Whether you’re new in town or a seasoned local with a go-to spot, St. Joseph, MO is quietly packed with pizza joints that go far beyond ordinary delivery fare. I’ve wandered its streets with a crust craving and found everything from wood-fired Neapolitan slices that sing with simplicity to deep-dish comfort layered in bubbling cheese. It’s not just about grabbing something quick—it’s about finding the slice that makes you pause after the first bite and reconsider everything you thought you knew about pizza.
This guide isn’t stitched together from secondhand opinions or vague “best of” lists. It’s built from actual flavor hunts, personal recommendations, and menu deep-dives across the city. You’ll find authentic local spots, tried-and-true chains, and a few unexpected gems that deserve your attention. Whether your palate leans thin and crispy or rich and hearty, we’ll walk through the most flavorful options this city offers—no shortcuts, no fluff. Let’s get into the crust of it.
Where to find the best pizza in St. Joseph, MO
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in St. Joseph, MO:
- Il Lazzarone
- Geneo’s Pizza and Pub
- Pizza Royal
- Simple Simon’s Pizza
- Pizza Ranch
- Pizza Shoppe
- Domino’s Pizza
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Gambino’s Pizza
- Pizza Hut
1. Il Lazzarone
Nestled on Frederick Avenue, Il Lazzarone offers a genuine taste of Neapolitan pizza right in St. Joseph. Visiting this spot feels like stepping into Italy, thanks to its adherence to traditional methods. The dough, made with just yeast, flour, water, and salt, is left to naturally leaven, resulting in a crust with a delicate, authentic texture. Watching the pizzas bake in a handmade wood-fired oven imported from Naples adds to the experience.
What sets Il Lazzarone apart is its dedication to tradition and quality. The pizzas cook in under 60 seconds, creating the signature leap of the crust. A must-try is the Margherita or the quattro formaggi—simple ingredients elevated to perfection. If you appreciate craftsmanship and authenticity, this pizzeria promises a memorable slice of Italy.
2. Geneo’s Pizza and Pub
Geneo’s Pizza and Pub, tucked away on Francis Street, brings a cozy, neighborhood feel to the downtown scene. It’s the kind of place where locals nod at each other from booth to booth and the pizza speaks louder than the signage. The pub-style atmosphere, paired with no-nonsense service, makes it easy to settle in without fuss.
The crust here is what struck me most—it’s crisp yet chewy, with a homemade feel that tells you someone in the kitchen actually cares. Their deluxe pizza is a local favorite, piled with quality toppings and just the right sauce-to-cheese ratio. If you’re after hearty, satisfying slices without pretense, Geneo’s delivers exactly that.
It’s the simplicity, consistency, and hometown charm that give this pizzeria its staying power in St. Joseph’s competitive pizza lineup.
3. Pizza Royal
Since the early 1980s, Pizza Royal has been a staple in St. Joseph, renowned for its exceptional cracker crust. Traveling extensively, I’ve rarely come across a place that can rival their signature thin, crispy base, no matter how many toppings are added. Even familiar chains like Domino’s struggle to match the level of perfection here.
Their pizza is built on consistency and quality, offering a flavor profile that keeps customers returning. The classic pepperoni and house specialty pizzas highlight their crisp crust and bold flavors. For those seeking a true hometown favorite, Pizza Royal’s pies reflect a commitment to tradition and craftsmanship that stands out in the city’s pizza scene.
4. Simple Simon’s Pizza
Simple Simon’s Pizza has been serving the St. Joseph community since the 1970s, earning a reputation for consistent, hearty slices. Located on Lake Avenue, it’s a convenient spot for lunch or dinner that guarantees a satisfying pizza experience. The relaxed atmosphere makes it perfect for a family night or casual get-together.
What sets Simple Simon’s apart is its emphasis on value and quality ingredients. Their thick, cheesy crust paired with generous toppings creates a classic American pizza style that many locals favor. I particularly enjoy their signature pepperoni pizza—crisp edges, gooey cheese, with a flavor that feels both comforting and nostalgic.
Simple Simon’s proves that great pizza isn’t about flash—it’s about dependable taste and satisfying portions. It remains a go-to spot for those craving a filling, no-frills slice in St. Joseph.
5. Pizza Ranch
Located on North Belt Highway, Pizza Ranch is more than just a pizzeria — it’s a community hub in St. Joseph. The restaurant offers a lively buffet experience, featuring savory pizzas, crispy chicken, and their iconic cactus bread. Visiting this spot feels like stepping into a family gathering with endless options for all ages.
What makes Pizza Ranch truly special is its commitment to community involvement and a family-friendly atmosphere. Their pizza, layered with quality ingredients and crafted to satisfy a crowd, stands out for its consistency and flavor. I recommend trying their classic pepperoni or the veggie lovers’ pizza, both showcasing the fresh ingredients and hearty style that define their menu.
For a satisfying, fun dining experience that combines good food with good cause, Pizza Ranch remains a top choice in St. Joseph.
6. Pizza Shoppe
Situated on N Belt Highway, Pizza Shoppe offers a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for a casual lunch or dinner. It’s a local favorite known for its family-friendly vibe and dependable pizza quality. During my visits, I’ve appreciated how quickly they serve flavorful pies that meet expectations every time.
Their pizzas are crafted with fresh ingredients and baked to perfection, balancing crispy crust with gooey cheese. I highly recommend the supreme or the classic pepperoni, both showcasing their focus on simplicity and taste. Pizza Shoppe stands out by consistently delivering satisfying, well-made pizza in a friendly setting that feels like a true neighborhood spot.
7. Domino’s Pizza
When you’re looking for consistency, speed, and flavor, Domino’s Pizza on Messanie St delivers—literally and figuratively. My last carryout experience was quick, with piping-hot pizza ready in under 15 minutes, just the way a fast-food favorite should work.
What makes this location stand out is how well it balances efficiency with quality. The Parmesan Stuffed Crust adds a sharp, savory bite that elevates their Hand Tossed options, while the Brooklyn Style is foldable, slightly chewy, and ideal for those who lean New York.
If you’re after something with a little more depth, the Handmade Pan Pizza offers a buttery, thick crust that holds generous toppings without falling apart. It’s Domino’s classic done right in St. Joseph, MO.
8. Papa Johns Pizza
At Papa Johns Pizza on N Belt Hwy, quality ingredients are the foundation of every slice. During a recent family dinner, I appreciated how quickly the staff prepared fresh, flavorful pizza with their signature sauce and high-quality toppings. It’s clear they prioritize better ingredients to deliver better pizza.
Their crust is always freshly made, crisp on the edges, and soft inside, making their classic pepperoni or sausage pizzas a reliable choice. I also recommend trying their Lemon Pepper Wings for a perfect pairing that complements the rich flavors of the pizza. Papa Johns stands out by consistently providing pizza that emphasizes taste and quality with every order in St. Joseph.
9. Gambino’s Pizza
Located on Frederick Avenue, Gambino’s Pizza offers a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for casual dining. From my visits, I’ve always appreciated their consistent quality and generous slices that satisfy both the craving and the appetite. The staff’s friendly service makes every meal feel like a treat.
Their pizza features a crispy crust topped with fresh ingredients and flavorful sauce. I recommend trying their supreme or meat lover’s pizza to experience the bold flavors and hearty toppings that exemplify Gambino’s style. Known for a balance of quality and value, Gambino’s stands out as a dependable favorite for pizza lovers in St. Joseph.
10. Pizza Hut
Located on South Belt Highway, Pizza Hut in St. Joseph is known for its iconic stuffed crust and classic flavors. During a recent visit, I enjoyed how quickly their pizza was ready, with a warm, gooey cheese edge that lives up to the brand’s reputation. It’s a reliable choice for comfort food on busy nights.
Their Meat Lovers® pizza is a standout, featuring a hearty combination of meats on a crispy crust. For those wanting a bit of everything, the Supreme combines toppings in perfect harmony. Pizza Hut’s consistent quality and familiar favorites make it a go-to spot for casual, satisfying pizza in St. Joseph.
More Things to Try in St. Joseph, MO
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best wood-fired pizza in St. Joseph?
Il Lazzarone is your top pick for authentic Neapolitan-style pizza. They use imported ingredients and a traditional oven to create crisp, flavorful pies that lean artisan over fast food.
Which pizza places offer halal or vegetarian options?
Several spots offer vegetarian choices. Pizza Shoppe and Domino’s have clear veggie menus. For halal concerns, it’s best to call ahead—most chains don’t advertise certified halal ingredients in this region.
What pizza place delivers fastest in St. Joseph?
Domino’s Pizza and Papa Johns are known for speedy delivery, especially in central areas. Local chains like Gambino’s offer delivery too, but timing may vary.
Are there any local, non-chain pizza places worth trying?
Yes. Pizza Royal and Geneo’s Pizza and Pub are locally loved for their unique sauces and crust styles. They offer a change from national chains and bring character to the table.
Who has the best take-and-bake pizza in town?
Papa Murphy’s is the go-to for take-and-bake. Their pizzas are made fresh and designed to be cooked at home, ideal for those who like a hot slice straight from their oven.
Is there gluten-free pizza available?
Yes. Pizza Ranch, Pizza Hut, and Domino’s offer gluten-free crusts. Selection may vary, so it’s smart to check each location’s menu or ask directly.
Which pizza spots are good for dining in with family?
Pizza Ranch is popular for its buffet-style service and spacious seating. Simple Simon’s Pizza and Pizza Tascio also provide cozy dine-in atmospheres for families and small groups.