There’s something about biting into a perfect slice that turns a regular day into a memorable one. I once found myself dodging Tallahassee’s midday rain and ducked into a no-frills pizzeria off Tennessee Street. The crust was just right—firm yet tender, with a sauce that knew not to steal the spotlight. That slice taught me what locals already knew: Tallahassee understands pizza. Whether you’re after New York-style foldables, rustic Neapolitans, or a pie stacked so high it’s practically a casserole, this city does not disappoint.
This guide isn’t built on whimsy or search results—it’s rooted in authentic experience and curated with care. From campus-favorite dives to quiet neighborhood gems, we’ve tracked down the most satisfying, quality-driven pizza spots across Tallahassee. Each listing highlights what sets them apart: taste, atmosphere, consistency, and commitment to halal-friendly options wherever applicable. So if you’re craving clarity on where to grab your next slice, keep reading—you’re in exactly the right place.
Where to find the best pizza in Tallahassee, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Tallahassee, FL:
- Momo’s Pizza – Tennessee Street
- Blaze Pizza
- Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen
- Momo’s Pizza
- Village Pizza & Pasta
- Gaines Street Pies
- Decent Pizza
- Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana
- Dave’s Pizza Garage
- Brickyard Pizzeria
1. Momo’s Pizza – Tennessee Street
At Momo’s Pizza on Tennessee Street, the slices aren’t just big—they’re practically plate-sized. I remember ordering one on a busy weekday afternoon, expecting a casual lunch. The moment it arrived, half the table turned to stare. That generous portion wasn’t just for show—it delivered on flavor.
Known for its relaxed vibe and loyal college crowd, Momo’s makes pizza that feels crafted, not mass-produced. Their crust has that golden edge with just enough chew. If you’re indecisive, go for the Big Meat Veggie. It’s piled with vibrant veggies and hearty meat-free toppings—perfect if you’re after something satisfying and halal-conscious.
With vegan and vegetarian options available, Momo’s stands out for both variety and atmosphere. And if you’re catching a late bite, they’re open well past sunset, making it an easy go-to any time.
Call ahead, or just walk in hungry. Either way, Momo’s knows how to feed a craving with style.
2. Blaze Pizza
Blaze Pizza is where speed meets customization without sacrificing quality. I stopped in after a long walk downtown and was surprised by how quickly my pizza was ready—just three minutes from oven to tray. But what impressed me more was the crisp crust and fresh toppings that didn’t taste rushed.
Blaze stands out for its build-your-own approach. With over 30 toppings, you can craft a pie that suits your taste and dietary needs. I went with their signature Red Vine—a simple yet flavorful mix of mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, and fresh basil. It’s a great pick if you want something light but satisfying.
Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options are clearly marked, making it easy to order with confidence. The staff is helpful, and the space feels modern without being cold.
If you’re craving pizza that’s fast, fresh, and tailored to you, Blaze delivers—literally and figuratively.
3. Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen
Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen offers a warm, inviting atmosphere paired with authentic Italian flavors. During a recent visit, I was greeted with the rich aroma of fresh baked bread and simmering marinara. Their menu showcases a range of classic dishes, but the pizza truly stands out for its thin, crispy crust and generous toppings.
Known for its authentic Italian style, the restaurant’s pizza balances perfect flavor with quality ingredients. I recommend trying the Margherita pizza, topped with fresh basil and mozzarella—simple, yet full of flavor. It reflects their dedication to traditional Italian cooking.
Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options are available, catering to various dietary needs. Whether dining in or ordering online, Tour of Italy prioritizes quality and authenticity in every bite.
4. Momo’s Pizza
This Momo’s Pizza location in Market Square brings the same bold flavors and sky-sized slices Tallahassee locals love. I dropped in during a Friday night rush and still had a seat within minutes. The staff was upbeat and the kitchen was firing pies out fast, each one made fresh to order.
Their style leans toward big, hearty, and crowd-pleasing. If you’re after something with balance, try the Treehugger—a colorful mix of spinach, mushrooms, and olives that’s flavorful without feeling heavy. It’s ideal for those looking for a vegetarian-friendly, halal-conscious option without compromising taste.
This spot stays open late, so it’s perfect if you’re hunting for pizza outside typical dinner hours. With its laid-back energy and reliable quality, Momo’s at Market Square keeps the tradition strong.
Big slices, fresh toppings, and plenty of seating—sometimes that’s exactly what a good night needs.
5. Village Pizza & Pasta
Village Pizza & Pasta offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere tucked inside Village Commons. I visited on a quiet weekday evening and was immediately drawn to their warm hospitality. The menu showcases classic Italian comfort food, with a focus on fresh ingredients and generous portions.
Their pizza features a crispy crust and well-balanced toppings, making it a clear standout. I recommend trying the Veggie Deluxe, loaded with vibrant vegetables and perfectly seasoned. It’s a great choice for vegetarians and reflects their commitment to quality and flavor.
With both dine-in and takeout options, Village Pizza & Pasta caters to busy schedules while maintaining high standards. Whether you’re craving a simple margherita or a hearty pasta dish, this spot delivers authentic taste in every bite.
It’s a go-to place when you want comfort food that feels homemade and satisfying.
6. Gaines Street Pies
Gaines Street Pies blends creativity with comfort in a laid-back downtown setting. I stopped by on a breezy Saturday afternoon and was greeted by the scent of fresh herbs and stone-fired dough. The interior hums with personality—quirky, relaxed, but clearly serious about good food.
Their pizza menu is where flair meets flavor. The Margherita with roasted garlic stands out for its perfect balance of charred crust, vibrant tomato, and silky mozzarella. If you’re in the mood for something bolder, try the Veggie Stack, a colorful medley that’s both hearty and refreshing.
Gaines Street Pies makes it easy to dine your way—vegetarian-friendly, with vegan and gluten-free options—without sacrificing quality. It’s the kind of place that feels like your new regular after just one slice.
7. Decent Pizza
Decent Pizza lives up to its name—but don’t let the modesty fool you. Tucked along N Monroe Street, this local favorite balances casual vibes with consistently good pies. The seating’s unpretentious, the crowd’s eclectic, and the pizza? It’s quietly bold.
The crust hits the sweet spot between chewy and crisp. Go for the classic veggie or the white pie with ricotta, garlic, and spinach—it’s a standout. Each slice comes with generous toppings and a sauce that doesn’t overpower.
What makes Decent Pizza special isn’t just the food. It’s the atmosphere. It’s the kind of spot where regulars linger and first-timers immediately feel like regulars.
If you’re craving reliable, unfussy pizza with real flavor, this is the one to remember when roaming through Tallahassee’s pizza scene.
8. Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana
Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana offers an authentic taste of Italy right in Tallahassee. I visited their cozy location on Gaines Street and was captivated by the inviting aroma of freshly baked Neapolitan-style pizza. The wood-fired oven gives each pie that signature smoky flavor and perfect, blistered crust.
Their menu showcases a commitment to quality and tradition. I recommend trying the Margherita with fresh mozzarella, basil, and a delicate tomato sauce—simple yet exceptional. For those seeking vegan or vegetarian options, Isabella’s provides flavorful choices that don’t compromise on authenticity.
What sets Isabella’s apart is their dedication to traditional techniques paired with fresh ingredients, delivering a true Neapolitan experience. It’s a place where pizza feels both handcrafted and special.
9. Dave’s Pizza Garage
Dave’s Pizza Garage is a hidden gem in Tallahassee, known for its laid-back vibe and hearty, satisfying slices. I stopped by after a long day, and the friendly staff made me feel like a regular. Their menu offers a variety of classic and creative options, all crafted with fresh ingredients.
Their crust is crisp on the edges and perfectly chewy inside. I recommend trying the Garage Special, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, veggies, and cheese—an excellent showcase of their flavor-packed approach. Vegetarians will appreciate the Veggie Delight, offering a generous medley of fresh toppings.
Whether dine-in, takeout, or delivery, Dave’s Pizza Garage is a reliable choice for quality, comfort, and taste. It stands out through its consistent quality and its welcoming, unpretentious atmosphere.
10. Brickyard Pizzeria
Brickyard Pizzeria combines a friendly atmosphere with high-quality ingredients. I visited on a quiet evening and was quickly impressed by the inviting vibe and attentive service. Their menu features classic pizzas with a modern twist, perfect for a casual craving.
The crust is beautifully crispy, and the toppings are fresh and generous. I highly recommend the Margherita—simple, flavorful, and showcasing their commitment to authentic quality. For those seeking vegetarian options, the Garden Supreme offers a vibrant medley of fresh vegetables that doesn’t compromise on taste.
Delivery, dine-in, or takeout, Brickyard Pizzeria stands out for its dedication to good pizza and a welcoming environment. It’s a dependable spot for both family nights and solo bites.
More Things to Try in Tallahassee, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best pizza in Tallahassee?
Many locals recommend Momo’s Pizza for its oversized slices and laid-back vibe. If you prefer customizable thin-crust options, Blaze Pizza is a solid choice. For authentic Italian-style pies, Isabella’s Pizzeria Napoletana stands out.
Which pizza places offer vegetarian options?
Several pizzerias cater to vegetarians. Gaines Street Pies and Village Pizza & Pasta offer veggie-loaded pies. Blaze Pizza also allows you to build your own pizza with a wide range of plant-based toppings.
Are there any local pizza spots open late?
Yes. Gaines Street Pies and Five Star Pizza are known for staying open past midnight, making them popular with night owls and college students.
Do any pizza places offer gluten-free crusts?
Blaze Pizza and Uncle Maddio’s Pizza offer gluten-free crust options. Always check with the restaurant to confirm preparation methods if you have dietary restrictions.
Which pizza restaurants are good for families?
Tour of Italy Italian Kitchen and Brickyard Pizzeria provide a relaxed atmosphere and kid-friendly menus. Pizza Hut and Papa John’s are also reliable for family-style dining.
Can I get pizza delivered in Tallahassee?
Absolutely. Most major chains like Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Papa John’s offer delivery. Local favorites such as Five Star Pizza and Decent Pizza also deliver within city limits.
What’s unique about pizza in Tallahassee?
Tallahassee’s pizza scene blends classic New York-style slices with creative, locally inspired toppings. Places like Momo’s Pizza are known for their massive portions, while Gaines Street Pies adds a quirky twist to traditional recipes.