Searching for the best pizza in Springfield, MA can feel like a quest worthy of its own comic strip. Springfield’s pizza scene is surprisingly diverse, serving up chewy crusts, bubbling cheese, and the undeniable aroma of a well-fired oven. There’s a certain comfort in biting into a slice that doesn’t disappoint—and in this city, disappointment is rare.
I remember weaving through Springfield’s neighborhoods, determined to test every pizzeria’s signature pie. From tiny counters tucked behind grocery stores to family-run institutions with decades-old recipes, the choices kept me coming back for “just one more.” This guide shares those standouts—the shops with lines worth waiting in, the secret sauces, and the slices that turn casual dinners into loyal habits. If you’re hungry for the right slice, you’re in the right place.
1. Pizza Makers
Pizza Makers on Allen Street brings reliable comfort to Springfield’s pizza lovers. Over my visits, I’ve found that their menu reads like a greatest hits collection from the Italian-American playbook—but it’s the pizza that truly shines. Their hand-tossed pies balance just the right chew with crispness at the edges, while the cheese lands in that golden, bubbling territory that tells you to wait before diving in (even if you never do).
What sets Pizza Makers apart is the sheer range. Traditionalists can go for classic red sauce and mozzarella, but a Sicilian square or a veggie-loaded deep dish really show their depth. If you’re after a crowd-pleaser, order the Gourmet Pizza—each slice holds its own and doesn’t skimp on toppings.
Staff always greet you with easy confidence, and tables fill fast with regulars who know a good thing when they find it. Pizza Makers is the local go-to for big flavors, fair prices, and that essential sense of belonging with each bite.
2. Red Rose Pizzeria
Red Rose Pizzeria is more than a Main Street staple—it’s the place friends suggest first when the craving hits. It draws a lively crowd, especially at dinner, with booths that fill quickly and a tempting aroma that settles you in before the first menu glance. My first visit turned into an unplanned feast because everything looked too good to pass up.
What sets Red Rose Pizzeria apart is its signature thin, chewy crust and a sauce with genuine layers of flavor. Each pie lands with the confidence of decades-old recipes that never needed much tweaking.
I always recommend the House Special Pizza. Its balance of cheese, fresh veggies, and meaty toppings is peak Springfield. The vibe is upbeat, the slices disappear fast, and you’ll be planning your next visit before the last bite.
3. Pizza Works
Pizza Works on Dickinson Street is home to a menu that stands out for its blend of classic pizza and bold, unexpected flavors. You’ll spot regulars who know to grab a booth before the dinnertime rush; the vibe leans unfussy and genuinely friendly. My own introduction came through a friend who swore their pies had “the most addictive crust in town.” He wasn’t wrong.
Pizza Works goes beyond standard offerings by layering in influences from soul food and Spanish dishes. This approach brings a twist to the usual lineup, keeping things interesting for pizza fans with adventurous taste buds.
If it’s your first visit, go for their Super Works Pizza—it’s loaded but never heavy, and every slice tastes thoughtfully built. For something different, their veggie combinations and specialty pies are worth diving into. Simple, satisfying, and full of personality, Pizza Works captures Springfield at its inventive best.
4. Wild Olive Pizzeria
Wild Olive Pizzeria on Sumner Ave pairs neighborhood warmth with a flare for hand-crafted pies. You’ll notice, even before you walk in, the steady stream of takeout orders—a good sign in Springfield’s pizza landscape. My first slice here arrived piping hot, with a crust so crisp I had to pause and appreciate the simplicity.
Wild Olive Pizzeria takes pride in fresh ingredients and inventive toppings, making even the classics feel slightly elevated. The staff are friendly, and there’s this no-rush approach to good pizza that feels rare these days.
If you want a true taste of their style, order the Artisan Veggie Pizza or a simple cheese slice, which puts all their technique on honest display. Wild Olive is proof that in Springfield, excellent pizza doesn’t have to break the bank or overdo the fuss.
5. MJ’S Pizza & Grinders
MJ’S Pizza & Grinders on Worthington Street has that classic neighborhood feel—a spot where you can count on friendly service and pizza that hits the spot every time. Lunch hours here are full of regulars grabbing quick slices or grinders, proving this place has earned local loyalty. My most memorable visit involved a spontaneous order of their signature pizza during a rainstorm; it was the kind of comfort that only a good pie can deliver.
MJ’S Pizza & Grinders excels in balancing soft, chewy dough with generous cheese and a tangy, well-seasoned sauce. Their grinders have a reputation all their own, but the pizza deserves attention for its classic approach and always-fresh toppings.
If you’re here for pizza, try the Special Combo Pizza. It’s a satisfying mix of hearty flavors, perfect for sharing or for when you can’t decide what to order. There’s nothing pretentious here—just straightforward, well-made pizza at prices you’ll appreciate.
6. Tony’s Pizza
Tony’s Pizza on Boston Road has been spinning dough since 1979, and the family touch is clear from the first bite. You get a sense of tradition in the warm dining room, with regulars greeting each other between mouthfuls of homemade Italian specialties. My own introduction came during a midweek dinner rush, where the energy in the air matched the bustle behind the counter—fast, but never rushed.
Tony’s Pizza is known for its hand-tossed pies, with chewy, golden crust and toppings that taste impossibly fresh. The sauce isn’t shy—there’s depth, a little tang, and it sets the stage for the cheese to shine through.
The standout order is their Classic Margherita Pizza, showcasing quality ingredients with every bite. For bigger appetites, their specialty pizzas cover all the bases. It’s tradition served up, one slice at a time.
7. Peppa’s Xpress
Peppa’s Xpress on Wilbraham Road is a lively, down-to-earth spot where the staff make you feel right at home. My first visit was late one evening, and I was struck by the aroma of fresh dough and the easy camaraderie among customers and staff. The “made from scratch” approach here is more than a motto—it shows up in every meal.
Peppa’s Xpress sets itself apart with inventive specialty pies and a rich selection of classic and creative toppings. The menu is loaded, but pizza stands front and center, with New York-style, Sicilian, and deep dish all making their case.
If you’re indecisive, try the Supreme Pizza or a slice of their Sicilian pie—both showcase generous toppings piled over a perfectly balanced crust. There’s a genuine sense that each pizza is crafted for both comfort and flavor, right down to the last bite.
8. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Sumner Ave brings consistency to Springfield’s fast-paced pizza scene. It’s a go-to for late nights or last-minute cravings, and the speed of service never disappoints. I still remember calling in an order during a game night; the quick delivery and hot slices kept the party going with zero fuss.
Domino’s stands out for its flexible options. You can create your own with dozens of topping choices or snag a deal on their long-time crowd-pleasers. The Handmade Pan Pizza always comes out buttery and indulgent, while their thin crust makes for an easy, foldable slice.
For something extra, try the Parmesan Stuffed Crust Pizza. It’s cheesy, satisfying, and delivers on what Domino’s does best—fast, reliable flavor that never feels like a gamble.
9. Paramount Pizza
Paramount Pizza on Main Street is the definition of a dependable local spot—always bustling and always open just when you need it most. My go-to move here has become grabbing a couple of fresh slices to take on a walk through downtown Springfield. The quick service manages to feel personal, even during the lunch rush.
Paramount Pizza has mastered the art of classic cheese and pepperoni, but their menu reaches beyond the expected. The crust is sturdy, never greasy, and holds up well to generous toppings. There’s a satisfying balance between chewy and crisp in every bite.
For a solid taste of what they do best, try the All Meat Pizza—hearty, rich, and built for anyone who likes plenty of protein on their pie. If you’re more indecisive, their veggie combo offers equal enthusiasm for fresh flavors.
10. Pan Pizza
(413) 455-1292Call
Pan Pizza on Wilbraham Road is the kind of spot where Greek-style pies take center stage. The first time I stopped in, the aroma of fresh dough and tangy tomato sauce drew me straight to the counter. There’s a comfort to this place—friendly staff and a no-nonsense menu built around their signature pan pizzas.
Pan Pizza sets itself apart with its soft, golden crust that’s firm around the edges and just thick enough to hold plenty of toppings. You taste the difference in each mouthful—the balance of cheese, sauce, and that classic Greek seasoning keeps things interesting.
Order the Greek Special Pizza for a satisfying bite packed with vibrant veggies, black olives, and feta. This spot proves that sometimes, familiar flavors done well are exactly what you want.
Frequently Asked Questions
What style of pizza is most popular in Springfield, MA?
You’ll find a mix—classic New York-style slices, hearty Sicilian squares, and Greek-style pan pizzas. Many local spots take pride in hand-tossed dough and creative topping combos.
Are there any vegan or vegetarian pizza options in Springfield?
Absolutely. Several pizzerias offer vegetarian pies, and you can find vegan cheese or veggie-heavy options at places like Wild Olive Pizzeria or All Things Pizza.
What’s a “must-try” pizza spot for first-time visitors?
Red Rose Pizzeria is legendary, but Pizza Makers and Tony’s Pizza are long-time favorites. For something different, Pizza Works blends Spanish and soul food influences into their pies.
Is delivery available from most pizzerias in Springfield?
Yes, almost every pizza shop—big chains and local gems—offers delivery and takeout, making it easy to enjoy a slice anywhere in the city.
Where can I find late-night pizza in Springfield?
Peppa’s Xpress and some Domino’s locations keep later hours, so you can satisfy your cravings even after most places close.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Springfield?
Some spots, such as major chains and a few local favorites, offer gluten-free crusts or can build a gluten-free pizza on request. Always call ahead to check availability.