Finding the best pizza in St. Petersburg, FL, is like embarking on a culinary treasure hunt. Over the years, I’ve explored countless pizzerias across the city, each offering their own unique twist on this timeless classic. From thin, crispy Neapolitan slices to thick, hearty Sicilian squares, St. Petersburg’s pizza scene is as diverse as it is delicious. What truly stands out is the passion and skill that local chefs pour into every pie, ensuring each bite is memorable.
If you’re on the hunt for a truly satisfying pizza experience, this guide aims to point you in the right direction. Whether you crave authentic Italian flavors or innovative new combinations, the city offers something for every pizza enthusiast. Rest assured, this isn’t just a list — it’s a curated journey through the very best that St. Petersburg has to offer. Prepare to discover your new favorite slice.
Where to find the best pizza in St. Petersburg, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in St. Petersburg, FL:
- Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria
- Oak & Stone
- Pizza Box
- Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza
- DeRussos Pizzeria
- Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen
- Cappy’s Pizzeria
- Gianni’s NY Pizza
- Paisano’s Pizza N Pasta
- Colony Grill
1. Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria
Located at 945 Central Ave, Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria stands out as a pioneer of authentic Neapolitan pizza in St. Petersburg. Since opening in 2009, it has maintained a steadfast commitment to tradition, using hand-crafted, wood-fired brick ovens and centuries-old recipes brought directly from Italy. My own experience with their pizza reveals a perfect balance of smoky char and tender, flavorful crust that truly transports you to Naples.
For a genuine taste of Italy, ordering their classic Margherita pizza is a must — the fresh mozzarella, basil, and rich tomato sauce exemplify Bavaro’s dedication to authenticity. The Vegetarian options and gluten-free choices also reflect the restaurant’s thoughtful approach to accommodating all diners. Bavaro’s isn’t just a pizza spot; it’s a celebration of Italy’s culinary craft right in the heart of Florida.
2. Oak & Stone
Situated at 199 Central Ave, Oak & Stone offers a modern twist on artisan pizza in St. Petersburg. Their handcrafted, wood-fired pies undergo a meticulous 36-hour fermentation with triple-filtered water, resulting in a crust that’s both flavorful and light. During my visit, the aroma alone was enough to build anticipation for each slice.
Their Build Your Own pizza and diverse menu make it easy to customize a perfect meal. I recommend trying their signature Margherita pizza, which showcases fresh ingredients and a perfectly blistered crust. Pair it with a selection from the giant craft beer wall, featuring regional and national breweries. Oak & Stone’s innovative approach elevates pizza from comfort food to a culinary experience.
3. Pizza Box
Located at 923 Central Ave, Pizza Box is a favorite among locals for its welcoming atmosphere and versatile menu. My visit revealed a place that caters to diverse dietary needs, with vegetarian and vegan options that don’t compromise on flavor. The quality of ingredients and generous toppings make every slice satisfying.
For an authentic experience, try their signature pepperoni pizza, loved for its crispy edges and balanced sauce. The friendly staff and quick service make it perfect for a casual lunch or dinner. Whether dining in or taking out, Pizza Box delivers consistent, quality pizza that captures the casual, delicious spirit of St. Petersburg’s pizza scene.
4. Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza
Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza feels like stepping into a time capsule of classic pizzerias—no frills, just seriously good pizza. Tucked away on 49th Street, it’s the kind of place locals swear by and newcomers wish they’d found sooner. The red-checkered tablecloths and vintage charm set the tone, but it’s the food that keeps people coming back.
What sets Toby’s apart is its unapologetically old-school approach. The crust is crisp yet chewy, the sauce is tangy with just the right kick, and the cheese melts into a golden, bubbling layer of comfort. It’s pizza the way it was meant to be.
Order the Sicilian-style square pie—thick, hearty, and loaded with flavor. For something lighter, the vegetarian pizza is a standout, balancing fresh toppings with that signature crust.
5. DeRussos Pizzeria
Located at 1120 Pinellas Bayway S, DeRussos Pizzeria offers a warm, inviting setting for pizza lovers in St. Petersburg. During my visit, I appreciated their commitment to quality, evident in the perfectly baked pies that strike a balance between crispy edges and tender crust. The friendly service and relaxed atmosphere make every meal enjoyable.
DeRussos stands out for its fresh ingredients and thoughtful toppings. Their Margherita pizza showcases the use of fresh basil, ripe tomatoes, and creamy mozzarella, reflecting their dedication to authentic flavors. Whether dining in or taking out, DeRussos Pizzeria provides a consistently satisfying pizza experience rooted in quality and tradition.
6. Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen
Located at 210 1st Ave N, Joey Brooklyn’s Famous Pizza Kitchen captures the essence of New York-style pizza right in St. Petersburg. My experience there was memorable; the pizza had that perfect balance of a crispy crust, gooey cheese, and tangy sauce that defines authentic New York pizza. The bustling atmosphere added to the comfort of an all-American pizza joint.
What makes Joey Brooklyn’s stand out is its diverse menu, ranging from classic New York-style slices to hearty calzones. The pepperoni pizza is a crowd favorite, offering a generous topping of quality meat and cheese. For a truly satisfying meal, their salads and Italian pasta options provide a flavorful complement to the pizza.
7. Cappy’s Pizzeria
Located at 2900 1st Ave N, Cappy’s Pizzeria offers a warm, inviting atmosphere with a menu full of flavorful options. During my visit, I was impressed by their fresh ingredients and friendly service that make every meal feel special. Their commitment to quality is evident in every bite.
What truly sets Cappy’s apart is their inventive toppings and crust that’s perfectly baked. I highly recommend trying their Vegetarian pizza, topped with an array of fresh vegetables and tasty cheese, reflecting their dedication to satisfying all dietary preferences. Whether dining in or taking out, Cappy’s delivers consistent quality and great flavor in every slice.
8. Gianni’s NY Pizza
+1 727-381-3209
At Gianni’s NY Pizza, tradition runs deep and every slice tells a story. Rooted in recipes passed down from Rome and Naples, this family-run spot in Tyrone Gardens embraces honest ingredients and time-honored technique. It’s not just pizza—it’s a promise of authenticity.
One visit in, and I understood why locals swear by it. There’s a remarkable balance of crisp, foldable crust and rich, tangy sauce—clearly crafted with care. You won’t find shortcuts here, only the kind of flavor that comes from doing things right.
Start with the classic New York-style cheese slice—simple, but full of soul. Or try the white pizza with ricotta and garlic for a bolder edge. Whatever you choose, it’s a bite of Italy with a New York attitude.
9. Paisano’s Pizza N Pasta
Located at 6000 4th St N, Paisano’s Pizza N Pasta is a welcoming spot known for its diverse menu and accommodating approach. During my visit, I appreciated their extensive gluten-free and vegan options, making it a great choice for various dietary needs. The fresh ingredients and generous toppings highlight their dedication to quality.
For a signature experience, try their Margherita pizza, which features a crispy crust, fresh basil, and flavorful tomato sauce. Their pasta dishes are equally satisfying, but it’s the pizza that truly reflects Paisano’s commitment to authentic, delicious Italian fare. It’s a go-to spot for a reliable and tasty meal in St. Petersburg.
10. Colony Grill
Located at 670 Central Ave, Colony Grill is a cozy spot known for its delicious pizza in St. Petersburg. My visit was memorable; the atmosphere is relaxed, perfect for a casual lunch or dinner. The focus here is on quality ingredients and a simple, satisfying menu.
What sets Colony Grill apart is its classic approach to pizza. The Thin-crust Margherita and specialty pies showcase perfectly balanced flavors and fresh toppings. Every bite reveals a commitment to authentic taste. Whether you prefer a straightforward slice or a creative combo, Colony Grill consistently delivers a satisfying experience rooted in tradition.
More Things to Try in St. Petersburg, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What is the best pizza in St. Petersburg, FL?
A: The best pizza depends on your taste, but options like Bavaro’s Pizza Napoletana for authentic Neapolitan style, Oak & Stone for wood-fired pies, and Gianni’s NY Pizza for New York-style slices are highly recommended.
Q: Are there vegetarian or vegan pizza options in St. Petersburg?
A: Yes, many pizzerias like Paisano’s Pizza N Pasta and Wrigley’s Pizza offer vegetarian and vegan options, ensuring everyone can enjoy a flavorful slice.
Q: Do these pizzerias offer delivery or takeout?
A: Most places, including Cappy’s Pizzeria and Slice of The Burg, provide both delivery and takeout services for convenience.
Q: Are gluten-free pizzas available in St. Petersburg?
A: Some spots like Paisano’s Pizza N Pasta and DeRussos Pizzeria offer gluten-free crusts for customers with dietary restrictions.