable.
If you’re searching for an authentic taste of Detroit without heading downtown, this spot has you covered. Buddy’s brings nostalgic comfort and perfect consistency, every single time.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Troy has a knack for consistency that never fails, especially when a quick, hot meal is what you need. I’ve lost count of late-night study sessions fueled by their pizza—always on time, always piping hot.
The Thin Crust Veggie offers a crisp bite that’s surprisingly light, and you can really taste the fresh peppers and onions. If you want extra comfort, their Handmade Pan is another reliable pick—cheesy, hearty, and satisfying in all the right ways.
Domino’s makes ordering simple, and the deals stretch your dollar. Whether you’re a loyal fan or just in need of a speedy slice, this location delivers flavor without the fuss.
10. Papa Romano’s Pizza
Papa Romano’s Pizza brings classic flavors and local charm to the Troy pizza line-up. I stopped in with friends on a busy evening, and the steady stream of takeout customers hinted at something good. It’s the kind of place where you know the dough is made fresh—every bite tells the story.
The Gourmet Veggie pizza is a standout, offering a plentiful mix of crisp veggies and melty cheese. The crust stays soft and chewy, with a sauce that’s bright but never overpowering. Everything about their pies feels balanced and thoughtfully built.
If you’re after classic comfort, try a traditional cheese pizza or go focaccia-style for something different. Papa Romano’s hits all the right notes for dependable, satisfying pizza in Troy.
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Troy, MI?
You’ll find just about everything—Detroit-style, classic round, thin crust, Sicilian squares, and even gluten-free and vegan options. Many local spots offer both traditional and creative takes.
Are there good vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Troy?
Definitely. Many places like Renee’s Gourmet Pizzeria and Crispelli’s offer flavorful vegetarian and vegan pizzas, including gluten-free crusts and vegan cheeses.
Which pizza place is best for families or groups?
Alibi of Troy, Shield’s, and Buddy’s Pizza all offer spacious dining rooms and menus that cater to groups, making them great picks for gatherings.
Can I get pizza delivered in Troy?
Almost every spot on this list delivers, including popular chains like Domino’s and local favorites like Papa Romano’s and Marco’s.
What’s the most unique pizza experience in Troy?
Renee’s stands out for its allergy-friendly menu and inventive options, while Buddy’s and Shield’s deliver classic Detroit-style square pies.