Discovering the best pizza in Strongsville, OH, can feel like a delicious adventure. Over the years, I’ve sampled countless slices, each with its own unique charm—from crispy crusts to gooey cheese and inventive toppings. What truly stands out is how many local spots offer exceptional pies that rival any big-city pizzeria. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita or a creative specialty, Strongsville’s pizza scene proves there’s something for every palate.
This guide is crafted from personal experiences, reviews, and deep dives into the local pizza culture. My goal is to steer you toward places that consistently deliver quality, flavor, and authenticity. If you’re tired of the same old options or simply searching for a new favorite, this list will point you in the right direction. Prepare to indulge in slices that will keep you coming back for more.
1. A Slice Above
Nestled on Pearl Road, A Slice Above has earned a reputation for delivering consistently quality pizza in Strongsville. From my visits, I’ve always appreciated how fresh and flavorful their pies are, with a crust that’s perfectly crispy yet tender. The welcoming atmosphere makes it a great spot for both lunch and dinner.
What sets A Slice Above apart is their attention to detail and commitment to variety. They’re vegetarian friendly, offering options that don’t compromise on taste. I recommend trying their signature Supreme Pizza—a well-balanced mix of toppings that truly showcases their craftsmanship. For a satisfying experience, their Vegetarian Delight is a healthy, flavorful choice that highlights their versatility and dedication to quality ingredients.
2. Gina’s Pizza
Located on Pearl Road, Gina’s Pizza has become a favorite among locals for its authentic and hearty pies. During my visits, I’ve noticed their commitment to fresh ingredients and classic Italian flavors, which always elevate the dining experience. The cozy atmosphere makes it ideal for both family dinners and quick takeout.
What makes Gina’s Pizza stand out is their vegetarian-friendly menu and consistent quality. I recommend trying their Veggie Supreme Pizza, loaded with fresh vegetables and rich cheese—it perfectly reflects their dedication to flavor and freshness. For a satisfying, authentic slice, Gina’s offers a delicious glimpse into traditional pizza crafted with care and skill.
3. Master Pizza
Tucked away on Pearl Road, Master Pizza has a storied history that dates back to 1955. My experience dining there shows why it’s considered a local icon—combining tradition with quality. The welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff make every visit special, and the aroma of freshly baked pizza is irresistible.
This pizzeria stands out because of its accolades, including being named one of the top five pizzerias in the world by PMQ. Their Margherita Pizza captures classic Italian elegance, with vibrant tomato sauce and fresh basil. For a heartier option, their Specialty Meat Pizza offers a rich, satisfying flavor that reflects Master Pizza’s commitment to excellence and authenticity.
4. Papa Johns Pizza
Located on Pearl Road, Papa Johns Pizza emphasizes the use of Better Ingredients to craft its signature pies. During my visits, I’ve consistently appreciated the fresh dough and high-quality toppings that set their pizza apart. The straightforward atmosphere makes it a reliable choice for quick and satisfying meals in Strongsville.
What makes Papa Johns stand out is their commitment to quality and their classic menu. I recommend ordering their Original Pizza with the signature sauce, which perfectly balances flavor and freshness. For something extra, their Wings or Breadsticks complement the meal well, reflecting their dedication to variety and quality for any occasion.
5. Sbarro
At Southpark Center, Sbarro has been delighting pizza lovers since 1956 with its iconic XL NY Slice. My visits always reveal a commitment to tradition, featuring made-daily hand-stretched dough and rich San Marzano style sauce. The slices are generously sized, offering a satisfying taste of New York’s pizza scene right in Strongsville.
What sets Sbarro apart is its dedication to authentic flavors and quality ingredients, especially their premium mozzarella cheese. I suggest trying their classic XL Cheese Slice to enjoy the full Sbarro experience. For a complete meal, a slice paired with their fresh salads or sides makes for an authentic and satisfying Italian-style meal.
6. Tommy’s Pizza Chicken & Catering
+1 440-316-2909
See Menu
Located on Pearl Road, Tommy’s Pizza Chicken & Catering has gained a reputation for hearty, flavorful American-style pizza and comfort food. My visits have shown that they prioritize quality ingredients and generous portions, making every meal satisfying. The welcoming atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for lunch or dinner with family and friends.
Since changing ownership in 2017, Tommy’s has continued to stand out with its dedication to homemade flavors. Their BBQ Chicken Pizza is a personal favorite—tangy, smoky, and topped with tender chicken. Pair it with their crispy chicken wings for a balanced, flavorful experience, reflecting their commitment to satisfying, high-quality food.
7. Mama Julianne’s
On Prospect Road, Mama Julianne’s offers a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like dining with family. My experience there has always been positive, thanks to their friendly service and consistently tasty dishes. The variety of options—from pizza to salads—caters to different tastes and preferences.
What makes Mama Julianne’s stand out is their commitment to quality ingredients and hearty, flavorful recipes. Their Calzone is a must-try—crispy, cheesy, and filled with savory toppings. Pair it with a fresh Garden Salad for a satisfying, authentic Italian-style meal that reflects their dedication to freshness and flavor.
8. Antonio’s Pizza Express
Located on Pearl Road, Antonio’s Pizza Express has become a reliable destination for pizza lovers seeking a quick, flavorful meal. My visits have always impressed me with their fresh ingredients and expertly baked pies. The efficient service makes it a perfect spot for lunch or dinner on busy days.
What sets Antonio’s apart is its focus on quality and consistency. I highly recommend trying their Specialty Pepperoni Pizza, which features a crisp crust, savory sauce, and generous toppings. For a satisfying, classic experience, their Cheese Pizza epitomizes the straightforward, delicious style they excel in—trusted, flavorful, and always satisfying.
9. Domino’s Pizza
On Pearl Road, Domino’s Pizza offers a wide range of options to satisfy any craving. My experience with their quick delivery and flavorful pies confirms why they’re a go-to choice in Strongsville. Whether I want a thin, foldable slice or a thick, hearty pan pizza, Domino’s consistently delivers quality and convenience.
What makes Domino’s stand out is their variety and value. Their Cheese Pizza is always dependable—golden, gooey, and topped with a flavorful tomato sauce. For something more indulgent, their Parmesan Stuffed Crust Pizza offers an extra layer of cheesy goodness, embodying the brand’s commitment to taste and innovation.
10. Marco’s Pizza
On Pearl Road, Marco’s Pizza is known for its flavorful, quality pies crafted with fresh ingredients. My visits have shown that their commitment to authentic Italian recipes results in a consistently satisfying experience. The crust is perfectly baked, and the toppings are always fresh, making every slice memorable.
What sets Marco’s apart is their emphasis on quality and taste. I recommend trying their Italian Classic Pizza, featuring a robust tomato sauce and freshly made cheese. For a heartier option, their Meat Supremo Pizza offers a satisfying combination of premium meats, reflecting their dedication to bold, authentic flavors.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q1: What is the best pizza place in Strongsville, OH?
A1: The best pizza spot depends on your preference, but many locals recommend places like A Slice Above, Master Pizza, and Gina’s Pizza for their quality, flavor, and authentic style.
Q2: Are there vegetarian pizza options in Strongsville?
A2: Yes, several places like A Slice Above and Gina’s Pizza offer vegetarian-friendly pizzas with fresh vegetables and cheeses.
Q3: Do restaurants in Strongsville offer delivery?
A3: Most popular pizza spots, including Papa Johns and Domino’s, provide delivery services for added convenience.
Q4: Are there gluten-free pizza options available?
A4: Some pizzerias, like Marco’s Pizza, offer gluten-free crust options for customers seeking gluten-conscious choices.
Q5: Which pizzerias in Strongsville are known for quick service?
A5: Chains like Domino’s and Papa Johns are known for fast, reliable delivery and takeout options.