Finding good pizza in Titusville is like flipping through a book of secret family recipes—you know there’s gold in there, you just have to know where to look. I’ve nursed cheese burns from ovens both wood-fired and electric, savoring slices from dimly lit corner joints and sleek new arrivals. Titusville’s pizza scene might seem quiet at first glance, but look again and you’ll notice crusts pulled by practiced hands, sauces with spice you won’t forget, and toppings that dodge cliché.
Let’s skip the tired debates about what makes the “best” pizza and actually talk about taste, texture, and the places where locals line up on Friday nights. This isn’t hearsay; it’s based on bites both brilliant and questionable, trying everything from classic New York style to pies with a local twist. Whether you’re a thin-crust devotee or a sauce-swirling traditionalist, you’ll find your next favorite slice right here. Ready to explore? Your Titusville pizza adventure starts now.
1. Kelsey’s Pizzeria & Eatery Titusville
If you ever find yourself debating where to eat in Titusville, Kelsey’s Pizzeria & Eatery will likely win the vote. There’s a warmth the moment you walk in—a feeling you’re about to become a regular. Their stone deck pizzas deliver a crisp crust and punchy flavor, with options like the bold Kelsey’s Special that loads on the toppings without overwhelming the base.
The menu goes beyond basic, from Northern Italian pies with heaps of mozzarella to bright vegetarian options. My pick? Share a pizza but keep the Greek Salad all to yourself. It’s legendary for a reason. Whether you go classic or adventurous, there’s something about Kelsey’s that keeps people coming back for another slice.
2. Mamma Rosa’s Pizzeria Restaurant
There’s a quiet charm about Mamma Rosa’s Pizzeria Restaurant that draws you in, whether you’re a longtime local or just passing through Titusville. Step inside, and it feels like someone’s nonna is about to serve you lunch. The staff greets you like family, and the pizzas are all about that comforting, homemade touch you crave on a mellow afternoon.
Mamma Rosa’s pies feature a dough that’s never rushed, topped with sauce that strikes the right balance of tang and sweetness. The classic cheese pizza hits the spot, while the veggie pie bursts with fresh flavors—a testament to their careful approach in the kitchen.
If you ask what to order, trust your gut and go for a generous slice, maybe alongside a garden salad. At Mamma Rosa’s, pizza is both a meal and a moment worth savoring.
3. Valentino’s New York Style Pizza & Restaurant
If your heart beats for classic thin crust and pies that fold, Valentino’s New York Style Pizza & Restaurant is the closest you’ll get to the real thing this side of the bridge. Tucked in Searstown Mall, this spot hums with old-school flair and the smell of fresh-baked dough. Each slice feels both hefty and light—crispy edges, chewy center, just the right touch of char.
What keeps me coming back? It’s that generous cheese-to-sauce ratio, which makes every bite a memory. The plain cheese pizza here needs no extras to impress, though their white pizza with garlic always gets rave mentions around the table.
Bring a friend, order a large, and grab a seat. One bite in, you’ll get why people keep returning for another round at Valentino’s.
4. Humpavelli’s Pizza
Humpavelli’s Pizza feels like the kind of place where every detail—and every slice—matters. You’ll notice the open kitchen first, with dough flying and cheese melting while staff chat about their favorite new creations. It’s a place where everything is made in-house, and it shows.
Their crust leans chewy, with just enough crispness to keep you reaching for another slice. I can’t resist the Veggie Pizza; the flavors of their fresh-cut toppings and homemade sauce come through in every bite. Vegan and vegetarian options aren’t an afterthought—they’re crowd favorites here.
If you’re looking for a pie that feels crafted just for you with a dash of personality, this is your spot. Order with confidence, and don’t skip their house-made dips.
5. Pizza At Titus Landing
+1 321-267-2800
See Menu
If you crave customization, Pizza At Titus Landing is a blank canvas for your pizza dreams. Here, building your own pie isn’t just encouraged—it’s the main event. Fresh dough, a colorful lineup of toppings, and quick service combine for a casual meal with no compromise on flavor or quality.
What sets this spot apart is the genuine control over your meal. I always end up with extra mushrooms and spinach, but you can choose anything from classic mozzarella to vegan cheese. The gluten-free crusts are surprisingly tasty and get bonus points for texture.
Ideal for groups or picky eaters, you’ll walk away with exactly what you want. Try their calzones for a cheesy, golden-baked change of pace.
6. Hungry Howie’s Pizza
Hungry Howie’s Pizza holds a steady place in Titusville for those who want big flavor without fuss. If you’re on the never-ending quest for a great delivery pie, these are the folks to call. The speedy turnaround and friendly staff are reliable, but the real star is their crust—that famous flavored crust in options like buttery garlic or sesame sets them apart from the usual.
The classic cheese or veggie pie always satisfies, but there’s a reason the Howie Special is hard to resist: lots of toppings, just enough crunch, and a burst of herbs in each bite. Budget-friendly deals make it popular with families and late-night snackers alike.
If you’re not sure what to pick, go for any pizza with that signature crust. It’s what keeps Howie’s fans loyal.
7. Little Caesars
Little Caesars in Titusville delivers on its promise of quick, affordable pizza anytime you get a craving. It’s the sort of spot where you can race in and leave with a hot, fresh pie before your playlist is halfway done. Simple, speedy, and consistent—that’s why it’s a fixture across town.
Fans swear by the classic Hot-N-Ready cheese and pepperoni pizzas: fluffy dough, plenty of cheese, and more than enough slices to share or hoard. For those who want something extra, the Crazy Bread never disappoints—soft, garlicky, and addictive.
Little Caesars doesn’t overcomplicate anything. When hunger won’t wait and you need something reliable, it’s an easy choice.
8. Pizza@
See Menu
Pizza@ at Titus Landing invites you to dive into pizza your way. The build-your-own approach means freedom: pick your dough, your sauce, and pile on as many fresh ingredients as you want. It’s a choose-your-own adventure in pizza, which is half the fun—especially if you love cross-topping experiments as much as I do.
The pies come out fast, with a golden, slightly crispy crust and toppings layered just the way you like. I’ve found the classic Margherita sings with fresh basil, but bold sorts might go for spicy jalapenos or extra cheese. You can’t go wrong mixing it up.
If you want pizza tailored exactly to your mood, Pizza@ turns every visit into something new, every time.
9. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Knox McRae delivers consistency and speed, making it a Titusville favorite when pizza cravings hit without warning. Their menu packs in variety, offering everything from thin, foldable New York-style slices to thick, hearty Handmade Pan options. If there’s one standout, it’s the Parmesan Stuffed Crust Pizza—crispy outside, gooey cheese inside, and loaded with flavor in every bite.
It’s hard not to appreciate Domino’s reliable delivery crew and the platform that makes customizing your order a breeze. You can keep it classic or build something wild, but each pie arrives hot and ready to share.
For weeknight dinners or group hangouts, Domino’s hits the spot every single time.
10. Grumbleys Pizza
There’s a cozy, old-school feel to Grumbleys Pizza that sets it apart in Titusville’s busy pizza lineup. It’s one of those local gems where the aroma of baking dough hits you before you even reach the door. Their approach is unfussy but rooted in classic Italian ways—freshly made dough, rich tomato sauce, and plenty of cheese, all gleaming under a quick bake.
The classic cheese pizza is a crowd favorite, but I never skip the veggie option—colorful, hearty, and full of flavor. What puts Grumbleys on the map is their balance: not too greasy, never stingy with toppings, and always baked just right.
If you want a straightforward, no-nonsense slice that doesn’t need extra bells and whistles, Grumbleys consistently delivers.
Frequently Asked Questions
What styles of pizza can I find in Titusville?
You’ll find a range here—classic New York thin crust, hearty pan-style pies, and plenty of places offering build-your-own or gluten-free and vegan options. Whether you like it saucy, extra cheesy, or piled with veggies, Titusville has you covered.
Which Titusville pizzerias are best for takeout or delivery?
For quick service and reliable delivery, spots like Domino’s, Hungry Howie’s, and Little Caesars keep things convenient. For a more local touch, consider Kelsey’s Pizzeria or Humpavelli’s for takeout with that handmade flair.
Are there good vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Titusville?
Absolutely. Pizza At Titus Landing, Humpavelli’s, and Mamma Rosa’s all offer vegetarian or vegan-friendly creations, so nobody has to skip pizza night.
Is gluten-free pizza available in Titusville?
Yes. Pizza At Titus Landing is known for their gluten-free rice or cauliflower crusts, and several other local spots are happy to accommodate if you ask.
Where should I go for a sit-down pizza meal in Titusville?
Try Kelsey’s Pizzeria or Mamma Rosa’s for table service, a cozy setting, and plenty of Italian specialties beyond pizza if you want to linger awhile.